|
Please keep this thread on topic. It's ok to discuss the professionalism of what happened, but don't turn this thread into personal attacks or it will be closed. |
On December 13 2011 23:50 mEatBucket wrote: I totally understand Nani and would probably do the same, myself I'd rather go out and get drunk rather than play useless games at that point. That game will do more for him then a couple hours of ''useless'' laddering.
|
On December 13 2011 23:42 Treziel wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:39 sereniity wrote:On December 13 2011 23:35 Treziel wrote:On December 13 2011 23:22 Derez wrote: The reasonable part of me would be happy if they booted him out of code S for this, the sadistic part of me wants him in there so I can see him get all-inned some more. Part of me makes me a bigger fan of all those players that do what they're supposed to. Haha this is great, I was also hoping GOM would strip him of code S but actually now you've said it it would be better if they left him in so the Koreans can pick up their freewins (they only allin him every game because they know he isn't good enough to stop it), he can throw another rage tantrum and leave Korea shamed and 0-14 in GSL (I believe he is 0-12 or 0-10 now). Wow... a big part of this community is fucking disgusting... The total blind fanboy bias of anyone that defends these kind of actions is the only thing that is fucking disgusting here, mate. Just so you know, I'd say the same if we were talking about a British (my nationality) player like DeMuslim or BlinG had done this. Maybe open up your eyes and see past your nationalism.
'Fucking disgusting'? Naniwa did a silly childish thing but all it is is impolite and inconsiderate; it's not the end of the world. Why the fuck would GOM strip him of Code S for one childish incident? Naniwa acts like a dick a fair amount of the time, but he's made it clear repeatedly that he cares only about winning. I can respect that, even if he has his glaring flaws.
Still a fan.
|
|
On December 13 2011 23:45 zidaneshead wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:36 quancer wrote:On December 13 2011 23:29 TheKefka wrote:On December 13 2011 23:26 colate wrote:On December 13 2011 23:07 oban wrote: The bullying towards Naniwa is disgusting. What a retarded, bandwagoning community this is. He threw a game that didn't mean anything. Get over it.
Pretty disgusting comment you made. We, the community, cares how our frontrunners act in korea. How the koreans think about the foreigners players as a whole. We want more foreigners in korea. Every step or actions affecting that relationship is important for the community - its something we care about. Just by looking at the twitter responses by the korean players and teams - the foreign scene got mocked. What irritates me is how people like you glorify the Koreans like they are the superior moral beings of this planet. The Koreans obviously approach esports like we do professional sports, and we approach esports as more of a game. I don't see how he ever said anything about them being more moral, but seeing as how the BW scene has thrived over there, and the professionality of how it's run in comparison to esports in the west, (minus a few countries like Sweden) we should try to take their lead. What really irritates me is how people like you seem to have some kind of inferiority complex/us vs. them mentality. Wise words. Maybe we shouldn't be singling out Naniwa, maybe this is more of a problem of how a lot of foreign players approach e-sports in general, as "games", because clearly other examples of players rage-quitting, giving up or throwing games have been cited here. I think everyone can agree that we ultimately want SC2 to have the notoriety of a professional sports, we want MLG to be the next NFL (maybe not right away, but eventually). Yet we still want to treat them as "games", and when we don't take what we do seriously we tend to not put max effort into them, and because of that results suffer. Obviously I'm not trying to insinuate that foreigners are "lazy" obviously there's a lot of them out there that are practicing their asses off and working hard to get better, but I just think it's more of a mentality issue that these kinds of occurrences are common or considered not a big deal. Part of the reason why mainstream sports are mainstream is because the league and the owners and the players respect the fan and the fact that it's their money that gives them the power to do what they love and get paid for it, and they make sure that the fans are rewarded for that. I think a lot of the Koreans understand that as well.
The thing is in mainstream sports (I'll use football since I know it best) there are governing bodies. FIFA is controlling all national associations. If you fuck up in league X you just cannot go over and play in league Y instead since your punished by FIFA (though suspensions dont necessarily have to be across leagues/tournaments, but the big bans will affect you everywhere). Also there's almost always an incentive to play good. End of the season - you're not in danger of relegation but also dont have a chance to advance to the international leagues. But your final standing is important for the TV money distribution (at least here in Germany). Place 10 gets more from the TV money pot than place 12. Also for the individual players there are often clauses in the contracts which are performance based. Score a goal? Get more money! Team is placing top10? Get more money! Of course the matches wont be seen as serious as the match for the championship, but still there are incentives to play.
So what do we need? The teams need those clauses in their contracts. "You may not forfeit a game or get fined". "If you win against a Code S player you get X$ bonus". Also the leagues need to form Kespa 2.0. If you do shit in MLG you cannot play in GSL or IEM or NASL or IPL. Hell even let the small tournaments / cups on board. I dont have a problem with Naniwa being punished (though I would dislike it since he didnt break any rules afaik) but I would have a problem with him being punished and the next time someone does something similiar in another tournament that player goes unpunished. "Oh he didnt do it in our tournament therefore we dont care". To get back to your point - such behaviour wouldnt show me that leagues/teams care about their fans - it would only show me that they care about themselves.
|
On December 13 2011 23:55 Giriath wrote:
It's up to GOM to provide us with entertaining matches. Not the players.
The tournament setup could be a lot better. BO1-matches, no losers-bracket. Results? Cheeses, risky strategies, all-ins et cetera.
|
|
I've lost all respect for naniwa, just forget about me nani, i know you don't know me but you broke my heart . Seriously though that is hilarious what he did and shit like this keeps it interesting. This whole spiel about being respectful to koreans is too funny, i mean really he threw a worthless game where he had a chance at winning if nestea 6 pooled. Kespa would have had a heart attack, but this is sc2.
|
From his interview with TL after the games:
"People are just hating because it's me who did it." -Naniwa
Sooo, soo true.
|
I really don't think it's important at all... There wasn't a chance of him advancing and the game meant nothing, he was upset that he lost and wanted to get out of there. Completely understandable if you ask me.
|
On December 13 2011 23:56 Alou wrote: Definitely wished he stayed and played. No excuse for not giving 100% all the time at that level in my opinion. :/
These are professional players, in it for the money. It's GOM's business to entertain, not theirs. If GOM wants to provide show matches, the players should get some compensation for their time.
|
On December 13 2011 23:58 CaptainTwig wrote:http://twitter.com/#!/oGsMCpossible someone could trans this please? l can only assume these long tweets are about this. Naniwa is mentioned in them yes, but google translate didn't make it much easier to understand.
|
Naniwas actions were childish and selfish.
He could only see how this game would (or would not) affect him in this exact moment.
One day he will come to realise he is only doing his own reputation harm and that all he had to do was swallow his pride and show a decent game to avoid looking like a spoilt child who did not get the toy they wanted.
|
On December 13 2011 23:55 Giriath wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:50 zidaneshead wrote:On December 13 2011 23:47 HMzK wrote: Every single nerd crying about this, are just selfish and they are killing esports. Gotta man up. One thumbs down from a swede and TL goes crazy. It is so retarded. Stop being selfish. The match was pointless for NANIWA, HE is what matters in the GSL not US, not FIRST however. SORRY. You're giving us as fans way too little credit. If we weren't around to watch Naniwa play, what value would he as a skilled Starcraft 2 player have? If it wasn't our money paying to watch GOM or MLG, if it wasn't our eyes that were watching these games being played, then where does the money in this sport come from? Advertisers paying for their ads to be watched by no one? Nope. Tournaments being run when no one shows up to watch them? Nope. A video game being created if no one is going to buy them? Nope. We as fans are the backbone of e-sports, so yes, when I pay to watch someone play, I expect those players to give me respect in kind and put on a good match. I don't think you'd enjoy a tournament where the pro players don't have anything to win, especially if they were all upset and not wanting to play; they wouldn't be good matches. It's up to GOM to provide us with entertaining matches. Not the players.
They have money to win because WE make sure they have money to win by paying for their product. That money in turn goes to Naniwa's pocket. He gets sponsors, he gets tournament winnings, he gets money just for PARTICIPATING not only because he's good at the game, but because we're there to front the dough and give the game and the players that play them attention.
I partly agree that GOM needs to provide a tournament format that doesn't allow for these extra matches to be played, but Naniwa, as a so-called Professional, has an obligation no matter what the format is. Instead of throwing matches, or complaining that a tournament is "a joke" in MLG's case, he should be playing with as much effort as he can. If that leads to a bad match, so be it.
|
On December 13 2011 23:53 Weemoed wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:51 mEatBucket wrote:On December 13 2011 23:50 Sneakyz wrote:On December 13 2011 23:42 Treziel wrote:On December 13 2011 23:39 sereniity wrote:On December 13 2011 23:35 Treziel wrote:On December 13 2011 23:22 Derez wrote: The reasonable part of me would be happy if they booted him out of code S for this, the sadistic part of me wants him in there so I can see him get all-inned some more. Part of me makes me a bigger fan of all those players that do what they're supposed to. Haha this is great, I was also hoping GOM would strip him of code S but actually now you've said it it would be better if they left him in so the Koreans can pick up their freewins (they only allin him every game because they know he isn't good enough to stop it), he can throw another rage tantrum and leave Korea shamed and 0-14 in GSL (I believe he is 0-12 or 0-10 now). Wow... a big part of this community is fucking disgusting... The total blind fanboy bias of anyone that defends these kind of actions is the only thing that is fucking disgusting here, mate. Just so you know, I'd say the same if we were talking about a British (my nationality) player like DeMuslim or BlinG had done this. Maybe open up your eyes and see past your nationalism. If you express nationalism in sweden people view you as a racist data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44632/446320620b2797481b98f0248bf47d03f83e2600" alt="" No they view you as a retard because odds is, you actually are. > Thinking nationalism is retarded. Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:50 Giriath wrote: I'd rather move on to the next match with something on the line than see two players half-ass in the middle of a serious tournament, because that's what happens when the format forces them to play with no chance of advancing. This.
It is massive douchebaggery from Naniwa actually because he knew Nestea wanted a rematch. He knew there was a rivalry going on. He had taunted Nestea in the interviews. And now it was time for a rematch. But Naniwa lacked the balls because he was getting owned left and right and he had everything to lose by being defeated by Nestea. Are people blowing this out of proportion? Yes. Is Naniwa a douchebag? Yes. Are you a douchebag if you say you stand by his actions? Yes.
The game was very meaningful.
|
On December 13 2011 23:46 colate wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:36 quancer wrote:On December 13 2011 23:29 TheKefka wrote:On December 13 2011 23:26 colate wrote:On December 13 2011 23:07 oban wrote: The bullying towards Naniwa is disgusting. What a retarded, bandwagoning community this is. He threw a game that didn't mean anything. Get over it.
Pretty disgusting comment you made. We, the community, cares how our frontrunners act in korea. How the koreans think about the foreigners players as a whole. We want more foreigners in korea. Every step or actions affecting that relationship is important for the community - its something we care about. Just by looking at the twitter responses by the korean players and teams - the foreign scene got mocked. What irritates me is how people like you glorify the Koreans like they are the superior moral beings of this planet. The Koreans obviously approach esports like we do professional sports, and we approach esports as more of a game. I don't see how he ever said anything about them being more moral, but seeing as how the BW scene has thrived over there, and the professionality of how it's run in comparison to esports in the west, we should try to take their lead. What really irritates me is how people like you seem to have some kind of inferiority complex/us vs. them mentality. ^ This pretty much sums up my opinion. Stop putting words into my mouth, TheKefka. I didn't mention anything about koreans being more moral beings than the foreigners. My focal point was, and still is, that NaNiwa is one of our front runners of the foreigner scene. Who doesn't want more foreigners in the korean teamhouses? Who doesn't want the foreigners to be able to compete with the koreans - by living there and competing in the GSL? NaNiwa isn't giving the foreigner scene the exposure they need. If NaNiwa actually won against the 3 times GSL champion Nestea on his turf. In front of the koreans. Now that would make an impact in the korean scene.
I didn't put anything into your mouth.Naniwa doesn't owe anything to you,to me,or any other foreigner.If teams really believe that Naniwa is hurting their image than they shouldn't have sent him there in the first place.Every team out there knows what Naniwa is like,get that into your heads people.If they don't know what a player is like and they make such a huge move as the one to send him across the globe to Korea than that team deserves to fail miserably as a professional establishment. Naniwa doesn't care what exposure and reputation the foreigners have in Korean eyes.All he cares about is if that W sits next to his name after a match.If you are expecting from Naniwa to be a ambassador of Esports than fucking LOL man.
|
On December 13 2011 23:56 Technique wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:50 mEatBucket wrote: I totally understand Nani and would probably do the same, myself I'd rather go out and get drunk rather than play useless games at that point. That game will do more for him then a couple hours of ''useless'' laddering.
I seriously doubt that, it was a BO1 anyway so it's pretty much the same as ladder. Even though I said I wouldn't waste my time because I'd go get drunk not go home and play ladder....
|
On December 13 2011 23:58 grobo wrote: From his interview with TL after the games:
"People are just hating because it's me who did it." -Naniwa
Sooo, soo true.
No. Imagine some other epic matchup. Leenock vs MVP or something, both down 0-3. And then one of them boxes workers and ggs. The community would be pissed, and koreans outraged.
|
On December 14 2011 00:00 Squeegy wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2011 23:53 Weemoed wrote:On December 13 2011 23:51 mEatBucket wrote:On December 13 2011 23:50 Sneakyz wrote:On December 13 2011 23:42 Treziel wrote:On December 13 2011 23:39 sereniity wrote:On December 13 2011 23:35 Treziel wrote:On December 13 2011 23:22 Derez wrote: The reasonable part of me would be happy if they booted him out of code S for this, the sadistic part of me wants him in there so I can see him get all-inned some more. Part of me makes me a bigger fan of all those players that do what they're supposed to. Haha this is great, I was also hoping GOM would strip him of code S but actually now you've said it it would be better if they left him in so the Koreans can pick up their freewins (they only allin him every game because they know he isn't good enough to stop it), he can throw another rage tantrum and leave Korea shamed and 0-14 in GSL (I believe he is 0-12 or 0-10 now). Wow... a big part of this community is fucking disgusting... The total blind fanboy bias of anyone that defends these kind of actions is the only thing that is fucking disgusting here, mate. Just so you know, I'd say the same if we were talking about a British (my nationality) player like DeMuslim or BlinG had done this. Maybe open up your eyes and see past your nationalism. If you express nationalism in sweden people view you as a racist data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44632/446320620b2797481b98f0248bf47d03f83e2600" alt="" No they view you as a retard because odds is, you actually are. > Thinking nationalism is retarded. On December 13 2011 23:50 Giriath wrote: I'd rather move on to the next match with something on the line than see two players half-ass in the middle of a serious tournament, because that's what happens when the format forces them to play with no chance of advancing. This. It is massive douchebaggery from Naniwa actually because he knew Nestea wanted a rematch. He knew there was a rivalry going on. He had taunted Nestea in the interviews. And now it was time for a rematch. But Naniwa lacked the balls because he was getting owned left and right and he had everything to lose by being defeated by Nestea. Are people blowing this out of proportion? Yes. Is Naniwa a douchebag? Yes. Are you a douchebag if you say you stand by his actions? Yes. The game was very meaningful.
Read this:
On December 13 2011 23:26 Liquid`Tyler wrote: The people who bought the HD Pass knew the format of the tournament and knew that it allowed for inconsequential games. Without the incentive of winning a tournament, progamers should not try to win. No one is good enough to waste their best effort on inconsequential games, especially with how many major tournaments there are nowadays. Whatever the best strategy Naniwa had in mind for the game, he should not use it. What irrational people want and expect is for the players to put on a false show of a competition, where they both seem to be trying enough for viewers to successfully suspend their disbelief. Such people don't constitute a significant enough part of the community to justify this huge reaction.
|
Rofl Naniwa is such a retard
|
oGsmc just posted several tweets regarding the situation. could someone get them translated properly? nvm I see it was done by Wax Angel in another thread
@oGsMC: I was really lost for words after watching today's game. Does he even know what the word "pro" is? My role model for professionalism is White-Ra. He really loves his fans, and doesn't give up his games until the end, and he's very mannered towards everyone. Does anyone dislike White-Ra?
I hope Naniwa can look at White-Ra and change his mentality. I don't think it's right to do that, not considering your opponent at all. I wish he'd think about how he would have felt if I had gone 3-0 and confirmed #1 in my group, and he was 0-3, and I thought that since I'm 1st place nothing matters and just GG'd out of my game against him.
Well, if you there's no big deal because there's no money on the the line, then I can't say anything to that, you're just not a pro. After seeing Naniwa, I thought HerO was all the more awesome for being so upset about losing his games yesterday.
@FXOChoya: [Can't believe] that kind of bastard is a pro-gamer.
|
|
|
|