EPTIf marv flips red then I'll re-evaluate everything, I think Moosy is probably town but with a red flip marv he could potentially be scum. If he flips anything else then in my eyes Moosy is practically confirmed town.
Student Mafia XV - Page 47
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
If marv flips red then I'll re-evaluate everything, I think Moosy is probably town but with a red flip marv he could potentially be scum. If he flips anything else then in my eyes Moosy is practically confirmed town. | ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:29 MoosyDoosy wrote: I'm going to wait on what Kelsier says and then make a decision. If he think I've been tunneling too, I'm going to have to accept that Shining made a terrible contradiction and play that made so sense and that he should be allowed to get away with it. But I'm still going to keep an eye on him. Don't get me wrong I don't think you've got NO case. I'm very interested to see who flips and what info we get out of that. But I just don't find it entirely convincing. Like I said, I can kinda see where he was going with it and it looks more like a poor explanation than a scum play. | ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
If he magically turns up right before it and votes then he's top of my suspicion list D2 unless he manages to look literally so green that I think he's a plant. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
I think shining is clearly town, his first list post was very good and seemed to line up, mostly, with how I was reading the game. I think ES's response was pretty shit with her "reaction test" or whatever that was. Like you said the post had loads of things wrong with it and then didn't say anything about it, The moosy-shining thing was a complete cluster fuck but it did give me some thoughts. There are situations where a townie is being piled on and people will come to their defence to gain credit. For me the people who were coming to his defence, in a round about way On October 12 2015 08:15 Vivax wrote: I like shining, he's like me when I get adrenaline injections On October 12 2015 13:33 sicklucker wrote: Like im pretty sure all of you are town. Make love not war On October 12 2015 12:58 ObviousOne wrote: When did the circus come into town? Not wanting to vote for someone because one of your scum reads is voting for them, on day one, where a bus is largely unlikely, when you have a scum read on someone else that you consider equally valid, is totally okay in my book. This tunneling shining into rage is really out of this world. Wow. Sincerely. Instead of being antagonizing, honest level-headed questions would get you a lot farther. The responses I got from Shining were decent enough and there wasn't any vitriol that I could sense. Equally, how many people have actually voted for you Shining? There's still many hours until the lynch and Marv is a much more likely majority candidate because the tells we have make it almost a sure thing he's mafia unless he comes back glowing green like the Hulk. Your fate isn't set in stone so getting too upset is only damaging to your cause. Like I said before, if things get emotionally charged, take a short break to collect your thoughts, think about what's going on and why it's happening. For instance, maybe Eversince is a super clever mafia player. This total antagonistic dialogue she has engaged in with you is not a healthy town player attitude. And it didn't seem to stop after the break she took. The assault continues. There's no town reason not to try to level with you on in a logical discussion, and it's breaking my town read of her because I'm particularly sensitive to the same kind of issue you're dealing with having been there multiple times. On October 12 2015 22:14 marvellosity wrote: no, he says he understands the meta arguments against me and that they are strong and "logically" a stronger case, but he trusts his own gut on FF more. ta-da. Probably at least one scum in that group of 4. I have OO listed there and although he was sort of scummy early on just reading his recent posts feel pretty town and just now his decision to consolidate and actually try to move things on was nice. marv,had a spam fest but i was unimpressed. Both vivax and SL have this vibe or just eating popcorn and watching town fight eachother. Giving comments but not driving things forward. On October 12 2015 08:17 Vivax wrote: ObviousOne posts very clean and almost too thought out for my taste, I remember reading him correctly as town when he got mislynched last time we played together, I don't know which game it was anymore though. I managed to get that read when he was in the process of trying to stop the lynch. and SL already had the quote of "you're all town stop fighting guys". I'd be happy lynching gummy his "play" is terrible. then Vivax/SL would be my next choice. | ||
|
Vivax
21682 Posts
| ||
|
MoosyDoosy
United States4519 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
21682 Posts
The tingling tinfoil wants me to believe they're bussing him in a way that will obviously make me their preference when it comes down to it. | ||
|
Vivax
21682 Posts
| ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:47 KelsierSC wrote: There are situations where a townie is being piled on and people will come to their defence to gain credit. For me the people who were coming to his defence, in a round about way -snip- Probably at least one scum in that group of 4. I was somewhat defending Shining over the last few pages because I think I can understand his train of thought and I can see where the misunderstanding is. Why am I not on your potential list here? I know you've said you like my posting before but even so that was quite some time ago now. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:49 Vivax wrote: OO and Kelsier confirmed suspicious of SL but ignoring my argument You seem to have had some issues reading what I posted so I apologise for that. After my initial suspicion of you, this latest scum read is the way you defended shining when the pressure was on him , it felt like a way of gaining easy credit. The same applied to SL. Therefore your argument against SL had absolutely no bearing on that interpretation. I did look at your argument on SL, yes I agree with the point you made about him. well done you. | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On October 13 2015 01:03 Vivax wrote: Yeah I think I want to lynch SL for what he said there. He entered the game in some sort of fake ecstasy (which is why he said something that didn't make much sense at the time, to me at least (in spoiler) + Show Spoiler + On October 11 2015 22:00 Vivax wrote: Read this part and tell me how it is a bad reaction but also too cheerful, didn't make much sense to me at the time. and spewed marv town while at the same acting as if he was suspicious of him. Vivax I can see your point. It's a weird thing to do. I don't know Sicklucker though, so I don't know if it's out of the ordinary. So I just let it be what it is, some random derp in the thread at the beginning. The strongest case against Sicklucker is that he's not scum hunting in the thread and has nothing to do with that post. | ||
|
Vivax
21682 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:57 KelsierSC wrote: You seem to have had some issues reading what I posted so I apologise for that. After my initial suspicion of you, this latest scum read is the way you defended shining when the pressure was on him , it felt like a way of gaining easy credit. The same applied to SL. Therefore your argument against SL had absolutely no bearing on that interpretation. I did look at your argument on SL, yes I agree with the point you made about him. well done you. But I didn't try to gain credit for the shining thing, I did something different than SL. I gave reasoning for my townread, while SL tried to stop what he said to be a tvt | ||
|
MoosyDoosy
United States4519 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:56 -Celestial- wrote: I was somewhat defending Shining over the last few pages because I think I can understand his train of thought and I can see where the misunderstanding is. Why am I not on your potential list here? I know you've said you like my posting before but even so that was quite some time ago now. He probably didn't refresh the page. tbh I don't care much for this game if Shining made that terrible play as town so I'm just going to sheep you or kSC. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:56 -Celestial- wrote: I was somewhat defending Shining over the last few pages because I think I can understand his train of thought and I can see where the misunderstanding is. Why am I not on your potential list here? I know you've said you like my posting before but even so that was quite some time ago now. As you mention I liked your early posting and that is part of the reasons you do not make the list. However with the manner of your defence, I would not call it a "round about" or soft defence for easy credit. There is very clear willingness to interact and actually challenge moosy not just to say "duh shining is town" so you look good later on. In essence I interpreted your points about shining differently to others on the list. | ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
 | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
| ||
|
MoosyDoosy
United States4519 Posts
| ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On October 13 2015 03:54 Vivax wrote: Kelsier OO and SL sounds like an incredibly sexy scumteam, I'm actually inclined to let the moosy stuff slide. Things that sound sexy often are let down by reality. Sorry, your scumteam is in another castle. You'll let Moosy off but are clinging to the single post by SL as your reason.... | ||
|
MoosyDoosy
United States4519 Posts
| ||
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
Marv, you asked me about why I like OO's posts and I answered it already when moosy asked me the same thing. On October 12 2015 10:56 Fecalfeast wrote: This post, the bolded shows that he is considering both worlds for marv, though obviously is ultimately tipped toward scum because lolmarv. Not only that but he doesn't like vivax and I am coming around to the idea of a vivax/marv/X team based on the lack of playing. On October 12 2015 10:56 Fecalfeast wrote: Not to mention the defense of me, I am pretty self centred. Besides, unless he's going for the hardest of pockets, he's defending me rather than pushing for my mislynch. Vivax is already on my case, shining with his pressure too. OO could have helped bury me but instead looks at it rationally and breaks down why shining's logic is flawed. On October 12 2015 10:56 Fecalfeast wrote: ok well that was supposed to be 1 post but forgot to cut/paste sorry | ||
| ||
