After seeing your tweet about this I was eagerly awaiting it.

Is it intentional that you cannot paste the key in to the box? Not a very user-friendly key to input in a masked box.

Torte de Lini

Germany30668 Posts

February 24 2015 21:28 GMT

On February 25 2015 06:27 RaymondFish wrote:
After seeing your tweet about this I was eagerly awaiting it.

Is it intentional that you cannot paste the key in to the box? Not a very user-friendly key to input in a masked box.

Works for me.

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 24 2015 21:30 GMT

It's just a regular text box so you should be able to paste into it.

RaymondFish

United States42 Posts

February 24 2015 21:40 GMT

On February 25 2015 06:30 R1CH wrote:

Show nested quote +

It's just a regular text box so you should be able to paste into it.

Very strange. Does not work on my end. Win7 Ult x64.

EDIT: Found reason.

Rodney

Germany9 Posts

February 24 2015 21:46 GMT

Are you sure the stream won't go live?
[image loading]

(I got this email at 21:56 CET and one yesterday shortly before you posted to twitter that you are testing this tool)

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 24 2015 21:56 GMT

Fixed, looks like it's a problem if you copied a space with your stream key.

Evire

Norway198 Posts

February 24 2015 22:04 GMT

#10

Hi, thanks for making this program.

I ran it, but got lower results than I was expecting.

With this internett, I'd expect better. What do you think the issue is?
[image loading]

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 24 2015 22:13 GMT

#11

Seems like your ISP has poor connectivity outside your country.

Sightbain

Canada81 Posts

February 25 2015 00:04 GMT

#12

Very cool, hopefully twitch makes this a feature or xsplit/obs add it :D Keep up the good work!

Cyro

United Kingdom19856 Posts

February 26 2015 14:21 GMT

#13

With a higher TCP window (i tried 1M, but checked for a second on 256k and it seemed fine) i get very solid and consistent ~6050kbit to all EU servers. With the OBS default, it's much lower - around 3000-3400. I sometimes have problems streaming at 3000-3500kbit using OBS. Is that something that's expected, or a problem? Fixable or not?

[image loading]

I clicked through all of the TCP windows testing the first server, 32k+ work the same (with steadily decreasing latency as it gets lower) but there's a huge drop off in bandwidth going below 32k.

32k ~6050kbit

16k ~4800kbit

8k ~3300kbit (this seems to be what OBS default uses)

[image loading]

other servers suffer more than the best ones

If this is a simple fix, it would be awesome. With 32k TCP window, i have pretty much all of my bandwidth and it's -extremely- stable (like 6040 - 6070 with no variance outside of that for the whole testing period) whereas right now i'm sometimes dancing around between 3500 and 2500 trying not to drop frames.

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 26 2015 14:28 GMT

#14

It seems like OBS Automatic mode isn't getting the signals to raise the window like it usually does. You can specify a 1M TCP Window manually in the OBS profile.ini under Publish, TCPBufferSize=1048576. OBS will always try to use at least 64k though. Minimize network impact may also affect the results.

Cyro

United Kingdom19856 Posts

February 26 2015 14:36 GMT

#15

Thanks, i'l manually set it to 64k. I don't have any of that minimize lag stuff on because i don't see any change in latency with or without streaming unless maybe i'm right up against bandwidth limits

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 26 2015 14:54 GMT

#16

It's set in bytes, eg 32k = 32768 bytes. You should check your OBS log though, it may be failing to raise the window to 64k for some reason as that should be the default.

Gumbi

Ireland463 Posts

February 26 2015 15:07 GMT

#17

The automatic TCP setting seems to be broken. My upload speed is exactly 12.5mbps (very stable too). When I set the TCP to automatic my scores are all over the place, however they increase hugely when I manually set it.

Here is my first score (automatic):

And my second score, at 32k is slightly higher (I'm edging my true upload score now in London (makes sense, I'm from Ireland).

And my 128k score, I'm consistently hitting my true upload score (most likely anyways, it doesn't actually record the exact score after 10k).

And now my 256k score, same again.

Any clue as to what might be going on with the automatic setting? It gives me by far the worst results.

Imgur links aren't loading properly on this page, I don't know why, but you can right click them and they'll open fine in a new tab.

Cyro

United Kingdom19856 Posts

February 26 2015 15:12 GMT

#18

Been looking at diagnostic stuff for a little while, my windows scaling seems to be correctly enabled and unrestricted but results in this program (and i think other stuff, i had some behavior like unexplained bandwidth losses to some servers, particularly far away ones, while connecting with bittorrent sync gave perfect bandwidth) doesn't show that

OBS itself seems to work fine now, just put on 5500Kbit to twitch stockholm server. Not sure if i changed that behavior by messing with windows settings though. I didn't do anything that positively affected the results in the bandwidth tester or manually set a tcp window size for OBS yet

15:14:22: SO_SNDBUF was at 8192
15:14:22: SO_SNDBUF is now 65536

^at the start of log, so that's probably good

R1CH

Netherlands10028 Posts

February 26 2015 15:47 GMT

#19

On February 27 2015 00:07 Gumbi wrote:
The automatic TCP setting seems to be broken. My upload speed is exactly 12.5mbps (very stable too). When I set the TCP to automatic my scores are all over the place, however they increase hugely when I manually set it.

Automatic asks Windows to suggest a TCP window, it's possible due to the short test duration Windows doesn't have enough data to recommend one. I did notice a bug where automatic mode starts at system default instead of 64k (like OBS) which may affect the results.

Cyro

United Kingdom19856 Posts

February 26 2015 16:05 GMT

#20

Thanks for the info, i can't say for sure if it was even a problem before but i'm a bit more aware of networking stuff now and where to look if i have issues