|
On December 13 2012 23:36 austinmcc wrote: Well, hello there.
Palmar, can I ask not for names but whether there are other linked pairs, or at least the possibility for other/different linked pairs in the future?
Bitch please.
|
On December 14 2012 00:03 austinmcc wrote: I'm not used to seeing complete thoughts like this from Palmar to random questions. Palmar also heavily telegraphed how Foolishness's response would shape his read, whether honest or not, which feels a bit strange though. If Palmar's read is truly going to be influenced by Foolishness's response, then he wouldn't go telling Foolishness how to respond. I dunno, when I first read this post I liked it a lot, found it very townie, but the more I think about it the more it feels a bit out of character - fully formed response to a question, giving out a thought process that's invalid once you put it into thread.
I was explaining how I had expected him to answer, that's why I asked him to lay out his thoughts before I actually explained what I had hoped for hearing. To put it simply, by the time I explained what I wanted from him, I also closed the window on an explanation from him.
|
On December 14 2012 00:28 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On December 14 2012 00:03 austinmcc wrote: I'm not used to seeing complete thoughts like this from Palmar to random questions. Palmar also heavily telegraphed how Foolishness's response would shape his read, whether honest or not, which feels a bit strange though. If Palmar's read is truly going to be influenced by Foolishness's response, then he wouldn't go telling Foolishness how to respond. I dunno, when I first read this post I liked it a lot, found it very townie, but the more I think about it the more it feels a bit out of character - fully formed response to a question, giving out a thought process that's invalid once you put it into thread.
I was explaining how I had expected him to answer, that's why I asked him to lay out his thoughts before I actually explained what I had hoped for hearing. To put it simply, by the time I explained what I wanted from him, I also closed the window on an explanation from him. Fair enough.
If you don't want to claim anything further about your role, fine, but you can't really get peeved at Clarity for swapping people with no notice if you're going around attaching them with no notice, and no explanation for what might be going on in the future.
|
The king does as he wishes.
|
On December 14 2012 00:35 Palmar wrote: The king does as he wishes. I'm going to interpret this as
"I've still been playing sven as a hard-support the last couple months."
|
On December 14 2012 00:41 austinmcc wrote:I'm going to interpret this as "I've still been playing sven as a hard-support the last couple months."
I stopped playing sven, I don't enjoy it now that everyone expects me to carry.
I now play Rylai all day long. Here's a dota tip: if you get any +str or +hp item on rylai other than magic wand you're doing it wrong.
Anyway, now I don't know who to lynch in this world, tempted to kill someone useless/inactive.
|
@Sandroba in the other thread.
Do you think austinmcc could be scum?
|
I'm hoping that at least 1-2 inactive-y folks become less so, and not just an hour before lynch. Just being able to halve the pool of ?s would really help.
|
marv, what does "Dieno is Dieno" mean?
##Vote (GreY): Crossfire99
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On December 14 2012 01:02 slOosh wrote: marv, what does "Dieno is Dieno" mean?
##Vote (GreY): Crossfire99
He played in Chrono and he was cute and cuddly Dieno with his diagrams and generally just fluffing about.
Work's been pretty hectic for me this week, I'll put in effort later to get proper reads, anything I say right now is just feel
|
@Darkfire
You need to be a bit more clear as to what you do:
In your first post, you said: After several turns your ability reveals a person who was swapped. You're forever stuck in your world Potentially "we" can tag a scum if "we guess" a swap reveal correct
Later: Your ability shows alignment and/or role you assume
Later later: You get to observe swaps that happen at night
Do you have to activate this ability in order to "observe swaps that happen at night"? Does your ability stay activated permanently? What do you mean by "observe swaps" (We can all see who gets swapped, but you don't seem to be saying you can check everyone who gets swapped each night. So do you actually observe anything that the rest of us don't?) Your ability specifically says it "reveals" someone? If there's no detail, you probably should be asking what that means, rather than just saying it isn't specific. Are you un-swappable? If not, what do you mean by "forever stuck in your world"?
|
Brunei Darussalam622 Posts
On December 13 2012 23:51 austinmcc wrote: Dienosore, thoughts on clarity's swap? Read on Keirathi? Do you still find yamato townie?
I think Clarity is a total poop head for trying something like this hours before our vote. My heart's first instinct is to start a bandwagon to lynch Clarity, but my brain supposes he didn't actually know this was going to happen. I hope the people in iSL finish the job for us on their lynch day. Clarity, please no more random swaps.
My maps show me Keirathi has no support from anyone in this world, but not in the same way as Fool;He has no incomming lines AT ALL, which says to me that he's done a good job staying out of the spotlight. In iSL, he has one positive connection with Sandroba, who thinks he is town. He's been actively reading both threads. Blah blah blah. The only extraordinary point of interest so far is that Keir's main scum target was Kenpachi, not Fool. Not sure what that means, but I do find it intriguing that he would pick on someone who hasn't really done much this game.
The reason I find Yamato as town is because my maps indicate he has been fiercely interacting with something like 60% of the game's population. I just don't see a scumball creating such a large profile so early in the game, specially on a relatively non-threatening swap day. I guess you could argue that scum would use this time of peace to stir up as much trouble as possible, but my gut tells me he is just a deranged towny. I know you guys had a tense interaction in the other world, so please, I'd like to hear more of your thoughts about him too.
|
On December 14 2012 03:14 Dienosore wrote: The reason I find Yamato as town is because my maps indicate he has been fiercely interacting with something like 60% of the game's population. I just don't see a scumball creating such a large profile so early in the game, specially on a relatively non-threatening swap day. I guess you could argue that scum would use this time of peace to stir up as much trouble as possible, but my gut tells me he is just a deranged towny. I know you guys had a tense interaction in the other world, so please, I'd like to hear more of your thoughts about him too. I'm actually alright with that logic, although he doesn't seem to have a mode of interaction besides "fierce."
My current thoughts are that he's overly aggressive and that I don't really want to follow or put faith in his reads, but that he's not scummy.
His continued insistence on the mementoss read when we didn't have a lynch for another 72 hours in that world tells me that it's a real read, something he wants to push, and not just for show. Scum could have caved, or at the very least could have sought more opinions and then caved later, whereas he just continued to hammer the same point.
Overall, I'm mildly townie on him.
|
Could someone in this world please type out the following statement:
"None of the following players are anti-town at the moment: Palmar, slOosh, Crossfire99"
|
I'll go ahead and note that I think I work differently than past iterations, as I receive an answer via PM, not in the thread itself.
|
Keirathi,
I'm primarily concerned with lynching scum at the moment. Scum would be anti-town all day urrday, so this question catches them. It doesn't catch any kind of weird alignment swapping, and I omitted clarity_nl because all sorts of weird things could happen there. I just want to narrow down candidates for today's lynch, since the swap kind of reset this world to the beginning and we're not doing much.
|
Or...we can go with
"None of the following players have anti-town roles at the moment: Palmar, slOosh, Crossfire99"
|
I'm grabbing lunch. Please someone type out that second phrase here. I'd like to narrow down some lynch options for today, and potentially have 2 strong townies to trust.
|
Pheonix Wright? I got you.
None of Palmar, slOosh or Crossfire99 are anti-town.
|
Keir are you saying that we should make it strictly a scum catch question?
|
|
|
|