My read on everyone, based mostly by reading through the last 20 pages of debate around the Radfield lynch. Toades, surviving vigis and Batman, whoever you are, I think you should shoot into the first category of players.

- 90% scum:
Jaybrundage
risk.nuke
VisceraEyes
Chaoser

- 50/50:
tunkeg
Hiro Protagonist
Katina
Layabout
Tyrran

- 90% Townlist:
rgSchworz
Kitaman27 (against the lynch but claimed blue, who hasn´t been counterclaimed)
Rayzorflash
Evantrees (screams newbie town to me)
Adam4167 (Revoted Radfield despite Kitamans claim)
Bill Murray (claimed Medic, only reason he´s here)

- 100% Townlist:
Toadesstern
Qualis
Jayjay54
Forumite <- Shameless self-promotion

- Ignore list:
Palmar
Kurumi

If there´s anything you think is wrong or odd in my list, please speak up. I know there are at least 5 townies in the first two categories, but I think most are in the 50/50 group, not the 90% scumlist.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

February 14 2012 13:53 GMT

#3154

Tunkeg's so town that we don't have such green colour here.

Adam4167

Australia1426 Posts

February 14 2012 13:56 GMT

#3155

How is Jayjay 100% town? What makes him undeniably town?

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

February 14 2012 13:56 GMT

#3156

On February 14 2012 22:50 Forumite wrote:
My read on everyone, based mostly by reading through the last 20 pages of debate around the Radfield lynch. Toades, surviving vigis and Batman, whoever you are, I think you should shoot into the first category of players.

- 90% scum:
Jaybrundage
risk.nuke
VisceraEyes
Chaoser

- 50/50:
tunkeg
Hiro Protagonist
Katina
Layabout
Tyrran

- 90% Townlist:
rgSchworz
Kitaman27 (against the lynch but claimed blue, who hasn´t been counterclaimed)
Rayzorflash
Evantrees (screams newbie town to me)
Adam4167 (Revoted Radfield despite Kitamans claim)
Bill Murray (claimed Medic, only reason he´s here)

- 100% Townlist:
Toadesstern
Qualis
Jayjay54
Forumite <- Shameless self-promotion

- Ignore list:
Palmar
Kurumi

If there´s anything you think is wrong or odd in my list, please speak up. I know there are at least 5 townies in the first two categories, but I think most are in the 50/50 group, not the 90% scumlist.

these kind of posts are hurting my feelings. 4 times 90% mafia, 4 times 50% mafia and it's only 4 mafias left. That's not adding up and we're not in russia :p
Back to topic: I don't think tunkeg is mafia
I'd definatly put Hiro higher on the list which is a problem because again there's only 4 mafia left.
VE looks like the most confirmed mafia to me, chaoser&nuke&jaybrundage are all about the same level of scumminess a little bit behind VE imo.

So noone hit tunkeg, Katina, Layabut, Tyrran imo.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

February 14 2012 13:58 GMT

#3157

Toad, if You can, shoot either:
VE or Risk.Nuke

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

February 14 2012 14:00 GMT

#3158

On February 14 2012 22:23 Tunkeg wrote:

Show nested quote +

Hiro, Razor, risk, jayjay all of those are pretty good vigshots tonight.

Risk is a good target, Radfield and scummy players wanted to buss Hiro instead of Radfield, so perhaps him.

Jayjay is not a good target, he looked Town during the lynchdiscussion and still do after the flip. Not sure anymore why I thought Razor is probably Town, but please stay off him anyway.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

February 14 2012 14:01 GMT

#3159

I already said I'm not going to tell you what I'm about to shoot, I'm the only one that has a blockable shot. I'd much rather see you and Palmar call out your shots and I'm picking whatever is left.

As mentioned, I think risk.nuke, VisceraEyes, hiro make all good hits. Chaoser and jaybrundage as well but I haven't looked into them for a while after my furious attack on chaoser and the fact that we did not end up lynching him.