Carnival Cruise Mafia - Page 92

On May 21 2013 10:04 kushm4sta wrote:
um dont shit on prome. He is town mvp. His actions directly enabled us to win.

On May 20 2013 15:47 kushm4sta wrote:
grush57
slOosh
kushm4sta
strongandbig
shirokami
VisceraEyes
prplhz
ObviousOne
WaveofShadow
Oatsmaster
Promethelax

On May 21 2013 10:55 ObviousOne wrote:
Only read I have any real doubt on right now is VE and it's activity based only. HIs early D2 felt like town VE and he just hasn't been around since. So yeah, I think Kush's list pretty much solves the game.

sloosh - huge mega case on 3p, very little effort in finding mafia. the post about 3p comes right after a night with no town deaths so i'm led to believe it was constructed with the idea that he 1) as mafia knows the mafia kp 2) saw that the actual kp was higher and 3) bullet did not go thru ergo case on 3p to get rid of threat to his side.
snb - heavily interested in lynching prome as soon as it was topical. thinks oats is scum (this is really lol). letting Siri write his posts (LOL AGAIN!) contrast it to how hard he pushed for lynches on known townies / your town reads.
shiro - refuses to participate in the scum hunting, defensive about his posting but not proactive about anything at all. hiding.
prplhz - "AMA" is not proactive, playing reactive / "by-ear" is scummy IMO. most recently his wagon went nowhere after his martyring, nobody called him scummy for it (i didn't, handily enough i was the litmus test for whether or not people would jump on scum for it and you saw how differently people reacted when I did it versus when prp did it)

it's a fucking slam dunk

On May 21 2013 02:31 Promethelax wrote:
hi guys, I'm back.

This is how today goes: we lynch either Oats or Sloosh. Both of whom are scum. My only point on a town Oats was my early belief that scum had two night hits and his suggestion of a vig for the second hit. Since based on how the NKs worked out (as Sloosh correctly pointed out) there is probably a serial killer and scum only have one NK which means that Oats' townslip was actually a scumslip.
Why is sloosh scum? Well its because he is really easy to read as scum. If you need help because you are bad though look at his play this day: he is SK hunting not scum hunting. An sk lynch is the same as a town lynch for scum, probably even better since the SK needs to be shooting Scum right now as evidenced by the BH shot last night. Having the SK alive assuming that it is indeed an SK (KISS suggests it is) is way more beneficial to town than it is to scum. We get to lynch and Scum need to nk the SK since he is the only non-scum kp in the game (besides the flipped vivax).

SnB: no, there is no reason for me to think you are scum, but I need to call Kush scum to be able to read him and that was my chance to do so.

I said I liked the prp/kush lynch dichotomy earlier but I like it a lot less now. Kush seems really townie in these last few pages his appeals to me to claim serial killer and ally myself with town are a thing he would not suggest as scum.

In case you guys decide to lynch me I'm posting a full reads list with reasons so that you can maaaaybe make this a win for us.

Oatsmaster has played anti-twon the whole game, his activity is pathetic and his interest is minimal. Plus scumslip about n0 nk
SloOsh lurky scum play, focused attack on me trying to pass off sk-hunting as pro town while avoiding scum hunting. Chainsaw defense of bh.

VE less sure than I am on the above but his OO stuff early wasn't right and my meta case from Chrono still holds. VE hasn't added anything to the game that he should as a townie. This is either VE's scumgame or the single worst town game I have ever seen from him.

Shiro he was such an idiot early on that I had him as town, Rayn had a similar read. If we assume Rayn was the scum shot though that might have been to cover Shiro from someone who knew him. I wouldn't lynch him yet but I'm damn sure that I don't want him in lylo if it is at all avoidable.
OO I do like his d2 play. BH's retard push on him for martyring also suggests that he is town. Of the three guys in this null column he is the one I think would have the skill to fool me as scum though. For the moment not really worth calling scum but he'll need to be looked at again as the game goes on.
prp My heuristic with prp early game tells me he is town, his play hasn't done anything for me since that and he certainly could be scum. I find it somewhat unlikely though.


Me[/me]
WoS seriously the towniest mother fucker in the world.
Kush his play today, he is actually interested in killing scum and winning game for town. Asking sk to claim is a very townie thing for kush to do.
[b]Grush I believe in STARSENSES

For the purposes of the above list I treated this game as anti-scum/scum since the SK is on our side for now. I'm not to worried about him as town is so far behind right now (5-4-1) that he is shooting scum for a while and because of that scum HAVE to shoot him or push through a lynch on him. I say we lynch scum today and make scum waste their kp on sk so we can win this game.

##Vote: Oatsmaster you are all welcome to sheep me now.

If scum seriously think I am the sk it probably means they shot me last night and I was protected from their nk, that would explain the retard push on me today. I'll probably get hit next night since they are so sure I'm sk so after I flip remember this post and come back and read it. I'd like you all to pull out the win for us kthx.

On May 21 2013 10:00 Oatsmaster wrote:
Ezezezezezez
Get a coach Prome.


Well WoS, you have to think about the fact that Prome's win con is to kill everyone, which means he has to get the game to a 1-1-1 preferably.
So I assume some of his townreads are scum, some of his null reads are town, some of them are scum or whatever.
Which means its not all that useful for picking out stuff that helps us.

Ok so for sloosh, nobody thought of the 3P explanation before, and I feel that his post was too clean to be townie. He knew that his shot didnt kill anyone, and if prome was 3P or not, it doesnt matter, just that 3P would get lynched if he called it out. So sloosh is scum.

On May 21 2013 11:27 ObviousOne wrote:
That post looks like him making himself look like less of a threat to mafia.

Kush his play today, he is actually interested in killing scum and winning game for town. Asking sk to claim is a very townie thing for kush to do.

On May 21 2013 11:32 Oatsmaster wrote:
Nah there was no way he was gonna get me lynched.
0 ways.


What I find interesting about this is that scum want SK dead too. So the second part isnt town indicative at all. If scum gets SK to shoot a townie, they win the game. Not a bad plan from kush as scum I feel. Especially since not a lot of people would go for that, tendency is to lynch dudes with KP. Kush isnt town cause he wanted SK to claim.

Also about Prome wanting to lynch me.
He knew night 0 that scum probably have 1KP, so he was using that whole thing to call me town, then switch when the presence of an SK was suspected. I dont see why he needs to do this if I was scum, surely there are many many more things that would be off that Prome could read. Therefore im town

On May 21 2013 02:31 Promethelax wrote:
Oatsmaster has played anti-twon the whole game, his activity is pathetic and his interest is minimal. Plus scumslip about n0 nk

On May 21 2013 12:42 VisceraEyes wrote:
Hi guys.

I'm catching up. Couldn't help but notice Prom was lynched...that came out of nowhere.

Jesus.

On May 21 2013 21:00 kushm4sta wrote:
new plan
actually let's lynch VE for being inactive and lynch oats and WoS for being dirty spammers. lylo shmylo we gotta clean this game up before we have a chance at lynching scum.

On May 21 2013 21:00 kushm4sta wrote:
new plan
actually let's lynch VE for being inactive and lynch oats and WoS for being dirty spammers. lylo shmylo we gotta clean this game up before we have a chance at lynching scum.