Aperture Mafia 2: Episode 2 - Page 67

On September 01 2013 03:30 Felkyr wrote:


Here is a question: Who are you? Really, just answer this question as you would like and we'll see where we get from there.



I suppose that's not a 3P claim?

On September 01 2013 04:37 Oatsmaster wrote:
Is it majority?

On September 01 2013 04:14 kitaman27 wrote:
I'm not sure there is anyone that I'm suspicious of to have enough posts to warrant a huge case on so I'll just be listing my opinions on a selected group of individuals that I have noted that warranted a filter read.

Cephiro is mostly interested about third party players and item mechanics. I'd want to lynch him if it weren't for the fact that he randomly decided to claim blue. I'm not sure why he wouldn't be worried about taking a hit, but if he has a way to prove that his power can benefit town then I'm willing to wait until day two.

I'm pretty sure this is like the 5th game in a row I've played with Zentor where he hasn't actually posted. Something to note is that he could be a vote rigger or something and make it appear as if geript is lynchproof. I'm not really sure why he would claim in that case though.

There are certainly some things I don't like about Wave's filter, but not enough to be confident that he is scum yet. His contribution picked up after I mentioned that I'd be looking into him, but that doesn't necessarily rule out a town reaction as well. The biggest thing against him is the fact that he appears "frustrated" by the lurkers and the suspicion on Dandel, calling Dandel the most active player in the game. At the point of his post, Dandel honestly has a couple words of value.

randombum's filter is pretty terrible. His name has hardly been brought up so he is definitely playing under the radar at the moment. He goes after geript on a gut read and has posted little since. He said he will be available to contribute to the majority if need be, but he provides little direction to who he actually wants lynched or who he is suspicious of.

cakepie seems to need to be prompted for his contributions, which is a concern. His vote is currently for a policy lynch, but it would be unfair for me out of all people to criticize that. He explains that he is filter diving, but there is little evidence that anything came out of that. I don't really understand the point of a pressure vote on felkyr if he is going to point out that it is a pressure vote. It isn't clear that there is anyone in this game that cakepie actually thinks is mafia.

ObviousOne is one of those people that I'm suspicious of based on his town read on Dandel so early into the game. He seems to be around, but not very interested in the game. He decides to sheep Dandel with the geript vote without actually mentioning him at any point in his filter.

clarity and stutters seem to have the biggest black mesa connections based on my exchange with rayn for questioning why Black Mesa members should be considered a mafia faction. Stutters already claimed BM, so that leaves clarity as the other possibility. I haven't read his filter today however.

I'm not incredibly familiar with Risen's play, but the difference between GoT where he was town and this game is pretty apparent. In GoT he was making a significant number of cases, even if most of them were off in left field. You could tell he was town simply by the way he was sharing his opinions. His defense and suspicion against Cheesecake is essentially that he hasn't done anything this game, so that means nothing he has done can be portrayed as anti-town. His response to Onegu doesn't seem like a town reaction in my opinion. I think he would be a good lynch.

geript has been playing blatantly anti-town. If memory serves me correct, he was more verbose as mafia in The Game, but there is next to nothing in his filter that is redeeming. That fact that he likely has identified the fact that he is going to be lynched, but has done nothing to stop it probably points to mafia. If he were a town lynchproof player, he would have realized that a day one no lynch would be a disaster and likely only mess up day two as well.

Risen, randombum, ObviousOne, cakepie, and geript are the players that I'd prefer to lynch into today. I still haven't read VE's filters, which is always something to dread. I'll probably decide on my preferred target within the next hour if possible for the sake of consolidation. I'd like to hear opinions on any of the individuals I've mentioned, outside of geript.

On September 01 2013 04:45 Blazinghand wrote:


vote geript