|
On November 26 2012 22:58 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 22:57 Acrofales wrote:On November 26 2012 22:54 marvellosity wrote:On November 26 2012 22:51 Promethelax wrote:
Marv: why would scum put up their (presumably) three best players as candidates day 1? That is Sand, Toad and Kita. oh yeah. that does sound kinda unlikely. On the other hand: why not? I understand running 2, because you can try to consolidate behind the 1 who looks more likely. 3 seems like spreading yourself too thin.
Oh, I can see it happening. They are all strong players who are expected to run.
Not that I feel Kita is scum, I still don't see a scum motivation behind his play, and 3P is more likely. I just don't feel that 3 scum running for the position is weird. Particularly because Toad was the last to jump in and Toad will always want attention.
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with.
|
On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with.
so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 26 2012 23:03 Promethelax wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with. so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind?
yeah, 3rd party is my best guess. And unlike some other people I don't throw it around lightly (too many 3rd party reads in this game). My last two 3rd party reads (rock band, liquid city) have been bang on.
|
On November 26 2012 23:09 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:03 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with. so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind? yeah, 3rd party is my best guess. And unlike some other people I don't throw it around lightly (too many 3rd party reads in this game). My last two 3rd party reads (rock band, liquid city) have been bang on.
you were scum in LC but you were magical town jailer of doom in Rockband so I'll accept that.
Kita: name claim please?
|
Prome, you have no right to ask for people's name claim when you dont want to claim your own.
|
mostly curious as to what his response will be, he can refuse. I have the right to do whatever I damn well please, thanks.
|
Phrased that offensively oops.
What would your response be if I asked you for a roleclaim now?
|
On November 26 2012 23:13 Promethelax wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:09 marvellosity wrote:On November 26 2012 23:03 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with. so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind? yeah, 3rd party is my best guess. And unlike some other people I don't throw it around lightly (too many 3rd party reads in this game). My last two 3rd party reads (rock band, liquid city) have been bang on. you were scum in LC but you were magical town jailer of doom in Rockband so I'll accept that. Kita: name claim please?
What do you feel Kita's claim will do for town at the moment?
PS. What changed all of a sudden that you are here to micromanage the game (your normal playstyle)?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 26 2012 23:13 Promethelax wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:09 marvellosity wrote:On November 26 2012 23:03 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with. so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind? yeah, 3rd party is my best guess. And unlike some other people I don't throw it around lightly (too many 3rd party reads in this game). My last two 3rd party reads (rock band, liquid city) have been bang on. you were scum in LC but you were magical town jailer of doom in Rockband so I'll accept that. Kita: name claim please?
I was indeed scum in LC, but after BC was protected night 1 (a perfectly natural protect) I still deduced during Day 2 that he was 3rd party from his play ^_^
Also, I like magical town jailer of doom.
|
I still don't see anything we as town gain from a full roleclaim from me so nope. I mostly want Kita to tell me I figured out his role even though I had never even heard of Chrono Trigger until this thread.
|
On November 26 2012 23:18 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:13 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 23:09 marvellosity wrote:On November 26 2012 23:03 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 23:02 marvellosity wrote:
I can see it happening, but on the balance of probability I would presume not. And that's what I usually work with. so kita=/=scum, Kita=3p in your mind? yeah, 3rd party is my best guess. And unlike some other people I don't throw it around lightly (too many 3rd party reads in this game). My last two 3rd party reads (rock band, liquid city) have been bang on. you were scum in LC but you were magical town jailer of doom in Rockband so I'll accept that. Kita: name claim please? What do you feel Kita's claim will do for town at the moment? PS. What changed all of a sudden that you are here to micromanage the game (your normal playstyle)?
I'm pulling an all nighter to write a 15 page term paper and I like mafia more than term paper.
see above for what I want from Kita's name claim. It isn't about benefit to town. I just wanna be right.
|
On November 26 2012 23:00 Oatsmaster wrote:if 3 of them are scum, who credible is gonna push their cases for them? No one wins if no one votes for them beside themselves. Im just sad that my initial read on Toad was wrong 
Theoretically, the more of them that run the higher chances townies will pick one of them up to be elected.
And Syllo. I can also write 4 names and point fingers while conveniently claiming that I can change any name anytime I want because I haven't read the thread. If you're going to show up then do it right or don't bother.
|
Ok guys, just a quick comment regarding the last developments of the thread, I find that Prome is getting way too much heat for the all the role-related stuff. Arguments like "your role is imb4 for town, you must be scum" are wrong, just plain wrong.
Never trust Grey, right ?
Moreover, the events corroborate the story. So I don't see why we should doubt this at this point.
Regarding Acro, I personally think that he is taking too much heat, even if not wanting to be in the party seems suspicious at first sight. I would say it's role or ability related (his own ability or targeted by another player). And like, there are players whose behavior is not acceptable at all.
For example, let's say that Toad, VE, Adam and S&B are the mafia players left. They would have nothing do to and could just watch the town atmosphere rotten. There are too many damn lurkers and I hate this because we have nothing for or against them !
Anyway, I have decided to step up and I'm going to officially announce that I'm going to inflict some damage tonight, and it's going to be one player among iamp, S&B, VE and Adam. I have not been using this since the beginning of this game so it's gonna hurt. Be warned.
I would like anyone who is pissed off by their attitude (seriously Adam, you and your "I'm lurking and I assume" attitude, I hope that you are going to die tonight), to join me and to inflict some damage on these players. I'm on this for real and I would guess that some other players would have no problem to join me as well 
Any ability you have to pressure the fucking lurkers (ie not using against the mafia), just use it against them, for the future sake of the town and also to teach them how to play.
Who is in ?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 26 2012 23:27 risk.nuke wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:00 Oatsmaster wrote:if 3 of them are scum, who credible is gonna push their cases for them? No one wins if no one votes for them beside themselves. Im just sad that my initial read on Toad was wrong Theoretically, the more of them that run the higher chances townies will pick one of them up to be elected. And Syllo. I can also write 4 names and point fingers while conveniently claiming that I can change any name anytime I want because I haven't read the thread. If you're going to show up then do it right or don't bother.
I actually agree with this. At the moment I trust my judgement over everyone else's including syllo, as he's gone all conspiracy on us.
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 26 2012 23:28 Djodref wrote:Ok guys, just a quick comment regarding the last developments of the thread, I find that Prome is getting way too much heat for the all the role-related stuff. Arguments like "your role is imb4 for town, you must be scum" are wrong, just plain wrong. Never trust Grey, right ? Moreover, the events corroborate the story. So I don't see why we should doubt this at this point. Regarding Acro, I personally think that he is taking too much heat, even if not wanting to be in the party seems suspicious at first sight. I would say it's role or ability related (his own ability or targeted by another player). And like, there are players whose behavior is not acceptable at all. For example, let's say that Toad, VE, Adam and S&B are the mafia players left. They would have nothing do to and could just watch the town atmosphere rotten. There are too many damn lurkers and I hate this because we have nothing for or against them ! Anyway, I have decided to step up and I'm going to officially announce that I'm going to inflict some damage tonight, and it's going to be one player among iamp, S&B, VE and Adam. I have not been using this since the beginning of this game so it's gonna hurt. Be warned. I would like anyone who is pissed off by their attitude (seriously Adam, you and your "I'm lurking and I assume" attitude, I hope that you are going to die tonight), to join me and to inflict some damage on these players. I'm on this for real and I would guess that some other players would have no problem to join me as well Any ability you have to pressure the fucking lurkers (ie not using against the mafia), just use it against them, for the future sake of the town and also to teach them how to play.Who is in ?
please don't hit s&b, I've metad him town for the moment.
|
On November 26 2012 23:28 Djodref wrote:Ok guys, just a quick comment regarding the last developments of the thread, I find that Prome is getting way too much heat for the all the role-related stuff. Arguments like "your role is imb4 for town, you must be scum" are wrong, just plain wrong. Never trust Grey, right ? Moreover, the events corroborate the story. So I don't see why we should doubt this at this point. Regarding Acro, I personally think that he is taking too much heat, even if not wanting to be in the party seems suspicious at first sight. I would say it's role or ability related (his own ability or targeted by another player). And like, there are players whose behavior is not acceptable at all. For example, let's say that Toad, VE, Adam and S&B are the mafia players left. They would have nothing do to and could just watch the town atmosphere rotten. There are too many damn lurkers and I hate this because we have nothing for or against them ! Anyway, I have decided to step up and I'm going to officially announce that I'm going to inflict some damage tonight, and it's going to be one player among iamp, S&B, VE and Adam. I have not been using this since the beginning of this game so it's gonna hurt. Be warned. I would like anyone who is pissed off by their attitude (seriously Adam, you and your "I'm lurking and I assume" attitude, I hope that you are going to die tonight), to join me and to inflict some damage on these players. I'm on this for real and I would guess that some other players would have no problem to join me as well Any ability you have to pressure the fucking lurkers (ie not using against the mafia), just use it against them, for the future sake of the town and also to teach them how to play.Who is in ?
yeah I hate lurkers and killing them over confirmed mafia is good play.../sarcasm
Djo: you aren't an idiot, don't play like one. A vig shot on a confirmed scum player is great that means to lynch the scummy lurkers we'll need a discussion and cases an no god damn sheep votes.
|
I've very strong reasons for considering Prom mafia, so how about directing your damage that way. Also you are just plain wrong in saying that whether his role seems ridiculous or not is irrelevant, just like you were yesterday when you were telling everyone how wrong they were about sandroba.
If you are town, how about not arguing against me every single day
|
On November 26 2012 23:30 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 23:27 risk.nuke wrote:On November 26 2012 23:00 Oatsmaster wrote:if 3 of them are scum, who credible is gonna push their cases for them? No one wins if no one votes for them beside themselves. Im just sad that my initial read on Toad was wrong Theoretically, the more of them that run the higher chances townies will pick one of them up to be elected. And Syllo. I can also write 4 names and point fingers while conveniently claiming that I can change any name anytime I want because I haven't read the thread. If you're going to show up then do it right or don't bother. I actually agree with this. At the moment I trust my judgement over everyone else's including syllo, as he's gone all conspiracy on us.
to confirm: you still think Syllo is town, right? Just crazy?
|
On November 26 2012 23:34 syllogism wrote:
I've very strong reasons for considering Prom mafia, so how about directing your damage that way. Also you are just plain wrong in saying that whether his role seems ridiculous or not is irrelevant, just like you were yesterday when you were telling everyone how wrong they were about sandroba.
If you are town, how about not arguing against me every single day
If you are town, how about not being a fucking idiot. You don't have strong reasons or you would make a case instead of having feelings.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
