Newbie Mini Mafia IV - Page 55

On March 09 2012 03:52 DoYouHas wrote:
slOosh did a great job of controlling the thread without immediately being drawn out as scum.

NightFury played the hapless noob extremely well.

J&H confused the hell out of me (though I blame most of that on them being a hydra).

Phagga tunneled Chocolate a little too hard, though I blame myself for not bringing him around.

Alderan, I really should have just started pushing people who would have cleared you early. Right from the start I realized we were thinking pretty similarly. If I had taken action to get a town read on you I think we could have torn the thread up.

Ghost, when you posted those 2 quick posts after slOosh's defense, I decided you either just made a very very bad play or you were scum. They did sound rushed, they were contradictory, and they showed you sided with slOosh at that point. Whether or not that was true, that is how they came across. I didn't have a full case against you. But for me, just those 2 posts were enough. I should have realized that slOosh wouldn't have taken the risk of bussing you with his day1 case. But with how easily those suspicions were dropped by slOosh and Alderan, I thought slOosh might have been just being extra sneaky.

k2hd, the fact that you were not posting often and you were posting extremely safe put you on both my radar and Alderan's. It took a scum vouching for your innocence before we would believe you. The scum team had you pegged as the DT day4. You in all likelihood would have been hit that night even if we lynched correctly. If your schedule permits it you have to take a more active role if you want to avoid being hit for looking blue by scum.

gumshoe, it saddened me a bit to watch you get frustrated with the game and just start posting things that were wrong or had no benefit to the town. You showed last game that you can look at the game from a different angle, which is extremely valuable. Instead of looking at the lack of activity as a bad thing, take that opportunity when you know that the town isn't going to be posting new things that you need to respond to to read filters and generate content.

zelblade, you need to start siding with me over slOosh. This is the second game you have picked up his cause and then offered a weak case against me. I wanted to believe that you were town. But the way you pushed me felt so much like SNMM7 that I started getting suspicious, and it also reduced my suspicion of slOosh. You threw a monkey wrench in my understanding of the game.

Janaan, sad you got hit.

On March 09 2012 04:08 gonzaw wrote:
To be honest, we weren't technically a "hydra". It was more like I was replaced by Jekyll.

Until N2, I was the only one that posted
After N2, Jekyll was the only one that posted.

I don't think we ever interacted with each other or posted reads at the same time, except for that "We just disagree with some reads" comment that happened only twice.

So, trying to analyse us would be the same as analysing zelblade/4face for instance.

On March 09 2012 04:17 jaj22 wrote:
Note that on the last day, as the DT hadn't claimed, it was valid to assume that the DT was happy about the direction that the voting was going. Therefore all townies should have voted Sloosh regardless of their personal reads. I suspect that's why Ghost did.

Someone should have actually stated this during the last 24 hours. With no blue influence, town has near zero chance in a 4-10 setup, so even meta-DT logic is critical.

On March 09 2012 05:08 DoYouHas wrote:
With the lack of a vig hit night 3 and with a roleblocker in the game. It is a pretty safe assumption to think there is a dt in the game.

On March 09 2012 05:46 jaj22 wrote:
In a 4-10 newbie game with a roleblocker, I think you can safely assume that there's a DT. You also have to assume that the DT is not a complete idiot, otherwise you're screwed anyway. Therefore if he's not claiming, it's because he thinks he doesn't need to.

If you're playing a GMarshal non-newbie game there might be two vets and two vigs, sure

Regardless, town were screwed unless all five townies were on one lynch. DYH, Chocolate and K2hd all looked pretty sure of their Sloosh votes, so unless you thought all of them were scum, the only choice was to vote Sloosh. The DT assumption just helps you out a bit with that decision.

On March 09 2012 05:49 EternaLSC2 wrote:
As a person who was spectating the entire game, i was a bit dissapointed by how things ended, so i want to try to top this. @dreamflower&Qatol, will you be hosting another newbie mini mafia or? i got on too late for SNMMVIII.
Also sloosh, im very surprised that you werent lynched, but that was some brilliant play on your part.

On March 09 2012 06:54 Janaan wrote:

There's a spot open in SNMM8 if you still want to join.

On March 09 2012 06:13 EternaLSC2 wrote:
Ghost, when i was looking over the game i noticed lots of people finding you suspicious... However, i didnt find you suspicious at all. I thought you played well except for not shooting, although it could have been a good move.

On March 09 2012 06:13 EternaLSC2 wrote:
Ghost, when i was looking over the game i noticed lots of people finding you suspicious... However, i didnt find you suspicious at all. I thought you played well except for not shooting, although it could have been a good move.

On March 08 2012 17:10 FourFace wrote:
Flawless Victory. GG scum. Shame on vig. DT claim faster ffs. Townies try to prove your innocence faster above all else. DoYouHas .. I'm sorry dude. Forget about it.