| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
archonOOid
1983 Posts
if possible set up a winners/loosers interview through skype, phone line or chat to buy time it could be predetermined set of questions for the players to answer Something else that would be cool is to award the best game/player of the week Awards in general is something that energizes both player and spectators, more awards! | ||
|
Thorxes
United States119 Posts
On April 13 2011 21:39 Tofugrinder wrote: no current Starleague (GSL and TSL) does this for good reasons! They will never release the replays and that is good! It would be unfair to the players, there's no need for the entertainment and - in the other cases besides the nasl - the sponsors wouldnt like it. But true for all Starleagues: they want to make a great show - not just but some replay files online (you can search the net for thta anyways) NASL isn't GSL or TSL. So they don't have to do what the other leagues do. I don't understand what you mean by "there's no need for the entertainment". I specifically said that replays are NOT for entertainment. They're for learning from and making yourself a better player. Exactly what the SC2 community has always been about. If the NASL is confident about their production value, then releasing replays won't effect them in any way. | ||
|
Tofugrinder
Austria899 Posts
On April 13 2011 21:52 Thorxes wrote: NASL isn't GSL or TSL. So they don't have to do what the other leagues do. I don't understand what you mean by "there's no need for the entertainment". I specifically said that replays are NOT for entertainment. They're for learning from and making yourself a better player. Exactly what the SC2 community has always been about. If the NASL is confident about their production value, then releasing replays won't effect them in any way. well as i posted before, there is simply no reason to release the replays. It would just be unfair to the players. | ||
|
Axeinst
Belize281 Posts
On April 13 2011 21:57 Tofugrinder wrote: well as i posted before, there is simply no reason to release the replays. It would just be unfair to the players. Reason: to share information for all players to help everybody Also, replays have nothing substantial danger for competitors what live streams dont already show. In streams we already see what is the style of the players and general timings for things which is enough to know how to those players play. | ||
|
Tofugrinder
Austria899 Posts
On April 13 2011 22:04 Axeinst wrote: Reason: to share information for all players to help everybody Also, replays have nothing substantial danger for competitors what live streams dont already show. In streams we already see what is the style of the players and general timings for things which is enough to know how to those players play. the pros are putting a lot of effort into refining their builds until they are perfect. Sure everyone can figure out a baic build when watching the vods, but the little things are hard to notice when there are no replays released. Why should the pros work their asses of just so others can steal their builds without putting any time on refinement? Seems kinda unfair for me | ||
|
antilyon
Brazil2546 Posts
On April 13 2011 22:04 Axeinst wrote: Reason: to share information for all players to help everybody Also, replays have nothing substantial danger for competitors what live streams dont already show. In streams we already see what is the style of the players and general timings for things which is enough to know how to those players play. he point about not releasing replays is because it's extremely easy for any youtube caster download it, and cast it. | ||
|
Pri1230
United Kingdom148 Posts
On April 13 2011 21:39 Tofugrinder wrote: no current Starleague (GSL and TSL) does this for good reasons! They will never release the replays and that is good! It would be unfair to the players, there's no need for the entertainment and - in the other cases besides the nasl - the sponsors wouldnt like it. But true for all Starleagues: they want to make a great show - not just but some replay files online (you can search the net for thta anyways) You can get all GSL and TSL replays off SC2Reps, if NASL does decide to release the replays it would only do more good than harm, the more people that watch the replays and see the quality of the games the more likely they are to tune in to the live stream. | ||
|
Axeinst
Belize281 Posts
On April 13 2011 22:12 antilyon wrote: he point about not releasing replays is because it's extremely easy for any youtube caster download it, and cast it. Whats the problem? | ||
|
Phaded
Australia579 Posts
| ||
|
Trisket
United States4 Posts
The Set. The set looks fantastic; the matte finish feels so stylish. It ushered a professional feel right from the beginning. At first, I did feel like a tiny bit more color would be nice. The Casting. You can tell both casters have practiced up. Incontrol is obviously the rock upon which the commentary rests, but Gretorp has dramatically improved since Clash. Overall, a good mix of narrative and analysis. I'm actually looking forward to hearing more from the duo, which is crazy after Gretorp left such a poor first impression on me. I appreciated the jackets- losing the hoodie was a good choice. Also, proletariat. The Content. While some of the games were more entertaining than others (It was painful for everyone to see Battlenet rear its ugly head between Morrow and Rainbow), they did well to find a storyline behind every matchup. In my opinion, NASL sets the standard in this regard. The post-game interviews were a fantastic addition, and they worked well with the other vidoes, map fly-throughs, etc, to keep the production from feeling stale. The Early Game Split Screen. This is a fantastic idea, but it could have been executed better. I would love to see each caster pick 1 player to focus on in the early game so we could continue to see the builds unfold in both camps. This is largely the only criticism I have. Overall, I was in love with the production quality- you could even tell time was taken to find the perfect way to present the NASL/JustinTV/Facebook/Twitter overlay. A big, big thanks to everyone involved. TL;DR I agree that Gretorp still has improvements to make, but he's on the road to winning me over. Production quality was not lacking. Everything seemed to serve as a device to finding the story behind the games. 5 stars. | ||
|
rastaban
United States2294 Posts
From a financial stand point it can be very bad as they are making money from this. If say Day9 Or Husky started casting their games many players who are fans of theirs might skip the live show and favor the versions by the more well known casters which would reduce revenues and decrease the chance that they can have more tournaments in the future. | ||
|
Celadan
Norway471 Posts
I would much rather see stuff live rather than having to watch the Vods. I end up looking at the results instead of watching the games. | ||
|
Trisket
United States4 Posts
Indeed- Synonyms: absolutely, amen, certainly, doubtlessly, easily, in point of fact, in truth, naturally, of course, positively, really, strictly, sure thing, surely, assuredly, truly, undeniably, undoubtedly, verily, veritably, very, very much, well | ||
|
emazzuca
Canada33 Posts
On April 13 2011 22:24 Phaded wrote: 19. release multiple resolutions of the VODs. 1080p is great, but I'd like to watch it at 480/720p without having it stutter every 2 minutes due to buffering 1) this is a big one, i went to to watch a match this morning cause i got 5 emails from NASL, and it only linked me to the HD stream. and it kept stuttering, so i went to the NASL's site, and no videos were there, so clicked full schedule, and it just shows me who won the matchup anyway... so much for keeping that a secret. how am i suppose to watch the replays? where are they putting the videos? 2) i was getting pretty upset being in the dark, because they just kept the income tab open most of the game. 3) casters kept missing key points. 4) gretorp seems like a nice guy, and i will give him a chance, but i have my doubts 5) I Feel like there are just to many matches, i think i would rather one match instead of a best of 3 between each opponent this early. a potential of 15 (5*3) matches a night is to much. | ||
|
leviathan400
United Kingdom393 Posts
Need player/score title bar on screen allways. Should have NASL logo on screen allways in normal location (on right). Should have player country flags when showing detailed player info, we are trying to tell people more about the players and where they come from / represent is interesting. For the map analysis in the pregame show the 3D walkaround is good and all (and new  but I would love to see more of the traditional drawing on the map like I've see in OSL etc. The game/maps are still 2 dimensional so pointing out/marking chokes points and expansion paths would be great. Day9 has done this great before.Example: ![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/swanized/Maps/Montecristo_1.jpg) | ||
|
Thorxes
United States119 Posts
On April 13 2011 22:12 antilyon wrote: he point about not releasing replays is because it's extremely easy for any youtube caster download it, and cast it. If the NASL is confident about their production value, which they've been marketing from the start, then releasing replays won't effect them in any way. Youtube casters just won't have the same quality in production that NASL has. That's a big part of what you're paying for. | ||
|
DannyJ
United States5110 Posts
| ||
|
Uracil
Germany422 Posts
- music: more music | ||
|
Durantula
United States108 Posts
| ||
|
mechavoc
United States664 Posts
I could see other drops/fights happening on the mini map that were not shown. I remember in one match they were focusing on a small muta harass when a huge battle was going on in the middle of the map. Also it would be nice if they had a very quick segmant in the pre-game to go over what SC2 is (tried to get my wife into watching but she was lost). | ||
| ||
|
|
CSO Contender
Sparkling Tuna Cup
Online Event
Esports World Cup
ByuN vs Astrea
Lambo vs HeRoMaRinE
Clem vs TBD
Solar vs Zoun
SHIN vs Reynor
Maru vs TriGGeR
herO vs Lancer
Cure vs ShoWTimE
Esports World Cup
Esports World Cup
Esports World Cup
CranKy Ducklings
|
|
|
EPT
