yamato
town. just town. His early suspicion on thrawn doesn't look like a bus. Plus process of elimination (I already have one too many scummers lol)

kush explain this read, preferrably with quotes.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 05:02 GMT

#382

On January 05 2014 13:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

kush explain this read, preferrably with quotes.

yeah i can't find it now that I look for iit. Someone came out hard against thrawn d1, I remember. Must have been someone else though. im demoting him to null.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 05:09 GMT

#383

why is alaka town? can people answer that question for me?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

January 05 2014 05:09 GMT

#384

Like that's your only reason to think he is town and it's a thing that does not even exist..

raynpelikoneet

Finland43188 Posts

January 05 2014 05:09 GMT

#385

I've given my reasoning on D1 on Slam. Not totally sure he is town and need more posts from him especially now that we have flips.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 05:36 GMT

#386

i think i attributed a quote you said to yamato for some reason (probably because it was smart, burn)

cool rayne thanks for making me search through your filter

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 05:40 GMT

#387

This list is actually so bad.
First the slam thing. Just wrong. All he has done is appeared to be trying hard without actually doing anything.
CC - townish??? hes confirmed town due to being a vet...
sent - red??? how the fuck is the vet red?
kush - kush. not really since when he wrote that literally all i had posted so far was "catching up"

On January 05 2014 05:09 yamato77 wrote:
Slam - town

makes more sense and is playing better than anyone in the game.

Rayn - cop claim (probably town)

hard to see a world where scum rayn is this active and in the spotlight, but not impossible. Now that we assume there is a vig and have a vet claim, I will have to run through the possibilities.

CC - townish

protown, but I have some concerns (formerly stated), now vet claims, will have to scrutinize

thrawn - red

voting, low activity, typical scum thrawn (skill!)
ish

hammer on gumshoe, called me out for hilariously bad reasons, but is often weird to me

coag - null

?
hopeless - red

look at filter, lynch with fire (does not change much)

sent - redd

kush - kush

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 05:55 GMT

#388

that list looks like yamato didn't even read the game actually

Coagulation

United States9633 Posts

January 05 2014 06:58 GMT

#389

On January 04 2014 12:06 thrawn2112 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Here's the deal, I'm done talking about your claim for right now, so make what you will of it. Yes, I am straight up refusing to talk to you about this and you're just gonna have to deal with it.

so this exchange makes rayn look pretty solid town imo

[UoN]Sentinel is vig obv town

Yamato is playing piss poor and im leaning scum on him. Hes using pretty shit logic like

On January 05 2014 05:33 yamato77 wrote:
You would not lynch me before coag or kush in a game like this, don't be silly.

alakaslam has been lurker hunting the entire game and thats a red flag. scum like to focus on lurker discussion a lot. gonna fos on slam. likely scum.

Kush looks town to me so far. but that aint worth shit cause hes unreadable.

Mr. Cheesecake is vet. gonna assume its legit.

Hopeless1der sorta got a scum vibe but dunno. mostly null

and of course these reads come with the
[image loading]

yamato77

11589 Posts

January 05 2014 07:55 GMT

#390

I'll be catching up soon.

yamato77

11589 Posts

January 05 2014 07:59 GMT

#391

No one is confirmed town for claiming anything, for starters.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 08:06 GMT

#392

lol coag I'm so readable. You just haven't seen my scum game recently to know how bad it looks. but yeah coag looks pretty town and I agree with his reads.
yamato should be given time, obiviously.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 08:10 GMT

#393

On January 05 2014 16:59 yamato77 wrote:
No one is confirmed town for claiming anything, for starters.

did you read the game? because sent, rayn, cc are 100% confirmed and that's not even an opinion.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 05 2014 08:12 GMT

#394

yamato, reread alaka's filter and tell me about how he is the most townie player in this game

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

January 05 2014 08:21 GMT

#395

o.0

yamato77

11589 Posts

January 05 2014 08:29 GMT

#396

On January 05 2014 17:10 kushm4sta wrote:

Show nested quote +

did you read the game? because sent, rayn, cc are 100% confirmed and that's not even an opinion.

This is a bit silly. There's no conclusive evidence that any of their claims is 100% confirmed.

Of the three, I trust CC's the most. It's believable that scum wanted to let Rayn live because of how he played D1 (or that Rayn is possibly scum) and thus shot CC, who is a better player than Slam and the second towniest player behind him.

If I believe CC's claim, I kinda have to believe Sent's claim as well, considering the setup. There is a possible scenario where they are the last two mafia and intentionally did this, but I haven't enough reason to doubt my read on CC to believe in it yet. Sent seemed mafia-ish D1, but it's not enough to take a leap of faith.

Rayn's claim makes no sense as any alignment, so I'm basically ignoring the fact that he claimed altogether. There is NO WAY to confirm his claim yet and NO REASON to ignore him now because of it. He led the lynch D1, and has now basically just peaced out of any responsibility for how D2 goes. It's definitely possible that he was scumbuddies with thrawn and accused him D1.

That leaves Coag, you, and Hopeless as possible mafia, with AT LEAST ONE likely to be, POSSIBLY TWO, if Rayn is to be believed. The correct play would be to thus pick one of you three and lynch him, and I'm pretty sure I already said Hopeless is the scummiest.

By the way, the list was MOSTLY based off reads I made during the night phase. I have only just now begun to consider the implications of the claims seriously.