Grack starts off with a list of hard town reads that kinda show that he isn’t really thinking critically because it’s way too early to have that much confidence. He also never talks about these people again other than listing it in a spoilered list post that he never expects anyone to read
He randomly points out ace’a post and never comes back to it or even refers to it when he’s talking about tubesock or tumble wood being mafia, even though coincidentally it lines up with his only two scumreads at the time
He also didn’t vote for himself for mayor really early on.
His reasoning for choosing Palmar assumes that Palmar is town already and there is 0 doubt in his mind whether Palmar is town, only that he has a good chance to lynch mafia
On March 05 2019 03:00 Trfel wrote: Was making a list post but I don't like Fecalfeast, thoughts?
FecalFeast - Perfect example of being present and being suspicious of people while not actually pushing anything. This post in particular. But throughout his play, being suspicious of general thread suspects without actually showing investment in that, all he cares about doing is asking to be mayor despite his only mayoral vote being himself.
What is it with people reappearing in the thread after being absent for 24h or so and appearing completely clueless to anything that happened since their disappearance. There's no way trfel has read the thread. Surely this case was predetermined to be his reentry into the thread. Like.. WTF?
On March 04 2019 03:35 Fecalfeast wrote: catchup and reads post
I think LS is mafia
I think rayn and HF are town but I have a stronger townread on rayn because HF is acting sneaky
rsoul was giving me mafia vibes but every time I would try to make anote on a quote for her it petered out so neutral until I can find my words?
I dislike acrofales just pointing at lurkers and agreeing with people. Seems not only lazy but trying to seem not lazy so mafia
palmar is lowkey playing on a weekend and that's suspicious
yes a number of my points are rehashes of things in rayns big post because I agreed with it
damdred is scum but maybe not
sentinel didn't say he read his role pm and I don't want to vote HF or palmar as mayor VOTE FOR ME AS MAYOR I AM TOWN AND WILL NOT BE SWAYED BY EVIL MAFIA FORCES THIS GAME
On March 03 2019 06:39 Holyflare wrote: If you don't comment on a really obvious inconsistency I'll be sad.
I agree Oatsmaster's play has been quite subpar so far, and I agree that his assessment of your play this game is awful. However maybe I'm wrong in this but I don't feel like his play is mafia-motivated at all. I don't really think mafia would want to enter the thread late and use a bunch of garbage reasons to push suspicion at people, including people like you who are quite likely to respond and respond with a lot of weight. It would be an exceptionally stupid move.
Maybe it's dumb but that makes me actually not want to lynch Oatsmaster right now. Or was there something else you were referring to?
honestly one of my least favourite posts in the game
This reads as a towbie post. He even added some quotes in a spoiler. Townies keep things organosed to solve the game. Why is that a mafia post that shows mafia sentiment????????????
as lukewarm as Wiggles is being, I have eerie feelings about Tubesock that I did in my first game back that he ended up endgaming win as mafia. I'll meta check his filter and see if I still feel icky
On March 05 2019 03:03 Koshi wrote: Tfrel you enter the thread with a complete new read. Again no continuity with earlier posts. Why is there such disconnect in your filter?
Maybe that things change over the (iirc) 36+ hours since I last posted? Maybe because I did some more reading and have some new thoughts?
If you want continuity, here's my sicklucker read (null): sicklucker+ Show Spoiler +
His play still feels like mafia to me but I also think he'd be more invested as mafia in particular, I'd like to wait to see him get more involved before making a decision.
Simply put, I find Fecalfeast much more likely to be mafia than sicklucker, I'd like to wait on sicklucker for a while. We can discuss this further if you would like but I would appreciate it if you took a look at Fecalfeast.
On March 05 2019 03:06 Oatsmaster wrote: I also like how trefel says that his vote on me was a pressure vote even though nobody asked lol.
Plenty of people (Vivax, sicklucker, Mocsta, etc) have been calling me suspicious for changing my vote really easily upon request. I feel it deserves an explanation. Though I also felt it was obvious enough initially, but it is what it is.
On March 05 2019 03:03 Koshi wrote: Tfrel you enter the thread with a complete new read. Again no continuity with earlier posts. Why is there such disconnect in your filter?
Maybe that things change over the (iirc) 36+ hours since I last posted? Maybe because I did some more reading and have some new thoughts?
If you want continuity, here's my sicklucker read (null): sicklucker+ Show Spoiler +
His play still feels like mafia to me but I also think he'd be more invested as mafia in particular, I'd like to wait to see him get more involved before making a decision.
Simply put, I find Fecalfeast much more likely to be mafia than sicklucker, I'd like to wait on sicklucker for a while. We can discuss this further if you would like but I would appreciate it if you took a look at Fecalfeast.
I did. Your read sucks unless you van proof to me why mafia fefe made this post or why it is more likely mafia fefe made that post over a townie fefe.
Just quoting a lost post and yell fake news does not sway me.
On March 05 2019 03:03 Koshi wrote: Tfrel you enter the thread with a complete new read. Again no continuity with earlier posts. Why is there such disconnect in your filter?
Maybe that things change over the (iirc) 36+ hours since I last posted? Maybe because I did some more reading and have some new thoughts?
If you want continuity, here's my sicklucker read (null): sicklucker+ Show Spoiler +
His play still feels like mafia to me but I also think he'd be more invested as mafia in particular, I'd like to wait to see him get more involved before making a decision.
Simply put, I find Fecalfeast much more likely to be mafia than sicklucker, I'd like to wait on sicklucker for a while. We can discuss this further if you would like but I would appreciate it if you took a look at Fecalfeast.
How can your catching up over 36h result in a single goddamn post about fefe????
On March 05 2019 03:06 Oatsmaster wrote: I also like how trefel says that his vote on me was a pressure vote even though nobody asked lol.
Plenty of people (Vivax, sicklucker, Mocsta, etc) have been calling me suspicious for changing my vote really easily upon request. I feel it deserves an explanation. Though I also felt it was obvious enough initially, but it is what it is.
I didn't call you suspicious for changing your vote easily.
On March 05 2019 03:06 Oatsmaster wrote: I also like how trefel says that his vote on me was a pressure vote even though nobody asked lol.
Plenty of people (Vivax, sicklucker, Mocsta, etc) have been calling me suspicious for changing my vote really easily upon request. I feel it deserves an explanation. Though I also felt it was obvious enough initially, but it is what it is.
I didn't call you suspicious for changing your vote easily.
@ Conversion
Why is Trfel not an option for you?
mostly cause I didn't read his filter yet
I'm chasing a tubesock thing right now and it's becoming a nagging thing in my head but it seems to be only a tone thing and idk how good my meta read on him is
On March 05 2019 03:06 Oatsmaster wrote: I also like how trefel says that his vote on me was a pressure vote even though nobody asked lol.
Plenty of people (Vivax, sicklucker, Mocsta, etc) have been calling me suspicious for changing my vote really easily upon request. I feel it deserves an explanation. Though I also felt it was obvious enough initially, but it is what it is.
On March 05 2019 03:03 Koshi wrote: Tfrel you enter the thread with a complete new read. Again no continuity with earlier posts. Why is there such disconnect in your filter?
Maybe that things change over the (iirc) 36+ hours since I last posted? Maybe because I did some more reading and have some new thoughts?
If you want continuity, here's my sicklucker read (null): sicklucker+ Show Spoiler +
His play still feels like mafia to me but I also think he'd be more invested as mafia in particular, I'd like to wait to see him get more involved before making a decision.
Simply put, I find Fecalfeast much more likely to be mafia than sicklucker, I'd like to wait on sicklucker for a while. We can discuss this further if you would like but I would appreciate it if you took a look at Fecalfeast.
How can your catching up over 36h result in a single goddamn post about fefe????
One of 23h ago. Holy fuckkkkk this smells like lurking mafia who found a post he could comment on x hours ago and kept it for a rainy day or something.
Really. Explain this fefe post again and why it is scummy.