Personality Mafia 2 - Page 45
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
HiroPro
United States2624 Posts
| ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On March 11 2013 07:25 wherebugsgo wrote: the man in the sky tells us the rat is not a rat but a mouse but the not-rat (actually a mouse) says he may be a mouse with a mask today and a rat tomorrow. "Today I die," the mouse says. And, he says, he will not tell us when he turns into a rat! Of course, any doorknob would know that a rat does not announce its own presence. So is this mouse a mouse under the bridge, or a mouse over the bridge? I say, brothers, that we burn the mouse and say our prayers, for it shall be safer for us if the mouse does not become rabid. So basically bugs, apart from being useless, it comes down to what we think of this post. Of course, any doorknob would know that a rat does not announce its own presence. Why, then, would a "rat" announce that he would turn into a rat at all? Why even mention it if you're a "rat"? There seems to be a logic breakdown. bugs is basically advocating lynching a townie on the basis he might not be town later. It's so *lazy*. | ||
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:03 Oatsmaster wrote: Wait wtf, how has BUGS DONE ANYTHING IN THIS GAME. Like how are you seeing scum bugs? Every other weird poster has been somewhat useful. even slOosh has been more useful than Bugs. Town bugs is useful. This bugs in not, and it bugs me. You seem to be applying for a position on my Panel. However, I am not convinced that you are a loyal constituent. Whereas other constituents have analyzed specific posts, specific lines, here is what you have done: On March 11 2013 13:34 Oatsmaster wrote: ##Unvote ##Vote: wherebugsgo WBG, can you start playing the game now that the 'rat' has died? Or are you intent on doing NOTHING? On March 11 2013 22:45 Oatsmaster wrote: VE VOTE FOR EVERYBODY!!!!!! I dont see why WBG doesnt have like 15 votes on him. How is he town"? On March 12 2013 01:03 Oatsmaster wrote: Wait wtf, how has BUGS DONE ANYTHING IN THIS GAME. Like how are you seeing scum bugs? Every other weird poster has been somewhat useful. even slOosh has been more useful than Bugs. Town bugs is useful. This bugs in not, and it bugs me. Quite the case, quite the analysis. You have made a couple D1 cases. You have accused a bunch of other people of not scumhunting, or doing this or that little thing. However, despite bouncing your vote around all over the place, you have it resting on a guy that you aren't saying much about. I think I like that you are attempting to sling mud at every possible person who could oppose me for mayor, but yet...there seems to be no method to your slinging. | ||
Vivax
21682 Posts
Doesn't look to me like suspicious townie rather like scum that doesn't mind switching his target to a guy that's basically grushlike as town and unknown as mafia since he was scared of pushing a guy who has been announced as town. | ||
Oatsmaster
United States16627 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:16 austinmcc wrote: You seem to be applying for a position on my Panel. However, I am not convinced that you are a loyal constituent. Whereas other constituents have analyzed specific posts, specific lines, here is what you have done: Quite the case, quite the analysis. You have made a couple D1 cases. You have accused a bunch of other people of not scumhunting, or doing this or that little thing. However, despite bouncing your vote around all over the place, you have it resting on a guy that you aren't saying much about. I think I like that you are attempting to sling mud at every possible person who could oppose me for mayor, but yet...there seems to be no method to your slinging. Um so how is that scummy? How am I supposed to make a case when all he says is LYNCH THE IMPOSTER/RAT/MOUSE ALL THE FUCKING TIME?? | ||
HiroPro
United States2624 Posts
| ||
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:11 HiroPro wrote: im on my phone so i cant quote so you guys will have to look at it yourself. There seems to be a lot of opposition to the Stutters lynch based on the fact that people think he always plays like this. Look ay the two games that people hacve brougght up. In both yet normal and lix hee offers explanations and makes reads. There is some level of effforty to engage with the thread. He may be inactive in those but he shows some level of intereest in what is going on. In this game has not offrred a single opinion on anyone beyond "hiro isnt traitor". I dont see any reasonkng for anthing he says or any genuine interest at all. Lynch this man. Read the travesty that was Themed. He didn't even post there from a certain point onwards, he just ninja-voted and was generally a very, very useless person. And that after MTG where he played okay, even by non-lurker standards. Policy lynching him is chill and all, but saying that he doesn't pull that shit as town is wrong. Why don't you go after a lurker that's actually guaranteed to be scum, namely Crossfire. | ||
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
I will continue to find people scummy who just disregard cryptic posts as useless. There are, at the very least, some thoughts in wbg's posts. See marv 's post above. See my post in response to snb yesterday, bugs had a somewhat neat post on how scum would be looking for targets, and why kurumi fit that bill. wbg looks scummy. I don't know how scum wbg responds to pressure, and if this is how he does so, then he should hang. But you are flinging mud everywhere, either to try and be useful OR to try and be active/point to your suspicions later when we lynch scum. Your mud has no weight behind it though. It is very thin, mostly water. It's pretty clear from other posts that you can read wbg's posts and get something out of them, his filter isn't entirely devoid of content. | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:18 Vivax wrote: Marv what do you make of Hiro? I don't see anything making me think he's town yet instead he seems to be sure that yamato's announcement meant Kurumi was confirmed town, wouldn't he doubt it at first since he's been pushing him as scumread just before? Doesn't look to me like suspicious townie rather like scum that doesn't mind switching his target to a guy that's basically grushlike as town and unknown as mafia since he was scared of pushing a guy who has been announced as town. Hiro's not really on my radar at the moment. He's not done anything to massively convince me he's town, but nothing to particularly make me think he's mafia either. He had the same reaction as I did to kita's announcement; without further evidence there is extremely little point lynching someone the host has announced as town. There are simply way more other viable targets - xfire, sloosh, prplhz, Stutters, corazon, bugs - for me to worry about Hiro right now. | ||
Oatsmaster
United States16627 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:24 austinmcc wrote: Don't read that as "you haven't made a case." Read it as "there ARE posts, even if you say wbg has done nothing." Yet you haven't looked at them at all. I will continue to find people scummy who just disregard cryptic posts as useless. There are, at the very least, some thoughts in wbg's posts. See marv 's post above. See my post in response to snb yesterday, bugs had a somewhat neat post on how scum would be looking for targets, and why kurumi fit that bill. wbg looks scummy. I don't know how scum wbg responds to pressure, and if this is how he does so, then he should hang. But you are flinging mud everywhere, either to try and be useful OR to try and be active/point to your suspicions later when we lynch scum. Your mud has no weight behind it though. It is very thin, mostly water. It's pretty clear from other posts that you can read wbg's posts and get something out of them, his filter isn't entirely devoid of content. So do you think Im scummy or not? Im confused at this point. If not me, then who is your top scum read. | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:24 Dandel Ion wrote: Read the travesty that was Themed. He didn't even post there from a certain point onwards, he just ninja-voted and was generally a very, very useless person. And that after MTG where he played okay, even by non-lurker standards. Policy lynching him is chill and all, but saying that he doesn't pull that shit as town is wrong. Why don't you go after a lurker that's actually guaranteed to be scum, namely Crossfire. twice now i've seen you use 'guaranteed'. Why is it guaranteed? | ||
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:26 marvellosity wrote: twice now i've seen you use 'guaranteed'. Why is it guaranteed? Because I deem him scum, so he is. | ||
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
| ||
HiroPro
United States2624 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:24 Dandel Ion wrote: Read the travesty that was Themed. He didn't even post there from a certain point onwards, he just ninja-voted and was generally a very, very useless person. And that after MTG where he played okay, even by non-lurker standards. Policy lynching him is chill and all, but saying that he doesn't pull that shit as town is wrong. Why don't you go after a lurker that's actually guaranteed to be scum, namely Crossfire. If yiu have some great reason thent ell me what it is because i have not see anything from you on why crossifire is mafia. Quote me posts please for stutters mtg it is such a pain to go through on my phone. | ||
Vivax
21682 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:23 HiroPro wrote: Are youa moron vivax? No I just think your play might be scum motivated so I'm inquiring. You only comment on few people and stutters has been one of my favourite choices to push early as scum in earlier games cause you don't have to do much. He doesn't reply quickly and has few posts without being very confrontative so it's a comfortable target to push as scum. Also no one sees much of a reason to defend him cause people don't know if he's town or not based on so little. But anyway just go on with it if you think it's the best course of action. | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:27 Dandel Ion wrote: Just sheep me. ... no. I did just go back and skim Stutters' filter in Themed by the way. Just like LIX there's evidence of critical thought that isn't in this game, e.g. On February 15 2013 05:44 Stutters695 wrote: After checking his full filter, what really concerns me is that he does it again (misusing meta). If he said I should be policy lynched because he doesn't like how I'm playing I'd totally understand that. But implying I'm scummy despite multiple games with me with similar d1 posting by me doesn't sit wellwhen combined with what I said about Marv and him. Other than those posts he doesn't say a whole lot. I'm leaning scum since all his other posts are calling people town and saying kurumi was scummy but never following through. I'd really like to hear his thoughts on who he'd lynch if I wasnt an option before I rush to judgement on him though since I've had people do this who were scum and town. Going through filters who really concerns me is Mr.CC. I cohosted one of his games and obsed the others and I don't think I've ever seen him this inactive. That feels like a really large change. I need to see if he has actually played any non-newbies but unless he shows up he'd be a good policy lynch. Still going through filters though, that just stood out as really off to me. | ||
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:28 HiroPro wrote: If yiu have some great reason thent ell me what it is because i have not see anything from you on why crossifire is mafia. Quote me posts please for stutters mtg it is such a pain to go through on my phone. No I won't play this game for you, sorry. | ||
HiroPro
United States2624 Posts
| ||
Stutters695
2610 Posts
| ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
On March 12 2013 01:30 Stutters695 wrote: Seriously guys I'm not scum. Last time xfire did this that I remember he was total scummers (MtGII), last time I did this I was still town. you've never done this. | ||
| ||