|
On September 01 2013 01:41 Oatsmaster wrote: I dont understand why its a policy to lynch the unlynchable dude day 1..
it's more that he hasn't done anything except say im unlynchable, umad?
|
On September 01 2013 01:27 VayneAuthority wrote: like the people on felkyr more than geript right now so add me in on felkyr. I liked his last post so hopefully we can agree on something else.
##vote: Felkyr what
|
It's like you talk about why geript is best lynch and how felky's last post looks townie, so obviously it makes complete sense to vote felky over geript because that makes sense and makes complete sense.
|
On September 01 2013 01:54 Dandel Ion wrote: It's like you talk about why geript is best lynch and how felky's last post looks townie, so obviously it makes complete sense to vote felky over geript because that makes sense and makes complete sense. I like Dandel. Dandel voting geript. ##sheep and ##sleep
##vote geript
|
aaaand one more on the pile of terrible disappointments.
|
it does make sense, considering I know im wrong given the people on geript currently
|
On September 01 2013 00:56 cakepie wrote:Reverting last vote (actually extraneous, as was not posted in the voting thread.) ##Unvote ##Vote: Alakaslam ---- Alright Felkyr here's one for you Show nested quote +I don't feel good about Rayn. He hasn't said that much, and most of it is the BM stuff from the beginning. He talked about BM a lot, while he didn't want to talk about BM. He tried to sketch it as a scumteam. Looked like scum who wanted to direct attention to other scum. But now I'm not sure anymore. I don't see the Black Mesa discussion from Rayn as insiduous, can you explain further why he looks like "scum who wanted to direct attention to other scum"? Before Onegu came out with his information about BM, Rayn's stance that BM should be treated as a scum faction is reasonable, no? Plus his disagreement with kitaman revolved around a misunderstanding. Is there anything else that supports your suspicions, perhaps?
Alright, I have time to answer that question, then I'm gone again.
Well, I was actually not sure if it really was a misreading. Maybe I read it wrong. I mean, HE states it was a misreading, but it was a nice way for him to make BM look scum, or at least create some chaos/random shit. If scum has infiltrators in BM, they might have known or guessed at that point that BM has no goal (do they?). Onegu/Stutters is that possible with the timing, when did it seem to you that BM had no goal (if it is allowed to compare those timings)? In any case it doesn't matter that much. After it was 'clarified' as a misreading, he seems to 'attack' people for not pointing out the misreading. More chaos? He hasn't done much more since then, has he? That's maybe not much, but I have the feeling this game is about accusing/reading people for not much. If you want I'll put some more time in it when I'm back, I haven't really got the time now.
|
|
Blazinghand
United States25550 Posts
On September 01 2013 02:22 geript wrote: Well BH any last words?
Everything I did, I did for my people.
|
On September 01 2013 02:22 geript wrote: Well BH any last words? Be Brown! Kill the Red Man! Paint the streets with his blood.
|
On August 31 2013 19:24 Dandel Ion wrote: Oh I see what the brown thing is.
well, what it was.
the house that has been built need not stay the same.
clarity, are you town?
snb, are you town?
These are ez yes/no questions. Surely you will not have trouble answering them. i win with town. winning with town is my only win condition. i am a member of no other alignment than town. this is literally true i am town. this is metaphorically true but my rolename is not "town" so it is not literally true.
On August 31 2013 23:10 yamato77 wrote: What about lynching Rayn?
1) It's hilarious.
2) He's been less than useless.
3) He'll bitch for all eternity.
4) I've never seen him play town and give so little of a damn about a game.
Yeah, I like this idea. nope rayn's filter is way more game-related and way less fight-picky than when he was scum in got either he's suddenly gotten much better at playing scum or he's a different alignment, either way we're not lynching him today.
OKAY SO GERIPT
possibilities: 1 he's town and some-shot lynchproof 2 he's scum or third party and some-shot lynchproof 3 he's town and lying 4 he's scum or third party and lying
i'm going to ignore 3 for now because fuck him then.
I don't think 1 is likely. if he was really town then the only reason to try to get lynched like he has been would be if he gains some kind of power. there is literally no reason not to tell us that, but instead he just sits around and trolls the thread.
so he's scum. which is more likely, 2 or 4.
i think 2 is more likely. geript claimed unlynchable on page 49. when he claimed it he was at 3 votes, only one of which had even come in the previous 20 hours. this was not a desparate move by a scum or a 3p trying to reverse-psychology us into not lynching them. there's no way that was anything other than someone trying to get lynched.
why give scum what they want. we don't know why they want it but i think it's more likely that geript wants to be lynched than that he doesn't. and i don't want to give him what he wants.
who do I want to kill? Well, VE. I still think his geript case was suspicious as fuck. The fact that I now believe geript is scum doesn't mean I don't think VE is also scum. Remember, geript wants to get lynched! VE could easily be his scum buddy. Also, remember the possibility of multiple scum factions. regardless of whether or not the black mesa pm circle thing is one of them. last aperture game there was a mixed-alignment pm circle and also two scum factions.
I challenge everyone to read what I wrote about VE's case on geript up until geript claimed lynchproof. tell me how VE could have been pushing that case from a townie mindset. Hell, when VE answered me he didn't even respond to my takedown of his case at all, he just attacked me for "not drawing strong enough conclusions from it."
I guess since it's less than twelve hours from lynch I should be talking about consolidation as well. Currently I would also lynch Kita. Not so sure about BH anymore. Don't want to kill wos anymore either. I could get down with lynching felkyr but the case on him is kind of a coinflip between scum or noob imo. still better odds of hitting scum than a policy lynch on zentor or alakaslam (both of whom are reasonable policy lynch targets).
I'm leaving my vote on VE for now, there's still 6+ hours until the lynch.
|
It's not possible to kill VE today strong. They aren't reading his posts
|
hiro you're experienced enough to know if you really want to get bh lynched you're going to have to be more persuasive than that and you're going to have to analyze more of his output than just his vote switch to geript. at this point all you're doing is building up meaningless thread presence.
why dont you want to kill VE? talk to me about it.
alternatively: how strongly do you feel about not giving geript the lynch he so fervently desires? would you switch to felkyr or mrzentor if need be to avoid it?
|
On September 01 2013 02:41 HiroPro wrote:It's not possible to kill VE today strong. They aren't reading his posts but maybe they will! I already wrote a big takedown of his day1, all they have to do is read it there's still hope!
|
On September 01 2013 02:44 strongandbig wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2013 02:41 HiroPro wrote:It's not possible to kill VE today strong. They aren't reading his posts but maybe they will! I already wrote a big takedown of his day1, all they have to do is read it there's still hope! But strong, don't you know? It's not about what you say, it's about how many posts you make!
On September 01 2013 02:44 strongandbig wrote: hiro you're experienced enough to know if you really want to get bh lynched you're going to have to be more persuasive than that and you're going to have to analyze more of his output than just his vote switch to geript. at this point all you're doing is building up meaningless thread presence.
why dont you want to kill VE? talk to me about it.
alternatively: how strongly do you feel about not giving geript the lynch he so fervently desires? would you switch to felkyr or mrzentor if need be to avoid it? At this point geript is probably vengeful or something. Or he just is doing whatever he feels like because he can. /shrug As far as I see it right now, we're either going to end up with a nolynch or a geript lynch.
I don't the case on Felkyr is very strong at all. Could be town, could be mafia. but again no real reason to kill him over others. Zentor is a vig shot - you know this.
|
My read through some filters has left me with a few town reads, but no real scum reads. I'm still not planning on voting until later in the day, but geript looks like he's still my strongest anti-town read. I'm having trouble seeing the town motivation in basically saying "I'm unlynchable, so vote for me." I can't seem to rationalize what he's doing from any perspective. It's a weird situation, because he appears to want to be lynched (or at least voted for). On one hand, I don't want to give that to him if he's scum/3p, but at the very least we'd eliminate a scum/3p. And if he's town, then it'll likely help us to lynch him (or he's playing against his wincon). It's where I'm most comfortable with my (eventual) vote atm.
|
Fuba just give the item to me. Most importantly I'm town, but what might appeal to you is that I won't do anything stupid with it. It will basically just be in the hands of town. That's if you HAVE to give it to anyone, because to me the act of just holding onto it achieves the same result and would appease me quite thoroughly.
|
##unvote
I like his recent posting.
And geript WILL FLIP TOWN GUYS. MARK MY WORDS. AND SOMEONE WILL DIE BECAUSE OF IT. Lynch Yamato cause hes been fucking useless and not made anyone angry. He wants to lynch Dandel. lulno. And geript. lultown.
##vote yamato
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
On September 01 2013 03:09 VisceraEyes wrote: Fuba just give the item to me. Most importantly I'm town, but what might appeal to you is that I won't do anything stupid with it. It will basically just be in the hands of town. That's if you HAVE to give it to anyone, because to me the act of just holding onto it achieves the same result and would appease me quite thoroughly.
I'm catching up right now, but I can't seem to find what you are referring to here?
|
11589 Posts
On September 01 2013 03:13 Oatsmaster wrote: ##unvote
I like his recent posting.
And geript WILL FLIP TOWN GUYS. MARK MY WORDS. AND SOMEONE WILL DIE BECAUSE OF IT. Lynch Yamato cause hes been fucking useless and not made anyone angry. He wants to lynch Dandel. lulno. And geript. lultown.
##vote yamato You're not even reading.
|
|
|
|