• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 10:16
CET 16:16
KST 00:16
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Rongyi Cup S3 - RO16 Preview3herO wins SC2 All-Star Invitational12SC2 All-Star Invitational: Tournament Preview5RSL Revival - 2025 Season Finals Preview8RSL Season 3 - Playoffs Preview0
Community News
Weekly Cups (Jan 12-18): herO, MaxPax, Solar win0BSL Season 2025 - Full Overview and Conclusion8Weekly Cups (Jan 5-11): Clem wins big offline, Trigger upsets4$21,000 Rongyi Cup Season 3 announced (Jan 22-Feb 7)24Weekly Cups (Dec 29-Jan 4): Protoss rolls, 2v2 returns7
StarCraft 2
General
PhD study /w SC2 - help with a survey! herO wins SC2 All-Star Invitational Oliveira Would Have Returned If EWC Continued StarCraft 2 not at the Esports World Cup 2026 [Short Story] The Last GSL
Tourneys
$21,000 Rongyi Cup Season 3 announced (Jan 22-Feb 7) OSC Season 13 World Championship $70 Prize Pool Ladder Legends Academy Weekly Open! SC2 All-Star Invitational: Jan 17-18 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament
Strategy
Simple Questions Simple Answers
Custom Maps
[A] Starcraft Sound Mod
External Content
Mutation # 509 Doomsday Report Mutation # 508 Violent Night Mutation # 507 Well Trained Mutation # 506 Warp Zone
Brood War
General
[ASL21] Potential Map Candidates Gypsy to Korea BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Fantasy's Q&A video BW General Discussion
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues Azhi's Colosseum - Season 2 Small VOD Thread 2.0 [BSL21] Non-Korean Championship - Starts Jan 10
Strategy
Current Meta Simple Questions, Simple Answers Soma's 9 hatch build from ASL Game 2 Game Theory for Starcraft
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Battle Aces/David Kim RTS Megathread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Beyond All Reason Awesome Games Done Quick 2026!
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
Vanilla Mini Mafia Mafia Game Mode Feedback/Ideas
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread Canadian Politics Mega-thread NASA and the Private Sector
Fan Clubs
The herO Fan Club! The IdrA Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
How Esports Advertising Shap…
TrAiDoS
My 2025 Magic: The Gathering…
DARKING
Life Update and thoughts.
FuDDx
How do archons sleep?
8882
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1741 users

MLG statement on Providence Code S spot - Page 37

Forum Index > SC2 General
1158 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 35 36 37 38 39 58 Next
hunts
Profile Joined September 2010
United States2113 Posts
December 16 2011 03:08 GMT
#721
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.
twitch.tv/huntstv 7x legend streamer
rotegirte
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany2859 Posts
December 16 2011 03:15 GMT
#722
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".
Benjef
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
United Kingdom6921 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:24:28
December 16 2011 03:21 GMT
#723
Knew this was the case and have been waiting for this exact statement for a while.

I hope it has some huge ramifications on GOM, mainly MLG aint gonna be doing their bidding and taking korean players so easily anymore.

Also so much for this whole honor thing GOM is going with... Couldn't keep their honor by holding an agreement they've had for months.

Either way no matter what choice they made there would be a shitstorm on either side be is the foriegners or koreans...
<3 | Dota 2 | DayZ | <3
Skyreaper
Profile Joined December 2011
70 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:26:08
December 16 2011 03:24 GMT
#724
[image loading]


Edit : Blizzard Cup Interview with Pro-players
SkimGuy
Profile Joined December 2010
Canada709 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:36:04
December 16 2011 03:35 GMT
#725
GOM should apologize for the misconception, but it wouldn't matter anyway since Naniwa wasn't getting the Code S spot after what happened, even if he earned it through Providence
eshlow
Profile Joined June 2008
United States5210 Posts
December 16 2011 03:42 GMT
#726
On December 16 2011 12:35 SkimGuy wrote:
GOM should apologize for the misconception, but it wouldn't matter anyway since Naniwa wasn't getting the Code S spot after what happened, even if he earned it through Providence


It doesn't matter that Naniwa would or would not have gotten the code S spot anyway. That's not the point.

It's a huge misconception because they:

1. Did not notify MLG who they had a partnership with
2. Did not notify all of the foreign fans, who were under the impression that Naniwa had secured a code S.

If we are going to get on Naniwa for acting unprofessional, then it would be hypocritical not to get on GOM for this blatant unprofessional changing of the rules without notifying anyone.
Overcoming Gravity: A Systematic Approach to Gymnastics and Bodyweight Strength
lOvRyooMak
Profile Joined November 2011
Australia5 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:48:02
December 16 2011 03:42 GMT
#727
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was changed
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for his sacrifice. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted the change. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated him from the candidate list due to his conduct in blizzcup which angered korean gamers fans and staff.. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the future tournament itself
rotegirte
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany2859 Posts
December 16 2011 03:47 GMT
#728
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.
Spaceneil8
Profile Joined February 2011
United States317 Posts
December 16 2011 03:50 GMT
#729
I think it's important that koreans could have won Code S through MLG. This change is bad, and MLG should have been notified.
jinorazi
Profile Joined October 2004
Korea (South)4948 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:52:00
December 16 2011 03:50 GMT
#730
On December 16 2011 12:47 rotegirte wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.


i think you're making it a bigger deal than it actually is. especially when people are connecting it with naniwa.
you're making it like they actually changed the money prize, which would be significant but its not the same.
regardless of change, naniwa and others would still have been most likely invited for code s.
age: 84 | location: california | sex: 잘함
rotegirte
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany2859 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:55:49
December 16 2011 03:52 GMT
#731
On December 16 2011 12:50 jinorazi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:47 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.


i think you're making it a bigger deal than it actually is. especially when people are connecting it with naniwa.
you're making it like they actually changed the prize pool, which would be significant but its not the same.


So rewards to player performance in tournaments should be generally held subject to change, and tournament organizer's judgement will suffice on evaluating significance?

Who is gonna be responsible to draw a line? Was CoCa match-fixing or not? Should tournament organizers decide for themselves if it is appropiate to conform to the rules they have set up?
RetoX
Profile Joined October 2010
Hong Kong252 Posts
December 16 2011 03:54 GMT
#732
On December 16 2011 05:05 Eee wrote:
They should appologize to Naniwa to IMO

LOL and we should congrat Nani for his manners...
Twitter : http://bit.ly/twitt-RetoX ♦ facebook http://on.fb.me/RetoX ♦
lOvRyooMak
Profile Joined November 2011
Australia5 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:56:31
December 16 2011 03:54 GMT
#733
On December 16 2011 12:47 rotegirte wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.



Yes it is goms fault they didnt announce earlier. I just want to help explain why this happened
In my original post.. They have a limited number of people working there.. Decisions
May come to close slowly over there.. The reason why they didnt announce earlier is because the decisions
For the 2012 gsl were not final when the mlg started. Gom was shortsighted in making this change abruptly if anything they are to apologize.. But im just saying it wasnt their intention to pick
On naniwa or do anything damaging intentionally
And certainly no "conspiracies" of such
eshlow
Profile Joined June 2008
United States5210 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:56:52
December 16 2011 03:54 GMT
#734
rote, you shoulda just quoted my post instead of making an analogy. :p

Basically,

1. GOM does not notify that they are changing the rules of code S.
2. MLG, and foreign fans, and Naniwa and other players are under the impression top 3 of non-code S at providence will get code S spot.
3. GOM says this is not true and that Naniwa was only in consideration, in their recently released statement. Thus, retrospectively changing the rules.

This is unprofessional to change the rules after the fact BECAUSE they didn't notify MLG (whom they have a partnership with) and the foreign fans, and the players who were all under the impression that Naniwa had a code S spot.

If we are going to get on Naniwa's case for being unprofessional, EVERYONE should ALSO be getting on GOM's case for being unprofessional by retroactively changing their own rules without notifying anyone.

It's airtight logic. There's no way anyone should be arguing the opposite side.

edit:

Note that changing the rules is fine. Notifying MLG, the fans, etc. of the changed rules IS professional and fine. The fact that they did not do this, and then came out with a statement that is contrary WITHOUT TELLING US THEY CHANGED THE RULES is blatantly unprofessional.
Overcoming Gravity: A Systematic Approach to Gymnastics and Bodyweight Strength
jinorazi
Profile Joined October 2004
Korea (South)4948 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 03:58:20
December 16 2011 03:57 GMT
#735
On December 16 2011 12:52 rotegirte wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:50 jinorazi wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:47 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.


i think you're making it a bigger deal than it actually is. especially when people are connecting it with naniwa.
you're making it like they actually changed the prize pool, which would be significant but its not the same.


So rewards to player performance in tournaments should be generally held subject to change, and tournament organizer's judgement will suffice on evaluating significance?


depending on the situation, yes. in this case, the change was for the better. according earlier post, blizzard cup's seeding changed after blizzard cup's announcement (this was for the better also), where was everyone then?

just saying, this is getting extra attention because of naniwa, not because changing rules are evil.
age: 84 | location: california | sex: 잘함
rotegirte
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany2859 Posts
December 16 2011 03:59 GMT
#736
On December 16 2011 12:54 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:47 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:42 lOvRyooMak wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:15 rotegirte wrote:
On December 16 2011 12:08 hunts wrote:
On December 16 2011 10:53 lOvRyooMak wrote:
Hi im a korean living in korea..
I regularly visit korean sites playxp and thisisgame for sc2

There seems to be a lot of misscommunication and confusion overseas

I dont see what the fuss is about regarding the format change
To be exact the new 2012 gsl format was announced at night dec10th korean time, the night before the start of the blizzard
Cup.
So what if the format was changed before or after the blizzard cup?
The gsl format was always changed every one or two seasons for improvement
I remember seeing reactions by people here on TL - i like the new GSL
Format! But i dont like the new GSTL format.. Etc

Regarding the code S seeding change...
As the MLG also clearly stated it is in all gomtv's right to change seeding however they please.
Why can't you see that the seeding change was meant to give international players more opportunity in the GSL?
The previous seeding would give the seed to the top placed players in the mlg regardless if it were a korean or not.

Instead they decided to nominate top international players as candidates for the two seed spots, and the judges would select two probably based on various criteria. i.e personal reasons- not every player may wish to come play in korea.
In this case as mentioned in gomtv's latest post sen.idra and naniwa were selected as candidates. But due to naniwa's conduct in the blizzard cup they decided to give it to sen and idra. The nominees and criteria were not announced prior to the decision because the criteria was probably not decided yet! Naniwa's misbehaviour made the decision easier for gom IMO. You have to understand that the gsl is still experimental. Gomtv knows there is room for improvement here and there and is constantly trying to change and develop their league.
Making announcements before the system were solidified and decisions were made would make an even bigger confusion and possible shitstorm if it were changed everday.

Yes it would be nice if gomtv could just post here on TL and explain ever little thing that is going on what they are discussing and wanting to change. But as you might have noticed the people at gomtv are not that good at english and there can only be misinterpretations here and there. I have been to the gomtv studio many times and what you must understand is that it is quite smaller than you may think. In fact its tiny compared to competitions like mlg or dreamhack. The whole gomtv staff only number about 20people. There are only limitations to what these 20people can do at omce. They cant be everywhere answering all questions here and there and making decisions at once.

What i would really like to say is there is always a perfectly good explanation to everything.. Otherwise the korean community would have a bigger shitstorm. The last thing koreans want is something like kespa. instead of making blunt observations on misscommunication and Misinterpretations perhaps wait for a proper announcement by gom or maybe help on a better translation on korean articles before making a shitstorm out of nothing


Thank you very much for that. Quoting it in hopes more people read it, it's a very well written post with many good points. I really wish more people would think straight rather than letting their emotions get the better of them and make them completely unreasonable and biased.

I think with the naniwa incident GOM got caught between a rock and a hard place. If they did nothing, many of the koreans that were throwing a shitstorm would stop supporting them. If they took action, as you can see a lot of the naniwa fanboys decided to throw a shitstorm and stop supporting them. In the end as they are a korean based organization and there are far more koreans outraged at naniwas actions than there are nanniwa fans outraged at GOMs actions, I think they did the right thing both morally and for business purposes.

I do wish things could've been a bit clearer as to what happened with the GSL/MLG exchange program with providennce, but I think it's starting to make sense now, I just wish more people would take the time to read up on what happened and try to understand it rather than coming here and flaming GOM without even reading the facts.


It has little to do with "misunderstanding".

When they want to punish NaNiwa, just say it as it is. "What NaNiwa did was wrong, he gets no Code S seed, period." Fanboys would be raging no matter what.

Instead they climbed into a time machine and said "Remember the rules you agreed to and played under back in November in Providence? Right, forget them. We are changing the rules now, a month after the tournament finished".

You don't do that- you could even call it fraud. Have you ever supported any other tournament to go call one of their previous winners and say "The money you should recieve for your last win, actually we now think you should only get half of it".


What im saying is yes his prize was change
The prize was changed because the seed format was chamged.
Im only pointing out there is a good reason for the change-to give more opportunities
It is a sacrifice naniwa was forced to make for the good of the gsl. Naniwa should be well credited for it. The change in seed format had nothing to do with blizzcup, naniwa and quantic have accepted it. Fans of naniwa can be angry.. But it wont change anything. Naniwa still had a chance for the code S seed being a candidate but gom eliminated
Him from the candidate list due to blizzcup. End of story
You can be angry as you like at gom for changing his prize and or taking his candidate position
But im just pointing out it was an optimal decision for the tournament itself


Please take your time and re-read my posts. Especially the long one. No one here discusses the change. It is a whole different matter. Many in TL actually find the new format really good, or at least a good improvement.

It also doesn't matter whether NaNiwa get's Code S or not. I think you deliberately skipped 99% of my posts. Because that's another thing I had to repeat over and over.

It is about changing rules afterwards.

Imagine a test in school.
Your teacher tells you: "draw a house".
One week later he gives you the results of the test.
And says: "By the way, I changed the rules of the test. The new goal is to draw a horse. You have 0 points, enjoy"

What I am saying is, they can change their format. Just tell others about it before the tournament. And not after.



Yes it is goms fault they didnt announce earlier. I just want to help explain why this happened
In my original post.. They have a limited number of people working there.. Decisions
May come to close slowly over there.. The reason why they didnt announce earlier is because the decisions
For the 2012 gsl were not final when the mlg started. Gom was shortsighted in making this change abruptly if anything they are to apologize.. But im just saying it wasnt their intention to pick
On naniwa or do anything damaging intentionally
And certainly no "conspiracies" of such


Well then we have no disagreement
jinorazi
Profile Joined October 2004
Korea (South)4948 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 04:01:21
December 16 2011 03:59 GMT
#737
On December 16 2011 12:54 eshlow wrote:
rote, you shoulda just quoted my post instead of making an analogy. :p

Basically,

1. GOM does not notify that they are changing the rules of code S.
2. MLG, and foreign fans, and Naniwa and other players are under the impression top 3 of non-code S at providence will get code S spot.
3. GOM says this is not true and that Naniwa was only in consideration, in their recently released statement. Thus, retrospectively changing the rules.

This is unprofessional to change the rules after the fact BECAUSE they didn't notify MLG (whom they have a partnership with) and the foreign fans, and the players who were all under the impression that Naniwa had a code S spot.

If we are going to get on Naniwa's case for being unprofessional, EVERYONE should ALSO be getting on GOM's case for being unprofessional by retroactively changing their own rules without notifying anyone.

It's airtight logic. There's no way anyone should be arguing the opposite side.

edit:

Note that changing the rules is fine. Notifying MLG, the fans, etc. of the changed rules IS professional and fine. The fact that they did not do this, and then came out with a statement that is contrary WITHOUT TELLING US THEY CHANGED THE RULES is blatantly unprofessional.


its been done before, where was the fuss then?

no need to answer, just saying. but a few posts this page and last page seems to sum up the situation well. there's really no need for hate and pointing fingers and blaming someone.
age: 84 | location: california | sex: 잘함
eshlow
Profile Joined June 2008
United States5210 Posts
December 16 2011 04:04 GMT
#738
On December 16 2011 12:59 jinorazi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 12:54 eshlow wrote:
rote, you shoulda just quoted my post instead of making an analogy. :p

Basically,

1. GOM does not notify that they are changing the rules of code S.
2. MLG, and foreign fans, and Naniwa and other players are under the impression top 3 of non-code S at providence will get code S spot.
3. GOM says this is not true and that Naniwa was only in consideration, in their recently released statement. Thus, retrospectively changing the rules.

This is unprofessional to change the rules after the fact BECAUSE they didn't notify MLG (whom they have a partnership with) and the foreign fans, and the players who were all under the impression that Naniwa had a code S spot.

If we are going to get on Naniwa's case for being unprofessional, EVERYONE should ALSO be getting on GOM's case for being unprofessional by retroactively changing their own rules without notifying anyone.

It's airtight logic. There's no way anyone should be arguing the opposite side.

edit:

Note that changing the rules is fine. Notifying MLG, the fans, etc. of the changed rules IS professional and fine. The fact that they did not do this, and then came out with a statement that is contrary WITHOUT TELLING US THEY CHANGED THE RULES is blatantly unprofessional.


its been done before, where was the fuss then?

no need to answer, just saying. but a few posts this page and last page seems to sum up the situation well. there's really no need for hate and pointing fingers and blaming someone.


People have thrown games before. Where's the fuss then?

The fact is if we are going to hold Naniwa to a professional standard here, then anything to do with the current situation in regards to his being labeled "unprofessional" then the accusers (in this case GOM) should not be unprofessional in their actions either.

No one likes hypocrites.
Overcoming Gravity: A Systematic Approach to Gymnastics and Bodyweight Strength
Flipside
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
United States141 Posts
December 16 2011 04:05 GMT
#739
I think this whole thing negatively effects GOM more than it does any other party involved. Funny how things work out huh? Oh well we will all forget about it soon. Just hope this doesn't happen again it's never a positive thing.
Clbull
Profile Blog Joined February 2011
United Kingdom1439 Posts
December 16 2011 04:08 GMT
#740
On December 16 2011 12:54 eshlow wrote:
rote, you shoulda just quoted my post instead of making an analogy. :p

Basically,

1. GOM does not notify that they are changing the rules of code S.
2. MLG, and foreign fans, and Naniwa and other players are under the impression top 3 of non-code S at providence will get code S spot.
3. GOM says this is not true and that Naniwa was only in consideration, in their recently released statement. Thus, retrospectively changing the rules.

This is unprofessional to change the rules after the fact BECAUSE they didn't notify MLG (whom they have a partnership with) and the foreign fans, and the players who were all under the impression that Naniwa had a code S spot.

If we are going to get on Naniwa's case for being unprofessional, EVERYONE should ALSO be getting on GOM's case for being unprofessional by retroactively changing their own rules without notifying anyone.

It's airtight logic. There's no way anyone should be arguing the opposite side.

edit:

Note that changing the rules is fine. Notifying MLG, the fans, etc. of the changed rules IS professional and fine. The fact that they did not do this, and then came out with a statement that is contrary WITHOUT TELLING US THEY CHANGED THE RULES is blatantly unprofessional.

Why aren't GOM being called out on this more rigorously? I feel like they've treated the first (and only) foreigner to actually "win" a Code S seed from MLG really unfairly here. This just feels like GOM urinating over the international SC2 scene. I mean even now several months into the League Exchange Program, the GSL may as well be called the KSL (although that name has been taken already by a small league made up of 8 Korean teams)

In fact, I think Sundance is being far too lenient upon GOMTV for fabricating new rules and applying them retroactively to players who won seeds fairly and squarely. Sure, it's not exactly their business on how the GSL conducts its business but
Prev 1 35 36 37 38 39 58 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
BSL 21
15:00
NKorea Champ Playoff Final Day
LiquipediaDiscussion
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
12:00
Bonus Cup #2
uThermal973
IndyStarCraft 413
SteadfastSC213
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
uThermal 973
Harstem 438
IndyStarCraft 413
SteadfastSC 180
Rex 148
ProTech119
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 4480
Sea 3401
Shuttle 1622
Jaedong 1278
EffOrt 812
Larva 808
Stork 616
Mini 584
BeSt 417
GuemChi 397
[ Show more ]
hero 357
Hyuk 343
Light 325
firebathero 296
ZerO 259
actioN 245
ggaemo 165
Rush 157
Killer 148
Barracks 131
ZZZero.O 109
Hyun 103
Soulkey 83
Mong 82
Mind 71
Sharp 60
Shinee 46
Yoon 38
Hm[arnc] 34
Backho 31
sorry 30
Free 23
soO 21
Shine 20
GoRush 17
Rock 14
Noble 14
zelot 11
HiyA 11
Terrorterran 8
JulyZerg 7
Dota 2
Gorgc3490
singsing2642
qojqva2138
420jenkins814
syndereN457
LuMiX0
Counter-Strike
fl0m1700
kennyS1672
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King72
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor449
Other Games
B2W.Neo1776
Liquid`RaSZi1563
DeMusliM193
XaKoH 114
ZerO(Twitch)15
Organizations
Other Games
EGCTV724
StarCraft: Brood War
Kim Chul Min (afreeca) 15
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• Michael_bg 5
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Jankos3628
• TFBlade733
Upcoming Events
Replay Cast
8h 44m
Wardi Open
22h 44m
Monday Night Weeklies
1d 1h
OSC
1d 8h
Replay Cast
1d 17h
WardiTV Invitational
1d 22h
Replay Cast
2 days
WardiTV Invitational
2 days
The PondCast
3 days
HomeStory Cup
4 days
[ Show More ]
Korean StarCraft League
5 days
HomeStory Cup
5 days
Replay Cast
6 days
HomeStory Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-01-24
OSC Championship Season 13
Tektek Cup #1

Ongoing

C-Race Season 1
BSL 21 Non-Korean Championship
CSL 2025 WINTER (S19)
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 1
Acropolis #4 - TS4
Rongyi Cup S3
Underdog Cup #3
BLAST Bounty Winter 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter Qual
eXTREMESLAND 2025
SL Budapest Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 8
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025

Upcoming

Escore Tournament S1: W6
Escore Tournament S1: W7
Acropolis #4
IPSL Spring 2026
uThermal 2v2 2026 Main Event
Bellum Gens Elite Stara Zagora 2026
HSC XXVIII
Nations Cup 2026
PGL Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 1
BLAST Open Spring 2026
ESL Pro League Season 23
ESL Pro League Season 23
PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026
IEM Kraków 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.