|
The seeding system was always stupid for me. Not because foreigners couldn't compete, because some of them honestly can.
It's that the system basically says "You can play in the GSL. Now, uproot yourself, move to Korea, and we'll have you play your first match before you've even settled down".
Given actual time to practice and adjust themselves, a good number of foreigners have managed to settle themselves into the GSL tournaments fairly well (meaning not losing to every Korean they play against).
|
Stop giving seeds, I want too see some more over the shoulder shakey cam video diaries from Artosis following a plucky foreigner attempt to qualify for Code A.
|
i think you should earn your spot like any other player .
|
Code A only, keep it competitive and fair for everyone.
|
I think they seed foreigners for business reasons. More people will buy season tickets if a foreigner plays. This, however, is detrimental to the quality of the tournament.
|
The reason why no one complains in Korea, is because it's good for Esports overall to add foreign support. Not like it matters to the Koreans anyways, they don't feel threatened by foreigner play right now anyways. So if it's going to increase funding, support, awarness, etc for SC2 in Korea, why not let a few foreigners in? I know I would fully support it being a Korean Pro gamer. Lets also not forget that allowing foreigner play in Korea has also transitioned to allowing average Korean players to come back to the States (etc), to become 'well known' players, when they never could do it in Korea. I think it works both ways and is great for Esports all together.
|
I wouldn't mind if they could play at Code S level...
|
I like the idea behind the seeds but make it a qualifier of some sort perhaps the best non GSL player that make it through a MLG season can earn a spot? LOL + Show Spoiler +renew the MLG exhange program
|
Up&Downs feels about right, otherwise they'd play only 2 games at Code A and then leave already. It's not easy to live at another country, so it would turn into a 1 month chance I think. I am not sure how it works.
|
Give Code A spots - but just to the very best of them.
|
Code S is another world for now, way out of reach of foreigners. If they get seeded into Code S, they're just going to be embarassed. Code A seeds however are acceptable.
|
On February 01 2012 07:40 rafaliusz wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2012 03:27 Zyphen wrote:On February 01 2012 02:39 iky43210 wrote: Huk and idra are not the only foreigner in gsl... there are still hopes.
Sen, morrow, xigua, macseed, and hero are still in it! they can still make it to code S When people say "foreigners", they really mean "white dudes". Of those, only morrow qualifies as such. You can go through dozens of posts without Sen and foreigner being mentioned in the same sentence, if at all. "White dudes" do not see Sen as their representative. It's just the truth. That being said; good job Sen! I'm rooting for you. Sen's been a part of our foreign scene and has been participating in out events for roughly 10 years. You may not remember that tho.He is a foreigner by all means and he represents me. Agree on the chinese part tho, their scene always been separated from foreign one but I'm still interested how would chinese players do against koreans.
Huh? You realize Sen is chinese right? And chinese aren't "foreigners"? I know what you're trying to say but cognitive dissonance permeates throughout the board on this subject.
Sen is more acceptable to most people because he speaks English and participates in more western events (especially in recent years) than other pros from China/Taiwan. Someone like Select is accepted similarly along those lines. Though, if you read enough posts, you'll realize there's a fine distinction made by most people, which sometimes get spelled out by the more honest (Select is ethnically Korean). If you truly believe Sen represents "foreigners", you're in the minority along with me. Congratulations for having, in my opinion, a more enlightened view.
Take the reaction to today's results for example. The vast majority of comments both here and in the GSL thread are about how Huk and Idra lost, not how Sen won. I guarantee you that people would be much less gloomy if say Sen and Huk lost and Idra won. Don't be naive. Take a look at who make up the fan bases, how big their fanclubs are, and how many people even choose to acknowledge Sen's accomplishments for the foreign scene vs an Idra or Huk or Jinro or Naniwa, etc... I posed a question about people's responses to Loner (chinese player) back in GSL's infancy and I got some very honest responses (which I appreciate). If you care to read them, they're probably still attached to my post history. People identify by race/ethnicity, culture, and language, in that order.
|
Code A seeds is the best option IMO, it'll allow foreigners a chance to compete in the GSL without seeming overly undeserving.
Nothing against Idra or Sen, but they (Idra especially) haven't been showing the greatest play as of late and if anything their poor performance in code S (and A for Idra) is proof of that.
|
In my opinion, not too many foreigners are at the same level as Koreans. Look at todays Code A results... I think It's a marketing stategy more then anything.. More foreigners in GSL more interest among the fans.
|
On February 01 2012 00:44 pStar wrote:+ Show Spoiler +stop giving foreigners seeds. We are terrible. Just look at HuK and idrAs play today. wasn't even close to the Korean's they were playing ( to be fairt hough, Sen played reasonably well)
May seem harsh, but just my opinion.
I don't think it's fair to say that IdrA's play was not even close to Avenge's. Avenge all-in'd him twice. We didn't get to see the results of the lategame training that IdrA has been doing, and to be fair, IdrA's strength is in long games, not defending crazy warp prism all ins.
|
On February 01 2012 07:48 Fus wrote:Stop seeding foreigners, it's racism 
I find it funny. I'm against affirmative action in principle but this whole thing just amuses me to no end. Who says white dudes get the short end of the stick? Take a look at Berkeley right after they dropped racial quotas. It just exploded with Asians. My Indian friend is pissed he got wait-listed by Harvard because they still incorporate that archaic practice.
|
So are Huk and Idra leaving Korea or are they going to try to Jinro it back to GSL? I think the problem with the whole foreigner thing -- as someone else pointed out in this thread -- is that foreigners lack the infrastructure to just go and sit around on the Korean ladder for 6 months before actually playing a televised game. And if that is the reality then why not go back to NA where the pickings are easy and they can finish top 10 at an MLG, especially if the best Koreans dont come out because of GSL commitments, and collect a steady paycheck and a successful stream revenue? As semi-pro streamers like Destiny show its possible to make a pretty solid revenue stream without ever actually being a consistently good player.
|
On February 01 2012 08:49 Zyphen wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2012 07:40 rafaliusz wrote:On February 01 2012 03:27 Zyphen wrote:On February 01 2012 02:39 iky43210 wrote: Huk and idra are not the only foreigner in gsl... there are still hopes.
Sen, morrow, xigua, macseed, and hero are still in it! they can still make it to code S When people say "foreigners", they really mean "white dudes". Of those, only morrow qualifies as such. You can go through dozens of posts without Sen and foreigner being mentioned in the same sentence, if at all. "White dudes" do not see Sen as their representative. It's just the truth. That being said; good job Sen! I'm rooting for you. Sen's been a part of our foreign scene and has been participating in out events for roughly 10 years. You may not remember that tho.He is a foreigner by all means and he represents me. Agree on the chinese part tho, their scene always been separated from foreign one but I'm still interested how would chinese players do against koreans. Huh? You realize Sen is chinese right? And chinese aren't "foreigners"? I know what you're trying to say but cognitive dissonance permeates throughout the board on this subject. Sen is more acceptable to most people because he speaks English and participates in more western events (especially in recent years) than other pros from China/Taiwan. Someone like Select is accepted similarly along those lines. Though, if you read enough posts, you'll realize there's a fine distinction made by most people, which sometimes get spelled out by the more honest (Select is ethnically Korean). If you truly believe Sen represents "foreigners", you're in the minority along with me. Congratulations for having, in my opinion, a more enlightened view. Take the reaction to today's results for example. The vast majority of comments both here and in the GSL thread are about how Huk and Idra lost, not how Sen won. I guarantee you that people would be much less gloomy if say Sen and Huk lost and Idra won. Don't be naive. Take a look at who make up the fan bases, how big their fanclubs are, and how many people even choose to acknowledge Sen's accomplishments for the foreign scene vs an Idra or Huk or Jinro or Naniwa, etc... I posed a question about people's responses to Loner (chinese player) back in GSL's infancy and I got some very honest responses (which I appreciate). If you care to read them, they're probably still attached to my post history. People identify by race/ethnicity, culture, and language, in that order.
Sen is Taiwanese
|
On February 01 2012 09:01 Sub40APM wrote: So are Huk and Idra leaving Korea or are they going to try to Jinro it back to GSL? I think the problem with the whole foreigner thing -- as someone else pointed out in this thread -- is that foreigners lack the infrastructure to just go and sit around on the Korean ladder for 6 months before actually playing a televised game. And if that is the reality then why not go back to NA where the pickings are easy and they can finish top 10 at an MLG, especially if the best Koreans dont come out because of GSL commitments, and collect a steady paycheck and a successful stream revenue? As semi-pro streamers like Destiny show its possible to make a pretty solid revenue stream without ever actually being a consistently good player. I'm pretty sure Idra is moving back and Huk is staying. Idra didn't want to stay in Korea long-term any ways.
|
On February 01 2012 09:02 Dexington wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2012 08:49 Zyphen wrote:On February 01 2012 07:40 rafaliusz wrote:On February 01 2012 03:27 Zyphen wrote:On February 01 2012 02:39 iky43210 wrote: Huk and idra are not the only foreigner in gsl... there are still hopes.
Sen, morrow, xigua, macseed, and hero are still in it! they can still make it to code S When people say "foreigners", they really mean "white dudes". Of those, only morrow qualifies as such. You can go through dozens of posts without Sen and foreigner being mentioned in the same sentence, if at all. "White dudes" do not see Sen as their representative. It's just the truth. That being said; good job Sen! I'm rooting for you. Sen's been a part of our foreign scene and has been participating in out events for roughly 10 years. You may not remember that tho.He is a foreigner by all means and he represents me. Agree on the chinese part tho, their scene always been separated from foreign one but I'm still interested how would chinese players do against koreans. Huh? You realize Sen is chinese right? And chinese aren't "foreigners"? I know what you're trying to say but cognitive dissonance permeates throughout the board on this subject. Sen is more acceptable to most people because he speaks English and participates in more western events (especially in recent years) than other pros from China/Taiwan. Someone like Select is accepted similarly along those lines. Though, if you read enough posts, you'll realize there's a fine distinction made by most people, which sometimes get spelled out by the more honest (Select is ethnically Korean). If you truly believe Sen represents "foreigners", you're in the minority along with me. Congratulations for having, in my opinion, a more enlightened view. Take the reaction to today's results for example. The vast majority of comments both here and in the GSL thread are about how Huk and Idra lost, not how Sen won. I guarantee you that people would be much less gloomy if say Sen and Huk lost and Idra won. Don't be naive. Take a look at who make up the fan bases, how big their fanclubs are, and how many people even choose to acknowledge Sen's accomplishments for the foreign scene vs an Idra or Huk or Jinro or Naniwa, etc... I posed a question about people's responses to Loner (chinese player) back in GSL's infancy and I got some very honest responses (which I appreciate). If you care to read them, they're probably still attached to my post history. People identify by race/ethnicity, culture, and language, in that order. Sen is Taiwanese
Right, like that makes all the difference. Thank you for missing the point completely.
And for the record, he's about as different from a "Chinese" person as a North Korean is from a South Korean. Same ethnicity, culture, and language with a different form of government. Whoop-dee-doo. There's a bigger difference between the Irish, Scots, and Welsh.
|
|
|
|