|
Poland3769 Posts
I noticed people find it entertaining to predict their top 10 for Stuchius list.
Well then - let's find out if we can figure out - as a community - the rest of the list:
Edit: Rain is missing, use "Someone else".
Poll: #10 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (18) 12% Dear (2) 1% herO (CJ herO) (12) 8% INnoVation (21) 14% Life (4) 3% MC (1) 1% MMA (4) 3% Mvp (8) 5% Nestea (8) 5% Parting (8) 5% Polt (8) 5% sOs (6) 4% Stephano (27) 18% Soulkey (5) 3% TaeJa (5) 3% Zest (9) 6% Someone else (7) 5% 153 total votes Your vote: #10 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #9 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (10) 10% Dear (0) 0% herO (CJ herO) (3) 3% INnoVation (7) 7% Life (0) 0% MC (2) 2% MMA (2) 2% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (8) 8% Parting (27) 28% Polt (3) 3% sOs (7) 7% Soulkey (4) 4% Stephano (6) 6% TaeJa (1) 1% Zest (11) 11% Someone else (5) 5% 98 total votes Your vote: #9 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #8 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (2) 2% Dear (1) 1% herO (CJ herO) (5) 5% INnoVation (22) 24% Life (1) 1% MC (2) 2% MMA (4) 4% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (4) 4% Parting (11) 12% Polt (9) 10% sOs (5) 5% Soulkey (3) 3% Stephano (3) 3% TaeJa (2) 2% Zest (11) 12% Someone else (6) 6% 93 total votes Your vote: #8 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #7 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (3) 3% Dear (0) 0% herO (CJ herO) (3) 3% INnoVation (21) 21% Life (1) 1% MC (5) 5% MMA (6) 6% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (14) 14% Parting (8) 8% Polt (9) 9% sOs (2) 2% Soulkey (4) 4% Stephano (3) 3% TaeJa (8) 8% Zest (8) 8% Someone else (2) 2% 99 total votes Your vote: #7 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #6 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (3) 3% Dear (1) 1% herO (CJ herO) (5) 5% INnoVation (4) 4% Life (2) 2% MC (5) 5% MMA (6) 6% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (13) 13% Parting (8) 8% Polt (27) 27% sOs (1) 1% Soulkey (1) 1% Stephano (4) 4% TaeJa (6) 6% Zest (9) 9% Someone else (3) 3% 100 total votes Your vote: #6 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #5 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (2) 2% Dear (0) 0% herO (CJ herO) (3) 3% INnoVation (2) 2% Life (3) 3% MC (7) 6% MMA (29) 25% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (27) 23% Parting (11) 9% Polt (6) 5% sOs (5) 4% Soulkey (0) 0% Stephano (4) 3% TaeJa (10) 9% Zest (3) 3% Someone else (2) 2% 116 total votes Your vote: #5 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #4 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (4) 3% Dear (0) 0% herO (CJ herO) (1) 1% INnoVation (4) 3% Life (3) 2% MC (32) 26% MMA (36) 29% Mvp (2) 2% Nestea (8) 7% Parting (3) 2% Polt (2) 2% sOs (1) 1% Soulkey (2) 2% Stephano (2) 2% TaeJa (20) 16% Zest (3) 2% Someone else (0) 0% 123 total votes Your vote: #4 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #3 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (2) 1% Dear (1) 1% herO (CJ herO) (2) 1% INnoVation (2) 1% Life (11) 8% MC (42) 30% MMA (7) 5% Mvp (6) 4% Nestea (6) 4% Parting (3) 2% Polt (2) 1% sOs (1) 1% Soulkey (0) 0% Stephano (4) 3% TaeJa (49) 35% Zest (4) 3% Someone else (0) 0% 142 total votes Your vote: #3 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #2 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (4) 3% Dear (0) 0% herO (CJ herO) (1) 1% INnoVation (0) 0% Life (89) 58% MC (10) 6% MMA (4) 3% Mvp (28) 18% Nestea (8) 5% Parting (2) 1% Polt (0) 0% sOs (2) 1% Soulkey (1) 1% Stephano (1) 1% TaeJa (4) 3% Zest (0) 0% Someone else (0) 0% 154 total votes Your vote: #2 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
Poll: #1 on stuchiu's GOATs list will beBomber (3) 2% Dear (1) 1% herO (CJ herO) (2) 1% INnoVation (0) 0% Life (34) 17% MC (0) 0% MMA (1) 1% Mvp (139) 71% Nestea (2) 1% Parting (3) 2% Polt (0) 0% sOs (2) 1% Soulkey (0) 0% Stephano (3) 2% TaeJa (4) 2% Zest (0) 0% Someone else (3) 2% 197 total votes Your vote: #1 on stuchiu's GOATs list will be (Vote): Bomber
(Vote): Dear
(Vote): herO (CJ herO)
(Vote): INnoVation
(Vote): Life
(Vote): MC
(Vote): MMA
(Vote): Mvp
(Vote): Nestea
(Vote): Parting
(Vote): Polt
(Vote): sOs
(Vote): Soulkey
(Vote): Stephano
(Vote): TaeJa
(Vote): Zest
(Vote): Someone else
|
Poland3769 Posts
I missed Rain in the lists :/
|
i will be mad if hero joins the top 10 instead of parting
|
Poland3769 Posts
Please vote Someone else if you want Rain somewhere. I think he will be top receiver of someone else's votes.
|
Poland3769 Posts
On April 13 2015 21:30 Paljas wrote:
i will be mad if hero joins the top 10 instead of parting
I don't see how herO > Parting so you're safe.
|
opterown
Australia54784 Posts
hey it's a poll thread =/
|
Poland3769 Posts
On April 13 2015 21:38 opterown wrote:
hey it's a poll thread =/
Yes. I imagine that will mean the thread will be shut down? The polls will live on.
|
how is soO not on this list?
|
Poland3769 Posts
|
United States97276 Posts
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th?
|
Poland3769 Posts
On April 13 2015 22:02 Shellshock wrote:
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th?
I guess because I missed that and I think he is in the running?
|
On April 13 2015 22:05 nimdil wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2015 22:02 Shellshock wrote:
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th? I guess because I missed that and I think he is in the running?
You fail the literacy test
|
I don't see how PartinG, herO, Dear or Stephano can be in top 15, especially given that sOs is #16. I think in all cases, looking at which three of TaeJa, Soulkey, INnoVation, Bomber and Rain are in the top 10 is the priority. There isn't room for all of them.
Mvp, Life, MC, Nestea, Zest and Polt are too hard to leave out, in my opinion. Note that these aren't my top six, just that the first four's achievements are unmatched, Zest's 2014 was very special, and Polt's longevity and ability to clutch tournaments is tremendous.
You could argue that TaeJa can't be left out. However, I have this feeling that TaeJa's lack of Korean results will see him miss out entirely. Bomber, on the other hand, dominated "Korean" international events and has the same longevity as Polt, albeit without the same highs early on (Super Tournament > Code A, even if their runs were comparable).
Two out of INnoVation, Rain and Soulkey being top ten with the other missing out leads me to believe that I have screwed up somewhere. INnoVation was ahead on dominance, Soulkey on consistency. All three players played a very pure and mechanical style of their respective races. I wouldn't leave any of them out but I don't see who else drops out. Maybe Polt or Bomber has to go, in which case I would keep Bomber. However, I don't think Polt and Bomber lose out to Leenock.
INnoVation has to be in the ten. He has played - by far - the most amazing games of 2013+. By this I mean that he and his opponent have met in a clash of styles, mechanics and mentality more often than any other player. Just check the Best Games threads and it was all INnoVation.
Soulkey and Rain is a toss up. It is such a toss up that I almost think stuchiu will throw another curve ball, maybe dumping MC for Rain.
|
On April 13 2015 22:54 metzninja wrote:
I don't see how PartinG, herO, Dear or Stephano can be in top 15, especially given that sOs is #16. I think in all cases, looking at which three of TaeJa, Soulkey, INnoVation, Bomber and Rain are in the top 10 is the priority. There isn't room for all of them.
Mvp, Life, MC, Nestea, Zest and Polt are too hard to leave out, in my opinion. Note that these aren't my top six, just that the first four's achievements are unmatched, Zest's 2014 was very special, and Polt's longevity and ability to clutch tournaments is tremendous.
You could argue that TaeJa can't be left out. However, I have this feeling that TaeJa's lack of Korean results will see him miss out entirely. Bomber, on the other hand, dominated "Korean" international events and has the same longevity as Polt, albeit without the same highs early on (Super Tournament > Code A, even if their runs were comparable).
Two out of INnoVation, Rain and Soulkey being top ten with the other missing out leads me to believe that I have screwed up somewhere. INnoVation was ahead on dominance, Soulkey on consistency. All three players played a very pure and mechanical style of their respective races. I wouldn't leave any of them out but I don't see who else drops out. Maybe Polt or Bomber has to go, in which case I would keep Bomber. However, I don't think Polt and Bomber lose out to Leenock.
INnoVation has to be in the ten. He has played - by far - the most amazing games of 2013+. By this I mean that he and his opponent have met in a clash of styles, mechanics and mentality more often than any other player. Just check the Best Games threads and it was all INnoVation.
Soulkey and Rain is a toss up. It is such a toss up that I almost think stuchiu will throw another curve ball, maybe dumping MC for Rain.
Parting Code S like 12-13 times in a row now? He's really really really good. Also he's been innovating new meta-changing strategies since early WoL.
8 min gateway rush vs terran, 3 Nexus 1 gate PvT, Soul Train, Mass Templar, Blink/Colossus
|
Poland3769 Posts
On April 13 2015 22:54 metzninja wrote:
Mvp, Life, MC, Nestea, Zest and Polt are too hard to leave out, in my opinion. Note that these aren't my top six, just that the first four's achievements are unmatched, Zest's 2014 was very special, and Polt's longevity and ability to clutch tournaments is tremendous.
MMA matched MC and Nestea, more or less, I easily put MMA between MC and Nestea and I'm still not sure if he shouldn't be #3.
|
MMA and MC have both achieved far more than nestea, if the cutoff was 2013 it would be a different story.
|
I dont know.... Still trying to cheer for third place Taeja 
|
Fiddler's Green42661 Posts
On April 13 2015 22:02 Shellshock wrote:
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th?
We need to test for literacy.
|
On April 14 2015 00:19 stuchiu wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2015 22:02 Shellshock wrote:
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th? We need to test for literacy.
Will you be going by these votes?
|
Fiddler's Green42661 Posts
On April 14 2015 00:23 OMGIMNestea wrote:Show nested quote +On April 14 2015 00:19 stuchiu wrote:On April 13 2015 22:02 Shellshock wrote:
why is sOs on any of these polls when it's already written in stuchiu's thread that sOs is 16th? We need to test for literacy. Will you be going by these votes?
Wouldnt that make it a Top 15 most popular players in SC2 list instead?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
