What is really interesting (at least according to the interviewed former US official) is that Russia is lost on their own objectives for the war.
Russo-Ukrainian War Thread - Page 501
Forum Index > General Forum |
NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets. Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source. | ||
pmp10
3245 Posts
What is really interesting (at least according to the interviewed former US official) is that Russia is lost on their own objectives for the war. | ||
{CC}StealthBlue
United States41117 Posts
Ukrainian forces reportedly launched a massive push against Russia's front-lines in the country's southeastern Zaporizhzhia region, threatening Russian positions that had been overseen by a general who was recently fired. The surge marks a dramatic change in pace for Ukraine's ongoing counteroffensive. For nearly two months, Kyiv's troops were forced to make slow and steady advances to liberate occupied territory as they faced Russia's formidable defensive lines, which include deadly networks of trenches, barbed wire, anti-armor obstacles, and minefields. Clearing the Russian fortifications — particularly the minefields — has been a painstaking process for Ukraine, which managed to preserve lots of its firepower and combat capabilities, such as heavy armor provided by the US and its NATO allies. But it now seems as though Kyiv has committed significantly more resources into the fight. Pentagon officials told the New York Times on Wednesday that Ukraine has poured thousands of reinforcements — many who have been trained and outfitted by Western countries — into battle along the Zaporizhzhia axis, which is one of several locations along the several-hundred-miles-long front line where Kyiv is fighting. The sheer scale of this thrust as reported suggests a main attack has begun, coming after weeks of probing attacks and mineclearing that suggests Ukraine's war commanders think they've found a vulnerable spot in Russia's formidable defenses. The fired Russian general had demanded changes after suffering losses in artillery battles with Ukraine that were crucial to holding their defensive lines. According to the US officials, Ukraine has expressed a desire to press south toward the occupied city of Melitopol, near the Sea of Azov. Doing so would allow Kyiv's military to split the territory that Russia currently occupies and threaten its hold on the Crimean peninsula. Russian state-run media outlet TASS said Ukraine carried out a "massive tank attack" in the Zaporizhzhia area, citing a defense ministry official, who claimed the attacks had been repelled and that Kyiv lost a number of tanks, armored vehicles, and personnel. The battlefield picture, however, was disputed and unclear on Wednesday, and Insider was not able to immediately verify Moscow's assertions. Ukrainian officials did not publicly reveal many details about the new push on Wednesday, although Kyiv's General Staff of the Armed Forces said in a Facebook update that Russia "is concentrating its main efforts on preventing the further advance of our troops" in Zaporizhzhia. The General Staff added that Ukraine's air force carried out over a dozen strikes on Russian troops, military equipment, weapons, and anti-air defense systems. It said Kyiv's missile and artillery units managed to strike Russia's own artillery units and command posts. "By the way, today our guys at the front had very good results. Well done. More details later," Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said in his address to the nation on Wednesday. The new Zaporizhzhia assault comes shortly after Russia's military leadership fired Maj. Gen. Ivan Popov, who previously commanded Russia's 58th Combined Arms Army, which had been battling Ukraine's offensive in that region. Popov was apparently dismissed from his role earlier this month after he raised concerns over several front-line weaknesses plaguing his forces, including deficiencies in Moscow's artillery defense. Popov later said in an audio message that he raised concerns about "the lack of counter-battery combat, the absence of artillery reconnaissance stations, and the mass deaths and injuries of our brothers in enemy artillery fire." Lacking air superiority, Ukraine has relied heavily on artillery to strike Russian troop positions, command and control locations, communications sites, and heavy guns. According to the Times, Ukrainian officials told the US that the new operation in Zaporizhzhia could take up to several weeks. Kyiv's military leadership previously expressed frustration with some in the West who have suggested that the counteroffensive should be moving faster than it had been, saying that every meter of territory is extremely costly for Ukraine to liberate. Top Pentagon officials have also pushed back on discourse around the speed of the offensive. Source No idea if this is in the same area, cause Google Maps gives me nothing. | ||
pmp10
3245 Posts
That might be the point when Ukraine commits their reserves. Having it reported in the press before they even start is not optimal. | ||
0x64
Finland4520 Posts
Drone recon and harass seems to be the key to lower the efficiency of trenchs + artillery. | ||
Gorsameth
Netherlands21369 Posts
On July 27 2023 16:56 pmp10 wrote: If people are talking about it, even if off the record, then I would hope that its already underway and Russia already knows of it.https://twitter.com/shashj/status/1684298647414902786 That might be the point when Ukraine commits their reserves. Having it reported in the press before they even start is not optimal. If not then I hope these people are caught and prosecuted to the full extend of the law because they are literally killing people by talking. | ||
![]()
2Pacalypse-
Croatia9476 Posts
Reporting from Ukraine made a video about the Russia's breakthrough last night: | ||
Ardias
Russian Federation605 Posts
On July 27 2023 17:55 Gorsameth wrote: If people are talking about it, even if off the record, then I would hope that its already underway and Russia already knows of it. If not then I hope these people are caught and prosecuted to the full extend of the law because they are literally killing people by talking. Russian sources were reporting the positions of these brigades for weeks as well as the increase of breakthrough attempts since the day before yesterday. Hard to hide large troop movements in this day and age. 82nd Air Assault brigade (the one with Marders/Challys) is still in reserve near Dniepropetrovsk, for example. Or at least was couple of weeks ago. Meanwhile Prigozhin returned to St.Petersburg, where Russia-Africa summit is held, reportedly to meet and discuss something with representatives of CAR, Mali and Niger. https://www.fontanka.ru/2023/07/27/72538025/ Guess Wagner is still on track in terms of African business. | ||
JimmiC
Canada22817 Posts
| ||
StasisField
United States1086 Posts
| ||
{CC}StealthBlue
United States41117 Posts
The African Union called today to urgently reinstate a United Nations-brokered deal allowing Ukraine to export millions of tons of grain that was terminated at Russia's behest. "The problem of grains and fertilizers concerns everyone," Comoros President Azali Assoumani, who heads the 55-nation African Union, told Russian state newswire RIA Novosti. He was speaking in St. Petersburg, where Russian President Vladimir Putin is hosting a summit with African leaders. Putin last week pulled out of the Black Sea Grain Initiative that had allowed Ukraine — one of the world's breadbaskets — to export grains and oilseeds through three Ukrainian ports on the Black Sea: Odesa, Chornomorsk and Yuzhny/Pivdenny. Russia, which has waged all-out war on Ukraine for 17 months, has since launched a series of air strikes against the country's port facilities and reimposed a maritime blockade — making countries that need to import food more reliant on Russia and increasing the risk that they will go hungry. "We will talk about this in St. Petersburg, we will discuss it with Putin to see how we can restart this agreement," Assoumani added. Putin is meeting with 17 African leaders on Thursday and Friday, as the increasingly isolated Russian leader attempts to maintain relations with a continent with close historical ties to Moscow. Source | ||
gobbledydook
Australia2593 Posts
Suppose next month the floodgates open, Ukraine takes back the land corridor, and the bad news is impossible to hide or explain away. What do we expect to happen? | ||
Sermokala
United States13750 Posts
On July 28 2023 13:32 gobbledydook wrote: What does a Russian defeat in Ukraine mean for Russians in Russia? Suppose next month the floodgates open, Ukraine takes back the land corridor, and the bad news is impossible to hide or explain away. What do we expect to happen? Saddam Hussain was able to hold onto power after losing Kuwait and the majority of his military power. I think things just move on like that afterword's. Their neighbors will be bitter but a weak, limping Russia is the best Russia for all other parties. I would expect NATO to offer to trade crimea in exchange for lifting the sanctions, with China stepping up to be the figurehead for getting this deal through. Ukraine will join NATO and the EU by some pathway and people will have to turn to figuring out how to survive climate change. Russia will become a chinese vassel state living off the scraps they can produce and their people will need to learn what its like to not be European anymore. | ||
Lmui
Canada6210 Posts
On July 28 2023 14:15 Sermokala wrote: Saddam Hussain was able to hold onto power after losing Kuwait and the majority of his military power. I think things just move on like that afterword's. Their neighbors will be bitter but a weak, limping Russia is the best Russia for all other parties. I would expect NATO to offer to trade crimea in exchange for lifting the sanctions, with China stepping up to be the figurehead for getting this deal through. Ukraine will join NATO and the EU by some pathway and people will have to turn to figuring out how to survive climate change. Russia will become a chinese vassel state living off the scraps they can produce and their people will need to learn what its like to not be European anymore. If Ukraine can push to the Black sea anywhere in the mainland I don't see Russia holding Crimea. Yeah there's a gigantic bottleneck, but if you down the Kerch bridge, have access to block off the water supply and have enough anti-ship weaponry to make sea based resupply hard, the attritional war is going to eventually go in Ukraines favor | ||
Yurie
11688 Posts
On July 28 2023 14:51 Lmui wrote: If Ukraine can push to the Black sea anywhere in the mainland I don't see Russia holding Crimea. Yeah there's a gigantic bottleneck, but if you down the Kerch bridge, have access to block off the water supply and have enough anti-ship weaponry to make sea based resupply hard, the attritional war is going to eventually go in Ukraines favor The risk is as always in the will to conduct the war. Both in Ukraine and in its allies. Crimea will likely take over a year to take even if you get everything else back. It will also be hard to hold Ukrainian borders with Russia since they aren't allowed to invade past them to logical defensive points, causing a massive drain on resources there as well. | ||
Simberto
Germany11339 Posts
On July 28 2023 13:32 gobbledydook wrote: What does a Russian defeat in Ukraine mean for Russians in Russia? Suppose next month the floodgates open, Ukraine takes back the land corridor, and the bad news is impossible to hide or explain away. What do we expect to happen? My (basically unfounded) guess: Not a lot immediately. No one will push into Russia, and no one will be able to, or actually try to, enforce war reparations. So the worst case for Russia is back to pre-2014 borders. Which doesn't actually effect the people in Russia at all. I expect sanctions to get removed pretty soon after the war is over, which might actually improve ther lives a bit. Regardless of the war ending or not, they will have to deal with their broken economy, which will be shitty for a lot of Russians. Of course, the political instability from Putin losing face is also interesting, but basically completely unpredictable. On the plus side, they will no longer be sent to Ukraine to die. | ||
Gorsameth
Netherlands21369 Posts
On July 28 2023 13:32 gobbledydook wrote: Absolutely nothing. What does a Russian defeat in Ukraine mean for Russians in Russia? Suppose next month the floodgates open, Ukraine takes back the land corridor, and the bad news is impossible to hide or explain away. What do we expect to happen? There is no will to resist in Russia, the people are not going to revolt or complain to loudly because then you get imprisoned. There will be no pressure from the people for peace because the people have no power. | ||
sertas
Sweden878 Posts
On July 28 2023 15:40 Gorsameth wrote: Absolutely nothing. There is no will to resist in Russia, the people are not going to revolt or complain to loudly because then you get imprisoned. There will be no pressure from the people for peace because the people have no power. Even if the people of Russia had power, they both like Putin and support the war so they would still not revolt. | ||
Harris1st
Germany6711 Posts
On July 28 2023 15:09 Yurie wrote: The risk is as always in the will to conduct the war. Both in Ukraine and in its allies. Crimea will likely take over a year to take even if you get everything else back. It will also be hard to hold Ukrainian borders with Russia since they aren't allowed to invade past them to logical defensive points, causing a massive drain on resources there as well. That is actually an interesting point: How far will Ukraine be pushing into Russia? Will they stop at exactly the old border stones? What is Western support gonna do if they push further in to secure their position? To take Crimea back they actually should push east to Rostow and then south to Krasnodar to encircle Crimea completely | ||
Magic Powers
Austria3709 Posts
On July 28 2023 17:16 Harris1st wrote: That is actually an interesting point: How far will Ukraine be pushing into Russia? Will they stop at exactly the old border stones? What is Western support gonna do if they push further in to secure their position? To take Crimea back they actually should push east to Rostow and then south to Krasnodar to encircle Crimea completely Putin won't send nukes just because one or two kilometers of motherland become a part of the active warzone. He may be a psychopath, but he's not stupid. You have to understand that he worries about staying in power above all else. If he sends nukes over a minor infraction, he'll be removed from office in an instant. There's only so much he can get away with before literally everyone around him agrees that he has to be assassinated. So nothing will happen. Putin will yell and threaten, but he won't do anything crazy as long as Ukrainian troops don't march deeper into Russia. Although I guess this doesn't directly answer the question. Ukraine will try not to push far into Russia. They'll secure only the areas that absolutely need to be secured, and they'll withdraw from them as soon as they can do so risk-free. | ||
RvB
Netherlands6191 Posts
On July 28 2023 15:40 Gorsameth wrote: Absolutely nothing. There is no will to resist in Russia, the people are not going to revolt or complain to loudly because then you get imprisoned. There will be no pressure from the people for peace because the people have no power. A coup against Putin does not have to come from the people. It can also come from some of the elite that has supported him up till now. Quite clearly the Russian people and army don't really care for Putin considering the ease at which Prigozhin could walk on Moscow. Putin's position is weak and losing the war wil only make it worse. | ||
| ||