|
On March 08 2012 12:22 k2hd wrote: Although I do find it amusing that DoYouHas chose the wrong person to believe when Nightfury and I both posted our newbie/no time defenses XD
I think because I got to it first. xD
|
Third night we were considering a lot of options, but we ended up going "safe" as we had several fake-claim plans ready, and we didn't want to take a risk that you would have not died if you were the Veteran.
I think on N2 we roleblocked you again since we really weren't sure of a target, although we were suspecting that k2hd and ghost were the most likely blues out of the remaining people. It could have turned against you (a very small possibility), so I guess that was a minor point too.
|
Obs QT please?
|
On March 08 2012 12:22 Cephiro wrote: Third night we were considering a lot of options, but we ended up going "safe" as we had several fake-claim plans ready, and we didn't want to take a risk that you would have not died if you were the Veteran.
I think on N2 we roleblocked you again since we really weren't sure of a target, although we were suspecting that k2hd and ghost were the most likely blues out of the remaining people. It could have turned against you (a very small possibility), so I guess that was a minor point too.
Not to mention a large number of hilarious suicide strategies. LOL.
|
Actions List
Day 1 No lynch
Night 1 Mafia shoots Janaan JekyllandHyde roleblocks zelblade k2hd checks Chocolate nttea protects Alderan
Day 2 gumshoe is lynched
Night 2 Mafia shoots nttea JekyllAndHyde roleblocks zelblade k2hd checks Alderan
Day 3 Alderan is lynched
Night 3 Mafia shoots zelblade JekyllAndHyde roleblocks zelblade k2hd checks slOosh
Day 4 Chocolate is lynched
Links to the QTs, for anyone who is interested:
Observers' QT Mafia's QT
|
On March 08 2012 12:22 ghost_403 wrote: @zelblade I think shooting anyone would have pushed the town into MYLO a day sooner. Day 3, it was 5 townies, 4 scum. If I had mishot the night before, the game would have been over. Now, Night 2 on the other hand... Relying on the entire town to be on the same side in a lynch (especially when it's 5v4) is usually a losing bet. dreamflower and I were very surprised you didn't use your shot night 3.
|
On March 08 2012 12:22 NightFury wrote:Show nested quote +On March 08 2012 12:22 k2hd wrote: Although I do find it amusing that DoYouHas chose the wrong person to believe when Nightfury and I both posted our newbie/no time defenses XD I think because I got to it first. xD
I actually meant to point out to DoYouHas that I had posted something similar before you, just in a more abbreviated form when alderan grew suspicious of me, but I forgot to do it
|
@ghost
Yes but the lynch can be manipulated by scum easily. Which is why you should have just shot who you thought was most likely to be scum =/
|
Also we asked about the exact voting deadline for a switch. Since I think that came up before.
|
Also why did the thread go severely inactive half the times I posted something. I somehow managed to silence the thread like three times o_O.
|
This was my second post in the Obs QT thread. My inactivity fucked us. I apologize town.
Scum imo:
Sloosh TestSubject Nightfury Phagga
|
gg guys. I'm really sorry about missing a few days in there.
|
Yeah, I played a poor vig. Lesson learned! At the expense of the town
|
And my one complaint with Alderan's list is that Jekyll wasn't in there :-)
I had trouble choosing between NightFury and Phagga, although NightFury had laughably horrible voting reasons. Especially the Gumshoe one that no-one noticed.
|
On March 08 2012 12:22 DoYouHas wrote: I don't quite comprehend you not claiming k2hd. You had a scumcheck on slOosh and a towncheck on Chocolate. You would have single handedly line every town up behind slOosh with your claim.
This was a combination of me taking a risk that I would have time to check up on the thread before deadline and claim and me believing that phagga and ghost were scum. When I saw that others had already posted a sloosh vote, I decided to leave the claim for next day. I pretty much agreed with your list near the end of it and was not expecting my town reads to ninja vote.
EDIT:
Basically I got greedy and wanted the chance to make one more check.
|
jaj22 on Obs QT wrote: I'd be surprised if there was a godfather going by standard balance. There was a 4/9 game recently with vig/DT/doc and no mafia power roles. This game has a roleblocker unless Zelblade is crazy.
My main concern with your scum team is Jekyll: He's a relatively experienced player (and ObsQT lurker), he's had no suspicion on him at all, and he's playing incredibly blue. So why is he still alive?
Sloosh's last post is pretty damn funny because it's so true. Whole bunch of reasoning-free votes and a town that's too scared of getting themselves lynched to scumhunt properly. The bastards keep lynching my best town reads.
I'd really love to know what the DT is doing. They'll probably get vigged tonight.
So the first time we are even mentioned in a suspicious light, is at the beginning of N3?
Alderan on Obs QT wrote: I have a tough time reading Jekyll because of the hydra, one of them has had a lot better analysis than the other. This makes me lean town, because with this quiet of a town, scum has plenty of time to make really good cases for the weaker of the 2.
So...who were you talking about there with the "better analysis"? >_>
Wait...
OBS QT; WHY Y NOT FOS US NOT EVEN A SINGLE TIME!!!????
Really? No players from the game FoSed us a single time; and no one from the Obs QT FoSes us either. Wtf? lol
I was making a bet with Ceph the other day (at the beginning of D3) about when players would FoS us for the first time He betted on halfway through D3, I betted on halfway through N3...
....we were both hilariously wrong >_>
DYH, may you explain why you thought we were town?
EDIT: Apart from that "You guys were blue!" thing. Ceph already explained that to me like 1000 times >_>
|
It looks like I gave the obsQT a bit of fleeting hope near the end there.
|
On March 08 2012 12:56 DoYouHas wrote: It looks like I gave the obsQT a bit of fleeting hope near the end there. You had the right idea but the town had to be unanimous. The problem is your list wasn't quite right and you didn't have everyone on board with your lynch target.
|
I really should have just focused on slOosh instead of giving out all my reads at that point.
|
On March 08 2012 12:59 Qatol wrote:Show nested quote +On March 08 2012 12:56 DoYouHas wrote: It looks like I gave the obsQT a bit of fleeting hope near the end there. You had the right idea but the town had to be unanimous. The problem is your list wasn't quite right and you didn't have everyone on board with your lynch target.
Considering he convinced 4/5 townies to vote sloosh (well, at least not k2), I'd say it wasn't a bad job.
Also Qatol, any thoughts about the game?
|
|
|
|