• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
TeamLiquid Liquipedia LiquidDota LiquidLegends
EST 06:16
CET 12:16
KST 20:16
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • WCS
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
NationWars 2019: RO4 & Finals Preview13NationWars: Italy, Finland, Korea, France to semis14NationWars 2019: Quarterfinals Preview8[HotS] New Year, New Faces1HomeStory Cup XX Preview - The New Season10
Community News
Mkers: Payment Withhold Dispute77Liquibet SC2 Season 22 Begins2Toodming joins Chivo14Cure joins DPGaming15JinAir part with Cure and Creator, re-sign Maru, sOs, Rogue, Trap38
StarCraft 2
General
4.11.0 Patch - Major balance changes, Mengsk Commander Imagine if WESG had TakeTV or O’Gaming organize Mkers: Payment Withhold Dispute Liquibet SC2 Season 22 Begins Cure joins DPGaming
Tourneys
[Nationwars 2019] Semi Finals + Grand Final WESG 2019 Qualifiers Master Swan Open (Global Bronze-Master 2) Afreeca World 48! SC2Online Weekly Community Open. $50 USD.
Strategy
[D] Terran Base-Order Dealing with WM harass as Protoss Simple Questions Simple Answers [G] TheCore - Advanced Keyboard Layout
Custom Maps
Work In Progress Melee Maps [M] (4) Autumn Fields [M] (2) Seaside Resort [M] (2) Ruins of Nafrut
External Content
Mutation #188 Equivalent Exchange Mutation Week 187 Onslaught Ranks/Tiers Mutation #187 Onslaught Mutation #186 Medieval Times
Brood War
General
Hello to foreign StarCraft fans. Foreigners elo ranking BSL Season 8 Announcement Starcraft offline event in Stockholm, Sweden! Patch 1.23.2
Tourneys
The Casual Games of the Week Thread Have At You 29 - Dec 7 @ 3:00PM PST BSL8 Ladder Tours, December 14 & 15 BSL8 Ladder Open #1
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers 2vs2 strategies for (almost) all MUs Collection of tricks? cadenzie muta micro tutorial 2019
Other Games
Heroes of the Storm
HotS: WP and Funny Moments Deathwing is the next new hero [HotS] New Year, New Faces QQ/Rage Thread. [HotS] Blurred Lines: Heroes and the FGC
General Games
Path of Exile Tekken 7 - PC/PS4/Xone, June 2nd 2017 Pokémon Go! Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne World of Warcraft Classic
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Liquid Arcanon News [0]Paper TL Mafia Plays: Diplomacy
Hearthstone
LiquidHearth.com closing on April 10th
LoL General
LoL Tournaments
LoL Strategy
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread The Big Programming Thread Tesla Motors Ask and answer stupid questions here! If you're seeing this topic then another mass shooting happened and people disagree on what to do
Fan Clubs
Serral Fan Club The Scarlett Fan Club The Polt Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker SPOILERS ALLOWED [Manga] Shingeki no Kyojin Anime Discussion Thread Korean Music Discussion Series you have seen recently...
Sports
NBA Season 2019-2020 2019 - 2020 Football Thread 2019 NFL and CFB Season TL Fantasy Football '19 TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2019
Tech Support
Changing gmail nickname Simple Questions Simple Answers Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
[Interview] NrGdde The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Winning, improving and…
coffeesession
SIAN #003: PvP - Not Enough…
NeoBlade
TvP Guide
Archangelsc2l
Dialysis
Jockmcplop
Last news
c0mp1exx
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 744 users

Bittersweet Symphony - Page 2

Forum Index > Articles
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 9 10 11 Next All
Kickass
Profile Joined August 2005
Sweden29 Posts
September 01 2005 18:57 GMT
#21
I agree, living on poker can give you a fat bank account, bur i dont have any respect for people that arent contributing to the society. Regardless of how much money you make, you need a purpose and meaning with life to be happy.
travis
Profile Blog Joined May 2003
United States23587 Posts
September 01 2005 18:59 GMT
#22
I wasn't born into a jungle indian tribe. I am of the belief that people are entitled to live as selfishly as they desire as long as they are not inflicting harm upon anyone else.

Im sure there's been the occasional indian who's gone off to live by himself.

The tribe is there because of mutual benefit. Every member of the tribe gains by being a part of it. The tribe is not there because of some innate concept of helping your fellow man.

Im not saying that there is something wrong with feeling an obligation to do good for others in your life, Im just saying I think it doesn't make you morally superior to those who do not feel that obligation. It's all relative, anyways.
Team Liquid
travis
Profile Blog Joined May 2003
United States23587 Posts
September 01 2005 19:00 GMT
#23
so you guys are saying hermits are bad people.
Team Liquid
Rekrul
Profile Blog Joined November 2002
Korea (South)17172 Posts
September 01 2005 19:01 GMT
#24
"I am of the belief that people are entitled to live as selfishly as they desire as long as they are not inflicting harm upon anyone else."

is this an oxymoron

but, i get your point, we are on different sides of the fence nothing to debate really
why so 진지해?
Liquid`Drone
Profile Joined September 2002
Norway25466 Posts
Last Edited: 2005-09-01 19:07:24
September 01 2005 19:06 GMT
#25
"I am of the belief that people are entitled to live as selfishly as they desire as long as they are not inflicting harm upon anyone else."

I agree with that actually
just that for every dollar you win at poker somebody loses $1+rake (which is significant? ) and that rake is then given to some rich fuck who doesnt even pay taxes because his business is located at the cayman islands or whatever

so basically, when you are a winning poker player you ARE inflicting harm upon other people.

(and im not saying hermits are bad people)
ModeratorI had to change my quote to seem more serious because I'm trying to use myself in an academic text :(
BlaCha
Profile Joined March 2005
Poland743 Posts
September 01 2005 19:17 GMT
#26
Nice post and interesting disscussion, the topic is very difficult though, because of different points of view.


and btw.who the hell are hermits ?

time to google..
Of course, fucking of course.
0x64
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
Finland3997 Posts
September 01 2005 20:13 GMT
#27
The grass is always greener on the other side.

I think even a selfish person should realize that poker is not a very good activity for the brain for a long time (many jobs aren't either).
Your brain is like a muscle and playing poker is like working out your jaws, your ankles and your left little finger.
The lack of social contacts and working for a mutual benefit is what bothers me most in poker.
When you have a normal job, you have money coming on a regular basis and you have a task you are (supposed to be) able to complete. When you do, the money you get comes from someone who gladly (most of the time) pays it.
Teamwork is a big part of what usually keeps people sane, they have coworkers they cares and even if the task is brainless and boring, you are happy to work because on the break or while working you can discuss all the crap in the world.
Poker doesn't provide long term personnal growth. You can learn what it is usefull to learn by just playing a year (if you manage to win ).
Poker teaches some very good thing to common man who usually goes "math are useless". Some probabilities (very low level), some mental calculation (challenging in the begining).
The difference now is when someone has learned and mastered those basic things, they just move to the next level. In poker you don't (you have other thing to learn obviously).
So basicly you can't stop poker and go to a company and say "I am a good poker player and my earnings are 5000$ a month, give me an equivalent position in your company".
It's a trap, you don't have a choice if you don't realize it in time. I am very happy Dan understand the situation.
There is nothing wrong to continue playing poker for fun to make some side money as long as the play time is small over a week.

(flame away this is all personnal opinion crap)


Good luck Rek for your plans!
Dump of assembler code from 0xffffffec to 0x64: End of assembler dump.
nortydog
Profile Joined December 2003
Australia3067 Posts
September 01 2005 20:20 GMT
#28
sometimes I think the same about playing broodwar, when I win I feel good but the other person could end up feeling like shit for whatever reason.. so cruel -_-
NoCleanFeed.com
{ToT}Strafe
Profile Blog Joined October 2004
Thailand7026 Posts
September 01 2005 20:28 GMT
#29
Hey Rek, somehow I got the feeling poker isn't going so well. First of all you everyone plays poker with the chance to win. You dont harm other people if that just happen to be you, sure they lose money, but they wouldn't give a fuck about you when they won yours. Its just a game with money and the person doesnt matter. The point why you are pretty tired of poker is probably because its such a meaningless activity. You dont meet new people and all you do is the sammmeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee fucking card game.
jjun212
Profile Joined December 2004
Canada2204 Posts
Last Edited: 2005-09-01 20:42:06
September 01 2005 20:39 GMT
#30
good write up, i dont know anything about poker players to criticize but all players are humans, cant they enjoy their winnings just like anyone else who makes 200K+ a year?
Liquid`Nazgul
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
22107 Posts
Last Edited: 2005-09-01 21:21:38
September 01 2005 20:58 GMT
#31
Any commercial job is harming people, unfortunately. So many non-profit jobs are harmful to others as well. You think of a job and I'll tell you what bad it does to the world. Poker makes it more obvious because there's no medium in between.

My social responsibility is to take money from rich Americans and do something with the money that I hope to be more useful than what others would have done with it.

On September 02 2005 05:39 jjun212 wrote:
good write up, i dont know anything about poker players to criticize but all players are humans, cant they enjoy their winnings just like anyone else who makes 200K+ a year?

They can but most of the people Rekrul has in mind are either young kids with too much money or old guys behaving like compulsive gamblers.

I agree more with Rekrul and Drone's point of view in this whole selfishness and social responsibility thing, but not the way they translate it to poker or anything else for that matter. Rekruls post has so many points that I can't agree with, while I support the ethics/thoughts behind it. Among other things this whole freedom thing is in my opinion bullshit.
Administrator
Clutch3
Profile Joined April 2003
United States1344 Posts
September 01 2005 21:05 GMT
#32
I agree with Travis. Although Rek's post purported to try to give people insight about poker and life, it comes off sounding hypocritical. The fact that Rek acknowledges this is a positive but does not give him a free pass.

Let's leave aside the obvious issue of a full-time poker player bashing "other full-time poker players" and the superior tone of the whole thing (the latter which I have been guilty of for sure).... My problem is the last sentence of the post in which it appears that, all philosophy aside, you're just bashing people who are in all senses the same as yourself as being posers. Honestly, you sound like a rapper screaming "keep it real!" to all the other identical rappers (and I am a fan of hip-hop, but enough is enough). Not to mention the fact that it's definitely not the first post in which you've given out life advice to others which directly contradicts how you are actually living your life. Do as I say, not as I do?

And yes, if you are just living off of poker you really aren't contributing much to society unless you're doing something more valuable with the time and money you are saving. There's no rule saying that you have to contribute to society, but it helps people to take your advice more seriously.

Rek, I hope you do use your winnings to go back to school and find a meaningful profession -- best of luck in the future.
Chibi[OWNS]
Profile Joined May 2003
United Kingdom10598 Posts
Last Edited: 2005-09-01 21:25:13
September 01 2005 21:22 GMT
#33
--- Nuked ---
Breavman
Profile Joined September 2004
Sweden598 Posts
September 01 2005 21:34 GMT
#34
Why do poker players assume that the people they win money from are rich americans?
Liquid`Nazgul
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
22107 Posts
September 01 2005 21:36 GMT
#35
I guess you just have to experience that first hand
Administrator
{ToT}Strafe
Profile Blog Joined October 2004
Thailand7026 Posts
September 01 2005 21:52 GMT
#36
because i make more money when its later on the day and I see more american cities behind their names.
decafchicken
Profile Blog Joined January 2005
United States19432 Posts
September 01 2005 22:03 GMT
#37
I only read this post because of the title. If the title had been "Rekruls deep long insiteful post about his life" I would've skipped it and told myself to read it some other time :p
how reasonable is it to eat off wood instead of your tummy?
Muhweli
Profile Joined September 2002
Finland5328 Posts
September 01 2005 22:20 GMT
#38
Morality is defined by people. Not agreeing with some of these views makes you a bad person. Thus I'm a bad person.

I like what 0x64 said about Team Work and poker is supposed to be fun, but poker not being social is probably referring to the online form of this. As far as I understood, the article Rek posted is not just about online poker.

I do see Rek's point though - thinking of poker as a long-time career seems a bit silly to me and it's no reason to abandon studies whatsoever, but I disagree on it being "evil" or "morally incorrect". The "someone wins => someone loses" bullshit is just plain stupid. I don't see trouble with the fact that losing players choose to play regardless of their losses. Harming other people should be defined otherwise since these losing players probably play for fun anyway and them losing the money doesn't directly harm them - If it does, they shouldn't play and that's again just their fault.

Someone mentioned rake. Now there's some thought in that. It's normal to set a rake at such business, because upkeeping such systems isn't free either, but the rake levels are very very high compared to what they should be. Either way, there are corporations in the other end too, upkeeping the servers, improving the software etc etc. They're working. Now sure there is a big filthy rich boss in the company that gets the cream of the profits, but then again, there's one in each big company, no?

Also about the taxes - yea if they don't pay them, they probably make a bit more - BUT the servers they run are international, people all over the world use it - shouldn't they be paying taxes in every country then? Big companies, let's say car makers sell cars all over the world, each country adds their own car taxes etc etc to these. Maybe we'd like to add a country specific rake into the pots to compensate for this?

And although people make more money in poker, it only easens their life's anyway. Thinking of poker players as bad evil people who take money from other's applies to all store owner's, game makers, and well, every corporation, shop or such that sells something. They give something to get something in return. Poker is a game where you play for yourself and it's the same for EVERY person. If you think you're evil because you're taking some moderately good player's money, should the moderately good player also feel he's doing wrong still making profit from the worse players. Should this continue to the very bottom of the penny tables where people lose or break even for ages.

My point being that the money will ANYWAY find itself back to the pockets of a hardworking citizen. Mr. John Doe is a head leader of a major car company. He goes to work and arranges meetings, he has this little hobby - he likes to gamble on rather high roll on his freetime. He loses a lot, but what the hell - it's still fun. Mr. Rek is a poker professional who plays and has Mr. John Doe fishlisted. He wins a lot of money from him and after the bankroll has increased enough, he decides he needs a new expensive car. He goes to John Doe's car store and buy's a car. A part of that sum goes as a rake to the goverment and a part goes all the way up, back to John Doe's pocket.

On his way home, Mr. Rek decides to purchase a hot dog from a genuinely happy seller with a supposedly a less good job. The hot dog is made and Rek get's a nice smile as he just made the person a bit richer. The hot dog girl (now let's just assume it was a girl) smiles knowing that she probably made a dollar again for a piece of bread and meat that didn't cost him jackshit and with no risk whatsoever at all (excluding food poisoning and lawsuit). Now where is the moral in that ? She just sits there all day and takes money from everyone that wants to give it to her.

I bet many people have done things such as downloaded music, movies or software from the internet. People work in doing these and downloading them from free is immoral, but I don't see Rek complaining about such things although it's a lot more questionable morally than taking money from people who willingly give it to you.

Cheers.
River me timbers.
BigshoT
Profile Joined July 2005
United States171 Posts
Last Edited: 2005-09-01 23:20:20
September 01 2005 23:12 GMT
#39
Happiness is different to each person...to simply say freedom = happiness isn't true.

Poker could be the worst career to ever pursue. For every success story there are hundreds (probably thousands) where people can't even feed their family. All I ever hear is how these ex-BW players play poker 24/7. Maybe if they had gone to college instead of wasting their life on a game..they wouldn't be playing poker in order to survive. Go step outside and get a job.

After reading this scroll down to the bottom of TL.net website...and look bottom left. Absolutely pathetic...
Ramble On~
Bill307
Profile Blog Joined October 2002
Canada9103 Posts
September 02 2005 00:24 GMT
#40
A very insightful and thought-provoking topic, this has become.

After much thinking, here is what I can say with confidence: it is not enough that some of the rich man's money makes its way back into the hands of the hardworker. Working from Muhweli's example, isn't there something obviously wrong with comparing the situations of Mr. Rek and John Doe? One is living a much more luxurious lifestyle than the other, despite SOME of the money finding its way back to hardworking John.

Part of the problem with getting rich through poker and then spending the money selfishly is that by virtue of having so much wealth and luxury, you increase the gap between rich and poor. Ultimately, the more wealth you have, the less wealth some poor person will have.

The other aspect is that your contribution to society through your work is minor or trivial compared to "hardworking" jobs. I mean, you can really stretch it and say that you're providing a means for John Doe to entertain himself or to practice to try and improve, while also supporting Pokerstars.com, etc. Now compare that to the other extreme: a paramedic who saves lives. Clearly different jobs will contribute varying amounts to society. And pro poker is clearly hovering around the less-helpful end of the spectrum.

On September 02 2005 03:40 travis wrote:
i don't believe in social responsibility, that's total bullshit.


We all owe society something because we all GAIN tremendously from society, from other people. So at the very least, we should aim to return the favour. Personally, I wouldn't consider playing pro poker and then spending selfishly a way to give back to society what it has given to you (not equally, that is). And if one person (society) is giving much more than the other (you), then the former is ultimately being harmed.
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 9 10 11 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
OSC
11:00
Community Open #127
WardiTV56
Belair 21
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Livibee 415
sOs 257
Cure 211
ProTech170
Ragnarok 152
TRUE 56
AxAlicia37
AusProbe 29
Symbol 15
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 2189
Flash 1915
Larva 1898
BeSt 706
Stork 377
ZerO 341
Horang2 285
Aegong 228
Bale 221
Light 170
[ Show more ]
Last 152
Soma 122
PianO 118
Rush 89
ggaemo 57
actioN 53
Noble 46
Mind 21
Hyun 17
Sacsri 17
sorry 14
Jaehoon 13
Hm[arnc] 12
ForGG 12
Nal_rA 11
Killer 5
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
shoxiejesuss1395
Other Games
Liquid`RaSZi2323
Organizations
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO3271
StarCraft 2
OgamingTV Inter796
OGamingTV SC2 360
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
dreamhackcs55
StarCraft 2
SC2 Vod Archives43
StarCraft: Brood War
Classic BW VODs23
StarCraft 2
TaKeTV27
[ Show 5 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• afternyte 14
• Fallenger 6
• Bosshoore 1
StarCraft: Brood War
• sscaitournament4
Other Games
• TSM TheOddOne1038
Upcoming Events
Blazing Series
15m
Rex vs Creator
Nice vs Bomber
StarCraft2.fi
4h 45m
GG of the Year
4h 45m
StarCraft Sundays
6h 45m
SpeCial vs Awers
Bly vs Awers
DnS vs Bly
SpeCial vs DnS
DnS vs Awers
SKillous vs DnS
SpeCial vs SKillous
SKillous vs Awers
Proxy Tempest
7h 45m
The Pizza Pie
14h 15m
OlimoLeague
23h 45m
StarCraft2.fi
1d 4h
GG of the Year
1d 4h
Path of Star
1d 23h
[ Show More ]
StarCraft2.fi
2 days
The Pylon Show
2 days
StarCraft2.fi
4 days
IndyK Event
5 days
Chance vs Angry
PassionCraft
5 days
Cheesadelphia
5 days
GG of the Year
5 days
IndyK Event
5 days
Grand Platypus Open
5 days
DSCL Nationals
5 days
BW Jeez Weekly
6 days
PassionCraft
6 days
Cheesadelphia
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

North American Autumn Starleague
WESG 2019 - North America Qualifier
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 3
EPL Season 10 - Finals

Ongoing

Titanes Del Ring Nation Wars
BWCL Season 49
KCM Race Survival Season 12
2019 Liquipedia Shinhan Tank Proleague
GPC 2019 - Grand Finals
HotS League: REVIVAL S4
H. Lounge Div. S S2 EU Qual.
Nexus Cup 3

Upcoming

BW Jeez weekly 52
BSL8 Ladder Open #3
BW Jeez weekly 51
BSL8 Ladder Gosu & Chobo #3
BSL8 Ladder Open #2
BW Jeez weekly 50
BSL8 Ladder Gosu & Chobo #2
WESG 2019
IEM Katowice 2020
OSC Championship Season 7
Copa América 2019 Season 3
Cheeseadelphia XI
WESG 2019 - China Qualifier
Agon Premier League: Season 1
H. Lounge Div. S S2 EU Crucible
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 4
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 5
Champions Cup Finals
EPICENTER 2019
ESEA S32 - Global Challenge
DH Open Sevilla 2019
cs_summit 5
BLAST Pro Series: Global Final
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2019 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.