|
On December 22 2015 22:52 Ve5pa wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 17:28 Liquid`Bunny wrote: I was gonna go but now with no koreans i don't care anymore Haha, this made me laugh xD But those tweets from the full of salt North Americans didn't, really sad to see that. Backhanded compliment from iNcontrol as well. IMO Blizzard should give the fans what they want, and clearly many people want to see Koreans at foreign events. Half of the issue a lot of pro's seem to have is the Koreans that have the right to play like Polt don't play on their local ladders and therefore don't contribute to that community getting better. I know total Biscuit had some ideas about this he went over in a soundcloud piece. Total Biscuit's ideas were very reasonable.
|
On December 22 2015 23:10 aQuaSC wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:05 Ve5pa wrote:On December 22 2015 23:00 Clonester wrote:On December 22 2015 22:52 Ve5pa wrote:On December 22 2015 17:28 Liquid`Bunny wrote: I was gonna go but now with no koreans i don't care anymore Haha, this made me laugh xD But those tweets from the full of salt North Americans didn't, really sad to see that. Backhanded compliment from iNcontrol as well. IMO Blizzard should give the fans what they want, and clearly many people want to see Koreans at foreign events. Half of the issue a lot of pro's seem to have is the Koreans that have the right to play like Polt don't play on their local ladders and therefore don't contribute to that community getting better. I know total Biscuit had some ideas about this he went over in a soundcloud piece. We acutally had Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Jjakji, Stardust, Sacsri and ForGG playing all day on the Europen ladder. We kicked their asses back to korea. Not to mention, that Fantasy and True were ready to move over. Even Rain. And the Invasion Esports Koreans. We shut the door right in their face. Yeah it seems mainly an NA issue to be honest from what I hear. Your right I do believe most of the GEM players and mYi players would play on EU, this is probably why the EU scene seems to be a lot more competative than the NA scene. I think the Koreans based in NA would just rather play on Korea server with higher ping, or so I gathered. Yeah, I agree. Unless there is a real incentive in playing local ladder, Koreans (I mean the majority or just the currently best ones) will never willingly play anywhere else than in their own region. I'm not even sure if money would fix that, as TB's solution proposed. And to counter an argument that foreigners playing with foreigners will hurt the overall player-base skill-wise, wouldn't the situation where Koreans play foreigners hurt Korean skill level? Wouldn't the "pure" skill got worse if they weren't forced to compete that hard, while they would be the best in the region? Hehe, well, Life's skill did not get worse by playing Lilbow three times in a row :-)
|
On December 22 2015 23:14 p4ch1n0 wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 22:49 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:44 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:40 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:On December 22 2015 22:35 AWalker9 wrote:On December 22 2015 22:13 p4ch1n0 wrote:On December 22 2015 20:57 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 20:42 aQuaSC wrote:On December 22 2015 20:13 WrathSCII wrote:On December 22 2015 20:05 aQuaSC wrote: [quote]
Wow it's your first post that I see when you don't shit on a foreigner lol Snute is kinda special. Ah, I understand. Sorry Diabolique if you felt insulted. I just couldn't help but see that you "shit" on foreigners stating that foreigner scene is irrelevant at all and only Korea (along with those that don't hold achievements) with foreigners who achieved something significant during last five years are the people that community should focus on. And only these are important to you. I can understand that obviously, I'd be pretty pissed if I was a big football fan and Champions League was resized all of a sudden to hold less champion-caliber teams for few that don't always qualify because of the barrier they need to break. And again - to me the worst thing about this system is the fact that it was introduced too late, after Koreans were let all over the world for the money to grab therefore extremely shrinking foreign scene. I said in other thread, that with the last systems to really break out in a non-WCS tournament to gain visibility you needed to be very lucky or incredibly good out of nothing - not having access to practice with Koreans on regular basis and be able to beat few of the KeSPA guys. Basically perform a miracle. But I am not shitting on any foreigners. Maybe Desrow, maybe Mana when they started to celebrate the new system. Snute is a good guy, I never saw any tweet "celebrating" the new system from him. And his comment was awesome, saying, how he would be happy to have the opportunity to still compete with the Koreans somewhere. I am even not saying that foreigners are bad. I am even not the kind of guy, who would just follow the highest level of SC2 only. Without the casters, I would be unable to recognize it. I even do not like that much GSL and SSL, in fact, I want to watch them only when my favorite player, sOs is playing. And with this new system, there is a big probability, he will not be playing any of them (= he will not qualify). I am angry, because this is not justice! This is injustice! Banning the best players from ALL international tournaments, reducing their own local events, this is significantly reducing their life options. How can people exist, who support this? This huge injustice! They could have created a new WCS circuit, they could have stolen DreamHack, it was anyway 99% foreigners and a few B-class Koreans always ... But cancelling it all? That is bad. OK, maybe, at the end, somebody will organize ONE INTERNATIONAL EVENT. So the Koreans will have this one event and BlizzCon. Were I a Korean pro, I would retire. Were I a young Korean, trying to become a pro, I would stop. Because the market is now too small for so many good players. This is fucking bad! Damaging the Korean scene is the way, they want to bring Koreans and foreigners closer. Yes i'm sad that we won't see koreans play at foreign tournaments. But it's not like these top koreans who went to foreign tournaments will starve to death without the money. They make a good living regardles. Also gsl rewards 100k$ more and Blizzcon 250k more than 2015. That is more money than the prizepool of dh and iem combined. It's really bad for B-tier and up and coming Koreans though as there's less opportunities to earn money and get noticed and earn anything. Copied from Diaboliques list: 1. IEM Taipei - herO, HyuN, Polt, Rain, Classic, Life, Soulkey, PartinG, Maru, TRUE, Hydra 2. IEM WC - 16 top Koreans 3. DH Tours - Rain, PartinG, MC, FanTaSy, GuMiho, MMA, TRUE, Hydra, HyuN 4. HSC XI - PartinG, Rain, GuMiho, HyuN 5. DH Valencia - Pigbaby, Terminator, HerO, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TaeJa, TRUE, HyuN, Leenock, Curious, Symbol 6. IEM Shenzhen - Losira, TY, SuperNova, Classic, Rain, YongHwa, herO, PartinG 7. IEM gamescom - soO, MMA, INnoVation, FanTaSy 8. MSI - INnoVation, Hydra, PartinG, HyuN, sOs, Solar, Jaedong, viOLet, Polt 9. DH Stockholm - HerO, Hurricane, sOs, Rain, FanTaSy, TRUE, Jaedong, Curious, Leenock, HyuN, Solar, Dark Hurricane pretty much the only small name on the list. Sorry. Soulkey, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TRUE, Pigbaby, Terminator, TaeJa, Leenock, Symbol, Losira, SuperNova, YongHwa, Hurricane ... Learn to count! :-) These are the names, who do not have much chance to make it far in the 2 seasons of GSL / SSL. And can't compete anywhere else. Except for the one cup. OK are only those, who play Proleague. So giving money to not top tier players is good for the sceene? I might be having a dejavu, but i think i have heard of a system that tries to do exactly that. Well, the not top tier Koreans were going to the DH events, where the top tier ones were not going. And that helped them to get the confidence and also some money. That was good for them.
User was warned for this post
|
Some of this also seems really bad for fan's. Say I like Jin Air GreenWings and their players are my favorite but I live in EU. When can I go to a live tournament and ever meet any of these players or watch them live? Now you would either have to travel to Korea or Blizzcon, which is pretty much as far away.
I wonder if their will be any tournaments held that are not affiliated to WCS so they can invite Europeans and Koreans??
Perhaps the online cups that do not have draconian player restrictions will become better supported.
As a few of the previous posts have stated having Koreans move over to EU in 2014 and participate here made the scene stronger in the opinion of many.
|
On December 22 2015 23:26 Ve5pa wrote: Some of this also seems really bad for fan's. Say I like Jin Air GreenWings and their players are my favorite but I live in EU. When can I go to a live tournament and ever meet any of these players or watch them live? Now you would either have to travel to Korea or Blizzcon, which is pretty much as far away.
I wonder if their will be any tournaments held that are not affiliated to WCS so they can invite Europeans and Koreans??
Perhaps the online cups that do not have draconian player restrictions will become better supported.
As a few of the previous posts have stated having Koreans move over to EU in 2014 and participate here made the scene stronger in the opinion of many.
My highest hope is HSC XIII in the Summer. The leagues wount again make TaKes and NarutOs live harder with setting preaseason and qualifiers on the same weekend then the Event and with much less tournaments to go anyway, I believe that more Kespa Koreans will be more likely to travel over. Other then that, when we dont find a billionare spending some money, I dont see how you will see a Event in Europe with in korea living players.
|
On December 22 2015 06:30 SetGuitarsToKill wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 06:29 ZAiNs wrote:So it seems like 'WCS Global Events' will be a rarity and aren't intended to be a significant part of the WCS system  . I mean, wasn't that obvious to begin with? Apollo was going talking on reddit how there will be tons of WCS global stuff for Koreans to compete in so it doesn't matter that there are only 4 leagues in Korea anymore...
|
On December 22 2015 23:25 Diabolique wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:14 p4ch1n0 wrote:On December 22 2015 22:49 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:44 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:40 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:On December 22 2015 22:35 AWalker9 wrote:On December 22 2015 22:13 p4ch1n0 wrote:On December 22 2015 20:57 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 20:42 aQuaSC wrote:On December 22 2015 20:13 WrathSCII wrote: [quote]
Snute is kinda special. Ah, I understand. Sorry Diabolique if you felt insulted. I just couldn't help but see that you "shit" on foreigners stating that foreigner scene is irrelevant at all and only Korea (along with those that don't hold achievements) with foreigners who achieved something significant during last five years are the people that community should focus on. And only these are important to you. I can understand that obviously, I'd be pretty pissed if I was a big football fan and Champions League was resized all of a sudden to hold less champion-caliber teams for few that don't always qualify because of the barrier they need to break. And again - to me the worst thing about this system is the fact that it was introduced too late, after Koreans were let all over the world for the money to grab therefore extremely shrinking foreign scene. I said in other thread, that with the last systems to really break out in a non-WCS tournament to gain visibility you needed to be very lucky or incredibly good out of nothing - not having access to practice with Koreans on regular basis and be able to beat few of the KeSPA guys. Basically perform a miracle. But I am not shitting on any foreigners. Maybe Desrow, maybe Mana when they started to celebrate the new system. Snute is a good guy, I never saw any tweet "celebrating" the new system from him. And his comment was awesome, saying, how he would be happy to have the opportunity to still compete with the Koreans somewhere. I am even not saying that foreigners are bad. I am even not the kind of guy, who would just follow the highest level of SC2 only. Without the casters, I would be unable to recognize it. I even do not like that much GSL and SSL, in fact, I want to watch them only when my favorite player, sOs is playing. And with this new system, there is a big probability, he will not be playing any of them (= he will not qualify). I am angry, because this is not justice! This is injustice! Banning the best players from ALL international tournaments, reducing their own local events, this is significantly reducing their life options. How can people exist, who support this? This huge injustice! They could have created a new WCS circuit, they could have stolen DreamHack, it was anyway 99% foreigners and a few B-class Koreans always ... But cancelling it all? That is bad. OK, maybe, at the end, somebody will organize ONE INTERNATIONAL EVENT. So the Koreans will have this one event and BlizzCon. Were I a Korean pro, I would retire. Were I a young Korean, trying to become a pro, I would stop. Because the market is now too small for so many good players. This is fucking bad! Damaging the Korean scene is the way, they want to bring Koreans and foreigners closer. Yes i'm sad that we won't see koreans play at foreign tournaments. But it's not like these top koreans who went to foreign tournaments will starve to death without the money. They make a good living regardles. Also gsl rewards 100k$ more and Blizzcon 250k more than 2015. That is more money than the prizepool of dh and iem combined. It's really bad for B-tier and up and coming Koreans though as there's less opportunities to earn money and get noticed and earn anything. Copied from Diaboliques list: 1. IEM Taipei - herO, HyuN, Polt, Rain, Classic, Life, Soulkey, PartinG, Maru, TRUE, Hydra 2. IEM WC - 16 top Koreans 3. DH Tours - Rain, PartinG, MC, FanTaSy, GuMiho, MMA, TRUE, Hydra, HyuN 4. HSC XI - PartinG, Rain, GuMiho, HyuN 5. DH Valencia - Pigbaby, Terminator, HerO, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TaeJa, TRUE, HyuN, Leenock, Curious, Symbol 6. IEM Shenzhen - Losira, TY, SuperNova, Classic, Rain, YongHwa, herO, PartinG 7. IEM gamescom - soO, MMA, INnoVation, FanTaSy 8. MSI - INnoVation, Hydra, PartinG, HyuN, sOs, Solar, Jaedong, viOLet, Polt 9. DH Stockholm - HerO, Hurricane, sOs, Rain, FanTaSy, TRUE, Jaedong, Curious, Leenock, HyuN, Solar, Dark Hurricane pretty much the only small name on the list. Sorry. Soulkey, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TRUE, Pigbaby, Terminator, TaeJa, Leenock, Symbol, Losira, SuperNova, YongHwa, Hurricane ... Learn to count! :-) These are the names, who do not have much chance to make it far in the 2 seasons of GSL / SSL. And can't compete anywhere else. Except for the one cup. OK are only those, who play Proleague. So giving money to not top tier players is good for the sceene? I might be having a dejavu, but i think i have heard of a system that tries to do exactly that. Well, the not top tier Koreans were going to the DH events, where the top tier ones were not going. And that helped them to get the confidence and also some money. That was good for them.
Well, the foreigners will go to IEMs and DHs, where the koreans will not go. And that will help the to get the confidence and also some money.That will be good for them.
See its the same with foreigners and the new system.
Maybe b-tier koreans will be screwed by the new system but they already have the best practice environment and infrastructure to become the best where as foreigners don't.
|
On December 22 2015 23:25 Diabolique wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:14 p4ch1n0 wrote:On December 22 2015 22:49 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:44 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 22:40 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:On December 22 2015 22:35 AWalker9 wrote:On December 22 2015 22:13 p4ch1n0 wrote:On December 22 2015 20:57 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 20:42 aQuaSC wrote:On December 22 2015 20:13 WrathSCII wrote: [quote]
Snute is kinda special. Ah, I understand. Sorry Diabolique if you felt insulted. I just couldn't help but see that you "shit" on foreigners stating that foreigner scene is irrelevant at all and only Korea (along with those that don't hold achievements) with foreigners who achieved something significant during last five years are the people that community should focus on. And only these are important to you. I can understand that obviously, I'd be pretty pissed if I was a big football fan and Champions League was resized all of a sudden to hold less champion-caliber teams for few that don't always qualify because of the barrier they need to break. And again - to me the worst thing about this system is the fact that it was introduced too late, after Koreans were let all over the world for the money to grab therefore extremely shrinking foreign scene. I said in other thread, that with the last systems to really break out in a non-WCS tournament to gain visibility you needed to be very lucky or incredibly good out of nothing - not having access to practice with Koreans on regular basis and be able to beat few of the KeSPA guys. Basically perform a miracle. But I am not shitting on any foreigners. Maybe Desrow, maybe Mana when they started to celebrate the new system. Snute is a good guy, I never saw any tweet "celebrating" the new system from him. And his comment was awesome, saying, how he would be happy to have the opportunity to still compete with the Koreans somewhere. I am even not saying that foreigners are bad. I am even not the kind of guy, who would just follow the highest level of SC2 only. Without the casters, I would be unable to recognize it. I even do not like that much GSL and SSL, in fact, I want to watch them only when my favorite player, sOs is playing. And with this new system, there is a big probability, he will not be playing any of them (= he will not qualify). I am angry, because this is not justice! This is injustice! Banning the best players from ALL international tournaments, reducing their own local events, this is significantly reducing their life options. How can people exist, who support this? This huge injustice! They could have created a new WCS circuit, they could have stolen DreamHack, it was anyway 99% foreigners and a few B-class Koreans always ... But cancelling it all? That is bad. OK, maybe, at the end, somebody will organize ONE INTERNATIONAL EVENT. So the Koreans will have this one event and BlizzCon. Were I a Korean pro, I would retire. Were I a young Korean, trying to become a pro, I would stop. Because the market is now too small for so many good players. This is fucking bad! Damaging the Korean scene is the way, they want to bring Koreans and foreigners closer. Yes i'm sad that we won't see koreans play at foreign tournaments. But it's not like these top koreans who went to foreign tournaments will starve to death without the money. They make a good living regardles. Also gsl rewards 100k$ more and Blizzcon 250k more than 2015. That is more money than the prizepool of dh and iem combined. It's really bad for B-tier and up and coming Koreans though as there's less opportunities to earn money and get noticed and earn anything. Copied from Diaboliques list: 1. IEM Taipei - herO, HyuN, Polt, Rain, Classic, Life, Soulkey, PartinG, Maru, TRUE, Hydra 2. IEM WC - 16 top Koreans 3. DH Tours - Rain, PartinG, MC, FanTaSy, GuMiho, MMA, TRUE, Hydra, HyuN 4. HSC XI - PartinG, Rain, GuMiho, HyuN 5. DH Valencia - Pigbaby, Terminator, HerO, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TaeJa, TRUE, HyuN, Leenock, Curious, Symbol 6. IEM Shenzhen - Losira, TY, SuperNova, Classic, Rain, YongHwa, herO, PartinG 7. IEM gamescom - soO, MMA, INnoVation, FanTaSy 8. MSI - INnoVation, Hydra, PartinG, HyuN, sOs, Solar, Jaedong, viOLet, Polt 9. DH Stockholm - HerO, Hurricane, sOs, Rain, FanTaSy, TRUE, Jaedong, Curious, Leenock, HyuN, Solar, Dark Hurricane pretty much the only small name on the list. Sorry. Soulkey, FanTaSy, GuMiho, TRUE, Pigbaby, Terminator, TaeJa, Leenock, Symbol, Losira, SuperNova, YongHwa, Hurricane ... Learn to count! :-) These are the names, who do not have much chance to make it far in the 2 seasons of GSL / SSL. And can't compete anywhere else. Except for the one cup. OK are only those, who play Proleague. So giving money to not top tier players is good for the sceene? I might be having a dejavu, but i think i have heard of a system that tries to do exactly that. Well, the not top tier Koreans were going to the DH events, where the top tier ones were not going. And that helped them to get the confidence and also some money. That was good for them. Now that is good for us foreigners
|
It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL.
|
On December 22 2015 23:43 Ve5pa wrote: It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL.
It's residency as requirement, they can come.
|
On December 22 2015 23:48 TBO wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:43 Ve5pa wrote: It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL. It's residency as requirement, they can come.
It is not just residency, we had residency. You need either a student, working or sports visa. Taking for example germany:
The koreans often left school with 15 to become a progamer and cannot just go to a university. They also dont want to study here, but want to be a full time pro in Germany, thus student visa does not work. E-Sport-Pros do not get sports visa in Germany. Working visa: Extremly complicated. As progamers are no sports athlets in germany, someone has to actually pay them like normal workers. But then the gouvernment checks if there arent any german unemployed people who could also do the job. And then you have to pay per month a large amount of payment to the progamer or it could also be illegal.
There is a reason why all residency koreans live in America while nobody lives europe. ForGG was only there due to the ForGG rule in the WCS handbook.
Residency like Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Sacsri, Jjakji and Stardust have been made impossible. So stop saying residency is the only requirement and they could just move their home here.
|
On December 23 2015 00:01 Clonester wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:48 TBO wrote:On December 22 2015 23:43 Ve5pa wrote: It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL. It's residency as requirement, they can come. It is not just residency, we had residency. You need either a student, working or sports visa. Taking for example germany: The koreans often left school with 15 to become a progamer and cannot just go to a university. They also dont want to study here, but want to be a full time pro in Germany, thus student visa does not work. E-Sport-Pros do not get sports visa in Germany. Working visa: Extremly complicated. As progamers are no sports athlets in germany, someone has to actually pay them like normal workers. But then the gouvernment checks if there arent any german unemployed people who could also do the job. And then you have to pay per month a large amount of payment to the progamer or it could also be illegal. There is a reason why all residency koreans live in America while nobody lives europe. ForGG was only there due to the ForGG rule in the WCS handbook. Residency like Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Sacsri, Jjakji and Stardust have been made impossible. So stop saying residency is the only requirement and they could just move their home here.
so basically people need to have proper visa like other people who work in other countries need...
|
On December 22 2015 23:22 Diabolique wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 23:10 aQuaSC wrote:On December 22 2015 23:05 Ve5pa wrote:On December 22 2015 23:00 Clonester wrote:On December 22 2015 22:52 Ve5pa wrote:On December 22 2015 17:28 Liquid`Bunny wrote: I was gonna go but now with no koreans i don't care anymore Haha, this made me laugh xD But those tweets from the full of salt North Americans didn't, really sad to see that. Backhanded compliment from iNcontrol as well. IMO Blizzard should give the fans what they want, and clearly many people want to see Koreans at foreign events. Half of the issue a lot of pro's seem to have is the Koreans that have the right to play like Polt don't play on their local ladders and therefore don't contribute to that community getting better. I know total Biscuit had some ideas about this he went over in a soundcloud piece. We acutally had Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Jjakji, Stardust, Sacsri and ForGG playing all day on the Europen ladder. We kicked their asses back to korea. Not to mention, that Fantasy and True were ready to move over. Even Rain. And the Invasion Esports Koreans. We shut the door right in their face. Yeah it seems mainly an NA issue to be honest from what I hear. Your right I do believe most of the GEM players and mYi players would play on EU, this is probably why the EU scene seems to be a lot more competative than the NA scene. I think the Koreans based in NA would just rather play on Korea server with higher ping, or so I gathered. Yeah, I agree. Unless there is a real incentive in playing local ladder, Koreans (I mean the majority or just the currently best ones) will never willingly play anywhere else than in their own region. I'm not even sure if money would fix that, as TB's solution proposed. And to counter an argument that foreigners playing with foreigners will hurt the overall player-base skill-wise, wouldn't the situation where Koreans play foreigners hurt Korean skill level? Wouldn't the "pure" skill got worse if they weren't forced to compete that hard, while they would be the best in the region? Hehe, well, Life's skill did not get worse by playing Lilbow three times in a row :-)
Heh, we still have different opinion on tournament games versus practice. Can you tell me how tournament games can be considered practice? :>
|
On December 23 2015 00:03 TBO wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2015 00:01 Clonester wrote:On December 22 2015 23:48 TBO wrote:On December 22 2015 23:43 Ve5pa wrote: It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL. It's residency as requirement, they can come. It is not just residency, we had residency. You need either a student, working or sports visa. Taking for example germany: The koreans often left school with 15 to become a progamer and cannot just go to a university. They also dont want to study here, but want to be a full time pro in Germany, thus student visa does not work. E-Sport-Pros do not get sports visa in Germany. Working visa: Extremly complicated. As progamers are no sports athlets in germany, someone has to actually pay them like normal workers. But then the gouvernment checks if there arent any german unemployed people who could also do the job. And then you have to pay per month a large amount of payment to the progamer or it could also be illegal. There is a reason why all residency koreans live in America while nobody lives europe. ForGG was only there due to the ForGG rule in the WCS handbook. Residency like Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Sacsri, Jjakji and Stardust have been made impossible. So stop saying residency is the only requirement and they could just move their home here. so basically people need to have proper visa like other people who work in other countries need...
Then your argument, "they can come" is invalid, as they cannot come as being a e-sport athlet is not just a normal job. Also thats not true, as the 2014 generation of EU Koreans had proper visa, the so called holiday&work visa, which was enough for the german state and allowed them to work. But Blizzard decided that these visa are not enough.
|
On December 23 2015 00:03 TBO wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2015 00:01 Clonester wrote:On December 22 2015 23:48 TBO wrote:On December 22 2015 23:43 Ve5pa wrote: It's really sad that Blizzard has made some of these changes, encouraging the best players to come to EU or NA and compete their seems like a good thing to me. Imagine this in football (soccer for the yanks) if south americans were banned because they were too OP, imagine no Messi or Aguerro.
Also if you think eSports can't be compared to 'real sports' you could look at League of Legends, NA was/is shit so they imported Europeans and a few Koreans, their NA LCS has gotten better, well more entertaining to watch at least. In EU they also allow imports, the team that utilised those imports most effectively, Fnatic, got to semi finals of the world championship, Origen didn't have any Koreans but they sure practiced against them and teams with Koreans on in scrims and they got to the semi finals as well. imports are limited to 2 per team of 5 for those unfamiliar with LoL. It's residency as requirement, they can come. It is not just residency, we had residency. You need either a student, working or sports visa. Taking for example germany: The koreans often left school with 15 to become a progamer and cannot just go to a university. They also dont want to study here, but want to be a full time pro in Germany, thus student visa does not work. E-Sport-Pros do not get sports visa in Germany. Working visa: Extremly complicated. As progamers are no sports athlets in germany, someone has to actually pay them like normal workers. But then the gouvernment checks if there arent any german unemployed people who could also do the job. And then you have to pay per month a large amount of payment to the progamer or it could also be illegal. There is a reason why all residency koreans live in America while nobody lives europe. ForGG was only there due to the ForGG rule in the WCS handbook. Residency like Patience, Golden, HyuN, MC, First, Yoda, Sacsri, Jjakji and Stardust have been made impossible. So stop saying residency is the only requirement and they could just move their home here. so basically people need to have proper visa like other people who work in other countries need... Except its eSports and it is on a different scale yeah?
|
So weird to effectively ban one country to participate in an international event whatever your stance is in the discussion.
|
I like the separate shot for the CN, TW, SEA regions. Usually they have no chance because they're lumped together with Korea. I don't like that Koreans are barred. Esports seems to be moving backwards in time with segregated leagues.
Personally, I would prefer to improve the skill level of foreigners instead of barring korea players. Make a requirement for korean qualifiers to have a set number of games played on NA or EU ladder or something.
|
On December 23 2015 00:52 royalroadweed wrote: I like the separate shot for the CN, TW, SEA regions. Usually they have no chance because they're lumped together with Korea. I don't like that Koreans are barred. Esports seems to be moving backwards in time with segregated leagues.
Personally, I would prefer to improve the skill level of foreigners instead of barring korea players. Make a requirement for korean qualifiers to have a set number of games played on NA or EU ladder or something.
Although I know that your proposition is just a loose way of pointing out direction which Blizzard should take, I believe making a requirement like that is not a good idea, since:
1. it could only be achieved if all of the regions played connected to each other with equal latency (this could actually solve everything, or let's make sc2 turn-based - or make Blizzard put good servers in-between EU and Korea), and 2. you can't guarantee that Koreans will try-hard these games outside of KR like they do on their own server. And this try-harding is what other regions need.
Basically KR tryhards practice full-time with each other and come for international tournaments (often they were, or still are invited) to secure most of the top 16 spots. That is what hurts everyone but Koreans. I wish this was not the case from the beginning, to invite Koreans to international tournaments as a tourist attraction to see how good infrastructure Korea has compared to other countries... now it feels like hurting Korea - their possibilites vastly expanded over possibilities of foreigners and now suddenly they are stopped.
What puzzles me is why Korean expansion over international scene was always viewed by majority as a good thing, while it was silently hurting every try of creating an infrastructure outside of it. Now everyone is amazed how unfairly Korea is treated in the new system. Imagine how every non-Korean player felt, pro or committed to becoming pro, with a fact that to be considered good you have to beat at least few super-competitive Koreans with nothing close to their infrastructure in what was officially seen as a local competition. Otherwise you are mediocre. DreamHack, IEM, you name it.
To some people 90% Koreans with 10% of lucky or "foreign hopes" was an objectively good thing. I also wish we never had a need to create a term "foreign hope". To me it never was a good thing. Instead of becoming professional and competitive you were doing your best to be a "foreign hope". But - everyone has their own truth.
|
On December 23 2015 01:12 aQuaSC wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2015 00:52 royalroadweed wrote: I like the separate shot for the CN, TW, SEA regions. Usually they have no chance because they're lumped together with Korea. I don't like that Koreans are barred. Esports seems to be moving backwards in time with segregated leagues.
Personally, I would prefer to improve the skill level of foreigners instead of barring korea players. Make a requirement for korean qualifiers to have a set number of games played on NA or EU ladder or something. Although I know that your proposition is just a loose way of pointing out direction which Blizzard should take, I believe making a requirement like that is not a good idea, since: 1. it could only be achieved if all of the regions played connected to each other with equal latency (this could actually solve everything, or let's make sc2 turn-based - or make Blizzard put good servers in-between EU and Korea), and 2. you can't guarantee that Koreans will try-hard these games outside of KR like they do on their own server. And this try-harding is what other regions need. Basically KR tryhards practice full-time with each other and come for international tournaments (often they were, or still are invited) to secure most of the top 16 spots. That is what hurts everyone but Koreans. I wish this was not the case from the beginning, to invite Koreans to international tournaments as a tourist attraction to see how good infrastructure Korea has compared to other countries... now it feels like hurting Korea - their possibilites vastly expanded over possibilities of foreigners and now suddenly they are stopped. What puzzles me is why Korean expansion over international scene was always viewed by majority as a good thing, while it was silently hurting every try of creating an infrastructure outside of it. Now everyone is amazed how unfairly Korea is treated in the new system. Imagine how every non-Korean player felt, pro or committed to becoming pro, with a fact that to be considered good you have to beat at least few super-competitive Koreans with nothing close to their infrastructure in what was officially seen as a local competition. Otherwise you are mediocre. DreamHack, IEM, you name it. To some people 90% Koreans with 10% of lucky or "foreign hopes" was an objectively good thing. I also wish we never had a need to create a term "foreign hope". To me it never was a good thing. Instead of becoming professional and competitive you were doing your best to be a "foreign hope". But - everyone has their own truth.
Nicely said! +1
|
On December 22 2015 20:42 aQuaSC wrote:Show nested quote +On December 22 2015 20:13 WrathSCII wrote:On December 22 2015 20:05 aQuaSC wrote:On December 22 2015 19:56 Diabolique wrote:On December 22 2015 19:50 Liquid`Snute wrote: As someone who usually would lose to the champion or someone KeSPA 2-3 in bracket stages of whatever DH/IEM Ro8 it's nice to see that a Ro8 finish here nets $500 more. but ... oh ... right ... lolol .... >_<
Massive money and support... I just hope there are opportunities for the best performing players somewhere down the line, more than once per year, to play vs Korean competition. EU-KR love all the way ~ You know, you are our hero. You brought us the amazing matches against the two protosses on IEM last year. These were the matches, we were looking forward to the whole year. Not to GSL, SSL ... not to WCS. And now, it is gone. There will be no opportunities to repeat it. At least, I hope, you will show good games in the RO16 group at BlizzCon. Wow it's your first post that I see when you don't shit on a foreigner lol Snute is kinda special. Ah, I understand. Sorry Diabolique if you felt insulted. I just couldn't help but see that you "shit" on foreigners stating that foreigner scene is irrelevant at all and only Korea (along with those that don't hold achievements) with foreigners who achieved something significant during last five years are the people that community should focus on. And only these are important to you. I can understand that obviously, I'd be pretty pissed if I was a big football fan and Champions League was resized all of a sudden to hold less champion-caliber teams for few that don't always qualify because of the barrier they need to break. And again - to me the worst thing about this system is the fact that it was introduced too late, after Koreans were let all over the world for the money to grab therefore extremely shrinking foreign scene. I said in other thread, that with the last systems to really break out in a non-WCS tournament to gain visibility you needed to be very lucky or incredibly good out of nothing - not having access to practice with Koreans on regular basis and be able to beat few of the KeSPA guys. Basically perform a miracle.
IMO, there's a group of foreigners like Snute and Bunny who I respect a lot because they've put in a lot of time to play well and I don't think they'd back down from a challenge from anyone in Korea. If they'd win, that's another story.
|
|
|
|