On August 21 2017 23:17 Hider wrote: One thing I do like that they moved away from since S1 is the amount of sex/naked-scenes. Generally I don't feel they added a lot to the plot, and it just makes it ackward to watch it with your family.
Considering the uselessness of the Missandei/Grey Worm scene of a few weeks ago, I don't think they'll resist to give a us a long and useless Jon/Dany scene, though
You're not going to see E.Clark naked again so don't expect that sex scene to be too much revealing.
But this is what the series started with, surely we need to end it with that as well :o
On August 22 2017 01:17 Plansix wrote: The plan they had seemed reasonable giving the time constraints that the characters are under. Bran told them that the army is marching that part of the wall. Considering they have seen the Nightking just raise his arms and raise up hundreds of undead, I bet they didn’t want to risk him getting to the wall itself. Because that is when the snowball army begins. So a desperate bad plan is sort of all they had.
It's no plan at all though besides "we go north and catch a wight". Well how do you plan on doing so. That's kinda important and there was simply nothing. Everything you said is right, but that doesn't mean that you can simply be "well we will figure something out on the fly", that's just ridiculous. Some form of idea should be there to even attempt it. The writers gave us nothing though, they literally found that little wight group where one stays "alive" to resolve it. So what if that wouldn't have happened.
On August 22 2017 01:22 KwarK wrote: I'm fine with having to prove to Dany that the threat is real, it's the proving to Cersei bit that bugs the hell out of me. You don't need to prove shit to Cersei for a few reasons. 1) Cersei has fuck all to offer you. She controls literally just King's Landing. Exactly 0 of the 7 kingdoms. 2) Cersei don't give a fuck about the north, the south, or anyone but herself. 3) Cersei is always going to turn on you. 4) Cersei isn't going to allow of her soldiers to die fighting the dead when she can have your soldiers die instead because she's always going to be thinking of her inevitable fight with you. 5) Cersei is absolutely going to murder any of your dragons she can given any opportunity. You literally can't let her army or people be near any of your shit. 6) To Cersei the army of the dead is probably less scary than the army of the Dothraki + Unsullied + 3 dragons. To her the dead aren't the ultimate enemy to be dealt with first before she fights Dany, Dany is the ultimate enemy. 7) Even if the army of the dead is more scary, the army of Dany is already here. 8) There's still a giant fucking wall, a wildling army, a north filled with her enemies, a riverlands filled with her enemies, and a vale filled with her enemies, between the army of the dead and her. Cersei don't give a fuck about them. 9) You can literally just go kill her whenever and then take her army if you want it. Dragons give an innate deep deployment perk that allows armies to be bypassed. 10) There is no possibility that Dany, through Tyrion, doesn't know literally all of the above.
If they'd had Dany be all unbelieving and Jon went to get a wight for her I'd be fine with that. But Dany's a single mom and Jon was good with her kids so now she's wet for him and his curly hair. So who is the wight for?
I mean proving it to all the lords of westeros pretty much, no? They need all the men they can get, Cersei is one factor but there are more.
Which lords though? The entire north is already in the fight. That's 1 of the kingdoms. The Riverlands is basically on fire because most of the civil war was fought there but with the Freys out it's back to Stark/Tully control. Nothing of value there but they're against the army of the dead so that's 2. Vale is in the north and in the fight already, that's three. Westernlands have been abandoned by the Lannisters and the Unsullied now hold them. Nothing of value there but that's four. Last we heard the Stormlands are basically depopulated. That was a few seasons ago. Stannis threw their entire army at King's Landing, then threw the survivors at Winterfell. Their army is basically Ser Davos, and he's on team north. That's five. The Reach was on team Dany, then the Tarly's switched sides, then they got set on fire and the rest bent the knee. That's six. That leaves Dorne, which has a completely untouched army (the only kingdom yet to get involved) and is on team Dany.
You have to wonder who is on team Cersei at this point. Surely nobody whose family was in the Sept of Baelor, which would have been most families. And of those, who is still on team Cersei after the Tarly's got roasted.
Cersei only has Lannister armies with some Greyjoy ships, and potential mercenary companies payed by gold. And that's it. There's ZERO reason to look for their assistance, knowing all you know about Cersei and correctly assuming she will try to use the situation to her advantage.
But that's nonsense. If they want to avoid it, they could storm KL. Even if they don't want to do that, there are countless of better plans than 'lets try to capture a wight and bring it to cersei even though we know she won't give a shit about that'.
Hell, they could even ignore Cersei, go fight the undead on the north and then when they are done go clean up Cersei.
On August 22 2017 01:54 Odoakar wrote: But that's nonsense. If they want to avoid it, they could storm KL. Even if they don't want to do that, there are countless of better plans than 'lets try to capture a wight and bring it to cersei even though we know she won't give a shit about that'.
They literally explained this in an episode. They don't want to storm kings landing because mass murder and the cycle of violence(aka, the wheel). They want to deal with the nightking's army and can't while at war with Cersei. They know they can win, so they want her to sue for peace and reach an armistice where they all fight the nightking's army. They want the wight as proof the army exist.
On August 22 2017 01:54 Odoakar wrote: But that's nonsense. If they want to avoid it, they could storm KL. Even if they don't want to do that, there are countless of better plans than 'lets try to capture a wight and bring it to cersei even though we know she won't give a shit about that'.
They literally explained this in an episode. They don't want to storm kings landing because mass murder and the cycle of violence(aka, the wheel). They want to deal with the nightking's army and can't while at war with Cersei. They know they can win, so they want her to sue for peace and reach an armistice where they all fight the nightking's army. They want the wight as proof the army exist.
The explanation was dumb as hell. They cannot fight alongside Cersei. They don't need to kill everyone in King's Landing. They could totally fight the Night King while at war with Cersei because Cersei is a bitch who can't do shit to anyone. They know that Cersei is never going to sue for peace, she'll never submit to another queen, she's always going to die fighting Dany.
On August 22 2017 01:54 Odoakar wrote: But that's nonsense. If they want to avoid it, they could storm KL. Even if they don't want to do that, there are countless of better plans than 'lets try to capture a wight and bring it to cersei even though we know she won't give a shit about that'.
They literally explained this in an episode. They don't want to storm kings landing because mass murder and the cycle of violence(aka, the wheel). They want to deal with the nightking's army and can't while at war with Cersei. They know they can win, so they want her to sue for peace and reach an armistice where they all fight the nightking's army. They want the wight as proof the army exist.
The explanation was dumb as hell. They cannot fight alongside Cersei. They don't need to kill everyone in King's Landing. They could totally fight the Night King while at war with Cersei because Cersei is a bitch who can't do shit to anyone. They know that Cersei is never going to sue for peace, she'll never submit to another queen, she's always going to die fighting Dany.
Ok, I am willing to accept that Cersei is a risk. But seizing cities with armies them is terrible for the people who live in those cities. This is the era of modern professional armies. Taking kings landing would be a blood bath with dragons. And this show has been all about how the cycle of violence will mean more violence in the next generation.
If they want to fight with Cersci, they put the condition of peace with Jamie leading the remaining armies north to fight with them. He isn't a hostage, but can't escape and won't leave his men. And he is effectively a man of his word.
On August 22 2017 01:54 Odoakar wrote: But that's nonsense. If they want to avoid it, they could storm KL. Even if they don't want to do that, there are countless of better plans than 'lets try to capture a wight and bring it to cersei even though we know she won't give a shit about that'.
They literally explained this in an episode. They don't want to storm kings landing because mass murder and the cycle of violence(aka, the wheel). They want to deal with the nightking's army and can't while at war with Cersei. They know they can win, so they want her to sue for peace and reach an armistice where they all fight the nightking's army. They want the wight as proof the army exist.
The explanation was dumb as hell. They cannot fight alongside Cersei. They don't need to kill everyone in King's Landing. They could totally fight the Night King while at war with Cersei because Cersei is a bitch who can't do shit to anyone. They know that Cersei is never going to sue for peace, she'll never submit to another queen, she's always going to die fighting Dany.
Ok, I am willing to accept that Cersei is a risk. But seizing cities with armies them is terrible for the people who live in those cities. This is the era of modern professional armies. Taking kings landing would be a blood bath with dragons. And this show has been all about how the cycle of violence will mean more violence in the next generation.
If they want to fight with Cersci, they put the condition of peace with Jamie leading the remaining armies north to fight with them. He isn't a hostage, but can't escape and won't leave his men. And he is effectively a man of his word.
And then she will betray them anyways, possibly in the worst possible moment - during or just before the final battle. The only way to deal with Cersei is to kill her. Speaking of which... If they wanted to remove Cersei and focus on the more important war, why didn't they try to remove/kill her and instead decided to do this insane plan... Surely sneaking someone in KL to assassinate the queen is more plausable than what happened. I'm sure that many people in KL will betray the Lannisters at the first possible moment.
It's almost like they're trying to channel the "keep your friends close and enemies closer adage," but the problem is that keeping Cersei closer is a recipe for utter disaster. Having her directly involved in their WW fighting efforts will 100% result in her sabotaging everyone else at every turn with some access to their battle plans (if they give her ALL the plans, they are simply insane, but it seems possible they will at this point).
On August 21 2017 21:50 Godwrath wrote: So littlefinger managed to put sisters against each other fairly quickly (not like Sansa helps, she obviously wants to be queen of the north). Now he needs to find a way to convince Sansa that Arya needs to be dealt with. Hopefully Arya is smart enough to steal his face pretty soon.
Sansa doesn’t want anyone to have power over her or be the victim of someone else’s bad decision(hence the fear of Jon being just like her father). She just doesn’t express this very well. I also don’t know if Little Finger has played them. Sansa sent Brie away because little finger recommend using Brie to talk to Arya. It is hard to tell if she did that because she doesn’t want to get along with Arya or she just doesn’t want to play into Little Finger’s hand.
Sry for the late quote. Imo Littlefinger played both of them. He purposefully lead Arya to something that would lead her to confront his sister, and it is a given that Sansa will do in most instances the opposite of what he would advise.
Now the ball is on Sansa's yard, whether her fear of Arya will lead her to do something about it, or finally fall in line and publicly support Jon's decisions to the other lords.
I have always been under the impression that the instant the Nightking gets beyond the wall, he will just go through destroying towns to increase the size of his already large army. And Jon's fear is that if they delay any longer, they will never be able to stop him once that happens. Plus its called the "Long Winter", I'm sure terrible things will happen once the NightKing gets beyond the wall. Jon's has been saying over and over they don't have time and need everyone they can get.
But lets get into it. How do we think Jamie will respond to seeing the undead? Because my bet is he is willing to take peace and fight that over assured defeat and death of him and his sister.
To me the obvious reason why they decided to do this is because they have nothing else to show. Imagine they defeated Cersei this season as all people believed they would. What would they have done with the last 7 episodes. They can't fill 7 hours or more with fighting and witty oneliners as well as Dany staring menacingly at someone. They need human drama for at least 5 more episodes and if Cersei is removed there is no one left of consequence. So they decided to kill off Littlefinger in ep 7 (probably) and then have next episode start with another telling of the fragile alliance theme, Cersei and Dany staring menacingly at each other to find out who is the tougher queen. They simply bought time.
There's only one logical way to interpret the Arya / Sansa plot. After discovering the note, it's odd that Arya confronted Sansa directly instead of acting on it (also she refuses to tell her where she found the note when asked). Then she carelessly leaves a bag of faces for her to find, and made some largely empty threats, leaving the dagger in Sansa's hand at the end of the scene. All of this leads me to believe Arya is setting up fake tension, putting up a show for Littlefinger.
Sansa sending away Brienne was probably part of LF's plan when he brought up that she could use Brienne for "protection" if Arya becomes a problem. I think she sent her away to avoid bloodshed, but played into LF's plan, which is to get rid of Brienne in the first place.
Storm the fucking KL castle with your 2 dragons. Kill the dumb bitch. Apologize to the citizens: "Sorry, fam. We had to use dragonfire all up in this bitch so that we dont have to worry about Cersei doing dumb shit while we fight the army of the dead *points direction*"
Citizens: "Oh okay, we forgive you, we never liked her anyways."
AT WORST, the citizens will be in upheaval and go into chaos at the sight of dragons attacking KL. But honestly, that can be kept contained way down south in KL while they deal with the real problem up north. My points are a little messy, but you get the idea right?
Perhaps Cersei goes full madness and capture Daenerys, her army can't do anything because they don't have anyone as backup (just like Tyrion was discussing), then Jaime has to kill Cersei next season.
Personally, I was very excited that they had one battle with the dragons and Jamie was like “We cannot win this.” The one part of conflict that they don’t get into in GoT is when a side knows it can’t win and is trying to obtain peace in the best way possible. There are so many instances of this in real history and none of them every get played up in cinema. As much as I hate Cersci, an ending where she does not die and lives in exile is interesting. Same with Littlefinger. Fates worse than death are where I want this show to go with the worst of the worst.
The entire plan feels like it hinges on Jaime keeping a leash on Cersei during the armistice. But she's been the dominant twin for the entire story so it just sounds stupid.
I just imagined Jaime killing Cersei after she tells him to burn Dany (after they somehow capture her) and everyone else, similarly to what the Mad King told him to do before getting killed. It would be hilariously bad.