On May 06 2004 17:16 PuertoRican wrote:
as for Rivc, Keir, Trunkz, i never played any of them nor seen them.

but i'll make a return to bw to play them if they are really that good.

You sound pretty confident. I'd put 5 bucks on Darki.

NerO

United States2071 Posts

May 06 2004 09:32 GMT

#122

ok rek goes to the top of my list and i'll bump off bigballs ^^

GoDHovZ

United States1869 Posts

May 06 2004 09:49 GMT

#123

--- Nuked ---

Dirk

United States1339 Posts

May 06 2004 10:01 GMT

#124

Darki? Wtf? This kids supposed to be good? Last i remember of him was beating him like 5-0 and he'd bitch about it. Then after id stop playing a few days he'd catch up to me in rank and then ask for a re. He sux.

XaI)CyRiC

United States4471 Posts

May 06 2004 10:02 GMT

#125

"A is better than B, although I admit that I have seen a substantially larger amount of A's replays than B's and have very little idea of how good B actually is (or even A admittedly). It may be an ignorant judgment, but hey it's just an opinion and therefore it doesn't matter if it's an ill-informed one. A's play is MORE impressive, but that's somehow different from saying that B's is LESS impressive and therefore inferior."

That seems to be Hasuwar's interpretation of Twitt's comments is. I fail to see why criticism is unwarranted. Why is his opinion on the relative skill of two players any more valid than my opinion of his opinion? Why should people be able to post on topics they have limited knowledge of and not have the weaknesses of their posts exposed?

Oh and I also agree that your analogy to basketball was a pretty weak one.

Dirk

United States1339 Posts

May 06 2004 10:05 GMT

#126

And about these top P's being listed. I think id be up there if i hadnt of quit.. cuz i remember playing with saddles and big balls (who are considered 2 of usa's best) and ofcourse they're good but back then I was same level as both. Obviously they're probably much better now though after about a year.

Mora

Canada5235 Posts

May 06 2004 10:13 GMT

#127

But no one knows how good any1 is.

I'm the best zerg outside of korea.

Not a single person on these forums can say otherwise: none of you know how good i am.

Every1 is equally as ignorant about skill as every1 else. You can't not be influenced by the people you play with most. The difference is that most people will value opinions of 'good' players *because they are thought of as good*. It doesn't mean that the good player's RIGHT though.

The guy admitted that he based his opinion off of his own experiences - and you people rag on him for it. The difference between him and the rest of you is that he is *admitting* to his ignorance, while the rest of you are naive enough to think that YOUR not ignorant.

----

These lists aren't pointless because skill is subjective. The only way you can 'prove' ones skill, is to observe their performance. At the same time, we all know that one's performance isn't necesarrily a true reflection of ones skill. ie: i am 2-0 with Trek. But i, and everyone else, know that i am nowhere near his level of skill.

----

On that note, i'd like to add that i think im top 10 zerg in NA. I'm assuming Day is better (because he's #1 on every1's list, and i've never played him). I've never seen Cocoa play, or have played him, so i will give him the benefit of the doubt and put him at #2 (being that he also gets alot of votes). Paul can't not be on the list. He's better than day and cocoa imo, but again, 'i dont know shit', cause i've never seen Day play.

After that, i don't believe there are any top zerg players. So i will put myself somewhere between 4 and 10. (just incase there might be some unknown gosu's).

Twitt

United States733 Posts

May 06 2004 10:41 GMT

#128

Look at what I started. =/

Sigh, if you feel that way about what I said, like I told Rek, everyone is entitled to their opinion so you can believe that, but I can continue to believe what I said as well.

Sadist

United States7328 Posts

May 06 2004 11:07 GMT

#129

theres these morons posting past usa players, when its supposed to be current. Then theres the morons arguing for canada, then theres the morons posting about whos good and who isnt when they are in no position to judge anyones skill. Lastly theres the dipshit who apparently thinks Testie has accomplished alot of things, then he thinks these latin american players will beat me. You are full of shit. Please take your garbage somewhere else. Next time someone makes a thread like this, please explain that it is CURRENt or PAST, and it is for 1 SPECIFIC country.

Also dumbass newbies shouldnt be allowed to post their opinions, as they dont matter and just lead to arguements.

Also morons like veg who are extremely cocky along with being extremely mentally handicapped shouldnt be able to express their opinions either O:

Countdown

1217 Posts

May 06 2004 11:13 GMT

#130

hey now settle down

Orlandu

China2450 Posts

May 06 2004 11:20 GMT

#131

On May 06 2004 19:13 Teroru wrote:
But no one knows how good any1 is.

I'm the best zerg outside of korea.

Not a single person on these forums can say otherwise: none of you know how good i am.

Every1 is equally as ignorant about skill as every1 else. You can't not be influenced by the people you play with most. The difference is that most people will value opinions of 'good' players *because they are thought of as good*. It doesn't mean that the good player's RIGHT though.

The guy admitted that he based his opinion off of his own experiences - and you people rag on him for it. The difference between him and the rest of you is that he is *admitting* to his ignorance, while the rest of you are naive enough to think that YOUR not ignorant.

----

These lists aren't pointless because skill is subjective. The only way you can 'prove' ones skill, is to observe their performance. At the same time, we all know that one's performance isn't necesarrily a true reflection of ones skill. ie: i am 2-0 with Trek. But i, and everyone else, know that i am nowhere near his level of skill.

----

On that note, i'd like to add that i think im top 10 zerg in NA. I'm assuming Day is better (because he's #1 on every1's list, and i've never played him). I've never seen Cocoa play, or have played him, so i will give him the benefit of the doubt and put him at #2 (being that he also gets alot of votes). Paul can't not be on the list. He's better than day and cocoa imo, but again, 'i dont know shit', cause i've never seen Day play.

After that, i don't believe there are any top zerg players. So i will put myself somewhere between 4 and 10. (just incase there might be some unknown gosu's).

I liked that post. Very unbiased statements.

Mora

Canada5235 Posts

May 06 2004 11:22 GMT

#132

thank you orlandu

i value your opinion, and always have. *_*

for what its worth; in the gayest way possible: <3 !

PuertoRican

United States5709 Posts

May 06 2004 11:33 GMT

#133

On May 06 2004 18:24 Countdown wrote:

Show nested quote +

You sound pretty confident. I'd put 5 bucks on Darki.

get it set up, and we can do this paypal style

GoDHovZ

United States1869 Posts

May 06 2004 11:46 GMT

#134

--- Nuked ---

Countdown

1217 Posts

May 06 2004 11:46 GMT

#135

On May 06 2004 20:46 GoDHovZ wrote:
shit if u people want to bet money, ill bet that i can rape darki

yeah, you probably would. Probably wouldn't be a clean sweep though :O

Orlandu

China2450 Posts

May 06 2004 11:48 GMT

#136

On May 06 2004 20:22 Teroru wrote:
thank you orlandu

i value your opinion, and always have. *_*

for what its worth; in the gayest way possible: <3 !

GoDHovZ

United States1869 Posts

May 06 2004 11:48 GMT

#137

--- Nuked ---

PuertoRican

United States5709 Posts

May 06 2004 11:59 GMT

#138

On May 06 2004 20:46 GoDHovZ wrote:
shit if u people want to bet money, ill bet that i can rape darki

thats not the point hovz, we know you can beat him.

i on the other hand believe i can beat him again, even though i havnt gamed in 4 months, 5 if you dont count the ggl games i threw.

PuertoRican

United States5709 Posts

May 06 2004 12:01 GMT

#139

i mentioned having bets through tl.net to Meat b4, but he either didnt see it or didnt care.

maybe he would need a license, not sure.

i love betting though, so we can bet on some games, wcg, etc.