|
On October 10 2007 01:35 himurakenshin wrote: Chinese ppl get fucked around by their government, by them not mentioning historical events, filtering media and communication, and they still support their government so much.
YOU CAN SAY THE SAME ABOUT EVERY OTHER COUNTRY.
|
Civil war was indeed not started over slavery, but it was definitely a big factor. A better representation would certainly have to be the American Revolutionary. Seeing, as how many fled from England to avoid certain things there and to start a new life, the United States gained it's independence. Similarities, certainly....Taiwan has control over it's own government with no influence at all from it's Chinese counterparts. As I said before, countries don't recognize Taiwan as a country simply because they wish to keep friendly political and economic ties with China.
|
Maybe PJ and the Chinese overrecated here, but you need to understand where they are coming from. This guy raising the flag of Taiwan is basically like a slap in the face to the Chinese, they had a right to be angry about it.
|
angry, maybe, to attack, no way
|
On October 10 2007 01:36 KissBlade wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2007 01:35 himurakenshin wrote: Chinese ppl get fucked around by their government, by them not mentioning historical events, filtering media and communication, and they still support their government so much. YOU CAN SAY THE SAME ABOUT EVERY OTHER COUNTRY.
I don't think so... look at the number of entertainers being anti-Bush administration. No problem. My friend was telling me about a Taiwanese pop singer who was really popular, but then she made a comment about Taiwanese independence and that was the end of her career.
|
Kissblade you need to stop posting. You only upset people and from here on out no one will read your content objectively anymore. You have became the sole defender of China's claim and you will be flamed by every other forum member here, except for some Chinese mainland members.
If you want me to start listing the things of China that are undemocratic, against freedom and against the general ideology of the west that are considered 'our' most valuable morals and virtues I could write up a list that contains more items than words you have typed in this thread altogether. Do you think Tibet is China too? Because the UN recognizes it as so and you have 'legitimate' claims on it. Well the same things can be said against it and no matter what the corrupt and aggressive Chinese government claims, Tibet does not belong. The cultural differences are huge and they have been repressed and sucked out for decades. China is behaving like an aggressive colonialist state, almost similar to Japan's previous aggression at certain points, whom you despise so badly. No Taiwan has an equal different past than China and the last 60 years of autonomous rule of China have made it become clearly different than China's mainland. If Taiwan wants to belong to China, then China should reach out an open hand for Taiwan to accept on their own willingness. Forcing Chinese pride on Taiwan is no good for anyone, and that is clearly what is the case here. You cannot have Taiwan unless you use force. This clearly means they don't want to be ruled by the Beijing government or want much to do with them. Now stop claiming territory.
|
On October 10 2007 01:55 {ToT}Strafe wrote: Kissblade you need to stop posting. You only upset people and from here on out no one will read your content objectively anymore. You have became the sole defender of China's claim and you will be flamed by every other forum member here, except for some Chinese mainland members.
If you want me to start listing the things of China that are undemocratic, against freedom and against the general ideology of the west that are considered 'our' most valuable morals and virtues I could write up a list that contains more items than words you have typed in this thread altogether. Do you think Tibet is China too? Because the UN recognizes it as so and you have 'legitimate' claims on it. Well the same things can be said against it and no matter what the corrupt and aggressive Chinese government claims, Tibet does not belong. The cultural differences are huge and they have been repressed and sucked out for decades. China is behaving like an aggressive colonialist state, almost similar to Japan's previous aggression at certain points, whom you despise so badly. No Taiwan has an equal different past than China and the last 60 years of autonomous rule of China have made it become clearly different than China's mainland. If Taiwan wants to belong to China, then China should reach out an open hand for Taiwan to accept on their own willingness. Forcing Chinese pride on Taiwan is no good for anyone, and that is clearly what is the case here. You cannot have Taiwan unless you use force. This clearly means they don't want to be ruled by the Beijing government or want much to do with them. Now stop claiming territory.
Tibet is Tibet. China will fall into pieces just like the Soviet Union did.
|
No China will not. Soviet had economic problems and after Stalin softened their terror. China still represses their subordinates and at the same time benefit from a great economic boom that will continue for a long period of time. If anything the grip of the central government will tighten and become even more dominating. Protests won't do them much good for the while being, unless a large group rises, but that seems unlikely. Last I remember is a peace square. Funny name.
|
On October 10 2007 02:02 ambit!ous1 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2007 01:55 {ToT}Strafe wrote: Kissblade you need to stop posting. You only upset people and from here on out no one will read your content objectively anymore. You have became the sole defender of China's claim and you will be flamed by every other forum member here, except for some Chinese mainland members.
If you want me to start listing the things of China that are undemocratic, against freedom and against the general ideology of the west that are considered 'our' most valuable morals and virtues I could write up a list that contains more items than words you have typed in this thread altogether. Do you think Tibet is China too? Because the UN recognizes it as so and you have 'legitimate' claims on it. Well the same things can be said against it and no matter what the corrupt and aggressive Chinese government claims, Tibet does not belong. The cultural differences are huge and they have been repressed and sucked out for decades. China is behaving like an aggressive colonialist state, almost similar to Japan's previous aggression at certain points, whom you despise so badly. No Taiwan has an equal different past than China and the last 60 years of autonomous rule of China have made it become clearly different than China's mainland. If Taiwan wants to belong to China, then China should reach out an open hand for Taiwan to accept on their own willingness. Forcing Chinese pride on Taiwan is no good for anyone, and that is clearly what is the case here. You cannot have Taiwan unless you use force. This clearly means they don't want to be ruled by the Beijing government or want much to do with them. Now stop claiming territory. Tibet is Tibet. China will fall into pieces just like the Soviet Union did. Actually I think Russia today is much more promising than USSR ever has been
|
|
But Strafe, as you put the problem (undemocratic and against the ideology of the west) is clear that you have no studies in this area.
But this discussion and arguing is futile.
This wasn't actually about china or taiwan belonging to china or not (but it actually does).
Xeris is right anyway (and end of arguing).
|
On October 10 2007 02:10 Pika Chu wrote: But Strafe, as you put the problem (undemocratic and against the ideology of the west) is clear that you have no studies in this area.
But this discussion and arguing is futile.
This wasn't actually about china or taiwan belonging to china or not (but it actually does).
Xeris is right anyway (and end of arguing).
Pikachu. What? At least say something useful.
Let me reply to you in equal manner.
You are stupid. Let's end this thread.
|
i like how some people are talking about china fucking over taiwan and shit but in reality im sure this case has been put up with already they arent going to war after some cyberathletic tournament..
and this is getting interesting =p
|
Chinese are unpredictable, they might just send boatshipments with economic refugees to Taiwan. Only this time all armed with a spoon to topple the Taiwanese government.
|
we do this topic liek couple times a year...do we really have to do this?
|
On October 10 2007 02:16 {ToT}Strafe wrote: Chinese are unpredictable, they might just send boatshipments with economic refugees to Taiwan. Only this time all armed with a spoon to topple the Taiwanese government.
LOLZ
|
Sweden33719 Posts
On October 10 2007 01:40 Xeris wrote: Maybe PJ and the Chinese overrecated here, but you need to understand where they are coming from. This guy raising the flag of Taiwan is basically like a slap in the face to the Chinese, they had a right to be angry about it. Lol yes they did. Lol no it wasn't. Lol no they didn't.
If he was burning a chinese flag I'd understand it, but this? I'm sorry, it's unacceptable, regardless of circumstances. Maybe it's personal to you (dunno if you are chinese), but when looked at from a neutral perspective (although I'm sure I'm biased since Taiwan is a bit more westernish than china) it's just pathetic.
|
I can't reply to an useless post like yours with something useful, sorry. Well i didn't want to offend you but since you called me stupid... well.. takes one to know one.
|
On October 10 2007 00:24 lilsusie wrote:It's like Texas thinking that they are their own country... I have Taiwanese friends who get really upset if you call them Chinese and ones who don't really care. I agree, it's mainly a pride thing.
pftt, we are our own country. tbh
|
I called you stupid, because you called for it. You immediately jumped to the conclusion someone is unknowing and lacking studies in a certain area from one posts, WHICH YOU COMPLETELY MISREAD.
Sorry if you are going to give criticism at least argue for it, but start with understanding the post of another person.
And seriously if you think I actually called you stupid, then I guess I was right.
|
|
|
|