|
On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever. 
I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game.
|
On July 05 2012 07:12 Dandel Ion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:10 Shikyo wrote: Depending on Jayce's numbers, I'm assuming that he's going to be incredibly overpowered. I'll instabuy him, learn to play him, and hopefully abuse myself some wins until he gets nerfed. The concept is just completely broken for him. I used to assume every new champ Riot makes is OP. Then I insta-bought Karma when she came out. 600 range.
"max aspd for a few attack" I'm assuming it goes like 2 3 4 5 6 by levels because otherwise it doesn't make sense, so 6 autos with 2.5 aspd from 600 range.
Also he's a bruiser who can get away with fully offensive itemization and thus wins all 1v1s even with other bruisers.
This is all in theory of course but I just don't see it being balanced at all if the numbers stay how they are. If his transform has like no cast time... It's going to be insane.
|
|
On July 05 2012 07:14 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever.  I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game.
... you serious?
you were claiming that "no one" can beat eve in lane
that implies no one can beat her 1v1, because you were listing all the qualities that make her strong 1v1. if you meant "no one" can beat her while her jungler camps the lane, then that's true of everyone
so don't use the "team game" excuse to dodge
|
On July 05 2012 07:14 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever.  I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game.
It actually proves a lot in a debate regarding whether or not 1 champ wins toplane versus an other champ without jungler interaction, as in that debate the actions of the rest of the team are completely irrelevant since they are a priori assumed to not influence toplane. The question if this then leads to winning games is a completely different one, and noone talked about that.
|
On July 05 2012 07:10 Shikyo wrote: Depending on Jayce's numbers, I'm assuming that he's going to be incredibly overpowered. I'll instabuy him, learn to play him, and hopefully abuse myself some wins until he gets nerfed. The concept is just completely broken for him.
20% of your max health in magic damage on a 10s cd. 380 base damage point blank AoE. 30% armor/MR reduction on the target of your next attack when you switch your weapon to ranged. Max AS for a few attacks from level 1 to win short trades every time. Gap closer AoE slow. Positional MS buff (well, that one is not as impressive, but the way I see it it can have a lot of uses due to its utility).
Dis 'nuff fo you?
|
In team games individual skill doesn't matter. Michael Jorwho? Wayne Gretzwha? One person can't win or lose a game, TSM replacing TRM and suddenly they start winning every single tournament they compete in was because they sacrificed children to Odin.
|
On July 05 2012 07:26 SnK-Arcbound wrote: In team games individual skill doesn't matter. Michael Jorwho? Wayne Gretzwha? One person can't win or lose a game, TSM replacing TRM and suddenly they start winning every single tournament they compete in was because they sacrificed children to Odin.
Actually it is highly likely that the reason TSM kicked the TRM was that they sacrificed children to Odin, he then imparted some of his legendary wisdom to them convincing TSM that RainMan had to go. Your point still stands though.
|
United States47024 Posts
On July 05 2012 07:17 Shikyo wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:12 Dandel Ion wrote:On July 05 2012 07:10 Shikyo wrote: Depending on Jayce's numbers, I'm assuming that he's going to be incredibly overpowered. I'll instabuy him, learn to play him, and hopefully abuse myself some wins until he gets nerfed. The concept is just completely broken for him. I used to assume every new champ Riot makes is OP. Then I insta-bought Karma when she came out. 600 range. "max aspd for a few attack" I'm assuming it goes like 2 3 4 5 6 by levels because otherwise it doesn't make sense, so 6 autos with 2.5 aspd from 600 range. Also he's a bruiser who can get away with fully offensive itemization and thus wins all 1v1s even with other bruisers. This is all in theory of course but I just don't see it being balanced at all if the numbers stay how they are. If his transform has like no cast time... It's going to be insane. His data is on PBE. Jayce has 500 range, not 600, and his W is fixed at 3 attacks at all ranks (% of your normal damage scales).
http://leagueoflegends.wikia.com/wiki/Jayce_the_Defender_of_Tomorrow
As a ranged AD, his attack range is prohibitively low. As a bruiser, he has the base stats of a ranged AD, not a bruiser.
EDIT: I know the data from the Reign of Gaming patch notes says 600 range for Jayce, but given how that post fucked up a lot of things (his other base stats), I'm inclined to believe the Wiki more than that post.
|
On July 05 2012 07:24 Simberto wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:14 PrinceXizor wrote:On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever.  I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game. It actually proves a lot in a debate regarding whether or not 1 champ wins toplane versus an other champ without jungler interaction, as in that debate the actions of the rest of the team are completely irrelevant since they are a priori assumed to not influence toplane. The question if this then leads to winning games is a completely different one, and noone talked about that.
I'm addition, a top lane where one champion almost certainly destroys the other champion places a ton of pressure on the team with the losing lane. Suddenly that team's jungler is under pressure to turn the top lane around or make something happen somewhere else to balance things out. Knowing which top lanes are unfavorable/lopsided is extremely important during champion selection and planning. 1v1s help teams identify or practice these bad matchups.
It's doubly important/useful because there are situations where your team can not help you due to other events demanding attention. A lot of teams lose games when their mid/top do not get the jungle support they are accustomed to.
|
Roffles
Pitcairn19291 Posts
On July 05 2012 07:05 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 06:56 Slusher wrote: Missed the Eve debate, went back to check out the action to find it was that Prince Xizor character.
I don't know what to tell you guys, guys clearly been looking to suicide by cop since he posted his I'm done with LoL post.
a)constant jabs at LoL vs DOTA2 b)Constant trying to promote Karma support c)the time he said all the NA teams suck dick and don't practice
this is the guy you gave serious debate over eve top? a. never made lol vs dota jabs.you guys took it that way (only a few of you actually, everyone else took i for what it was) b. It's good vs short range AD carries,it's a counterpick. having 1 discussion with people about it isn't "constantly trying to promote" :/ c. I said until recently it was accepted that they barely practiced, this was backed up by people in thread saying they used to take solo queue as "practice" which we all know is complete BS when trying to work as a team to win events. So kindly stop talking and don't say shit that is definitely a lie. I've been sleeping.  i haven't lied about a damn thing. eve wins her laning phase until the jungler starts coming top a lot as is the normal reaction to winning her lane phase. eve has to use invis jukes to avoid the jungler and hope her team takes dragon. a lot. and hope her team can 4v4 with both top lanes being insignificant in fights in the mid game. but whatever you guys are just intentionally being jerks to me now so i'm not even going to try anymore. *sigh* No one's intentionally being a jerk to you. If you'd just man the fuck up and stop dodging everyone that challenges you, maybe people would actually believe you. Words don't mean shit man. You gotta show us by giving us a replay or 1v1 people that challenge you. Instead you're fucking acting as if you're a martyr because people here are mean. But until you can legitimately show us, all this theorycrafting means absolutely nothing.
So man the fuck up and stop dodging your challenges. Cause I fucking hate coming in here and seeing you shit up this thread with your bullshit. You've singlehandedly turned this thread into a cesspool of shit with your incessant QQing about how this game sucks, the community blows, it's too hard to get better, people won't believe me, etc.
Didn't you say you quit this game? Then stop posting and shitting up this thread with your bullshit.
|
I feel that Jayce will be a strong laner but his teamfight utility is somewhat lacking. Then again, this may depend on his numbers on his E...
I do think his W is OP. At max rank, he does 3 hits in a bit more than one second with.... 130% damage each? That's pretty OP.
EDIT: one thing I noticed is that Jayce does not have MR/lvl. Very strange. EDIT2: I don't think he will be a good AD carry, but I am sure people will try anyway.
|
On July 05 2012 07:23 gtrsrs wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:14 PrinceXizor wrote:On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever.  I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game. ... you serious? you were claiming that "no one" can beat eve in lane that implies no one can beat her 1v1, because you were listing all the qualities that make her strong 1v1. if you meant "no one" can beat her while her jungler camps the lane, then that's true of everyone so don't use the "team game" excuse to dodge i didn't say no one can beat eve in lane i actually specifically mention that any character good at dealing mixed damage will beat her i'll amend that to people who clear waves super fast as well since i feel vlad would destroy her solely from that. in fact the only all situation was zulu saying EVERY top beats eve. i said she can bully down single damage type champions. so i don't even know. everyone is getting all puffed up and upset over shit i never said because they don't bother to read, why should the burden of proof be on me when if i post it it likely won't be read anyway. ???
and yeah 1v1ing a support player top is definitely gonna prove shit
... you serious? Re roffles: If people stopped being fucking assholes to me and actually started discussions instead of just total BS attacks on me then the thread wouldn't get so bad, would it?
We had a super positive discussion that occurred over the shitty ladder system and lack of organized inhouses. We had a positive discussion over itemizing in lol. The negative discussions came from "LOL NOPE" responses to me, instead of actually challenging the statement with a discussion. " LOL NOPE 1v1 ME NOOB" doesn't actually = a good debate. in fact, the majority of my posts have been pretty detailed explaining how you do it and what the end result should be. and the ONLY discussion against it was rooted in mistaken facts. so HOW is the discussion supposed to be positive when only 1 side is even trying. "Manning up" and 1v1ing doesn't make the thread any better, it just piles it into a "oh now me, now me" "pffft this guy can't beat a dedicated top laner in top laner when he plays support" that doesn't improve a damn thing does it? only through meaningful discussion will the thread get better, but i'm sorry that they don't want to have that. not my fault.
|
Eve might have a chance against AP Riven
|
On July 05 2012 07:55 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:23 gtrsrs wrote:On July 05 2012 07:14 PrinceXizor wrote:On July 05 2012 07:11 Slusher wrote: forgot to mention he camps the thread simply to disagree with people. people disagreed with me, i was defending my opinions. i don't see how... whatever.  I'll 1v1 you guys sure. not that it proves anything in a team game. ... you serious? you were claiming that "no one" can beat eve in lane that implies no one can beat her 1v1, because you were listing all the qualities that make her strong 1v1. if you meant "no one" can beat her while her jungler camps the lane, then that's true of everyone so don't use the "team game" excuse to dodge i didn't saw no one can beat eve in lane. in fact the only all situation was zulu saying EVERY top beats eve. i said she can bully down single damage type champions. so i don't even know. everyone is getting all puffed up and upset over shit i never said because they don't bother to read, why should the burden of proof be on me when if i post it it likely won't be read anyway. ??? and yeah 1v1ing a support player top is definitely gonna prove shit ... you serious? Re roffles: If people stopped being fucking assholes to me and actually started discussions instead of just total BS attacks on me then the thread wouldn't get so bad, would it? We had a super positive discussion that occurred over the shitty ladder system and lack of organized inhouses. We had a positive discussion over itemizing in lol. The negative discussions came from "LOL NOPE" responses to me, instead of actually challenging the statement with a discussion. " LOL NOPE 1v1 ME NOOB" doesn't actually = a good debate. in fact, the majority of my posts have been pretty detailed explaining how you do it and what the end result should be. and the ONLY discussion against it was rooted in mistaken facts. so HOW is the discussion supposed to be positive when only 1 side is even trying. "Manning up" and 1v1ing doesn't make the thread any better, it just piles it into a "oh now me, now me" "pffft this guy can't beat a dedicated top laner in top laner when he plays support" that doesn't improve a damn thing does it? only through meaningful discussion will the thread get better, but i'm sorry that they don't want to have that. not my fault. You said:
On July 04 2012 15:49 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 04 2012 14:25 zulu_nation8 wrote:On July 04 2012 13:59 PrinceXizor wrote:On July 04 2012 13:41 Shikyo wrote:On July 04 2012 12:19 Scip wrote: Damn guys, duoQing with Shykio atm, haven't had this hilarious games in a while. Carrying is so easy but we gain only 4-8 elo each game hahaha. Reccoment everyone who is 2K+ to duoQ with someone at 1300-1500 range. This experiment proves that last pick = support even among 1800 elos, even if you say that you are terrible at support with an average win rate of 22% with support champions, and when you play terribly as support they will report you. It's too bad, the Graves game I went 7-2 and the Poppy top game I went 13-5, both vs 1700-1800s Oh but it's hilarious how angry some people are <_< And also there was some eve main at 1900 elo who beat karthus mid in farm... Eve new karthus counter? Eve can beat anyone in lane except a heavy mixed damage dealer. to do so it takes two rune pages though,, 1 for vs magic 1 for vs physical. She's kind of a bitch to lane against if the eve knows what they are doing. However, eves usefulness drops off considerably if camped if the game makes it past laning phase if the enemy team is intelligent. and unfortunately you only need two of the three. what are you talking about lol Eve building tanky can right click the enemy and win every lane, she's just such a terrible character outside of that ability that it's not worth it. she does have the best attack animation in the game though.
|
United States47024 Posts
On July 05 2012 07:55 PrinceXizor wrote: i didn't saw no one can beat eve in lane. in fact the only all situation was zulu saying EVERY top beats eve. i said she can bully down single damage type champions. so i don't even know. everyone is getting all puffed up and upset over shit i never said because they don't bother to read, why should the burden of proof be on me when if i post it it likely won't be read
On July 04 2012 13:59 PrinceXizor wrote: Eve can beat anyone in lane except a heavy mixed damage dealer. to do so it takes two rune pages though,, 1 for vs magic 1 for vs physical. She's kind of a bitch to lane against if the eve knows what they are doing.
On July 04 2012 15:49 PrinceXizor wrote: Eve building tanky can right click the enemy and win every lane, she's just such a terrible character outside of that ability that it's not worth it. she does have the best attack animation in the game though. lol
|
On July 05 2012 07:36 TheYango wrote:Show nested quote +On July 05 2012 07:17 Shikyo wrote:On July 05 2012 07:12 Dandel Ion wrote:On July 05 2012 07:10 Shikyo wrote: Depending on Jayce's numbers, I'm assuming that he's going to be incredibly overpowered. I'll instabuy him, learn to play him, and hopefully abuse myself some wins until he gets nerfed. The concept is just completely broken for him. I used to assume every new champ Riot makes is OP. Then I insta-bought Karma when she came out. 600 range. "max aspd for a few attack" I'm assuming it goes like 2 3 4 5 6 by levels because otherwise it doesn't make sense, so 6 autos with 2.5 aspd from 600 range. Also he's a bruiser who can get away with fully offensive itemization and thus wins all 1v1s even with other bruisers. This is all in theory of course but I just don't see it being balanced at all if the numbers stay how they are. If his transform has like no cast time... It's going to be insane. His data is on PBE. Jayce has 500 range, not 600, and his W is fixed at 3 attacks at all ranks (% of your normal damage scales). http://leagueoflegends.wikia.com/wiki/Jayce_the_Defender_of_TomorrowAs a ranged AD, his attack range is prohibitively low. As a bruiser, he has the base stats of a ranged AD, not a bruiser. EDIT: I know the data from the Reign of Gaming patch notes says 600 range for Jayce, but given how that post fucked up a lot of things (his other base stats), I'm inclined to believe the Wiki more than that post.
I'm not quite sure it's prohibitively low. Sivir is viable and she also has 500 range. With strong bush control he could be viable. I can see him being similar to tristana in that he could combo with some insane burst early game. I see him being viable top lane since his melee form has a pretty strong knockback (escape), and from kennen /vlad, we can deduce that range is a pretty strong thing top lane. The MR/Armor bonus from being in melee form might make up for how low his base stats are otherwise.
|
I did say that, and then i amended it to be more accurate. So since when it correcting yourself a problem, you are acting like i go back and forth.
On July 05 2012 07:18 MooMooMugi wrote: 1v1s are a true display of skill
Lol this everyone should just do ezreal mirror 1v1s
|
United States47024 Posts
On July 05 2012 08:02 Lmui wrote: I'm not quite sure it's prohibitively low. Sivir is viable and she also has 500 range. With strong bush control he could be viable. I can see him being similar to tristana in that he could combo with some insane burst early game. I see him being viable top lane since his melee form has a pretty strong knockback (escape), and from kennen /vlad, we can deduce that range is a pretty strong thing top lane. The MR/Armor bonus from being in melee form might make up for how low his base stats are otherwise. Sivir's entire skillset also serves to extend her effective range. That's realy not a good comparison.
|
is it possible to ban this guy from this forum...? jesus christ
my friend and i were having a discussion on smartcast vs nonsmartcast and i tried to argue that some champs do better with and some do better without. ie alistar checking his w range is not easily done with smartcast or playing ryze without smartcast is just a huge bitch cause of the extra clicks. what do you guys prefer?
|
|
|
|