|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 01 2013 02:41 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2013 02:21 marvellosity wrote:On November 01 2013 02:15 Koshi wrote:On November 01 2013 02:09 HotCottonCandy wrote:On November 01 2013 02:01 Koshi wrote:On October 31 2013 09:59 HotCottonCandy wrote:
I honestly don't see anything egregious about Seuss' posting that makes me want to lynch him before a lot of other people. He just seems unsure of himself, I don't think that is scummy. Would scum purposely be that wishy-washy and avoid "important" discussion as you put it? I think that is more person indicative and not alignment. You still stand by this HCC? Because if Seuss is town, he must have been extremely clueless this game. There was nothing in his filter about that, it was all "I am a mathematician and an analyst, I know precisely what I am doing". You think I am over thinking his actions in my cases on him? Like his behavior around Oats/Me, Sentinel/WoS? @OatsYou didn't say anything about my cases on Seuss. At least Kush was honest. You don't have to spare my feelings. Yea I still think it's true but getting rid of null people isn't a worst case scenario, especially a replacement. If you guys want to change your mind and lynch anyone of sent/rayn/pandain/oats I would gladly do it tho. I have troubles believing rayn is scum. There are sentences I think he wouldn't use as scum.Oats I can totally lynch. I believe he is scum with Seuss. There are connections I simply can't ignore, and in the case Seuss is town he has a scumread on Oats so lynching Oats is fine. Also Clarity must really have believed in that Oats case so... Sentinel I don't know. I don't understand why 3p will use it's power so fast and what his wincon is. Pandain... You think he is scum now? Same level of confidence as your scumread on him in Thug life? Because rayn thinks he is town strangely enough. Could you give some examples and also explain why you think he wouldn't say them as mafia? Yeah... Hard to find them. I can't really quote them now and explain it.
But I think rayn will prove himself. And the reasons why you people say rayn is scum are pure meta. Give me examples where he is hardpushing bad lynches? His case on WoS was honest and not bad. You said so yourself instantly after he made it marv, you sheeped him. Sure, I though he would be mad after he came back and Clarity flipped town, (and I think he would flip town because I believe in Clarity his sincerity and honesty about not being scum, but WoS was also not looking scummy anymore and I wanted a switch), and then his lynch WoS wasn't going through. Just like in previous games in which he was mad then. But he came back before lynch and felt THE EXACT SAME THING WE ALL FELT, which was don't lynch WoS. So that isn't scummy at all and I don't understand why you want rayn to be a pushy fucker that only wants his lynch to go through or you give him a scumread...
This isn't very useful, you have insight into his alignment and I want to know what it is, "can't find them" and "he'll prove himself" isn't any insight that helps me at all.
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
Koshi, to your last paragraph, it's because I (perhaps unfairly) have the image of rayn of pushing his lynches like fuck around lynchtime come what may.
I agree it is not scummy to not want to lynch WoS in that situation. But the way he disappeared and left it to other people... well, I've discussed this, not going to rehash.
|
i am willing to concede its been possible ive been acting like a dumbass
|
On November 01 2013 02:43 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2013 02:41 Koshi wrote:On November 01 2013 02:21 marvellosity wrote:On November 01 2013 02:15 Koshi wrote:On November 01 2013 02:09 HotCottonCandy wrote:On November 01 2013 02:01 Koshi wrote:On October 31 2013 09:59 HotCottonCandy wrote:
I honestly don't see anything egregious about Seuss' posting that makes me want to lynch him before a lot of other people. He just seems unsure of himself, I don't think that is scummy. Would scum purposely be that wishy-washy and avoid "important" discussion as you put it? I think that is more person indicative and not alignment. You still stand by this HCC? Because if Seuss is town, he must have been extremely clueless this game. There was nothing in his filter about that, it was all "I am a mathematician and an analyst, I know precisely what I am doing". You think I am over thinking his actions in my cases on him? Like his behavior around Oats/Me, Sentinel/WoS? @OatsYou didn't say anything about my cases on Seuss. At least Kush was honest. You don't have to spare my feelings. Yea I still think it's true but getting rid of null people isn't a worst case scenario, especially a replacement. If you guys want to change your mind and lynch anyone of sent/rayn/pandain/oats I would gladly do it tho. I have troubles believing rayn is scum. There are sentences I think he wouldn't use as scum.Oats I can totally lynch. I believe he is scum with Seuss. There are connections I simply can't ignore, and in the case Seuss is town he has a scumread on Oats so lynching Oats is fine. Also Clarity must really have believed in that Oats case so... Sentinel I don't know. I don't understand why 3p will use it's power so fast and what his wincon is. Pandain... You think he is scum now? Same level of confidence as your scumread on him in Thug life? Because rayn thinks he is town strangely enough. Could you give some examples and also explain why you think he wouldn't say them as mafia? Yeah... Hard to find them. I can't really quote them now and explain it.
But I think rayn will prove himself. And the reasons why you people say rayn is scum are pure meta. Give me examples where he is hardpushing bad lynches? His case on WoS was honest and not bad. You said so yourself instantly after he made it marv, you sheeped him. Sure, I though he would be mad after he came back and Clarity flipped town, (and I think he would flip town because I believe in Clarity his sincerity and honesty about not being scum, but WoS was also not looking scummy anymore and I wanted a switch), and then his lynch WoS wasn't going through. Just like in previous games in which he was mad then. But he came back before lynch and felt THE EXACT SAME THING WE ALL FELT, which was don't lynch WoS. So that isn't scummy at all and I don't understand why you want rayn to be a pushy fucker that only wants his lynch to go through or you give him a scumread... This isn't very useful, you have insight into his alignment and I want to know what it is, "can't find them" and "he'll prove himself" isn't any insight that helps me at all.
Yes, I know. It's a bit sad. But I trust rayn to come here and make sure you know that he is town and otherwise we lynch.
|
On November 01 2013 03:11 OOHCHILD wrote:
i am willing to concede its been possible ive been acting like a dumbass
we waiting on dem fireworks.
|
On November 01 2013 03:18 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2013 03:11 OOHCHILD wrote:
i am willing to concede its been possible ive been acting like a dumbass we waiting on dem fireworks.
im just gonna read filters and try to figure out who scum is. d ont get your hopes up too much
|
can someone please share with me why sentinel isn't being lynched? anyone have a townread on him for any reason?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On November 01 2013 03:33 OOHCHILD wrote:
can someone please share with me why sentinel isn't being lynched? anyone have a townread on him for any reason?
This is what I said if you're interested:
On November 01 2013 01:37 marvellosity wrote:
Sentinel does fit the 3p bill, also I think we'll have a lot more information on his alignment when the nukes get used today, if any of them land, so it doesn't seem to be wise to lynch him right now. strongandbig was bang on with his meta analysis of Sentinel as well, he was much more serious in Noir than he has been in this game.
|
We are not lynching somebody who might be 3p or town. Is sentinel scum? The answer is not certain.
|
k that makes sense i guess
|
and is there an argument to clear promethelax?
|
Can you make a fucking case?
There is no argument against sentinel scum as well.
It's odds. Some people look scummier than others...
Everybody can be scum.
|
|
|
there was an argument against sentinel scum.. that being this doesn't look like his scum meta
|
the case making process doesn't even begin to start until after 10 pm est btw
|
On October 28 2013 23:49 strongandbig wrote:
Hey guys
I like promethelax and oatsmaster
Nothing as meta as Marv had (tho I don't disagree) but prome makes sense and his thread presence seems to be working towards a scumhunting-positive environment
Oats has way better SNR than I think he does as scum
Don't want to power up Marv yet and probably not at all today unless we decide to just power everybody, not bc I think he's scum but bc I can't trust a town read on him this early in the game unless he does something unintentionally telling, which he hasn't yet
Best case so far in the thread has been oatsmaster's case on pandaman, so weird.
I'm a belieber
##yolo Promethelax
##Refudiate Oatsmaster
What is SNR in this context?
|
United Kingdom36156 Posts
I didn't know either, but it's just come to me in a Eureka moment.
Signal to noise ratio.
|
what is the metacase in defense of prome?
|
Ok it 5 am I havent slept yet and my eyes cannot focus anymore, I will get like 4 hours of sleep the up eat and finish catching up. No plans at all tomorrow so should be caught up early and get in the game!!!
|
are you seriously going to read all 127 pages lol?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
