Sengoku Mafia - Page 25

On November 16 2010 17:11 Chezinu wrote:
So far from reading Caller's post, TheGloriousKnee seems like the most ruthless kingdom.

On November 16 2010 05:12 Caller wrote:
Finally, the typical opportunists that ruled TheGloriousKnee ran into province 3, killing the men, raping the horses, and riding off on the women.

On November 16 2010 17:14 kingjames01 wrote:




I don't know how much we can read into this. When I read it for the first time, I thought it was just for flavour.

On November 16 2010 17:21 DCLXVI wrote:

Well all of the other successful attacks (besides 19->17) included a note about how the other province's army was not around. This makes it sound like TGK had a gunpowder role as province 3 had it's men killed too

On November 16 2010 17:43 annul wrote:
by the way

"eliminated" territories are not always actually eliminated. read the rules.

communist nations with no territory can somehow be revived (?) as long as neutral land exists... and neutral land always has the possibility to be created (by simultaneous successful attacks)

guerillas can reclaim land they lost, and can do this at any time, evidently, under the rules. so for example if 17 was a guerilla, he could wait until like 10 days from now and then pop up and take 17 back, if i read the rules right

caller also says there are hidden roles ("may or may not be" = "there are", honestly) that might have death effects or abilities. we may also have roles that shift over time.

On November 16 2010 13:35 ghrur wrote:


Actually, I think that's the best explanation because Caller said 11's army was elsewhere.

Another thing to note, nothing happened with 18 nor 14. Now this brings up an interesting case. Let's start with 18 first:
Clearly 19 attacked 17... but why attack 17 when 18, a neutral territory, is right by? Furthermore, how did 17 get taken over without taking over 14?
Hmm, well, there are 3 actions possible for 17.
If they defended, yet were defeated, then obviously 19 and either 16 or 20 are mafia.
If they attacked, then they most likely attacked 14, but that didn't work because the attack canceled out with someone else (20). Obviously they aren't the same faction, so why would 20 be suspected of Mafia over 17? Because 19 attacked 17 instead of going after 18 indicating sureness in winning that battle. (Hmmm, idk if Caller reports stale-mated battles.)
I doubt 17 would assist someone unless they have a heavy PM circle going on.
However, what would be the MOST helpful would be if 15 claimed to us what they did.
If 15 attacked 18, 16 must've also attacked 18.
If 15 defended, then 16 COULDN'T have attacked 18, 19, NOR 13. 16 could've attacked 15 or 17. If 17, then he's mafia. If 15, then 20's mafia. Which means, if we can get a role claim from 2 of the three: 15, 16, and 20, we can most likely nail 2 mafias.
If 15 assisted, telling us who they assisted would help a lot as well.

Anyway, from what I can tell here, I'm guessing 19 is probably Mafia, 16 might be Mafia based on what 15 does, and 20 has a higher chance of being mafia than 16.

Btw, Batmania and Land of Preemptive Retaliation both seem to be eliminated now, do we get the player's name who were eliminated? Also, we seem to have 5 nations with 2 territories now (1&3, 4&8, 5&6, 11&13, and 17&19) Do these nations get to attack twice/defend twice/send aid twice or only once?

On November 16 2010 20:30 Loanshark wrote:
Fact that red is first on the list indicates they probably got their province choices/name in fairly quickly and was around for the first draft of the map. From that we can assume they were also active in the early stages of the game. Probably not too helpful, but it's a start.

If Coagulation is in this game (other than making the map), maybe he decided to put his country first as red

On November 16 2010 20:34 annul wrote:
yes i mean that post, specifically this part:

"Which means, if we can get a role claim from 2 of the three: 15, 16, and 20, we can most likely nail 2 mafias."

so 15 or 16 needs to speak up and we can start to lynch people.

On November 16 2010 22:37 bumatlarge wrote:
You are all pussies. If you are townie, try to get the most territories. Screw everyone else you don't know who they are. If you win town wins. I support the Ace propaganda.