Team Melee Mini Mafia - Page 27

1. Your first quoted post is decent. The first paragraph is a fair argument against what whoever suggested – I don’t think we should play any differently against 3 player teams from 2 player teams, especially because the 3 player teams are all a man down I think?
The bit I quoted above is an unnecessary statement, one of those “I’m here” posts that doesn’t say anything. It was early though, so I’ll give you a pass on that one. Also – plenty happens on the first day =D.

2. Your next post is really… meh. The first paragraph is pretty useless to me. The second paragraph: I for one disagree with Yellow, and favor your idea of a DT claiming Day 2 if they have red, else, day 3 with two green or a red/green. Good call for DTs to check actual reddish people.
Here’s why this post might be red to Yellow/others: well the first part is pretty useless, like I said. Bad town/mafia often have posts like that. The second paragraph, even if I agree with it, is pretty general/generic. Anyone can made commentary on a setup, and even they do it accurately, it’s not that bad for them (as mafia). What Yellow was screaming about was that you assumed there were all three power roles – DT, medic, RB, which suggests that you knew more than the rest of us. It’s suspicious, and it’s not something that you can apologize for. That kind of stuff goes on your permanent record, at least to me.

3. This next post is again, really general, and you’re talking about last game. It’s okay, but doesn’t contribute to your “townieness.” And posts like that, if they show up too often, end up being an indication of your scumminess. I also think that blues should try to stay alive. Better to be inactive than the mafia’s prime target simply because of posting. There are ~3 inactive teams right now and 2 half-inactive teams. That’s 1/2 of the teams – it’s a bigger crowd than the main posters.

4. Uhh. Next post like the 2nd post I think. A “correction,” but the same commentary applies.

5. This post is mostly useless tbh… I mean, Yellow would probably feel otherwise since it’s addressed to him, but all you’re really doing is defending against his accusations by saying that he’s accusing you solely because he disagrees with you, which is not the case, I don’t think.

6. This post is useless. You’re right, it’s pretty bad.

7. I considered pressuring you earlier, like I said before, but decided to go directly to Bill Murray and clear that up first. L’s comment wasn’t so much that there’s a lot to judge me and Ace by (although I have had multiple extremely long posts), but more that his fishing expedition was over.
Your second paragraph here says..nothing except that you’re admitting that you’re posting sucks? What?
Your third paragraph, you could listen to yourself. Post analysis >>> talk about game setup. Game plans are typically something that I don’t want to hear about for more than a few hours’ worth of posts in a 48 hour day. But yea, overall this post, not that great.

8. Hm. I’ve shared my thoughts on your day 4 lynch me scam, but I’ll repeat myself here: it’s scummy. There’s no weight in it, except what people decide to take from it. Actions-wise, no one’s going to be there to hold you accountable, assuming you’re still alive. So it’s a quick and easy ploy for you to get some fake credibility, to me.
Furthermore, your calls for “blues check me” is another thing that has no weight in it. By calling for something like that and assuming that you get the town to follow it, you take away all unpredictability that our blues (assuming we have any) have. Easy hit for the mafia tonight, no worries about medics that way. A great scheme for a scum to run. So this too is also scummy.

I don't think that BM's logic is off, his argument for YI was that his play in the current game and XXVII has differed among other things.

Uses the I'm-new-to-the-game card.



Proves he's new to mafia. Proposes to kill a yellow team. Nothing ground breaking



Useless post.



oooo, disagreement between the team. I do agree with this notion though to not vote for L but to vote for an inactive team.



What happened to voting for an inactive? Goes back to his original post to vote for BM's team

I can't seem to get a good read on him, his posts have so far been simple and easy to understand (probably because he doesn't have much to say). He doesn't seem to have a problem to publically show his disagreement with hi teammates.

Predicted role: undecided

I don't have much experience with mafia so I'm not sure if this quote is justified.


I agree with this to an extent. I believe he misinterpreted YI's argument.


Joke post, unless they're all mafia (including BM + Chez) I doubt this post holds any weight.


Nothing much here, further making fun of my mistake ;_;



Helps town translate (I for one have no idea what to do with the Di-dit crap).



I think it's a good way to spark discussion; accusing someone right at the beginning. I do agree however, accusing him from past game experience was pretty uncalled for (I wish YI would forget I almost caused the town to lose last game ^ ^;



??? I feel that they were just joking around and were not claiming medic day 1. I don't think this is a good move as there are inactive people to pressure ( like me ^ ^;; ).



I think the attacks on Jspazz was uncalled for. A random vote to spark discussion is quite solid.

His posts have mainly been defending himself - particularly for his initial accusation towards L. I read slightly pro town from him though he hasn't had much analysis and has thus far only attacked when provoked.

Some pretty solid analysis here especially on the morse code stuff and I agree with all of it.

The behavior from team 2 has been pretty random and I question whether any of it will help the town at all.


Just like Jspazz usually does, a defence post while trying to nail the other guy as well. I do agree with BrownBear here and I think he'll be very active and will be able to provide enough posts to get a good read on him. From this post alone, I'm willing to bet that he is a townie.

I however disagree with his dislike of the mass FoS, it allows better mafia players to be able to interpret them and be able to get good reads on the player.



First of all, I think it's important to note that he hasn't posted for 18 hours.

I do however agree with his suspicions for BM-Chez and L-Caller . And agree that actually killing team 7 is a bad idea even if they're inactive. I think the point of voting for them is just to apply pressure on them to post more, not to kill them outright.

I get a protown reading from him and I quite like his train of thought (I found it quite easy to follow). I sincerely hope he continues his posts

next time i'll just say, this is a random vote to start things off cause that was my real purpose of the vote/post
i think helping the town translate shows i'm leaning more pro-town than anti-town because if i was mafia, wouldn't i rather leave the lazy people who stay confused instead of translating the morse code for them?
it isn't really funny at all or helpful to the town to joke about being the medic. i totally agree with you that it's not a good move. i guess there are good things and bad things that can happen but the combination of their claim and posting history that makes me think it is a mafia ploy to lure out the medic instead of soaking a mafia hit. what if there are actually no medics in this game? then the mafia could potentially create a lot of confusion among the town by just not killing anyone.
there is a 50/50 chance that there is a medic in this game and if the mafia members are experienced enough to blend in well, then i think they would make this gambit.