|
On August 05 2018 21:18 sc-darkness wrote: Well, wasn't Nestea like 30 years old when he won? I'm not sure age here means anything. It's more about if there are new players and incentive as you mention.
This was the pre-KESPA era. After 2012 when KESPA joined, the skill ceiling for SC2 in Korea went up.
|
On August 05 2018 21:27 deacon.frost wrote:
Without a healthy Korean scene there will be no Korean vs Foreigners, the numbers will eventually fade out, many people will stop watching after Korean scene will be dismantled and without region lock it will probably soon happen.
This is misinformation and it hasn't played out like you said. From this Variety article:
“[Activision-Blizzard] made GSL clones around the world, and a bunch of Koreans were allowed to move to other regions, where they’d win easier tournaments,” remembers Plott. “We lost a lot of our star power, and the GSL clone tournaments never really picked up well because it was just a bunch of top Korean guys just bashing everyone.”
“There was one day [in the GSL studio] where just one guy came into watch. We’d gone from having a full studio to just one guy,” said Stemkoski.
https://variety.com/2018/gaming/features/starcraft-ii-esports-history-1202873246/
You should read the rest of that Variety article. It talks about how the SC2 scene has improved. We've gone from the empty GSL studios mentioned in that article to a nice crowd now. GSL vs the World looked packed to me for all the days of the event. And even in the Round of 32 in the GSL this season, the audience was pretty good.
|
On August 05 2018 21:48 xelnaga_empire wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:27 deacon.frost wrote:
Without a healthy Korean scene there will be no Korean vs Foreigners, the numbers will eventually fade out, many people will stop watching after Korean scene will be dismantled and without region lock it will probably soon happen. This is misinformation and it hasn't played out like you said. From this Variety article: Show nested quote +“[Activision-Blizzard] made GSL clones around the world, and a bunch of Koreans were allowed to move to other regions, where they’d win easier tournaments,” remembers Plott. “We lost a lot of our star power, and the GSL clone tournaments never really picked up well because it was just a bunch of top Korean guys just bashing everyone.”
“There was one day [in the GSL studio] where just one guy came into watch. We’d gone from having a full studio to just one guy,” said Stemkoski. https://variety.com/2018/gaming/features/starcraft-ii-esports-history-1202873246/You should read the rest of that Variety article. It talks about how the SC2 scene has improved. We've gone from the empty GSL studios mentioned in that article to a nice crowd now. GSL vs the World looked packed to me for all the days of the event. And even in the Round of 32 in the GSL this season, the audience was pretty good. We'll talk again in 2 years when most of the current korean pros are in military.
|
Czech Republic12129 Posts
On August 05 2018 21:50 Charoisaur wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:48 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:27 deacon.frost wrote:
Without a healthy Korean scene there will be no Korean vs Foreigners, the numbers will eventually fade out, many people will stop watching after Korean scene will be dismantled and without region lock it will probably soon happen. This is misinformation and it hasn't played out like you said. From this Variety article: “[Activision-Blizzard] made GSL clones around the world, and a bunch of Koreans were allowed to move to other regions, where they’d win easier tournaments,” remembers Plott. “We lost a lot of our star power, and the GSL clone tournaments never really picked up well because it was just a bunch of top Korean guys just bashing everyone.”
“There was one day [in the GSL studio] where just one guy came into watch. We’d gone from having a full studio to just one guy,” said Stemkoski. https://variety.com/2018/gaming/features/starcraft-ii-esports-history-1202873246/You should read the rest of that Variety article. It talks about how the SC2 scene has improved. We've gone from the empty GSL studios mentioned in that article to a nice crowd now. GSL vs the World looked packed to me for all the days of the event. And even in the Round of 32 in the GSL this season, the audience was pretty good. We'll talk again in 2 years when most of the current korean pros are in military. Maybe he trusts in Trump and his peace talks!
|
On August 05 2018 20:57 xelnaga_empire wrote: I think the gap has closed a little between foreigners and Korea, especially Europe. Korea is still better than the rest of the world, this is undeniable. But the gap has closed a little.
I suspect since the collapse of ProLeague and the collapse of the KESPA teams (with Jin Air the only team left), the practice environment for Koreans is not as it once was during the ProLeague and KESPA days.
On the other hand, the WCS region lock has done wonders for the foreign scene. I suspect the foreign pros are getting more chances to get prize money from tournaments, and this is motivating them to practice harder. At the same time, in the Europe scene, there are new up and coming players like Reynor and Clem, adding to the competitive environment of the Europe scene. Conversely, I don't know of any young and upcoming Korean players.
In cross tournaments that involve Koreans and foreigners (especially European players), the foreigners are performing quite well against the Koreans. You have HSC where the Koreans lost to many European players at HSC, although the finalists were Soo and Innovation. Scarlett won IEM Pyeongchang, denying sOs in the finals, while Elazer denied Zest in the same tournament. Then Scarlett made it as far as the Round of 8 in the GSL, which hasn't been done by a foreigner since Naniwa I think. In this season's GSL, you have Neeb and Reynor making it to the Round of 16, and Special came close. And in online tournaments, you see the Koreans losing to foreigners every now and then (although Koreans tend to win more in online tournaments). And of course, there were some upsets by European players at GSL vs The World.
I suspect the gap will continue to close because some of the top Korean pros now are getting older. For example, Classic is a few months from turning to 27 years of age. And there doesn't seem to be any new Korean youngsters coming through.
This isn't necessarily a bad thing if the gap is closing because the viewership has gone up for SC2 this year. If the closing gap between foreigners and Korea leads to more viewers, and therefore more sponsors and money injected into the SC2 scene, then all the better for the SC2 pro scene. So I am in favor of the region lock, for the overall health of professional SC2.
You have to stop saying Scarlett. Everything she did to win those games was patched out shortly after. You have neeb losing 3:0. You have HSC with bracket luck for foreigner. IEMXII. Good job cherry picking. "I suspect the gap will continue to close because some of the top Korean pros now are getting older. ". Top notch clairvoyance
|
On August 05 2018 21:27 deacon.frost wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:13 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:07 Elentos wrote:On August 05 2018 21:06 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:03 yubo56 wrote: Would mixing the two be good for the foreign scene just yet? Probably not for anybody not named Serral.
I don't think it's a good idea to remove region lock. Let the foreigners that want to, compete in the GSL. If one day, foreigners are on par with Korea, then remove the region lock. Until then, the region lock should remain because it is helping the SC2 scene recover. It's helping the non-Korean scene. It's not helping the Korean scene at all that the region-lock is only in one direction though. That's unfortunate for the Korean scene. But SC2 viewership numbers are on the rise. This means more sponsors, potentially more tournaments with better prize pools, and ultimately, more money for SC2 pros around the world. It may even lead to some of the Korean pros getting sponsors. I just saw that Classic got a sponsor. And don't forget that Innovation got sponsored by OGaming TV. I would rather have a sustainable pro scene than Koreans stomping on everyone, leading to the death of the SC2 pro scene. Since ProLeague disbanded, the SC2 scene needs more money. More viewership will ultimately lead to more money for SC2 pros. Without a healthy Korean scene there will be no Korean vs Foreigners, the numbers will eventually fade out, many people will stop watching after Korean scene will be dismantled and without region lock it will probably soon happen.
Yep, exactly this.
It is very naive to believe that viewership will continue to grow when the number and skill of top players (i.e. Koreans) will diminish.
|
On August 05 2018 22:06 207aicila wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:27 deacon.frost wrote:On August 05 2018 21:13 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:07 Elentos wrote:On August 05 2018 21:06 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:03 yubo56 wrote: Would mixing the two be good for the foreign scene just yet? Probably not for anybody not named Serral.
I don't think it's a good idea to remove region lock. Let the foreigners that want to, compete in the GSL. If one day, foreigners are on par with Korea, then remove the region lock. Until then, the region lock should remain because it is helping the SC2 scene recover. It's helping the non-Korean scene. It's not helping the Korean scene at all that the region-lock is only in one direction though. That's unfortunate for the Korean scene. But SC2 viewership numbers are on the rise. This means more sponsors, potentially more tournaments with better prize pools, and ultimately, more money for SC2 pros around the world. It may even lead to some of the Korean pros getting sponsors. I just saw that Classic got a sponsor. And don't forget that Innovation got sponsored by OGaming TV. I would rather have a sustainable pro scene than Koreans stomping on everyone, leading to the death of the SC2 pro scene. Since ProLeague disbanded, the SC2 scene needs more money. More viewership will ultimately lead to more money for SC2 pros. Without a healthy Korean scene there will be no Korean vs Foreigners, the numbers will eventually fade out, many people will stop watching after Korean scene will be dismantled and without region lock it will probably soon happen. Yep, exactly this. It is very naive to believe that viewership will continue to grow when the number and skill of top players (i.e. Koreans) will diminish.
And the Korean scene has always been a big part of Starcraft, so much of the games culture and scene was built around the Korean scene from the past
|
There has been no real new blood in Korea since Speed and that was like 2 years ago. Outside of the current top pro players, I'm guessing everyone involved in SC in Korea is simply hoping to coast along for the next 2 years until StarCraft 3 is released and some new blood enters the scene. There's no way Blizzard can hold off SC3 for longer than a couple of years - the GSL will just become a no stakes exhibition league for veterans like the ASL.
|
On August 05 2018 21:13 xelnaga_empire wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:07 Elentos wrote:On August 05 2018 21:06 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:03 yubo56 wrote: Would mixing the two be good for the foreign scene just yet? Probably not for anybody not named Serral.
I don't think it's a good idea to remove region lock. Let the foreigners that want to, compete in the GSL. If one day, foreigners are on par with Korea, then remove the region lock. Until then, the region lock should remain because it is helping the SC2 scene recover. It's helping the non-Korean scene. It's not helping the Korean scene at all that the region-lock is only in one direction though. That's unfortunate for the Korean scene. But SC2 viewership numbers are on the rise. This means more sponsors, potentially more tournaments with better prize pools, and ultimately, more money for SC2 pros around the world. It may even lead to some of the Korean pros getting sponsors. I just saw that Classic got a sponsor. And don't forget that Innovation got sponsored by OGaming TV. Unless korean pros are competing overseas, I very much doubt they'll get sponsors form decent orgs. Even average-good foreigners can get sponsors over koreans that are much better than them because of their exposure to western audiences. TY and Stats being on splyce seem like the only exceptions.
|
|
Absolutely not... The gap between Serral and the other foreigners has simply widened.
|
On August 05 2018 22:50 DarkPlasmaBall wrote: Absolutely not... The gap between Serral and the other foreigners has simply widened.
No. The gap between foreigner Zerg and Protoss has closed with Korea. Only foreigner Terran remain significantly behind Korean Terran.
|
Even though I root for Korean players usually, I have to admit the gap has closed. This year, the foreigners have won 2 global tournaments, made GSL ro4, GSL ro8 and a few GSL ro16. While I think it's unlikely they will have the same degree of success next year, I think it's hard to deny that the gap has closed. That said, the narrative that the gap has been closing every year is something I consider untrue. The gap closed a lot in 2016, but then it probably widened a lot in 2017 and now it has closed significantly again.
|
On August 29 2018 20:18 Anc13nt wrote: Even though I root for Korean players usually, I have to admit the gap has closed. This year, the foreigners have won 2 global tournaments, made GSL ro4, GSL ro8 and a few GSL ro16. While I think it's unlikely they will have the same degree of success next year, I think it's hard to deny that the gap has closed. That said, the narrative that the gap has been closing every year is something I consider untrue. The gap closed a lot in 2016, but then it probably widened a lot in 2017 and now it has closed significantly again. Well, Elazer eliminated Dark in 2017, Special topped his group against TY and Stats, and Neeb was the only one to take a series against the eventual Blizzcon winner. Neeb beat sOs 3-0, Showtime almost won against soO, Neeb was very close against TY in 2-3, and Special was very close against Stats 2-3. Serral topped his group in IEM Katowice. Yes, foreigners as a whole were not as successful, but they had a lot of close series against top players.
|
Yeah, to be fair, even though the foreigner results were kind of disappointing in 2017, there were a lot of close series and if the foreigners were able to clutch some of them, 2017 might also have been a good year for the foreigners.
|
On August 29 2018 20:29 Anc13nt wrote: Yeah, to be fair, even though the foreigner results were kind of disappointing in 2017, there were a lot of close series and if the foreigners were able to clutch some of them, 2017 might also have been a good year for the foreigners. I do agree that there was a lot of disappointment with foreigners in 2017. I do think the gap closed some, but I think people were expecting it to have closed more. Neeb especially, I think, disappointed in 2017 against Koreans.
|
On August 05 2018 22:47 Fango wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 21:13 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:07 Elentos wrote:On August 05 2018 21:06 xelnaga_empire wrote:On August 05 2018 21:03 yubo56 wrote: Would mixing the two be good for the foreign scene just yet? Probably not for anybody not named Serral.
I don't think it's a good idea to remove region lock. Let the foreigners that want to, compete in the GSL. If one day, foreigners are on par with Korea, then remove the region lock. Until then, the region lock should remain because it is helping the SC2 scene recover. It's helping the non-Korean scene. It's not helping the Korean scene at all that the region-lock is only in one direction though. That's unfortunate for the Korean scene. But SC2 viewership numbers are on the rise. This means more sponsors, potentially more tournaments with better prize pools, and ultimately, more money for SC2 pros around the world. It may even lead to some of the Korean pros getting sponsors. I just saw that Classic got a sponsor. And don't forget that Innovation got sponsored by OGaming TV. Unless korean pros are competing overseas, I very much doubt they'll get sponsors form decent orgs. Even average-good foreigners can get sponsors over koreans that are much better than them because of their exposure to western audiences. TY and Stats being on splyce seem like the only exceptions. This. SC2 scene had more sponsors back then, sponsors were flying koreans all over the place to represent them. Now most of the pros retired, because there isn't enough money from sponsors In Korea to sustain them, but that is just one of the problem. In the end Instead of watching the best players, now we are watching whats left of them and other representatives from around the globe.
|
In the end Instead of watching the best players, now we are watching whats left of them and other representatives from around the globe. A key sentence.
|
I honestly do not see something has changed since LoTV was released except Serral and Neeb.
Foreigner beating Korean in a series.. That's what actually happened a lot since WoL and HoTS. They just did not have any wins in a tournament vs top Koreans when the game was developed enough and much harder to play in pro level since HoTS. However, Serral and Neeb were able to accomplish that.
And also, Neeb dominated WCS Circuit in 2017, and now Serral is dominating in 2018. By looking at this results, other foreigners simply struggled to stop these two at their primes.
I don't think blizzard will unlock region lock just because Serral won gsl vs world and Neeb won kespa cup and went ro4 in gsl code s. They might don't wanna see 14 Koreans and 2 foreigners in next year blizzcon.
|
On August 29 2018 19:42 xelnaga_empire wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2018 22:50 DarkPlasmaBall wrote: Absolutely not... The gap between Serral and the other foreigners has simply widened. No. The gap between foreigner Zerg and Protoss has closed with Korea. Only foreigner Terran remain significantly behind Korean Terran.
Nope. Neeb and ShowTime are pretty good and are legit top-tier in at least one MU but overall I don't put them on the level of Zest, Stats, sOs, Classic, Trap, or herO. The rest of the foreign tosses are even further behind.
Korean Zergs vs Foreigners is the thinnest largely because most of the good Korean Zergs have left the game (about to lose another one if Leenock is serious about retiring). Even then, I'd only rank Serral and Scarlett up there with Rogue, soO, Dark, Solar and the recent Leenock.
|
|
|
|