Looney Lynching Mini Mafia - Page 65

On October 17 2012 15:13 thrawn2112 wrote:
There's a lot in the tone and motive of da0's posts that make me think he is scum, but I'm having a hard time differentiating that from what might just be language barrier problems, or general first time noobishness. Here are some examples. They include just general weirdness, hints of insincerity, and chiming in with agreement whenever people defend him.

+ Show Spoiler +

The alien invaders "joke" is just..... idk. Later on he said it was an attempt to get discussion moving but I do not see how he could expect anyone to take that idea seriously. Then he talks about "mini scum"..... just wtf once again. Da0 what were you talking about with mini scum?

Another point against him is that he laid down 9 votes on sandroba. That's already been addressed by people on both sides of the da0 debate but it still stands as a fact. He talked about his vote for sand and here was my initial take on his post:

+ Show Spoiler +


Also, he was who Sandroba most wanted us to kill, and from I can tell it's the same deal with ET. Both of those guys are dead. Sandroba's lst words about da0 were:



The only reason why I think he could be town is because his scumhunting posts show a lot of townie paranoia. Like a lot. And this being his first game that would make sense for him to be overly paranoid. And he has shown pretty consistent suspicion of memtoss but eh, scum or town would do that.

So for now he's gonna stay at number 3 spot,on my list and will possibly move up higher because I'm not confident that he's scum but there is so much against him (his posts seem forced, he was sandroba's and et's lynch choice, he voted 9 for sandroba)that it'd be dumb to let it slide. Also I think a do0 flip would be extremely useful.

As for austin.... bleh. I've played 1 game with him (town austin) and I've obsed a couple of his town games and he just seemed so much more straightforward and useful than he's being in this game. His word count is still really high but his post just seem way fluffier than what I'd come to expect from him. Also I still can't get over the vote sharing thing from D1. I can not understand how any town player would do that.... first of all that means that you don't trust your own judgement which I don't think that'd be the case with a town austin, and it also means that you have almost confirmed town reads in the people you're giving the votes to. He did it on D1... could he really have been so sure that kush and I were town at that point? Also, at the time he made the offer I believe kush was strongly in favor of lynching sandroba, and I was on the fence but I'd been the main person pushing sand's case all game. I am not convinced that town austin would have shared votes like that.

As for hiro, he got the 2 spot on my list basically because of process of elimination. I don't have the slightest town read on him, nor do I have the slightest scum read. That is very worrying and in the past when there's a player that I'm not really concerned with because they are off the radar, big surprise they end up being scum. I'll look through his filter next.

On October 16 2012 19:17 thrawn2112 wrote:
how exactly is it different? only thing I can think of is that I'm somewhat trollish this game.... not really sure why I'm being like that but it could be due to... to quote nony... "substances that we'll collectively call alcohol"

and yeah I'm actually in agreement with you about daoud. I'm also not convinced about memtoss. Lately I've been wading through the filters of hopeless/austin. Austin's play has just been weird compared to his normal meta. I'm used to seeing him writing these exhaustive walls of analysis where he details his exact reads on people... this game he's just been doing stranger stuff and he seems more willing to go into lurk mode if you don't call him out

On October 12 2012 05:19 HiroPro wrote:


The contradiction is that you accused daoud of this " He is not approaching the bracket as an opportunity to catch scum", when in fact you yourself were using the bracket to pick players who you thought were worse to advance, not those who you thought were scum.

I'd still like a response to this please. austin was someone you considered good and he directly refuted one of your points so I'm wondering why you didn't try to convince him otherwise, if you didn't accept his view:

---

I'm voting for Djodref over ET. Partly because I'm getting a town read on ET (the thoughts that he's sharing seem good and I liked the way he reacted to Mementoss's accusation). But also because of the way that he's posting: his posts seem manufactured to me. Especially the one above where he seems to be calling predictions for each matchup needlessly - it's not something that I see a townie really being interested in, but it is something that I think a new mafia player would consider a "contribution" and include just for the sake of making a bigger post.

Djodref x1

On October 13 2012 04:26 HiroPro wrote:
We're not lynching hopeless. His plan looks silly but it looks like a townie plan - bring attention onto yourself needlessly (not something scum would do) and try to make some attempt at advancing discussion.

Djodref's case on Hopeless honestly isn't very good. Except for the part about not scumhunting, he doesn't explain why any of those things are more likely to be done by scum and the whole thing about the kush/prplhz voting honestly looks like a complete misread. Not sure if town djodref would make a case like this, I'll need to read through his earlier game.

OriginalName x2

On October 13 2012 04:59 HiroPro wrote:


Because lynching sandroba on d1 is dumb. And he's done nothing to make me think he's scum.

On October 13 2012 05:01 HiroPro wrote:


Nothing. But I think hopeless is probably town. And ON is basically useless.

On October 14 2012 09:52 HiroPro wrote:
im here.

We should lynch ON. I can see sandroba getting frustrated like that as town and I honestly don't think the other stuff that people are bringing up is all that great. From what I've seen sandroba is a pretty temperamental guy and not someone prone to explaining stuff when he doesn't feel like it.

And when you have someone who is not posting at all it's better to kill them over someone who can absolutely be useful if they're town.

OriginalName x5