| Forum Index > Closed |
Read the rules in the OP before posting, please. In order to ensure that this thread continues to meet TL standards and follows the proper guidelines, we will be enforcing the rules in the OP more strictly. Be sure to give them a re-read to refresh your memory! The vast majority of you are contributing in a healthy way, keep it up! NOTE: When providing a source, explain why you feel it is relevant and what purpose it adds to the discussion if it's not obvious. Also take note that unsubstantiated tweets/posts meant only to rekindle old arguments can result in a mod action. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On June 27 2015 05:14 Gorsameth wrote: Marriage is equal, so is tax status. Don't tell me this is the next stupid thing to fight over lol They will find something stupid to fight over. | ||
|
Introvert
United States4951 Posts
| ||
|
{CC}StealthBlue
United States41117 Posts
| ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22308 Posts
On June 27 2015 05:24 Introvert wrote: I meant for churches or other organizations that refuse to host these ceremonies or what have you. I'm out so I can't find it, but I'm pretty sure it was mentioned in arguments. Ah well yes I agree a church should be able to refuse a service for a gay couple. But this fight by the gay community was for legal equality which they should now have. | ||
|
GreenHorizons
United States23930 Posts
On June 27 2015 05:31 Gorsameth wrote: Ah well yes I agree a church should be able to refuse a service for a gay couple. But this fight by the gay community was for legal equality which they should now have. The weird part was Republicans wanting the government in their churches telling them who they could and couldn't marry. Churches are a weird public/private hybrid though, so I wouldn't be surprised if they along with groups like the Conservative news site the church terrorist was into, end up not being able to both be bigots and tax exempt. | ||
|
Sermokala
United States14111 Posts
Month of zen. If anythings related to Us politics its Jon Stewart. People might think Minnesota an extremely conservative state from our jessie ventura and bachman's but we also elected the first muslum to congress that swore his oath on a koran so suck it. East central coast Represent! Churches are always going to be in an constitutionally gray zone. It's always going to be able to dance around the constitution The only reason why they get tax exempt status is because the federal government doesn't want to touch them with a 50 foot pole. | ||
|
OuchyDathurts
United States4588 Posts
On June 27 2015 05:54 Sermokala wrote: People might think Minnesota an extremely conservative state from our jessie ventura and bachman's but we also elected the first muslum to congress that swore his oath on a koran so suck it. East central coast Represent! Jesse also had some decent thoughts and said some things most politicians wouldn't be caught dead saying to this day. I wouldn't rank him with Bachmanm by any stretch. He's not my favorite person and the conspiracy theories are a bit much but he held a few views that a lot of liberals hold. | ||
|
Simberto
Germany11824 Posts
On June 27 2015 05:35 GreenHorizons wrote: The weird part was Republicans wanting the government in their churches telling them who they could and couldn't marry. Churches are a weird public/private hybrid though, so I wouldn't be surprised if they along with groups like the Conservative news site the church terrorist was into, end up not being able to both be bigots and tax exempt. I have been wondering about this for a while, how exactly does marriage work in the US? In Germany, it is basically a dual thing. You can have a marriage in church, but that is completely pointless and only for show. The legally binding marriage gets done by signing some paperwork in a state office. Is this also the case in the US, or do the churches (Or even only churches?) actually have the power to marry people? | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:31 Simberto wrote: I have been wondering about this for a while, how exactly does marriage work in the US? In Germany, it is basically a dual thing. You can have a marriage in church, but that is completely pointless and only for show. The legally binding marriage gets done by signing some paperwork in a state office. Is this also the case in the US, or do the churches (Or even only churches?) actually have the power to marry people? Its the same. You need a "license" which is you telling the state you are married. | ||
|
dAPhREAk
Nauru12397 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:31 Simberto wrote: I have been wondering about this for a while, how exactly does marriage work in the US? In Germany, it is basically a dual thing. You can have a marriage in church, but that is completely pointless and only for show. The legally binding marriage gets done by signing some paperwork in a state office. Is this also the case in the US, or do the churches (Or even only churches?) actually have the power to marry people? its basically the same. marriage license is what is necessary. | ||
|
Simberto
Germany11824 Posts
| ||
|
dAPhREAk
Nauru12397 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:36 Simberto wrote: So, how are churches in any way relevant to a discussion regarding legal marriage, if churches don't actually have anything to do with legal marriage at all, and are basically a place people have a big and absurdly expensive party at after/before getting legally married? question is whether a church can be forced to do a gay marriage if a gay couple insists. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:36 Simberto wrote: So, how are churches in any way relevant to a discussion regarding legal marriage, if churches don't actually have anything to do with legal marriage at all, and are basically a place people have a big and absurdly expensive party at after/before getting legally married? Churches have tax exempt status in the US as non-profits and charge to have marriages preformed in them. At some point a church is going to refuse to have a marriage preformed in it because the couple is gay and law suits will get thrown around. To be fair, churches are still refusing to admit interracial couples too. http://www.kentucky.com/2011/11/30/1977453/small-pike-county-church-votes.html Bigots are always a threat and they like to hid in churches. | ||
|
Danglars
United States12133 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:39 dAPhREAk wrote: question is whether a church can be forced to do a gay marriage if a gay couple insists. Legally, churches exist as nonprofit entities subject to special provisions in the tax code (for instance, housing allowance/parsonage). The question is similar in form to the quoted--Whether a church can be forced to do a gay marriage if a gay couple insists under threat of losing nonprofit tax exemption. Aka why are they nonprofit if they discriminate against a class of marriage licenses the state would otherwise recognize? The solicitor general said in oral arguments that the tax exemptions of some religious institutes would be in question if they opposed same-sex marriage. On June 27 2015 05:31 Gorsameth wrote: We'll see if people like Gorsameth will stand by tax exemptions for such churches along the lines of the exercise of religion. All kinds of discriminatory and malicious labels will be applied in public outcry in time. (You can even see the textbook language in the majority opinion itself, with words like demean and stigmatize)Ah well yes I agree a church should be able to refuse a service for a gay couple. But this fight by the gay community was for legal equality which they should now have. Like Roberts also says, we'll see questions about religious college married student housing and religious adoption agencies come before the court in due time. | ||
|
dAPhREAk
Nauru12397 Posts
| ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22308 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:36 Simberto wrote: So, how are churches in any way relevant to a discussion regarding legal marriage, if churches don't actually have anything to do with legal marriage at all, and are basically a place people have a big and absurdly expensive party at after/before getting legally married? Churches themselves are not relevant but a considerable part of the US is religious and they feel very strongly about such topics as we have seen in the past | ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22308 Posts
On June 27 2015 06:51 Danglars wrote:We'll see if people like Gorsameth will stand by tax exemptions for such churches along the lines of the exercise of religion. All kinds of discriminatory and malicious labels will be applied in public outcry in time. (You can even see the textbook language in the majority opinion itself, with words like demean and stigmatize) Like Roberts also says, we'll see questions about religious college married student housing and religious adoption agencies come before the court in due time. Since your asking. I don't necessarily think religious institutions should be tax exempt in the first place. | ||
|
zlefin
United States7689 Posts
As to Supreme court issues, I looked up some gallup poll data histories http://www.gallup.com/poll/4732/supreme-court.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/1600/congress-public.aspx and it looks like congress has consistently lower approval ratings than the supreme court by a sizeable margin over a sizeable time frame. | ||
|
cLutZ
United States19574 Posts
On June 27 2015 07:20 zlefin wrote: Certainly freedom of religion does not innately require freedom from taxation. As to Supreme court issues, I looked up some gallup poll data histories http://www.gallup.com/poll/4732/supreme-court.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/1600/congress-public.aspx and it looks like congress has consistently lower approval ratings than the supreme court by a sizeable margin over a sizeable time frame. Actually, I think it's hard to argue that you can have freedom of religion with taxation | ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22308 Posts
On June 27 2015 07:55 cLutZ wrote: Actually, I think it's hard to argue that you can have freedom of religion with taxation Please explain because I don't see how a church having to pay taxes limits your religious freedom. | ||
| ||
[ Submit Event ] |
|
|
|
OSC
Big Brain Bouts
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
RSL Revival
Classic vs GgMaChine
Rogue vs Maru
WardiTV Invitational
IPSL
Ret vs Art_Of_Turtle
Radley vs TBD
BSL
Replay Cast
RSL Revival
herO vs TriGGeR
NightMare vs Solar
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
