"##" Mafia - Page 126

On November 01 2013 01:36 Oatsmaster wrote:
Sure thanks for all these wonderful cases about me being scum. Such good play. Such townie play. Oohooh

On November 01 2013 01:37 marvellosity wrote:
Well, people seemed to think I was overstating my points on rayn. Koshi doesn't seem *that* interested, I'd expect him to be more interested if I were on to something. He might still be mafia, but I'm not sure enough on him to push anything like that at the moment, I'd rather give him time to display his true colours.

Sentinel does fit the 3p bill, also I think we'll have a lot more information on his alignment when the nukes get used today, if any of them land, so it doesn't seem to be wise to lynch him right now. strongandbig was bang on with his meta analysis of Sentinel as well, he was much more serious in Noir than he has been in this game.

On October 31 2013 23:33 strongandbig wrote:
##Twerk
Let me know if I got that wrong

Anyway I looked at sent again. I read his filter this game and his filter from noir where he was scum. No quotes cause on phone.

Filter this game feels very different from noir filter. Noir he was way more "srsbsns I'm makin reads guise". However, I can't decide whether that indicates an alignment difference or if it's just cause this game is a crazy themed game where he got a troll role from the hosts.

I'm still a little stuck on the stuff at the start of the game about not retweeting koshi, then doing Marv, then doing koshi anyway. It just all feels pretty over-done/under-explained, if that makes sense.

Also I kind of have a problem with him not really talking about anyone but kush and himself (and wos I guess). Like, the stuff in his case is mostly true - kush's actions were pretty much objectively scummy and terrible. But it's pretty convenient if sent's scum. But on the other hand, I know that can also happen to a townie under pressure, and judging by his noir filter it's not like tunneling is a scum tell for him.

In conclusion: Sentinel could very well be scum, and I would say he's higher on my scummy list than many others in this game, but I'm far from convinced.

On November 01 2013 01:39 Onegu wrote:
Lol I just got a PM I have a nuke, I will most likely not use it and let it expire. Still reading I put my son to sleep and showered and now power reading.

On November 01 2013 01:55 Promethelax wrote:
No you said the meta was right. Sent is playing dis-similarly to how he played previously as scum. He is also playing dis-similarly to how he has played as town. So is the meta conclusion 3P? Like I get that you agree that SnB is right about the meta change in Sent's play; I just don't get what you believe about Sent because of that.

On October 31 2013 09:59 HotCottonCandy wrote:
I honestly don't see anything egregious about Seuss' posting that makes me want to lynch him before a lot of other people. He just seems unsure of himself, I don't think that is scummy. Would scum purposely be that wishy-washy and avoid "important" discussion as you put it? I think that is more person indicative and not alignment.

On November 01 2013 02:01 Koshi wrote:

You still stand by this HCC? Because if Seuss is town, he must have been extremely clueless this game. There was nothing in his filter about that, it was all "I am a mathematician and an analyst, I know precisely what I am doing".

You think I am over thinking his actions in my cases on him?
Like his behavior around Oats/Me, Sentinel/WoS?



@Oats
You didn't say anything about my cases on Seuss. At least Kush was honest. You don't have to spare my feelings.

On November 01 2013 02:09 HotCottonCandy wrote:


Yea I still think it's true but getting rid of null people isn't a worst case scenario, especially a replacement. If you guys want to change your mind and lynch anyone of sent/rayn/pandain/oats I would gladly do it tho.

On November 01 2013 02:15 Koshi wrote:

I have troubles believing rayn is scum. There are sentences I think he wouldn't use as scum.

Oats I can totally lynch. I believe he is scum with Seuss. There are connections I simply can't ignore, and in the case Seuss is town he has a scumread on Oats so lynching Oats is fine. Also Clarity must really have believed in that Oats case so...

Sentinel I don't know. I don't understand why 3p will use it's power so fast and what his wincon is.

Pandain... You think he is scum now? Same level of confidence as your scumread on him in Thug life? Because rayn thinks he is town strangely enough.

On November 01 2013 01:31 Promethelax wrote:
So, Vayne's been tunneling Sent all game but hasn't actually pushed a lynch on him, this time is no different than earlier. He has been making cases and calling Sent scum but not pushing this lynch. Would be very happy with a lynch on Vayne.

On November 01 2013 02:21 marvellosity wrote:

Could you give some examples and also explain why you think he wouldn't say them as mafia?