|
hmm I think I would still prefer lynching hopeless cause I think he could be a strong scum player. Lonemeow is a decent lynch but lonemeow is a lurker and not difficult to lynch regardless of alignment. Having to lynch hopeless would be more of a chore and I think he still might be scum.
Here are the updated vote counts.
1. Balla24 2. Sidesprang 3. Alakaslam 4. cakemanofdoom -Hopeless, Oats 5. LoneMeow -Suki, Koshi, Jonnylaw 6. Jaybrundage -Alakaslam 7. Hopeless1der -Jaybrundage, Balla 8. Oatsmaster 9. JonnyLaw 10. Suki 11. Koshi -Cake, Lonemeow
Lonemeow is set to be lynched and we have about an hour and a half left.
(Also not this vote count doesn't track past unvotes. Or who voted who first and whatnot its just to know who we are gonna lynch.)
|
Unfortunately I've spent like the entire morning and early afternoon thinking and posting about Mafia and I have things to do >_<;
I'll be back before the deadline for maybe some last minute reads.
|
On February 06 2014 05:22 JonnyLaw wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:19 Balla24 wrote: Yep.
Like I said before. If Koshi's Jonny case was purposefully misrepresenting what jonny was saying, then he's scum. But evidence points to that it wasn't on purpose.
Another thing that is nagging me is I don't see anybody really doing anything together with Koshi. This is a terrible point since nobody has flipped but its still in the back of my mind.
LoneMeow on the other hand, still isn't really changing what he's doing. It's the same stuff that people have been calling him out for and he didn't change.
I'd still lynch Hopeless1der hard as hell too.
##unvote ##vote LoneMeow Where'd hopeless go? He made a case and posted for an hour. All pressure seemingly dropped off him and he afks without commenting on Cakeman again or really trying to push the lynch. I'll look at Jay again LM.
This is very true. Maybe he needed a break after our pretty silly argument.
|
On February 06 2014 05:21 Balla24 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:18 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote:On February 06 2014 04:48 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 04:42 suki wrote: I think slam and Balla are firmly town. I think Jonny is also town but that's more a meta read than any close analysis.
I'd agree with Balla24 and JonnyLaw being town, both are actively trying to find and lynch scum, but why Alakaslam? Call it a gut read? He's been contributing his reads and pushing people when he's here. That's actually what worries me most about him, since the town-Alakaslam I know plays far more scummy than this one :D On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote: That episode where he was typing on his phone and his words were totally getting jumbled and messed up also feels more like what a town would do. After that he was upfront with explaining any questions people had. It's just really hard to imagine why scum would do this.
This I do agree with. Not sure what to make of him overall. Point out what you're talking about. I only see a few posts where he seems more like scum-slam and FAR more non-sensical trolly town slam.
Take this for example:
On February 05 2014 02:34 Alakaslam wrote: He just isn't vocalizing his reasons.
Koshi is scummy at first because of his crazy entry to the thread. He is further scummy because he abandons the policy as some sort of joke as soon as he gets fire for it.
Oats is Oats, have you been in many games with him? I don't try to read him yet
Balla24 finally so town ist awesome.
Jaybrundage not near as scummy as I thought he was last night.
But I am devolving into list posting stuff you all either already know or won't care about.
I hope we aren't around looking for some sort of scum tell. I was and I was getting all pissy because I was finding them everywhere. What we need to do is find the unknown, by conventional or unconventional means.
Vote: LoneMeow
jaybrundage why are you scummy? I don't care if you know your alignment is town, why are you scummy? What have you done in this game that is scummy? I want you to look over stuff in your own filter and point it out.
if you feel like it, answer the same question Sidesprang. Or not.
He's freely giving out reads and doing things. This just isn't the Alakaslam I've played with before when he was town. The thing is, people change playstyles so I don't want to call him scum just yet, it's just that this change worries me.
The point is that in previous games he seemed like a total scum-Alakaslam when he was actually town, so now that he does not play like that I'm bothered.
|
##Unvote ##Vote Lonemeow
Again if we wanna do some last minute vote switch shannigans on Hopeless I would totes be down.
1. Balla24 2. Sidesprang 3. Alakaslam 4. cakemanofdoom -Hopeless, Oats 5. LoneMeow -Suki, Koshi, Jonnylaw, Balla, JayBrundage 6. Jaybrundage -Alakaslam 7. Hopeless1der - 8. Oatsmaster 9. JonnyLaw 10. Suki 11. Koshi -Cake, Lonemeow
Lonemeow is set to be lynched and we have about an hour left
(Also not this vote count doesn't track past unvotes. Or who voted who first and whatnot its just to know who we are gonna lynch.)
|
On February 06 2014 05:22 jaybrundage wrote: hmm I think I would still prefer lynching hopeless cause I think he could be a strong scum player. Lonemeow is a decent lynch but lonemeow is a lurker and not difficult to lynch regardless of alignment. Having to lynch hopeless would be more of a chore and I think he still might be scum. This is such a bad post. Just wow.
|
I lied LM. I'm not doing anything with Jay until d2. The only votes I can get for Jay would be yourself and Oats I think. It's not enough.
I'd rather focus my time on figuring out this lm, koshi, hopeless trio.
lm what do you think of hopeless?
|
Oh wait, koshi would lynch jay too?
|
So you think he's scum or what LoneMeow?
If he is then compile something, if not then what are you posting this about in the first place.
I totally understand what you are TRYING to say, but you need to just come out and say it. He has a few posts where he's pro-town non trolly sharing reads and whatever, but for the most part he's pretty trolly and non-sensical and cryptic. Which is town slam. So for the most part, I see him as town slam.
|
On February 06 2014 05:32 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:22 jaybrundage wrote: hmm I think I would still prefer lynching hopeless cause I think he could be a strong scum player. Lonemeow is a decent lynch but lonemeow is a lurker and not difficult to lynch regardless of alignment. Having to lynch hopeless would be more of a chore and I think he still might be scum. This is such a bad post. Just wow. O.o is explaining my thought process a bad thing?
|
On February 06 2014 05:32 JonnyLaw wrote: lm what do you think of hopeless?
I had him as scummy earlier, then he looked better with increased activity and posts that made sense to me, but the fact that he's disappeared now that the pressure on him has lessened is really suspicious. I can lynch him if I can't get any traction on Koshi.
|
I went to get lunch guys holy shit
|
On February 06 2014 05:33 Balla24 wrote: So you think he's scum or what LoneMeow?
If he is then compile something, if not then what are you posting this about in the first place.
I totally understand what you are TRYING to say, but you need to just come out and say it. He has a few posts where he's pro-town non trolly sharing reads and whatever, but for the most part he's pretty trolly and non-sensical and cryptic. Which is town slam. So for the most part, I see him as town slam.
I don't think he's scum, he's "null but watch carefully", and I want to talk about him with others because it helps me read both you and him, to some extent.
|
On February 06 2014 05:18 LoneMeow wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote:On February 06 2014 04:48 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 04:42 suki wrote: I think slam and Balla are firmly town. I think Jonny is also town but that's more a meta read than any close analysis.
I'd agree with Balla24 and JonnyLaw being town, both are actively trying to find and lynch scum, but why Alakaslam? Call it a gut read? He's been contributing his reads and pushing people when he's here. That's actually what worries me most about him, since the town-Alakaslam I know plays far more scummy than this one :D Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote: That episode where he was typing on his phone and his words were totally getting jumbled and messed up also feels more like what a town would do. After that he was upfront with explaining any questions people had. It's just really hard to imagine why scum would do this.
This I do agree with. Not sure what to make of him overall. Why, thank you- I guess this is working
Anyhow my rea on jaybrundage.
If he saw my trap a mile away, why did he still go trip it? Why didn't he post like balla24 and/or point out it was a trap? Why does he want me to think he is scum- as either alignment?
Yet he claims my stupid trap was blatant?
|
On February 06 2014 05:36 Hopeless1der wrote: I went to get lunch guys holy shit
Catch up then!
Do you still want to lynch cakeman or what?
|
@Jay you mentioned that you thought cakeman changing his mind and seeing new information was a townie trait. He did so regarding you with literally no new information. Why is that a townie mindset?
|
On February 06 2014 05:34 jaybrundage wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:32 Koshi wrote:On February 06 2014 05:22 jaybrundage wrote: hmm I think I would still prefer lynching hopeless cause I think he could be a strong scum player. Lonemeow is a decent lynch but lonemeow is a lurker and not difficult to lynch regardless of alignment. Having to lynch hopeless would be more of a chore and I think he still might be scum. This is such a bad post. Just wow. O.o is explaining my thought process a bad thing? It just reads incredible wrong. Red bells everywhere.
|
On February 06 2014 05:27 LoneMeow wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:21 Balla24 wrote:On February 06 2014 05:18 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote:On February 06 2014 04:48 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 04:42 suki wrote: I think slam and Balla are firmly town. I think Jonny is also town but that's more a meta read than any close analysis.
I'd agree with Balla24 and JonnyLaw being town, both are actively trying to find and lynch scum, but why Alakaslam? Call it a gut read? He's been contributing his reads and pushing people when he's here. That's actually what worries me most about him, since the town-Alakaslam I know plays far more scummy than this one :D On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote: That episode where he was typing on his phone and his words were totally getting jumbled and messed up also feels more like what a town would do. After that he was upfront with explaining any questions people had. It's just really hard to imagine why scum would do this.
This I do agree with. Not sure what to make of him overall. Point out what you're talking about. I only see a few posts where he seems more like scum-slam and FAR more non-sensical trolly town slam. Take this for example: Show nested quote +On February 05 2014 02:34 Alakaslam wrote: He just isn't vocalizing his reasons.
Koshi is scummy at first because of his crazy entry to the thread. He is further scummy because he abandons the policy as some sort of joke as soon as he gets fire for it.
Oats is Oats, have you been in many games with him? I don't try to read him yet
Balla24 finally so town ist awesome.
Jaybrundage not near as scummy as I thought he was last night.
But I am devolving into list posting stuff you all either already know or won't care about.
I hope we aren't around looking for some sort of scum tell. I was and I was getting all pissy because I was finding them everywhere. What we need to do is find the unknown, by conventional or unconventional means.
Vote: LoneMeow
jaybrundage why are you scummy? I don't care if you know your alignment is town, why are you scummy? What have you done in this game that is scummy? I want you to look over stuff in your own filter and point it out.
if you feel like it, answer the same question Sidesprang. Or not. He's freely giving out reads and doing things. This just isn't the Alakaslam I've played with before when he was town. The thing is, people change playstyles so I don't want to call him scum just yet, it's just that this change worries me. The point is that in previous games he seemed like a total scum-Alakaslam when he was actually town, so now that he does not play like that I'm bothered. This is a legitimate concern if anyone is wondering. Read "Extractor trick mafia" for an example. Or "Back to the Basics".
|
damnit slam...fucking king of WIFOM bombs over here.
Slam what are your thoughts on cakeman? You're just tuneling jay and not giving us anything else.
|
On February 06 2014 05:42 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2014 05:27 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 05:21 Balla24 wrote:On February 06 2014 05:18 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote:On February 06 2014 04:48 LoneMeow wrote:On February 06 2014 04:42 suki wrote: I think slam and Balla are firmly town. I think Jonny is also town but that's more a meta read than any close analysis.
I'd agree with Balla24 and JonnyLaw being town, both are actively trying to find and lynch scum, but why Alakaslam? Call it a gut read? He's been contributing his reads and pushing people when he's here. That's actually what worries me most about him, since the town-Alakaslam I know plays far more scummy than this one :D On February 06 2014 05:11 suki wrote: That episode where he was typing on his phone and his words were totally getting jumbled and messed up also feels more like what a town would do. After that he was upfront with explaining any questions people had. It's just really hard to imagine why scum would do this.
This I do agree with. Not sure what to make of him overall. Point out what you're talking about. I only see a few posts where he seems more like scum-slam and FAR more non-sensical trolly town slam. Take this for example: On February 05 2014 02:34 Alakaslam wrote: He just isn't vocalizing his reasons.
Koshi is scummy at first because of his crazy entry to the thread. He is further scummy because he abandons the policy as some sort of joke as soon as he gets fire for it.
Oats is Oats, have you been in many games with him? I don't try to read him yet
Balla24 finally so town ist awesome.
Jaybrundage not near as scummy as I thought he was last night.
But I am devolving into list posting stuff you all either already know or won't care about.
I hope we aren't around looking for some sort of scum tell. I was and I was getting all pissy because I was finding them everywhere. What we need to do is find the unknown, by conventional or unconventional means.
Vote: LoneMeow
jaybrundage why are you scummy? I don't care if you know your alignment is town, why are you scummy? What have you done in this game that is scummy? I want you to look over stuff in your own filter and point it out.
if you feel like it, answer the same question Sidesprang. Or not. He's freely giving out reads and doing things. This just isn't the Alakaslam I've played with before when he was town. The thing is, people change playstyles so I don't want to call him scum just yet, it's just that this change worries me. The point is that in previous games he seemed like a total scum-Alakaslam when he was actually town, so now that he does not play like that I'm bothered. This is a legitimate concern if anyone is wondering. Read "Extractor trick mafia" for an example. Or "Back to the Basics".
Why are you arguing that people should be taking him seriously when he's calling you mafia...
|
|
|
|