• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 08:08
CEST 14:08
KST 21:08
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Code S Season 1 - RO12 Group A: Rogue, Percival, Solar, Zoun3[ASL21] Ro8 Preview Pt1: Inheritors15[ASL21] Ro16 Preview Pt2: All Star10Team Liquid Map Contest #22 - The Finalists19[ASL21] Ro16 Preview Pt1: Fresh Flow9
Community News
2026 GSL Season 1 Qualifiers24Maestros of the Game 2 announced92026 GSL Tour plans announced15Weekly Cups (April 6-12): herO doubles, "Villains" prevail1MaNa leaves Team Liquid25
StarCraft 2
General
Code S Season 1 - RO12 Group A: Rogue, Percival, Solar, Zoun Blizzard Classic Cup @ BlizzCon 2026 - $100k prize pool Team Liquid Map Contest #22 - The Finalists MaNa leaves Team Liquid Maestros of the Game 2 announced
Tourneys
2026 GSL Season 1 Qualifiers Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament INu's Battles#14 <BO.9 2Matches> GSL CK: More events planned pending crowdfunding RSL Revival: Season 5 - Qualifiers and Main Event
Strategy
Custom Maps
[D]RTS in all its shapes and glory <3 [A] Nemrods 1/4 players [M] (2) Frigid Storage
External Content
The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 523 Firewall Mutation # 522 Flip My Base Mutation # 521 Memorable Boss
Brood War
General
ASL21 General Discussion BW General Discussion Leta's ASL S21 Ro.16 review [ASL21] Ro8 Preview Pt1: Inheritors BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
[ASL21] Ro8 Day 2 [ASL21] Ro8 Day 1 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [ASL21] Ro16 Group D
Strategy
Fighting Spirit mining rates Simple Questions, Simple Answers What's the deal with APM & what's its true value Any training maps people recommend?
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Dawn of War IV Diablo IV Total Annihilation Server - TAForever
Dota 2
The Story of Wings Gaming
League of Legends
G2 just beat GenG in First stand
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
Vanilla Mini Mafia Mafia Game Mode Feedback/Ideas TL Mafia Community Thread Five o'clock TL Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread 3D technology/software discussion European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread Canadian Politics Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
The IdrA Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece [Req][Books] Good Fantasy/SciFi books Movie Discussion!
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion McBoner: A hockey love story
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
streaming software Strange computer issues (software) [G] How to Block Livestream Ads
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Sexual Health Of Gamers
TrAiDoS
lurker extra damage testi…
StaticNine
Broowar part 2
qwaykee
Funny Nicknames
LUCKY_NOOB
Iranian anarchists: organize…
XenOsky
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 2111 users

MLG statement on Providence Code S spot - Page 49

Forum Index > SC2 General
1158 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 47 48 49 50 51 58 Next
NHY
Profile Joined October 2010
1013 Posts
December 16 2011 14:17 GMT
#961
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.
hmsrenown
Profile Joined July 2010
Canada1263 Posts
December 16 2011 14:19 GMT
#962
On December 16 2011 23:10 jellyjello wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 22:44 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:37 jellyjello wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:36 Soma.bokforlag wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:18 jellyjello wrote:
blame game in this thread is epic. it's highly entertaining. what's funny is that neither MLG nor GOM cares; they had already moved on.


you really think that GOM doesnt care that half the international community think they have acted in a stupid way?

they wont give naniwa his code s-spot back, they acted in affect and to stand up and say "we were wrong, sorry" now is indeed impossible, but i find it highly unlikely they will act in this manner again.

i would even say it is unlikely gom will keep having meaningless games in their tournaments, in that way naniwa may have done a e-sports a great favor


Go ahead and keep on waiting for GOM's "apology". In the meanwhile, there will be more GSLs and GSTLs, and who knows even KeSPA might jump in the SC2 market, and you know what, people will watch it over and over again, period.

This is not to say who is right or wrong in this whole drama. All major parties involved in this incident already came out with each of their own official statement, and they are now moving on to the next thing on their agenda, because you know, esports is a business entity and they can't simply cling on to what had happened. I had my own opinions on the whole matter and I've stated them more than once. I've read all official statements from all parties and understood their positions. And now I've moved on too.

This is not the end of the world for Naniwa or GOM. Nani will be back for GSLs and GOM will provide it to him. Nani didn't do any favors for GOM. If anything, Nani was the catalyst that caused this whole shit storm drama. But what is done is done. Seriously, how many dead horses can we beat on? There are a lot of people here who have such unrealistic views on the topic such as demanding that GOM needs to come out clean (what?) and apologize (yeah right...). Who are you to demand an apology from GOM? Technically speaking, GOM doesn't owe you guys anything. If you don't like the way GOM is doing their business, then all you need to do is stop supporting their products. If you feel that you are cheated out of something, then it is in your own right to sue them.

Argh.

The problem with this situation, is that there is nothing to stop GOM from doing it again, unless they issue an apology, admitting fault is incredibly important, even if there are no legal repercussions. Presently, a precedent has been set; there is now nothing to stop them from cancelling an agreement with MLG, IEM, NASL, or any other party with which they make an agreement in the future, without informing them of the change!

Let's assume Naniwa did not probe rush Nestea, he played a straight up game and lost. There is nothing to say GSL weren't going to, or couldn't have turned around and said "you aren't getting a code S spot." Despite him, MLG, his team, his fans, and the entire foreign community thinking that he had already earned it!

If you don't see the problem with that, then there's nothing else I guess I can say that will help you realise what is so inherently and utterly wrong with that situation.


It doesn't work like that. Reputation is something that's dear to GOM (or any other major business organizations). I don't doubt for a second that GOM has learned from this incident.

I'm gonna be honest and say I doubt it. GOM not giving out bans to CoCa while rescinding Nani's spot for either unilateral action without informing players involved or stretching rules for the sole purpose of punishing a specific action. If that's not a double standard I don't know what is. To pile on the issue, MC's antics and Keen's celebration are brushed off as players expressing themselves without disrespecting the other players, a rule on which Nani was punished (or not!)...yeah right.

I'll see GOM's action before I believe in their "professionalism".

PS: Rescinding a spot or prize (as is the case here) is a big deal, Nani earned the spot through spectacular playing abilities, and he had it taken away for a borderline discipline issue not stipulated in the rules. Unacceptable.
yeint
Profile Joined May 2011
Estonia2329 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 14:23:02
December 16 2011 14:20 GMT
#963
On December 16 2011 23:13 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 22:32 yeint wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:05 yeint wrote:
On December 16 2011 21:57 NHY wrote:

The news article was not written after the tournament. It was written when NaNiwa made winners bracket final.

It seems that GOM didn't tell MLG specifically, but they did announce the change publicly.


Making the winners bracket final means he's the highest placing non-Code S player and that means he's earned Code S, no matter what. So they announced the change after Naniwa earned it.

Edit: The part where "it is within GSL's jurisdiction to adjust placement" is also the part of the agreement.


I'm not claiming they're not legally allowed to do what they did. I'm claiming what they did is incredibly unethical.


If you can't read the article because it is in Korean, then stop making assumptions. The article is about whether NaNiwa will be invited to GSL now that he is the highest non-code S player in Providence. It's not any kind of announcement. The announcement was a month ago.


The announcement a month ago didn't say a damn thing about GOM unilaterally ending the MLG/GSL exhange program, which explicitly stated that during all the 2011 pro circuit events, the highest placing non-Code S player would be awarded a Code S seed. All it said was that their format for code S was changing, and that format included two foreign seeds.


The so called agreement also states that 4 Koreans will be placed into Championsip Pool for all the 2011 pro circuit events. Where's your outrage at MLG for not keeping their exact word?


I already addressed this ridiculous point, but I'll do it again.

GOM doesn't care if 4 more Koreans get sent to the finals. It doesn't benefit them, it in fact hinders them by causing scheduling issues for players. Koreans being sent to MLG is the "What MLG wants" part of the deal. The "What GOM wants" part of the deal is getting foreign fan favorites seeded into Code S. Neither party represents actual players so they don't really give a shit who goes where, as long as viewer numbers increase.

Also, there is no championship pool at the finals. This was know from the start of the 2011 circuit.

4) He didn't earn it. What's the problem with saying that?


Because it's not true. The fact that GOM unilaterally decided they didn't feel like honoring the agreement that was made public doesn't mean they're not ethically bound to honor it. Naniwa, and everyone else, entered Providence with the knowledge that Code S seeding was part of the rewards offered. It was GOM's responsibility to publicize that this wasn't the case BEFORE the tournament, not make some statement in Korean once Naniwa was already in the finals.
Not supporting teams who take robber baron money.
Skyreaper
Profile Joined December 2011
70 Posts
December 16 2011 14:20 GMT
#964
On December 16 2011 23:17 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.

Wasn't this the original agreement on LxP? I'm really confused here.http://www.majorleaguegaming.com/news/mlg-and-the-gsl-create-groundbreaking-player-exchange-program
NHY
Profile Joined October 2010
1013 Posts
December 16 2011 14:21 GMT
#965
On December 16 2011 23:05 skipgamer wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 22:50 jianming wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:44 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:37 jellyjello wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:36 Soma.bokforlag wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:18 jellyjello wrote:
blame game in this thread is epic. it's highly entertaining. what's funny is that neither MLG nor GOM cares; they had already moved on.


you really think that GOM doesnt care that half the international community think they have acted in a stupid way?

they wont give naniwa his code s-spot back, they acted in affect and to stand up and say "we were wrong, sorry" now is indeed impossible, but i find it highly unlikely they will act in this manner again.

i would even say it is unlikely gom will keep having meaningless games in their tournaments, in that way naniwa may have done a e-sports a great favor


Go ahead and keep on waiting for GOM's "apology". In the meanwhile, there will be more GSLs and GSTLs, and who knows even KeSPA might jump in the SC2 market, and you know what, people will watch it over and over again, period.

This is not to say who is right or wrong in this whole drama. All major parties involved in this incident already came out with each of their own official statement, and they are now moving on to the next thing on their agenda, because you know, esports is a business entity and they can't simply cling on to what had happened. I had my own opinions on the whole matter and I've stated them more than once. I've read all official statements from all parties and understood their positions. And now I've moved on too.

This is not the end of the world for Naniwa or GOM. Nani will be back for GSLs and GOM will provide it to him. Nani didn't do any favors for GOM. If anything, Nani was the catalyst that caused this whole shit storm drama. But what is done is done. Seriously, how many dead horses can we beat on? There are a lot of people here who have such unrealistic views on the topic such as demanding that GOM needs to come out clean (what?) and apologize (yeah right...). Who are you to demand an apology from GOM? Technically speaking, GOM doesn't owe you guys anything. If you don't like the way GOM is doing their business, then all you need to do is stop supporting their products. If you feel that you are cheated out of something, then it is in your own right to sue them.

Argh.

The problem with this situation, is that there is nothing to stop GOM from doing it again, unless they issue an apology, admitting fault is incredibly important, even if there are no legal repercussions. Presently, a precedent has been set; there is now nothing to stop them from cancelling an agreement with MLG, IEM, NASL, or any other party with which they make an agreement in the future, without informing them of the change!

Let's assume Naniwa did not probe rush Nestea, he played a straight up game and lost. There is nothing to say GSL weren't going to, or couldn't have turned around and said "you aren't getting a code S spot." Despite him, MLG, his team, his fans, and the entire foreign community thinking that he had already earned it!

If you don't see the problem with that, then there's nothing else I guess I can say that will help you realise what is so inherently and utterly wrong with that situation.


Tighter contracts can prevent this from happening again. It looks liek MLG and GOM agreed beforehand that they could do things like that.

It's irrelevant if they agreed beforehand that they could do things like that. They didn't let the players know! MLG were advertising that a Code S seed was a part of the prize for the tournament, therefore a Code S seed WAS a part of the prize for the tournament!!!

Perhaps even the onus may be on MLG, but I really doubt it. I'm sure if they did have an agreement it would have stated that should any changes be made to the agreement it would have to be communicated!

To take a prize away from someone because they broke rules in an unprecedented manner is fine... To say they had never earned the prize in the first place is wrong!

(feel like I've come full circle on my opinion, at least I know some more facts about the situation, but still, there is a massive problem with how it all went down.)


You can't look at Code S seed in LxP as a prize given out by MLG. GOM is giving the seed to the player, not MLG.
NHY
Profile Joined October 2010
1013 Posts
December 16 2011 14:22 GMT
#966
On December 16 2011 23:20 Skyreaper wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.

Wasn't this the original agreement on LxP? I'm really confused here.http://www.majorleaguegaming.com/news/mlg-and-the-gsl-create-groundbreaking-player-exchange-program


That would be the press release version of it. An actual agreement would be 10 times longer.
skipgamer
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Australia701 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 14:28:27
December 16 2011 14:22 GMT
#967
On December 16 2011 23:22 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:20 Skyreaper wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.

Wasn't this the original agreement on LxP? I'm really confused here.http://www.majorleaguegaming.com/news/mlg-and-the-gsl-create-groundbreaking-player-exchange-program


That would be the press release version of it. An actual agreement would be 10 times longer.


^ wtf?

You're asking for something that only GOM and MLG would be privy to?

I think your opinions in this thread are now invalid.

On December 16 2011 23:25 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:22 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:22 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:20 Skyreaper wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.

Wasn't this the original agreement on LxP? I'm really confused here.http://www.majorleaguegaming.com/news/mlg-and-the-gsl-create-groundbreaking-player-exchange-program


That would be the press release version of it. An actual agreement would be 10 times longer.


^ wtf?

You're asking for something that only GOM and MLG would be privy to?

I think your opinions in this thread are now invalid.


Are you blind...? I didn't ask for it.


edit: My bad, I got you and Skyreaper confused. Sorry, there's a few conversations going on here


On December 16 2011 23:21 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:05 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:50 jianming wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:44 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:37 jellyjello wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:36 Soma.bokforlag wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:18 jellyjello wrote:
blame game in this thread is epic. it's highly entertaining. what's funny is that neither MLG nor GOM cares; they had already moved on.


you really think that GOM doesnt care that half the international community think they have acted in a stupid way?

they wont give naniwa his code s-spot back, they acted in affect and to stand up and say "we were wrong, sorry" now is indeed impossible, but i find it highly unlikely they will act in this manner again.

i would even say it is unlikely gom will keep having meaningless games in their tournaments, in that way naniwa may have done a e-sports a great favor


Go ahead and keep on waiting for GOM's "apology". In the meanwhile, there will be more GSLs and GSTLs, and who knows even KeSPA might jump in the SC2 market, and you know what, people will watch it over and over again, period.

This is not to say who is right or wrong in this whole drama. All major parties involved in this incident already came out with each of their own official statement, and they are now moving on to the next thing on their agenda, because you know, esports is a business entity and they can't simply cling on to what had happened. I had my own opinions on the whole matter and I've stated them more than once. I've read all official statements from all parties and understood their positions. And now I've moved on too.

This is not the end of the world for Naniwa or GOM. Nani will be back for GSLs and GOM will provide it to him. Nani didn't do any favors for GOM. If anything, Nani was the catalyst that caused this whole shit storm drama. But what is done is done. Seriously, how many dead horses can we beat on? There are a lot of people here who have such unrealistic views on the topic such as demanding that GOM needs to come out clean (what?) and apologize (yeah right...). Who are you to demand an apology from GOM? Technically speaking, GOM doesn't owe you guys anything. If you don't like the way GOM is doing their business, then all you need to do is stop supporting their products. If you feel that you are cheated out of something, then it is in your own right to sue them.

Argh.

The problem with this situation, is that there is nothing to stop GOM from doing it again, unless they issue an apology, admitting fault is incredibly important, even if there are no legal repercussions. Presently, a precedent has been set; there is now nothing to stop them from cancelling an agreement with MLG, IEM, NASL, or any other party with which they make an agreement in the future, without informing them of the change!

Let's assume Naniwa did not probe rush Nestea, he played a straight up game and lost. There is nothing to say GSL weren't going to, or couldn't have turned around and said "you aren't getting a code S spot." Despite him, MLG, his team, his fans, and the entire foreign community thinking that he had already earned it!

If you don't see the problem with that, then there's nothing else I guess I can say that will help you realise what is so inherently and utterly wrong with that situation.


Tighter contracts can prevent this from happening again. It looks liek MLG and GOM agreed beforehand that they could do things like that.

It's irrelevant if they agreed beforehand that they could do things like that. They didn't let the players know! MLG were advertising that a Code S seed was a part of the prize for the tournament, therefore a Code S seed WAS a part of the prize for the tournament!!!

Perhaps even the onus may be on MLG, but I really doubt it. I'm sure if they did have an agreement it would have stated that should any changes be made to the agreement it would have to be communicated!

To take a prize away from someone because they broke rules in an unprecedented manner is fine... To say they had never earned the prize in the first place is wrong!

(feel like I've come full circle on my opinion, at least I know some more facts about the situation, but still, there is a massive problem with how it all went down.)


You can't look at Code S seed in LxP as a prize given out by MLG. GOM is giving the seed to the player, not MLG.


But MLG is awarding the seed.

If I enter a qualifier tournament, that says if I earn top 3 I will enter a bigger tournament, I expect to be given entry to that bigger tournament. Regardless of who is actually running that bigger tournament. Either the qualifier, or the bigger tournament needs to be held accountable.
Fjodorov
Profile Joined December 2011
5007 Posts
December 16 2011 14:23 GMT
#968

3) Naniwa didn't earn Code S spot. Either GOM is lying about it, in which case you can't make case 2) or GOM is telling the truth, in which case Naniwa didn't earn Code S spot. We also don't know what GOM did since Providence. I don't know personally what conversation took place between NaNiwa and GOM but I'd imagine that GOM told NaNiwa that he was going to get Code S spot for the next season. And for NaNiwa, it would not have occured to him to ask if it was specifically because of MLG/GSL exchange.


Why would Naniwa have any reason to suspect MLG were wrong about the prize they say he won at their tournament? A player shows up to a tournament, performs well enough to get second place. Tournament organisation, along with casters etc, tells player he has won a prize. Is it weird that the player actually thinks he has won the prize?!

NHY
Profile Joined October 2010
1013 Posts
December 16 2011 14:24 GMT
#969
On December 16 2011 23:19 hmsrenown wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:10 jellyjello wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:44 skipgamer wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:37 jellyjello wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:36 Soma.bokforlag wrote:
On December 16 2011 20:18 jellyjello wrote:
blame game in this thread is epic. it's highly entertaining. what's funny is that neither MLG nor GOM cares; they had already moved on.


you really think that GOM doesnt care that half the international community think they have acted in a stupid way?

they wont give naniwa his code s-spot back, they acted in affect and to stand up and say "we were wrong, sorry" now is indeed impossible, but i find it highly unlikely they will act in this manner again.

i would even say it is unlikely gom will keep having meaningless games in their tournaments, in that way naniwa may have done a e-sports a great favor


Go ahead and keep on waiting for GOM's "apology". In the meanwhile, there will be more GSLs and GSTLs, and who knows even KeSPA might jump in the SC2 market, and you know what, people will watch it over and over again, period.

This is not to say who is right or wrong in this whole drama. All major parties involved in this incident already came out with each of their own official statement, and they are now moving on to the next thing on their agenda, because you know, esports is a business entity and they can't simply cling on to what had happened. I had my own opinions on the whole matter and I've stated them more than once. I've read all official statements from all parties and understood their positions. And now I've moved on too.

This is not the end of the world for Naniwa or GOM. Nani will be back for GSLs and GOM will provide it to him. Nani didn't do any favors for GOM. If anything, Nani was the catalyst that caused this whole shit storm drama. But what is done is done. Seriously, how many dead horses can we beat on? There are a lot of people here who have such unrealistic views on the topic such as demanding that GOM needs to come out clean (what?) and apologize (yeah right...). Who are you to demand an apology from GOM? Technically speaking, GOM doesn't owe you guys anything. If you don't like the way GOM is doing their business, then all you need to do is stop supporting their products. If you feel that you are cheated out of something, then it is in your own right to sue them.

Argh.

The problem with this situation, is that there is nothing to stop GOM from doing it again, unless they issue an apology, admitting fault is incredibly important, even if there are no legal repercussions. Presently, a precedent has been set; there is now nothing to stop them from cancelling an agreement with MLG, IEM, NASL, or any other party with which they make an agreement in the future, without informing them of the change!

Let's assume Naniwa did not probe rush Nestea, he played a straight up game and lost. There is nothing to say GSL weren't going to, or couldn't have turned around and said "you aren't getting a code S spot." Despite him, MLG, his team, his fans, and the entire foreign community thinking that he had already earned it!

If you don't see the problem with that, then there's nothing else I guess I can say that will help you realise what is so inherently and utterly wrong with that situation.


It doesn't work like that. Reputation is something that's dear to GOM (or any other major business organizations). I don't doubt for a second that GOM has learned from this incident.

I'm gonna be honest and say I doubt it. GOM not giving out bans to CoCa while rescinding Nani's spot for either unilateral action without informing players involved or stretching rules for the sole purpose of punishing a specific action. If that's not a double standard I don't know what is. To pile on the issue, MC's antics and Keen's celebration are brushed off as players expressing themselves without disrespecting the other players, a rule on which Nani was punished (or not!)...yeah right.

I'll see GOM's action before I believe in their "professionalism".

PS: Rescinding a spot or prize (as is the case here) is a big deal, Nani earned the spot through spectacular playing abilities, and he had it taken away for a borderline discipline issue not stipulated in the rules. Unacceptable.


You know what is and what isn't there for Code S seed agreement or GSL agreement?
NHY
Profile Joined October 2010
1013 Posts
December 16 2011 14:25 GMT
#970
On December 16 2011 23:22 skipgamer wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 23:22 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:20 Skyreaper wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 23:15 Skyreaper wrote:
Can some one give a link about official original agreement on LxP?


There isn't one online. There is a press release.

Wasn't this the original agreement on LxP? I'm really confused here.http://www.majorleaguegaming.com/news/mlg-and-the-gsl-create-groundbreaking-player-exchange-program


That would be the press release version of it. An actual agreement would be 10 times longer.


^ wtf?

You're asking for something that only GOM and MLG would be privy to?

I think your opinions in this thread are now invalid.


Are you blind...? I didn't ask for it.
hmsrenown
Profile Joined July 2010
Canada1263 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 14:28:56
December 16 2011 14:27 GMT
#971
On December 16 2011 23:13 NHY wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2011 22:32 yeint wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:17 NHY wrote:
On December 16 2011 22:05 yeint wrote:
On December 16 2011 21:57 NHY wrote:

The news article was not written after the tournament. It was written when NaNiwa made winners bracket final.

It seems that GOM didn't tell MLG specifically, but they did announce the change publicly.


Making the winners bracket final means he's the highest placing non-Code S player and that means he's earned Code S, no matter what. So they announced the change after Naniwa earned it.

Edit: The part where "it is within GSL's jurisdiction to adjust placement" is also the part of the agreement.


I'm not claiming they're not legally allowed to do what they did. I'm claiming what they did is incredibly unethical.


If you can't read the article because it is in Korean, then stop making assumptions. The article is about whether NaNiwa will be invited to GSL now that he is the highest non-code S player in Providence. It's not any kind of announcement. The announcement was a month ago.


The announcement a month ago didn't say a damn thing about GOM unilaterally ending the MLG/GSL exhange program, which explicitly stated that during all the 2011 pro circuit events, the highest placing non-Code S player would be awarded a Code S seed. All it said was that their format for code S was changing, and that format included two foreign seeds.


The so called agreement also states that 4 Koreans will be placed into Championsip Pool for all the 2011 pro circuit events. Where's your outrage at MLG for not keeping their exact word?

The format before the change had MLG seed and it was gone for 2012. Instead there were 2 sponsor seeds.

Show nested quote +
1) They entered a deal through which they publicly declared that Code S seeding was part of the prize package of the MLG 2011 Pro Circuit.
2) They then unilaterally reneged on that for Providence, without making any effort to communicate this to the involved parties, i.e. MLG and the Western esports scene.
3) They made a random comment about "we haven't decided" after Naniwa earned this prize, and then sat on it for almost a month, until Naniwa offended their sensibilities.
4) At this point they said he doesn't get the seed, and that he had never earned the seed in the first place.

That's what I think they did to be called unethical.


1) Nothing there
2) It is up to GOM to decide Code S seed in MLG/GSL exchange, so yeah it was unilateral. When GOM announced their new format it included the change to Code S seed. They could've communicated better, but miscommunication is hardly unethical unless you believe it was done so deliberately to deceive people.
3) Naniwa didn't earn Code S spot. Either GOM is lying about it, in which case you can't make case 2) or GOM is telling the truth, in which case Naniwa didn't earn Code S spot. We also don't know what GOM did since Providence. I don't know personally what conversation took place between NaNiwa and GOM but I'd imagine that GOM told NaNiwa that he was going to get Code S spot for the next season. And for NaNiwa, it would not have occured to him to ask if it was specifically because of MLG/GSL exchange.
4) He didn't earn it. What's the problem with saying that?

GOM's unofficial spokesperson?

Oh boy. MLG held up their end of the bargain. Providence has its unique format from the start of the season. It is impossible that GOM is not aware of the special format before or during negotiations.

The announcement on gomtv.net in October mentioned only Blizzard Cup and GSL format. Not a word on the official press release was about the source of the Code S players.

If such statement that specified the current "seeding" plan was published only in Korean, then it shows either gross negligence to contempt to both foreign players and spectators alike.
ScareCrow`
Profile Joined June 2011
Canada88 Posts
December 16 2011 14:27 GMT
#972
You're in a large room, with a divider between two different sections of it. You are here because you were told that there would be $5 dollars up for grabs for someone that attended. There is an announcement made that only one side of the divider gets to hear, stating that instead of $5 dollars you now receive a hat worth $5.

At the end of the day, someone from the side that didn't hear the announcement is chosen to be the lucky winner. He gets a $5 hat. He's confused.

It's not wrong that this hat was now the prize, but not informing everyone involved that the hat was the prize is disrespectful.
diehilde
Profile Joined September 2008
Germany1596 Posts
December 16 2011 14:29 GMT
#973
GOM fucked up big time and without a huge apology to nani and the foreign community I dont think theyll ever regain whatever respect they had before. Also, they should ban some of the korean pros, especially Choya for their twitter comments if they really mean it with their "players need to behave professionally" argument. I mean he called nani "bastard" on his twitter, if that isnt worse than 6 probe rushing I dont know what is. Right now its all too clear that all GOM cares about is their profits and nothing else.
Savior: "I will cheat everyone again in SC2!" - SCII Beta Tester
yeint
Profile Joined May 2011
Estonia2329 Posts
December 16 2011 14:29 GMT
#974
On December 16 2011 23:27 ScareCrow` wrote:
You're in a large room, with a divider between two different sections of it. You are here because you were told that there would be $5 dollars up for grabs for someone that attended. There is an announcement made that only one side of the divider gets to hear, stating that instead of $5 dollars you now receive a hat worth $5.

At the end of the day, someone from the side that didn't hear the announcement is chosen to be the lucky winner. He gets a $5 hat. He's confused.

It's not wrong that this hat was now the prize, but not informing everyone involved that the hat was the prize is disrespectful.


I think it's wrong that the hat was made the prize after people got in the room. Because, really, no one said anything about the hat until November 21st, and even then what they said was that they're still deciding between the five bucks and the hat.

(love your analogy though )
Not supporting teams who take robber baron money.
Skyreaper
Profile Joined December 2011
70 Posts
December 16 2011 14:30 GMT
#975
I really want to see a original agreement if the agreement clearly says that Providence was included or not. Because a manger from GOM twitted that Providence wasn't included
yeint
Profile Joined May 2011
Estonia2329 Posts
December 16 2011 14:31 GMT
#976
On December 16 2011 23:30 Skyreaper wrote:
I really want to see a original agreement if the agreement clearly says that Providence was included or not. Because a manger from GOM twitted that Providence wasn't included


And MLG's CEO said it was in an official statement.

I'll take that over what some random dude from GOM tweeted.
Not supporting teams who take robber baron money.
skipgamer
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Australia701 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-16 14:48:15
December 16 2011 14:32 GMT
#977
On December 16 2011 23:30 Skyreaper wrote:
I really want to see a original agreement if the agreement clearly says that Providence was included or not. Because a manger from GOM twitted that Providence wasn't included

Really???

Do you have a link to this tweet, or can you quote it?

Because that's really interesting... And finally explains the misunderstanding!

It turns this into a "he said"-"she said" argument (and will probably result in people taking sides), but still... It could wrap it up at least.


edit: eagerly awaiting the tweet. (and going through the thread incase it was already posted) It really will make sense to me why GOM didn't talk to MLG about the seed from providence if they thought it wasn't included in the League Exchange Program all along.

double-edit: Actually, wtf am I thinking... GOM have said they changed the seed to be for the Blizzard Cup, not GSL, so they obviously had planned for the League Exchange Program to include providence.

I dunno, screw this whole situation, I'm assuming it will never go resolved.

My confidence on the level of e-sports professionalism even on the highest tier has dropped tenfold. Mr Chae, Sundance, they really are just kids playing in a big sand lot at the end of the day.
Shardz
Profile Joined August 2010
United States349 Posts
December 16 2011 14:37 GMT
#978
I agree with Naniwa getting some kind of punishment, but the fact that MLG was not notified about it beforehand is pretty bad.
Oh Hi
Fjodorov
Profile Joined December 2011
5007 Posts
December 16 2011 14:39 GMT
#979
I really dont get why GOM just dont see how it would benefit them to make a statement and apologize to MLG and to the players attending MLG providence. They dont even have to mention Naniwa. Quantic gaming and Naniwa knew what had to be done and came out with an apology when they had offended ppl. Im pretty sure Naniwa doesnt think what he did was truly wrong but he realises he offended ppl and thus did the professional thing. Now GOM has offended lots of ppl and they fail to live up to professional standards.
TeeTS
Profile Joined June 2011
Germany2762 Posts
December 16 2011 14:53 GMT
#980
On December 16 2011 23:39 Fjodorov wrote:
I really dont get why GOM just dont see how it would benefit them to make a statement and apologize to MLG and to the players attending MLG providence. They dont even have to mention Naniwa. Quantic gaming and Naniwa knew what had to be done and came out with an apology when they had offended ppl. Im pretty sure Naniwa doesnt think what he did was truly wrong but he realises he offended ppl and thus did the professional thing. Now GOM has offended lots of ppl and they fail to live up to professional standards.


Well you should give GOM some time to evaluate the situation and come up with a statement, since it also took MLG several days to do so. But yeah, it's a communication error. The Information was there, but it wasn't presented well enough for everyone in the western scene to realise. So yeah, an apology would be nice.
Prev 1 47 48 49 50 51 58 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Kung Fu Cup
11:00
#6
IntoTheiNu 815
WardiTV390
Ryung 340
RotterdaM243
TKL 158
Liquipedia
Replay Cast
09:00
KungFu Cup 2026 Week 5
CranKy Ducklings83
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Ryung 340
RotterdaM 243
TKL 158
SortOf 119
Rex 77
StarCraft: Brood War
Jaedong 2639
Horang2 1827
Mini 881
BeSt 831
Hyuk 801
EffOrt 767
Soma 729
Killer 666
firebathero 437
Stork 387
[ Show more ]
Leta 346
Light 341
actioN 283
Zeus 204
Snow 187
Rush 128
ggaemo 115
Larva 111
ZerO 99
ToSsGirL 85
Hyun 85
PianO 81
Soulkey 66
Sea.KH 57
[sc1f]eonzerg 40
sSak 30
Free 25
Sexy 25
JulyZerg 25
Shinee 22
HiyA 21
soO 21
Barracks 19
Movie 17
yabsab 16
GoRush 15
Terrorterran 11
ajuk12(nOOB) 10
sorry 9
Sacsri 8
SilentControl 8
Icarus 7
Britney 0
Dota 2
XaKoH 536
XcaliburYe84
ODPixel83
Counter-Strike
olofmeister3001
zeus870
x6flipin360
Other Games
singsing1731
B2W.Neo303
crisheroes265
Lowko263
QueenE66
hiko45
ZerO(Twitch)2
Organizations
Dota 2
PGL Dota 2 - Main Stream234
StarCraft: Brood War
StarCastTV_EN76
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
[ Show 15 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• CranKy Ducklings SOOP42
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 1
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota229
League of Legends
• TFBlade1224
Other Games
• WagamamaTV273
Upcoming Events
PiGosaur Cup
11h 52m
GSL
21h 22m
Rogue vs Percival
Zoun vs Solar
Replay Cast
1d 11h
GSL
1d 21h
Cure vs TriGGeR
ByuN vs Bunny
The PondCast
1d 21h
KCM Race Survival
1d 21h
Replay Cast
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
Escore
2 days
OSC
3 days
[ Show More ]
Replay Cast
3 days
Replay Cast
3 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs Art_Of_Turtle
Radley vs TBD
BSL
4 days
Replay Cast
4 days
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
5 days
BSL
5 days
IPSL
5 days
eOnzErG vs TBD
G5 vs Nesh
Replay Cast
5 days
Wardi Open
5 days
Afreeca Starleague
5 days
Jaedong vs Light
Monday Night Weeklies
6 days
Replay Cast
6 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
6 days
Afreeca Starleague
6 days
Snow vs Flash
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Escore Tournament S2: W4
WardiTV TLMC #16
Nations Cup 2026

Ongoing

BSL Season 22
ASL Season 21
CSL 2026 SPRING (S20)
IPSL Spring 2026
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 2
StarCraft2 Community Team League 2026 Spring
IEM Rio 2026
PGL Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 1
BLAST Open Spring 2026
ESL Pro League S23 Finals
ESL Pro League S23 Stage 1&2
PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026

Upcoming

Escore Tournament S2: W5
KK 2v2 League Season 1
Acropolis #4
BSL 22 Non-Korean Championship
CSLAN 4
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
HSC XXIX
uThermal 2v2 2026 Main Event
Maestros of the Game 2
2026 GSL S2
RSL Revival: Season 5
2026 GSL S1
XSE Pro League 2026
IEM Cologne Major 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 2
CS Asia Championships 2026
Asian Champions League 2026
IEM Atlanta 2026
PGL Astana 2026
BLAST Rivals Spring 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.