Anime Discussion Thread - Page 1463

Prev 1 1461 1462 1463 1464 1465 6486 Next

If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg

For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net

Necrophantasia

Japan299 Posts

October 01 2011 07:52 GMT

#29241

On October 01 2011 14:08 Sentenal wrote:

Show nested quote +

You watched the show, and you aren't getting the joke??? What was Cure Moonlight's real name?

Also Sunshine sucked, reverse trap ftl. Marine was where it was at. Trolls are the best.

Oooooooohhhhhhhh. I was taking you too literally.

Meh. Reverse trap sucks, but in precure form dat twintails. Dat midriff!

Owned Noob

United States731 Posts

October 01 2011 08:14 GMT

#29242

Is the original FMA better or is brotherhood better? I want to watch the show, but i don't think i have the time to watch al one hundred or so episodes in a row. I'll probably end up watching the other show eventually, but which one is better to start with?

blahz0r

3030 Posts

October 01 2011 08:41 GMT

#29243

On October 01 2011 17:14 Owned Noob wrote:
Is the original FMA better or is brotherhood better? I want to watch the show, but i don't think i have the time to watch al one hundred or so episodes in a row. I'll probably end up watching the other show eventually, but which one is better to start with?

I liked brotherhood much more. The original's ending was stupid IMO.

[01:36:47] <wala> I unmounted everything
[01:36:51] <wala> now it's working
[01:36:53] <wala> wtf is this
[01:37:09] <wala> whatever as long as it installs who cares
[01:37:16] <wala> there has to be something wrong with my computer

What the... , how does that stuff happen to you all the time.

Shauni

4077 Posts

October 01 2011 09:35 GMT

#29244

On October 01 2011 12:26 Xahhk wrote:

Show nested quote +

Watch Monster. I can't think of anything else as well written and enjoyable as this.

Ahaha, your friend trolled you. Angel Beats and Bakamonogatari. Ahaha. Huge collection indeed.

Vaelone

Finland4400 Posts

October 01 2011 09:42 GMT

#29245

Brotherhood is better without doubt. Anyone that claims otherwise is just plain wrong.

Not going to go into details but lets just say that Brotherhood follows the manga unlike the original, Brotherhood provides an actual acceptable ending. It also has better art and has both cooler characters and more characters and the list goes on.

Latham

9590 Posts

October 01 2011 10:15 GMT

#29246

Brotherhood covers the whole manga from start to finish. FMA diverges at some point I forget which.

F/Z airs tonight in a few h!!! Let's hope for an awesome 1st ep. and a quick sub ^_^

MichaelEU

Netherlands816 Posts

October 01 2011 10:18 GMT

#29247

On October 01 2011 18:42 Vaelone wrote:

Show nested quote +

Anyone with a differing opinion is wrong, yes.

I liked both adaptations so just pick whatever. Really enjoyed the first movie. I even dropped Brotherhood because it didn't offer anything above the manga for me.

Zhasona

57 Posts

October 01 2011 11:22 GMT

#29248

On October 01 2011 19:15 Latham wrote:
Brotherhood covers the whole manga from start to finish. FMA diverges at some point I forget which.

F/Z airs tonight in a few h!!! Let's hope for an awesome 1st ep. and a quick sub ^_^

http://www.aniplex.co.jp/company/press110921_eng.html

Not going to wait for quick subs when they just simulcast with multi language subs.

Zergneedsfood

United States10671 Posts

October 01 2011 11:22 GMT

#29249

Over 20% of my posts are in here...

Too bad I barely post. D:

Blasterion

China10272 Posts

October 01 2011 12:05 GMT

#29250

Damn I post that much on ADT?

youngminii

Australia7514 Posts

October 01 2011 13:56 GMT

#29251

On October 01 2011 19:18 MichaelEU wrote:

Show nested quote +

I hated the movie.
I loved the first anime but Brotherhood makes a lot more sense in terms of story. I enjoyed the earlier single-episode story arcs of FMA though, which isn't available in Brotherhood.

zalz

Netherlands3704 Posts

October 01 2011 14:05 GMT

#29252

The first FMA anime is the better one. It's shorter and it knows more what direction it wants to go. Brotherhood suffers from an inability to keep tone.

I would always recommend you watch the first FMA anime just because it's more solidly constructed but that opinion gets quikly drowned out by the purists. For some reason:

Literal copy of manga > better production

But i suppose it's the same as with books. People that read them seem to have a peculiar need to justify their read through. They love the work so they love the author so they see any deviation from the plot to be akin to raping the author.

Vaelone

Finland4400 Posts

October 01 2011 14:24 GMT

#29253

Maybe I said too much, but regardless I preferred Brotherhood and I'm fairly confident that majority of people prefer it over the original.

Personally I just didn't see anything that would favour the original over Brotherhood. It's not that I didn't like the original back when it aired but Brotherhood just overshadowed it, given that I only started reading the manga as Brotherhood was airing.

I do generally think that works that follow the manga tend to be superior to the semi spin-offs.

DarthXX

Australia998 Posts

October 01 2011 14:29 GMT

#29254

On October 01 2011 23:05 zalz wrote:
The first FMA anime is the better one. It's shorter and it knows more what direction it wants to go. Brotherhood suffers from an inability to keep tone.

I would always recommend you watch the first FMA anime just because it's more solidly constructed but that opinion gets quikly drowned out by the purists. For some reason:

Literal copy of manga > better production

But i suppose it's the same as with books. People that read them seem to have a peculiar need to justify their read through. They love the work so they love the author so they see any deviation from the plot to be akin to raping the author.

Then there are people who like to go against the flow just because they think it's cool

As someone who never read the manga but watched both series I disagree, Brotherhood was a lot better for a few reasons.
-Action sequences were a lot better (eg Mustang actually blew shit up, and didn't get soaked/have his little circle cut up each time he was about to do something)
-Al wasn't only useful for being a shield for Ed when something exploded
-The supporting cast had a lot more depth to them, the original was very Ed heavy, which is fair I suppose since he is the MC but meh,
-Early episodes of Original are extremely drawn out.

I did think the original had a better ending though, but the way the plot got there didn't make too much sense and seemed quite forced.

Each series has its merits and I like them both, but Brotherhood is still the better between the two.

Blasterion

China10272 Posts

October 01 2011 14:47 GMT

#29255

Dammit Sent, I was accused of spamming >.<

Ferrose

United States11378 Posts

October 01 2011 16:10 GMT

#29256

On October 01 2011 14:39 Sentenal wrote:

Show nested quote +

Monster is good, I gave it an 8/10 on MAL. IMO, Monster's only problem is that it is paced kinda slow, but it makes up for it.

Posts in the Anime Discussion Thread, by Spazer:
+ Show Spoiler +

[01:39] <spazer> Ferrose 2123
[01:39] <spazer> Ecael 2034
[01:39] <spazer> Sentenal 1646
[01:39] <spazer> Spazer 1524
[01:39] <spazer> Blasterion 1457
[01:39] <spazer> Southlight 1401
[01:40] <spazer> that's how little I've posted
[01:40] <spazer> since #tladt
[01:40] <nagisama> you keep post counts for adt specifically!?
[01:40] <nagisama> wtf?
[01:40] <spazer> programs
[01:40] <KatejinaSama_> lololol
[01:40] <spazer> they are pretty cool things
[01:40] <KatejinaSama_> i drank a lot of rum
[01:40] <walawalawala> no nagisama, he counts every single post
[01:40] <KatejinaSama_> i'm tipsy
[01:40] <nagisama> hax T.T
[01:40] <AP0CALYPSE> lol
[01:40] <spazer> have you not seen the most bans thread lol
[01:40] <spazer> I hijacked that bitch
[01:40] <Sentenal> i didnt realise blasty was that high
[01:40] <KatejinaSama_> who wants to LoL
[01:40] <nagisama> i rarely visit the the other forums
[01:40] <KatejinaSama_> the
[01:41] <Sentenal> or that southlight was that low
[01:41] <KatejinaSama_> rooom is
[01:41] <spazer> he spams a lot sent
[01:41] <spazer> rofl
[01:41] <KatejinaSama_> spiwnning
[01:41] <spazer> southlight is low?
[01:41] <spazer> dude
[01:41] <spazer> gaoxi is next
[01:41] <spazer> with like
[01:41] <nagisama> is that under special forums or something?
[01:41] <spazer> 600ish
[01:41] <gAOxI> ?
[01:41] <gAOxI> whats that list?
[01:41] <Sentenal> southlight is alot lower than the top 2
[01:41] <spazer> post counts in adt
[01:41] <gAOxI> i have 600?
[01:41] <spazer> Gao Xi 616
[01:41] <spazer> konadora 603
[01:41] <spazer> tonight 576
[01:41] <spazer> Zergneedsfood 554
[01:41] <spazer> lol

TL;DR Version: Top 6 here are Ferrose/Ecael/Me/Spazer/Blasty/Southlight. Then there is a huge 800 post gap between Southlight and GaoXi.

Ecael and I are the only members of the 2k club. It feels so good being at the top, with him.

Latham

9590 Posts

October 01 2011 16:19 GMT

#29257

How do I fit in on that list? above 1K or below?

SkelA

Macedonia13085 Posts

October 01 2011 17:15 GMT

#29258

Hey guys so I was wondering if the manga TWGOK is good and kinda different from your usual harem manga ? The thing is TWGOK is probably great for your usual harem lover but harem genre is just so unapealing to me that I just skip everything that has that tag on it.

I despise the usual harem shows so much that I've only watched Ouran Host Club that i didnt find it that good and reading Nozoki Ana from the harem genre but I can see past it for obvious reasons

Emnjay808

United States10666 Posts

October 01 2011 17:23 GMT

#29259

On October 01 2011 18:35 Shauni wrote:

Show nested quote +

Ahaha, your friend trolled you. Angel Beats and Bakamonogatari. Ahaha. Huge collection indeed.

Imo, Bakemonogatari is great if ur looking for something different.

I would also recommend Ano Hana. http://myanimelist.net/anime/9989/Ano_Hi_Mita_Hana_no_Namae_wo_Bokutachi_wa_Mada_Shiranai

Please note: I only recently got into anime as of Fall 2010.

MichaelEU

Netherlands816 Posts

October 01 2011 17:40 GMT

#29260

On October 02 2011 02:15 SkelA wrote:
Hey guys so I was wondering if the manga TWGOK is good and kinda different from your usual harem manga ? The thing is TWGOK is probably great for your usual harem lover but harem genre is just so unapealing to me that I just skip everything that has that tag on it.

I despise the usual harem shows so much that I've only watched Ouran Host Club that i didnt find it that good and reading Nozoki Ana from the harem genre but I can see past it for obvious reasons

It's good, it's different from the usual harem manga but it's still a harem manga.

If I had to pinpoint why it's good/different/the same, it's because it feels like TWGOK has a lot more decisiveness in it. There's a clear goal in each of the stories and even the big arc it's in right now. Of course, that goal is clearing girls so it's still a harem manga.

Prev 1 1461 1462 1463 1464 1465 6486 Next

Please or register to reply.

Anime Discussion Thread - Page 1463

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming