|
That is the question. Or is it a question at all? While Stimpack is considered to be the most important upgrade for Terran bio, one might wonder, is sacrificing HP to gain DPS always worth it? As LoneYoShi asked,
On August 22 2014 22:44 LoneYoShi wrote:
(might be stupid, but I want to make sure): is there a situation where it is better for a terran to not stim his bio units (extra health vs extra DPS) ? In all games, we see pro terrans always stim, but are there situations where this is the wrong choice ?
As it turns out, the question is not stupid at all, in fact very valid. To answer it, we once again use Lanchester's Square Law as a model. If you are not familiar with it, check it out here, otherwise the calculations below may be hard to follow.
Open the spoiler tag for detailed calculations of Stim effectiveness, or view in pdf here.
+ Show Spoiler +
TL;DR: The core idea is to calculate if the Marine/Marauder will trade better with Stim than without. We can do this calculation for an 55, 54, 53, ... HP Marine, and so we have a function of how "good" stimming is at different HP values. It turns out that there is almost always a point where using Stim actually hurts more than it helps, so it's not beneficial (well, except Marines vs. Thors). Where this point is depends on the upgrades and enemy unit type. At maximum health, though, it is always advisable to Use Stim, except against Banshees and DTs, appearently.
So there you have it, LoneYoShi  . As always, I am open to criticism, opinions and new ideas for new projects.
Check out my previous works as well:
+ Show Spoiler +
|
Terrans you heard it. DONT STIM
|
Stim doesn't just let your units have more dps, it also increases movement speed which makes kiting possible in an increased number of scenarios. Stimming bad vs banshees and dts? Not if they're running by a turret and will make it by if you don't stim.
How is this calculated btw? Is it one marine vs one of these other units?
|
Sweden33723 Posts
Why the distinction between ht archon and dt archon? Your posts are awesome and make me wish I had a stronger mathematical grounding.
|
I just hold down t, works for me.
|
On September 28 2014 01:32 -HuShang- wrote:
Stim doesn't just let your units have more dps, it also increases movement speed which makes kiting possible in an increased number of scenarios. Stimming bad vs banshees and dts? Not if they're running by a turret and will make it by if you don't stim.
How is this calculated btw? Is it one marine vs one of these other units?
Of course, but the effect of movement speed increase (which is obviously important) is neglected here. This calculation only focuses on battles with big unit numbers (and anyway, you are not likely to encounter 10+ Banshees or DTs). It is calculated as army vs. army, so not just one unit vs. one unit (see the calculation in the spoiler tags, though).
On September 28 2014 01:30 TheBloodyDwarf wrote:
Terrans you heard it. DONT STIM
Oh, no, you revealed that my plan is to secretly manipulate Terrans into not ever stimming and defeat everyone on the ladder...
|
|
|
|
|
On September 28 2014 01:34 Liquid`Jinro wrote:
Why the distinction between ht archon and dt archon? Your posts are awesome and make me wish I had a stronger mathematical grounding.
There is no difference, obviously. The reason they are treated separately is that the program I used to draw the plots and make the calculations was originally made for calculating cost-efficiency, and there it did matter what the Archon exactly cost. Thanks for the compliment, by the way, I am really honored.
|
stim mostly used for running, splitting the army and killing banelings.
edit: maybe next time you should look about bunker. if marines or marauders or hellbats or whatever the best is vs protoss all-in.
|
1001 YEARS KESPAJAIL22272 Posts
you should show this to flash, he apparently thinks stimming twice makes his marines stronger
|
Thanks for taking the time to answer my question ! <3
So there are indeed situations where stimming is bad. I'm always wondering if I should re-stim a second time or not when my units aren't fully healed (I tend to overstim a lot). Good to know there are situations where I shouldn't ! (marine vs marine fights in TvT for example) !
|
We used to say among friends:
- What to do if a Terran opponent presses T?
+ Type GG and out.
|
These mathematics don't take into account player skill and kiting micro allowed the by the increased speed of your units. In 99% of real SC2 games you will usually want to stim your marine/marauder.
|
From a pure mathematical and theorical point of view this looks awesome. I admire your math knowledge
|
You really deserve that Tl+ by now, have fun with it :D
( I would have bought you a beer but thats harder to do)
|
On September 28 2014 01:39 hellokitty[hk] wrote:
I just hold down t, works for me.
I once won against a terran because while his death force was marching into my natural and all i had was a tiny number of muta ling bling, but his T key got stuck so all his marines had 5 hp, and he lost the whole army
|
On September 28 2014 03:02 Tufas wrote:
You really deserve that Tl+ by now, have fun with it :D
( I would have bought you a beer but thats harder to do)
Thanks, man!
|
Another interesting topic!
|
It also depends on army ratio: If you got 50 marines vs a probe, I am pretty sure stimming is not worth it (well unless you need to stim a few to chase down the probe).
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/t4sxq7X.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/0RAF73X.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/OYU0Apc.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/fdmkba2.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/VrfbuZx.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/bYnopHB.jpg)
