|
lol what? You need to read more.
I'm not voting you because you disagreed with me, I'm voting you because you are seeing things that aren't there aka misrepresenting my position on the issue. You have noticed that you are not the only person that has disagreed with me correct?
Dragon isn't even on my train, more so he's chilling at the boarding station deciding whether or not to buy a ticket to WinvVille with me.
But why so sketchy bro?
He hasn't even placed a vote on you
|
And actually, you've agreed that Random Lynch is a better way to start than intelligently choosing a target based on your suspicions. You've agreed with EVERYTHING that Ace has said actually.
Why are you lying?
|
Then why do you say I'm on the Ace train? The only relationship I have with Ace is that we both have called you scummy. I was the first to do so because his initial post in wanting to lynch you and palmar was a joke. So if there's any train ... Ace is on my train.
|
Please show me where I think random lynch is better. PLEASE. I would love to see this.
|
So VisceraEyes if your so against random lynch what would be your alternative? Sit around and do nothing while scum picks us off at night? Can you provide a better option backed up with reasoning other then "NO THATS BAD!!!!!"?
|
And yes VisceraEyes, it does look like your making stuff up and putting them in people's mouths. It's quite annoying actually, and it hasn't even happened to me yet.
|
Uh, aprudds...my suggestion was to scum-hunt...you know, play the game? Decide who's scummiest and lynch them? That's been my suggestion all along. When did I say 'NO THAT'S BAD!!!!'? It's not bad - I'll concede that it has about a 25% success rate. But I won't agree to it here because there's no need.
Ace just wants to. That's why it's being considered.
|
[B]On July 22 2011 12:17 Ace wrote:[/B Relative to a setup with no power roles? Isn't that self explanatory?
Maybe this will clear it up:
I'm operating under the assumption that we are in a setup with Vanilla Town vs some combination of Mafia so we don't have to rely on Power Roles. However if one does pop up then we narrow down the setup possibilities.
Does that help?
Actually, I realized you probably misunderstood my post. What i was wondering is: In what way would we be in a better position d2, in the medic only setup, if we RL d1 and kill a townie?
|
On July 22 2011 12:31 aprudds wrote: So VisceraEyes if your so against random lynch what would be your alternative? Sit around and do nothing while scum picks us off at night? Can you provide a better option backed up with reasoning other then "NO THATS BAD!!!!!"?
I don't really like this post. I don't really have anything concrete either. I mean this looks so scummy it can't actually be scummy right?
|
On July 22 2011 12:29 DragonReborn422 wrote: Please show me where I think random lynch is better. PLEASE. I would love to see this.
This is accurate - every post you've been VERY clear that you have NO opinion whatsoever.
Thanks for bringing that up.
|
On July 22 2011 12:34 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On July 22 2011 12:29 DragonReborn422 wrote: Please show me where I think random lynch is better. PLEASE. I would love to see this. This is accurate - every post you've been VERY clear that you have NO opinion whatsoever. Thanks for bringing that up.
Not trying to be mean....but a couple of people have already accused me of doing this or saying this or that. I keep having to repeat myself because you guys don't take the time to read the post thoroughly. If there is something confusing, I will be more than happy to explain.
|
On July 22 2011 12:33 Jacinto wrote:Show nested quote +[B]On July 22 2011 12:17 Ace wrote:[/B Relative to a setup with no power roles? Isn't that self explanatory?
Maybe this will clear it up:
I'm operating under the assumption that we are in a setup with Vanilla Town vs some combination of Mafia so we don't have to rely on Power Roles. However if one does pop up then we narrow down the setup possibilities.
Does that help? Actually, I realized you probably misunderstood my post. What i was wondering is: In what way would we be in a better position d2, in the medic only setup, if we RL d1 and kill a townie?
Not much better if the medic doesn't save someone Night 1. Of course this is ignoring everything else going in regards to the RL discussion. We'd still have no idea what setup we'd be in and down a Townie.
Just to further my point though: I'm in the game assuming "worst case scenario" is where we start - that being all Vanilla vs 3 scum.
|
On July 22 2011 12:37 Ace wrote: Not much better if the medic doesn't save someone Night 1. Of course this is ignoring everything else going in regards to the RL discussion. We'd still have no idea what setup we'd be in and down a Townie.
Yeah, that's what i mean. RL could be an option, since we've actuelly got 25% chance to gain from it(assuming we lynch a townie, which is likely that we will), but only as last resort. But I understand you're no longer(and maybe have never been) for a straight up RL.
|
On July 22 2011 12:33 VisceraEyes wrote: Uh, aprudds...my suggestion was to scum-hunt...you know, play the game? Decide who's scummiest and lynch them? That's been my suggestion all along. When did I say 'NO THAT'S BAD!!!!'? It's not bad - I'll concede that it has about a 25% success rate. But I won't agree to it here because there's no need.
Ace just wants to. That's why it's being considered. Then go scum hunt. Why are you getting so worked up over something pointless? Do you honestly believe people will go for a random lynch if you have solid evidence against someone? I think you just have a bone to pick with ace and are trying to find any excuse to point at him.
|
On July 22 2011 12:45 Jacinto wrote:Show nested quote +On July 22 2011 12:37 Ace wrote: Not much better if the medic doesn't save someone Night 1. Of course this is ignoring everything else going in regards to the RL discussion. We'd still have no idea what setup we'd be in and down a Townie.
Yeah, that's what i mean. RL could be an option, since we've actuelly got 25% chance to gain from it(assuming we lynch a townie, which is likely that we will), but only as last resort. But I understand you're no longer(and maybe have never been) for a straight up RL.
never have been, I've got more in the pot I'm just waiting on more people to post. If we do go with a RL it won't be straight up that's for sure.
|
@Ace:
Does the 3 day rule apply to you? If you're still alive on day3 you're a mafia?
|
Even if it did, if I was Mafia what do you think my answer would be?
|
your answer should be the same regardless of your role presumably. and thus you should be telling the truth.
|
Right, so obviously the answer would be "No" no matter my alignment - agreed?
|
if "no" is the truth then that's fine. i'm honestly too lazy to go dig up other games and to see the meta and stuff of what's going on. the people that have played with you can also tell...
|
|
|
|