|
On August 14 2010 06:39 FabledIntegral wrote: They would if it portrays them with a negative image. They'd do it in a second.
Not true in all cases, they would only drop if that negative image affects profits.
|
On August 14 2010 06:41 Aex wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:39 FabledIntegral wrote: They would if it portrays them with a negative image. They'd do it in a second. Not true in all cases, they would only drop if that negative image affects profits.
the assumed negative image will not quite be in their favour would it given that they are antagonising their own market...
|
On August 14 2010 06:37 Aex wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 05:59 Phyrion wrote: If we want to see ESports come to the West, we have to adhere to the same standards of language that is on public TV sports. I would love to see Starcraft II Tournaments shown on TV and make into the mainstream just like football or soccer or basketball.
I have never once heard a football commentator say "JESUS CHRIST did you see that pass?" Or a basketball commentator say "That was the longest fucking three pointer I have ever seen!" "GOD he is raping the other team all by himself!"
If we continue to use the words rape, faggot, Jesus Christ to commentate games, we will never move ESports to any major network ever. Having read this thread and seeing that most gamers don't care too much about others feelings and sensitivity to certain words and phrases, ESports will never make it in the West. Basically this ^ It is not the responsibility of the gaming community to stop using words like 'rape' and 'owned', just like it is not the responsibility of the sports watching community to stop using the words described above. It is the responsibility of the broadcasters if they want to attain mass appeal, if they want to appeal to the Soccer Moms of America. You could claim it is the responsibility of the community to condemn the usage of the word, but I don't feel that the majority of the gaming community finds the words offensive in this context, and this is definitely not a community where the Soccer Moms of America have a large say, unlike broadcasted television. Sure, the rest of the world might find it offensive, but the rest of the world probably doesn't even take gaming seriously, so why should we care what they think? OP, Perhaps you should have said something along the lines as the poster quoted here. Something along the lines as, you can personally use the word as much as you like, but refrain from using it during tournaments or broadcasts, and hold those who do responsible. So, that we as a community can display ourselves in a much more positive light to an outsider looking in. Instead you come off as trying to tell the community what words to use and not use, because of how you and your friends feel they are offensive. You portray a holier than thou complex, insisting your opinion is '100% right', and that is not a good way to get your core message across.
Hip hop celebrates drive bys shootings, the gangsta life style and drug dealing. Yet it is the driving force of our music and pop culture at the moment. Why is that? The soccer mums of America would be outraged that Eminem is singing about killing his girlfriend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Stop being so damn sensitive. Money dictates what will be in popular culture. If the money is right, E-sports will grow. And the money will come from the audience, which will appreciate rape and pwnage in all its un adulterated un filtered use. Unless we're tryng to expand into the soccer mums of America audience, well then we're shit out of luck.
|
On August 14 2010 06:41 Aex wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:39 FabledIntegral wrote: They would if it portrays them with a negative image. They'd do it in a second. Not true in all cases, they would only drop if that negative image affects profits.
No, they wouldn't. They'd drop it before they could even find out. Please be a realist.
On August 14 2010 06:43 toadstool wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:37 Aex wrote:On August 14 2010 05:59 Phyrion wrote: If we want to see ESports come to the West, we have to adhere to the same standards of language that is on public TV sports. I would love to see Starcraft II Tournaments shown on TV and make into the mainstream just like football or soccer or basketball.
I have never once heard a football commentator say "JESUS CHRIST did you see that pass?" Or a basketball commentator say "That was the longest fucking three pointer I have ever seen!" "GOD he is raping the other team all by himself!"
If we continue to use the words rape, faggot, Jesus Christ to commentate games, we will never move ESports to any major network ever. Having read this thread and seeing that most gamers don't care too much about others feelings and sensitivity to certain words and phrases, ESports will never make it in the West. Basically this ^ It is not the responsibility of the gaming community to stop using words like 'rape' and 'owned', just like it is not the responsibility of the sports watching community to stop using the words described above. It is the responsibility of the broadcasters if they want to attain mass appeal, if they want to appeal to the Soccer Moms of America. You could claim it is the responsibility of the community to condemn the usage of the word, but I don't feel that the majority of the gaming community finds the words offensive in this context, and this is definitely not a community where the Soccer Moms of America have a large say, unlike broadcasted television. Sure, the rest of the world might find it offensive, but the rest of the world probably doesn't even take gaming seriously, so why should we care what they think? OP, Perhaps you should have said something along the lines as the poster quoted here. Something along the lines as, you can personally use the word as much as you like, but refrain from using it during tournaments or broadcasts, and hold those who do responsible. So, that we as a community can display ourselves in a much more positive light to an outsider looking in. Instead you come off as trying to tell the community what words to use and not use, because of how you and your friends feel they are offensive. You portray a holier than thou complex, insisting your opinion is '100% right', and that is not a good way to get your core message across. Hip hop celebrates drive bys shootings, the gangsta life style and drug dealing. Yet it is the driving force of our music and pop culture at the moment. Why is that? The soccer mums of America would be outraged that Eminem is singing about killing his girlfriend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Stop being so damn sensitive. Money dictates what will be in popular culture. If the money is right, E-sports will grow. And the money will come from the audience, which will appreciate rape and pwnage in all its un adulterated un filtered use. Unless we're tryng to expand into the soccer mums of America audience, well then we're shit out of luck.
I truly hope you're not talking about his song with Rihanna that is preaching against the harms of domestic violence.
|
Kyrgyz Republic1462 Posts
Everybody says "he/she/it sucks" and nobody gets mad at it, but if you think about it, it has pretty obvious sexual connotations. It's just the matter of perception.
"Rape" in the gaming culture is not offensive at all, but it should not be used in public casts.
|
On August 14 2010 06:43 FireBlast! wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:41 Aex wrote:On August 14 2010 06:39 FabledIntegral wrote: They would if it portrays them with a negative image. They'd do it in a second. Not true in all cases, they would only drop if that negative image affects profits. the assumed negative image will not quite be in their favour would it given that they are antagonising their own market...
Well it seems that their market, us, doesn't have a big issue with the words 'rape' or 'owned', if we did and people started to tune out because their broadcasters let it slip every now and then, then of course you'd see sponsors pulling out, start holding their commentators to higher standards or go about finding new broadcasters that don't let it slip, but that currently is not the case.
|
Let's be clear about this. We use the word "rape" because it has a connotation of being utterly controlled, destroyed, and violated. Similar to an actual sexual assault. Hell, sometimes we do say "raped in the ass" or "his ass must hurt." Using exaggerations like this and "probe genocide/worker Holocaust" is colorful and makes the commentary more interesting, but can offend some. I'd rather have the commentary be more interesting. But hey, I also enjoy racist jokes and dead baby jokes (not that I would tell either in the presence of certain groups).
|
On August 14 2010 06:33 thatdontmakecent wrote: Thank you thank you thank you OP. I have been trying to formulate the words for this for so long. I understand that 'rape' is embedded in gaming culture, but just think how it sounds to the outside world. Gaming and gamers will continue to garner an adolescent (and horridly immature) reputation if we insist on defending the use of word like this. YOU don't think it's a big deal. I get it. It is. So stop. It's a small change with a hugely positive impact. You can't know how it affects people if it hasn't happened to you, so by saying it you are speaking out of ignorance, and then defending our own ignorance. It sounds moronic. Consider yourself lucky you don't know what it's like, and defer to the people who are asking you to stop. Being competitive is one thing, being grossly macho and sophomoric is something else.
If you disagree, ok. But think about it? Please?
Great post OP. What would you do if those words offended someone? Sophomore is just someone in second year of high school. By yours and the OP's argument you must adhere to my sentiment of, let's make up a common story, being picked on by the seniors for being a sophomore. I was bullied and picked on and physically abused, and you using that word makes me feel terrible. How do you feel about that logic? Are you enticed to cater to my wishes because you had a different meaning, as well as different aim in your statement?
|
On August 14 2010 06:36 Chimon wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:34 AmbitiousNub wrote: So, you're in the heat of the moment. Your opponents HT/colossi army is sitting in the middle of the map, and you are in the perfect position to strike. You move in, quickly and ruthlessly, only to find out that he had a hidden mothership. It recalls a whole mass of carriers, which proceed to decimate your force.
What is the first thing that comes to your mind?
A) My inaccurate assessment of his composition has inevitably led me to this inglorious demise. B) I just got raped. "I shouldn't have done that," or for the even more hastily-inclinded, "Oh ____" (Insert expletive). Not so hard, is it?
I think you missed my point. I'm not going to change the way I think because someone, millions of miles away, got raped, and they might possibly be offended at my train of thought.
This whole moral argument of people saying that rape should not be used in context of getting owned because it offends people is almost as laughable as saying that airplanes are dangerous because terrorists can hijack them.
Rape has happened. And so have airplane hijackings. Does that mean I shouldn't ride an airplane? Does that mean I shouldn't use the term raped, when I did, indeed, get raped?
|
On August 14 2010 05:32 RosaParksStoleMySeat wrote: The etymology of "beat" shows that the two meanings evolved independently. They simply happen to be homophones. "Beat," as in "strike," was the earliest known form of the word. "Beat," as in "defeat," actually evolved from a later form of "beat" which meant "escape" or "legally avoid."
"Rape" is a completely different story. It obviously derived from the word "sexually abuse" due to the mental trauma and complete helplessness of the victim. The word "rape" also has multiple meanings, just like "beat".
According to dictionary.com:
–verb (used with object) 6. to force to have sexual intercourse. 7. to plunder (a place); despoil. 8. to seize, take, or carry off by force.
"from Latin rapere to seize" Words change their meaning over time. I wouldn't be surprised at all if in ten years time the dictionary has added a new meaning for the word "rape".
9. to utterly defeat an opponent.
Is it insensitive to use the word in the meaning "to rape the land"? No, this is the original meaning. Is it insensitive for a gamer to use the word to describe a victory? Maybe, but it's hardly clear-cut. And even if it's considered insensitive today it may not be tomorrow.
I wouldn't personally use such a loaded word but that's mostly cause I'm a total pussy.
|
If gamers stopped flippantly using the words rape, own, fag, gay, the world would be a better place. But too many gamers feel selfishly entitled to use offensive speech regardless of how it affects others. They don't realize that using abusive language can only harm your reputation with others and has no positive benefits.
|
On August 14 2010 06:45 Aex wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On August 14 2010 06:43 FireBlast! wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:41 Aex wrote:On August 14 2010 06:39 FabledIntegral wrote: They would if it portrays them with a negative image. They'd do it in a second. Not true in all cases, they would only drop if that negative image affects profits. the assumed negative image will not quite be in their favour would it given that they are antagonising their own market... Well it seems that their market, us, doesn't have a big issue with the words 'rape' or 'owned', if we did and people started to tune out because their broadcasters let it slip every now and then, then of course you'd see sponsors pulling out, start holding their commentators to higher standards or go about finding new broadcasters that don't let it slip, but that currently is not the case.
The current broadcasting of SC2 games is not a commercial industry, the broadcasters you are referring to are not paid professionals, they are passionate contributors. The idea of 'losing profit' here is far off the mark from the model you are proposing.
|
The age-old argument. As society is exposed more and more to violence and sex, we become more immune. Hence, we need stronger dosages to get the same euphoric sensations. Likewise words lose their appeal and vocabulary evolves as well.
It's funny because other mediums want more censorship in video games.
EDIT: My post was in response to toadstool's btw. I digress.
|
On August 14 2010 06:46 Roe wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:33 thatdontmakecent wrote: Thank you thank you thank you OP. I have been trying to formulate the words for this for so long. I understand that 'rape' is embedded in gaming culture, but just think how it sounds to the outside world. Gaming and gamers will continue to garner an adolescent (and horridly immature) reputation if we insist on defending the use of word like this. YOU don't think it's a big deal. I get it. It is. So stop. It's a small change with a hugely positive impact. You can't know how it affects people if it hasn't happened to you, so by saying it you are speaking out of ignorance, and then defending our own ignorance. It sounds moronic. Consider yourself lucky you don't know what it's like, and defer to the people who are asking you to stop. Being competitive is one thing, being grossly macho and sophomoric is something else.
If you disagree, ok. But think about it? Please?
Great post OP. What would you do if those words offended someone? Sophomore is just someone in second year of high school. By yours and the OP's argument you must adhere to my sentiment of, let's make up a common story, being picked on by the seniors for being a sophomore. I was bullied and picked on and physically abused, and you using that word makes me feel terrible. How do you feel about that logic? Are you enticed to cater to my wishes because you had a different meaning, as well as different aim in your statement?
LOL, what a failure of a post. Go look up the the definition of sophomoric.
|
On August 14 2010 06:46 Slow Motion wrote: Let's be clear about this. We use the word "rape" because it has a connotation of being utterly controlled, destroyed, and violated. Similar to an actual sexual assault. Hell, sometimes we do say "raped in the ass" or "his ass must hurt." Using exaggerations like this and "probe genocide/worker Holocaust" is colorful and makes the commentary more interesting, but can offend some. I'd rather have the commentary be more interesting. But hey, I also enjoy racist jokes and dead baby jokes (not that I would tell either in the presence of certain groups). Okay good good, now take the following step: Think about others who will read what you write. Just think about it, nothing more. You mention the presence of 'other groups', and you and I understand what you mean by that. You don't know what your audience is when you post on TL. Certainly not with the recent growth due to SC2. Those 'certain groups' might withhold you from saying certain things out of fear of retaliation. Those sensitive to the word 'rape' (with their minds on the negative connotation, of course) won't hurt you, but they'll feel hurt indirectly and shun this community. Sure you don't have to care, but you could.
|
On August 14 2010 06:49 Zealotdriver wrote: If gamers stopped flippantly using the words rape, own, fag, gay, the world would be a better place. But too many gamers feel selfishly entitled to use offensive speech regardless of how it affects others. They don't realize that using abusive language can only harm your reputation with others and has no positive benefits.
this.
I think this post perfectly sums up the argument for why using rape, fag and gay could be seen as bad. Like all the 4chan /b/tards who use it, noone takes them seriously.
|
The idea is both sides are competing and wanna win. But the superior gamer is one that imposes his will and rapes the inferior gamer. The inferior gamer did not want to lose, he wanted to fight and win, but ultimately had no choice but to be "raped."
|
On August 14 2010 06:49 Zealotdriver wrote: If gamers stopped flippantly using the words rape, own, fag, gay, the world would be a better place. But too many gamers feel selfishly entitled to use offensive speech regardless of how it affects others. They don't realize that using abusive language can only harm your reputation with others and has no positive benefits. Gaming IS selfish. I'm not playing Starcraft to make the world a better place. I'm playing to entertain myself. I do this by raping noobs left and right, and by telling them so if I so choose. Low brow and immature? Sure. Great way to blow off steam after a long day at work? Fuck yeah.
|
On August 14 2010 06:43 toadstool wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2010 06:37 Aex wrote:On August 14 2010 05:59 Phyrion wrote: If we want to see ESports come to the West, we have to adhere to the same standards of language that is on public TV sports. I would love to see Starcraft II Tournaments shown on TV and make into the mainstream just like football or soccer or basketball.
I have never once heard a football commentator say "JESUS CHRIST did you see that pass?" Or a basketball commentator say "That was the longest fucking three pointer I have ever seen!" "GOD he is raping the other team all by himself!"
If we continue to use the words rape, faggot, Jesus Christ to commentate games, we will never move ESports to any major network ever. Having read this thread and seeing that most gamers don't care too much about others feelings and sensitivity to certain words and phrases, ESports will never make it in the West. Basically this ^ It is not the responsibility of the gaming community to stop using words like 'rape' and 'owned', just like it is not the responsibility of the sports watching community to stop using the words described above. It is the responsibility of the broadcasters if they want to attain mass appeal, if they want to appeal to the Soccer Moms of America. You could claim it is the responsibility of the community to condemn the usage of the word, but I don't feel that the majority of the gaming community finds the words offensive in this context, and this is definitely not a community where the Soccer Moms of America have a large say, unlike broadcasted television. Sure, the rest of the world might find it offensive, but the rest of the world probably doesn't even take gaming seriously, so why should we care what they think? OP, Perhaps you should have said something along the lines as the poster quoted here. Something along the lines as, you can personally use the word as much as you like, but refrain from using it during tournaments or broadcasts, and hold those who do responsible. So, that we as a community can display ourselves in a much more positive light to an outsider looking in. Instead you come off as trying to tell the community what words to use and not use, because of how you and your friends feel they are offensive. You portray a holier than thou complex, insisting your opinion is '100% right', and that is not a good way to get your core message across. Hip hop celebrates drive bys shootings, the gangsta life style and drug dealing. Yet it is the driving force of our music and pop culture at the moment. Why is that? The soccer mums of America would be outraged that Eminem is singing about killing his girlfriend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Stop being so damn sensitive. Money dictates what will be in popular culture. If the money is right, E-sports will grow. And the money will come from the audience, which will appreciate rape and pwnage in all its un adulterated un filtered use. Unless we're tryng to expand into the soccer mums of America audience, well then we're shit out of luck.
Those songs you are describing often get censored heavily to attain mass appeal. If they didn't censor them, they would get no radio play time. If they received no radio playtime, their profits would not be as high... Money dictates that to gain mass appeal, you need to censor yourself in certain cases...
I'm not advocating in telling someone what they can or cannot say. I'm just saying that if they want to gain mass appeal, they need to accommodate a lower common denominator.
|
although everything you said is the absolute truth, the fact is that there is just no censorship on the internet, and there is nothing you can do about it. Everyone on the internet is, for the most part, hidden, and their personal life and experiences are meaningless. English changes every day. the meanings of words change daily. Look at many of the curse words that in the 90s were absolutely forbidden and now they're thrown around like the change in your pocket. Rape is an expression, it's said for the lols. If you are offended by it you clearly have a predisposed bias on the word and you really need to grow up and understand that what people say and what people mean are two different things and what they said is not directed at you simply because you have emotional baggage attached to the word.
|
|
|
|