Hearthstone Mafia - Page 53

On November 02 2014 10:03 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Ugh HF voted me again.

This game is going to be really fucking annoying.

On November 02 2014 09:54 Blazinghand wrote:
L, what you think of OWD

On November 01 2014 14:10 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
The dichotomy between lian/Circumstance is something I'm looking at. I really don't like how lian nitpicks at one of Circumstance's posts and then turns around and then says "hey, it reminds me of when I was new."

When you're new, you end up leaving a ton of holes in your game that people can pick at, which is what I've seen in Circumstance's play. (not having enough scumreads, putting quite a bit of emphasis on setup, etc)

You'd think that would mean you would put more effort into figuring that player out instead of just pushing a tiny thing like that, but I guess lian doesn't feel like doing that. I find it strange.



Where do you stand on Circumstance?

Also, the analysis thing on Jay is a waste of time because he's town. I'm not going to elaborate on this because the cat is going to explain it for you. On the off chance that the cat is actually controlled by 3p or mafia, I can compare my read to whatever it gives us and see if it's actually a town entity or not by seeing if it agrees with me.

##Analyze: JB

I kind of realized that I contradicted myself in that paragraph, but w/e it's fine don't think about it.

On November 02 2014 10:20 Lord Tolkien wrote:

If you mean me, he leans town based on muh gut.

His filter is reasonable in my read, nothing scummy stands out, and personally, I like this post.

On November 02 2014 04:10 Damdred wrote:


what the literal fuck.... i'm claiming a blue power role and this is the response? I post my notes though ve mad about redacting and this is what you do.

Good job gb is a good lynch then

On November 02 2014 10:43 liancourt wrote:


your role doesn't really indicate where it's good or bad really. What I do know is that you've made things harder for town to lynch anyone today because we need 9 votes on 1 person. I would really appreciate flips so we can move the discussion onto someone else tomorrow. What was your motive for making it a majority vote?

On November 02 2014 10:39 ritoky wrote:


so you don't think it was weird that he was defending damdred and calling him innocent before he even claimed? then why do you think damdred is town outside of his blue claim?

On November 02 2014 10:49 Lord Tolkien wrote:

Part One: Somewhat, but town can be erratic perfectly well. Don't see any major issue with his defense of damdred.

Part Two: Yes. At the least, I'd rather lynch someone else today.

Since the day is now long enough for risk.nuke to post tomorrow, I want to read a good set of posts from him.

On November 02 2014 10:52 jrkirby wrote:
LT, if day 1 ended on time, misder would have ended it with his vote on you (as it would be over in the next 10 minutes).

How do you feel about that? I think that's too much lurking.

On November 02 2014 10:52 ritoky wrote:


yeah except the part where you didn't answer WHY outside of his claim damdred is town.

On November 02 2014 10:56 Lord Tolkien wrote:
Reread your question:

I do think Damdred is townish, One: because while yes, it's now a majority lynch, town should be perfectly able to consolidate with another 24 hours, and quite frankly, the extra 24 hours are much more important for town.

In any event, what point would mafia Damdred have to gain by breadcrumbing and revealing himself? It just puts him under scrutiny here.


My read of his filter is unremarkable, outside his strong townread on jay. Which I find lulzy.

On November 02 2014 10:20 Lord Tolkien wrote:
If you mean me, he leans town based on muh gut.

His filter is reasonable in my read, nothing scummy stands out, and personally, I like this post.

On November 02 2014 11:01 Lord Tolkien wrote:

Hard to describe. If you go through his filter, he clearly has a thought process, and is asking town-focused questions.

He's got appropriate skepticism.

On November 02 2014 05:59 Damdred wrote:
I think jrkirby is scum,

His entrance to the thread was odd, GB pointed this out in another post but the first real post that starts raising my suspicion is here

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=11#213

At this point, circumstance is being put under pressure for a slip on a word and his reaction is being tested. And the response that is given before any real explanation can be had is that circumstance is basically ok right now. It feels a little bit like a defend before any real information can be found out feels like buddying and given out a pass for no reason.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=18#351

gives out another townread without any explanation or going back to it.

What was good about hfs posts exactly?

Also he talks about the cat a good bit in his filter which is safe for scum to talk about,

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=14#270
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=15#283
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=15#293
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=22#421
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=25#493
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=25#494
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=25#496
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=27#526

Most of his second page of filter is talking about the cat safely.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=29#568

Wants to lynch a lurker who was not really active to that point, low hanging fruit.

He then goes on to talk about rng some, he seems some what against it but once BH answers him he says this

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=31#604

He has a town lean on GB but why leave his LT vote who he thinks hasn't done anything and is scummy and go to GB who he town reads. This is weird, it seems like hes trying to find a safe spot to put his vote it seems like BH might get some support in the thread so he moves his vote to go with it.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=32#622

Doesn't look like the GB lynch will take off so he moves back to LT once he looks up the stats on RNG lynch.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=35#689

Tries to find another spot to park his vote does not get the desired results chaulks it up o a misundersanding and moves on to misder

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=39#770

He then admits to being behind in the thread, goes on to say that he will try to read my filter again to answer gb

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=39#778

Never actually makes another comment about me (he has been absent though), and tries to jump on BH when someone else (oats) says he looks scummy.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia?page=40#791

Overall, He gives townreads without giving any thought, does not seem really to be scum hunting hes jumping his vote around to see what he can find easiest to lynch and really hasn't commented on a lot of burning issues. That in which he has commented on its been in a way thats easy for him to fall back from, I think he is scum and should be the lynch today.

On November 02 2014 09:53 Lord Tolkien wrote:

Aha, but you forget.

+ Show Spoiler +

I find this tunneling on me cute jay.


What I don't find cute is this whole GB train going. Ugh, I'm still reading GB as town despite being horrendous this game. No, you aren't being passive this game but good god, really? Nein, neeeeein.