EPTInterview with Code A caster KellyMilkies - Page 3
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Appendix
Sweden979 Posts
| ||
|
Krafty
Canada109 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:27 OptimusYale wrote: Starcraft 2 is coming out! Nerds: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, ROAR BROOD WARS IS WAY BETTER IM NOT GIVING SC2 TIME TO EVOLVE! New observer system in GSL NERDS: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, ROAR TASTELESS SHOULD HAVE THE OBSERVING RIGHTS BECAUSE ITS CHANGED AND WE DONT WANT TO GIVE IT TIME! New commentator who's a girl NERDS: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, IT SHOULD BE TASTELESS AND ARTOSIS CASTING 300 GAMES A DAY!!!! LETS NOT GIVE HER A CHANCE! Seriously nerds, life's going to change and you have to adapt. The reason your socially awkward is because you don't like change. She's good, her accent is a non issue, she commentates well. Remember how nervous you were on your first day of school, or your first day of work. Now put that in front of a huge international audience and you'll imagine how difficult it will be! Stop the whining and live with the change. She's better than the korean female commentator, and having a female speak in my ear makes me feel much less gay than listening than 2 guys all the time! Her knowledge is very good, her humor will get more natural as she settles down, her accent will become neutral in time, her english is perfect. To those who say it's not, have you ever taught people who are learning english as a second language? Their lexical choice is often disjointed and their grammar has minor inflectional errors. As a language major and an english grammar teacher, I would say shes better grammatically than I guess 70% of native english speakers because we change the grammar to be more conversational and often its wrong! well said, I agree 100% | ||
|
dan1mal
Netherlands86 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:20 happyness wrote: Have you seen the GLHF casters? They are 10 times worse. There are plenty of worse casters out there. She's not great, but not terrible either. I dont care if the GLHF casters are worse, they arent the one casting gsl... People who cast GSL need to be the best casters alive, as it is the best players alive playing aswell... | ||
|
Lokian
United States699 Posts
I think its the koreans you are referring to.. Observer was terrible but improved o.o I want to say new commentator girl needs time and is going to improve, but cant since those kind of things probably will take a long long time. | ||
Candide
456 Posts
| ||
|
ucbEntilZha
United States96 Posts
What I don't like from watching the first few games she has casted in GSL so far is the lack of analysis that there is now for Code A matches. In the Tastosis casting archon, Tasteless did a great job of keeping the viewer engaged about what was happening on screen and the general game play. Artosis complemented this very well by offering very deep game analysis and a fundamentally sound and excellent understanding of builds and general gameplay. The problem I have with Kelly is that now she and tasteless are filling the same role. Both casters are now more focused on the onscreen action rather than what the players are thinking and planning. Maybe she can improve, but it is hard to argue that she can match Artosis's understanding of the game | ||
|
Leeoku
1617 Posts
User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
Monasou
United States218 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:27 OptimusYale wrote: Seriously nerds, life's going to change and you have to adapt. The reason your socially awkward is because you don't like change. She's good, her accent is a non issue, she commentates well. Remember how nervous you were on your first day of school, or your first day of work. Now put that in front of a huge international audience and you'll imagine how difficult it will be! Stop the whining and live with the change. She's better than the korean female commentator, and having a female speak in my ear makes me feel much less gay than listening than 2 guys all the time! Her knowledge is very good, her humor will get more natural as she settles down, her accent will become neutral in time, her english is perfect. To those who say it's not, have you ever taught people who are learning english as a second language? Their lexical choice is often disjointed and their grammar has minor inflectional errors. As a language major and an english grammar teacher, I would say shes better grammatically than I guess 70% of native english speakers because we change the grammar to be more conversational and often its wrong! Very good plat player knowledge. I'm a plat player myself. Why am I not in that chair? Because I don't deserve it. Artosis is one of the best minds of SC2, him and tasteless were a perfect combination. What is the purpose of putting in someone that has less than, or limited knowledge compared to someone who has been there, and done that? The job is speaking. If you've got an accent, then you probably wouldn't want to get a job that focuses on displaying that. Why couldn't we fly JP or someone else down there? Not sure why GOM would chose a plat player/casted to do that job. I don't know. Why bench Artosis for newblood? | ||
|
VoltsShock
18 Posts
| ||
|
29 fps
United States5724 Posts
| ||
|
dan1mal
Netherlands86 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:27 OptimusYale wrote: Starcraft 2 is coming out! Nerds: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, ROAR BROOD WARS IS WAY BETTER IM NOT GIVING SC2 TIME TO EVOLVE! New observer system in GSL NERDS: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, ROAR TASTELESS SHOULD HAVE THE OBSERVING RIGHTS BECAUSE ITS CHANGED AND WE DONT WANT TO GIVE IT TIME! New commentator who's a girl NERDS: WE DONT LIKE CHANGE, IT SHOULD BE TASTELESS AND ARTOSIS CASTING 300 GAMES A DAY!!!! LETS NOT GIVE HER A CHANCE! Seriously nerds, life's going to change and you have to adapt. The reason your socially awkward is because you don't like change. She's good, her accent is a non issue, she commentates well. Remember how nervous you were on your first day of school, or your first day of work. Now put that in front of a huge international audience and you'll imagine how difficult it will be! Stop the whining and live with the change. She's better than the korean female commentator, and having a female speak in my ear makes me feel much less gay than listening than 2 guys all the time! Her knowledge is very good, her humor will get more natural as she settles down, her accent will become neutral in time, her english is perfect. To those who say it's not, have you ever taught people who are learning english as a second language? Their lexical choice is often disjointed and their grammar has minor inflectional errors. As a language major and an english grammar teacher, I would say shes better grammatically than I guess 70% of native english speakers because we change the grammar to be more conversational and often its wrong! Wow, nice stereo-typing bro.. Herp derp nerds.. Its retarded to think we are all socially akward shut-ins who just sit around shouting at wierd change -.-" There are also the educated among us, and there are also people who have good reasons not to like the new caster.. And that rediculously annoying highpitched voice is a legitimate reason to not like her. | ||
|
HackBenjamin
Canada1094 Posts
| ||
|
lfs
United States54 Posts
| ||
|
Nemireck
Canada1875 Posts
Her game-knowledge needs some serious work, but I think she's just supposed to be the caster anyway, and should be told to do less analysis, and more just telling us what's happening. It's really awkward having Tasteless and Kelly cast together because they both fill the same role, you really need someone like Artosis in the seat next to either of them to provide proper and accurate analysis of the game. | ||
|
ucbEntilZha
United States96 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:39 Monasou wrote: Very good plat player knowledge. I'm a plat player myself. Why am I not in that chair? Because I don't deserve it. Artosis is one of the best minds of SC2, him and tasteless were a perfect combination. What is the purpose of putting in someone that has less than, or limited knowledge compared to someone who has been there, and done that? The job is speaking. If you've got an accent, then you probably wouldn't want to get a job that focuses on displaying that. Why couldn't we fly JP or someone else down there? Not sure why GOM would chose a plat player/casted to do that job. I don't know. Why bench Artosis for newblood? I assume that it wasn't that they benched Artosis. Perhaps he is busy enough that he wanted more time for himself or just wanted more break. Casting every day for several hours for as many as 3 weeks in a row can be quite a drain I would imagine. I do agree though, as you would know from my previous post, that I prefer Artosis. It would be pretty cool if they flew like Day9 over for a little bit to have the ultimate casting duo. | ||
|
Monasou
United States218 Posts
On February 21 2011 19:41 dan1mal wrote: Wow, nice stereo-typing bro.. Herp derp nerds.. Its retarded to think we are all socially akward shut-ins who just sit around shouting at wierd change -.-" There are also the educated among us, and there are also people who have good reasons not to like the new caster.. And that rediculously annoying highpitched voice is a legitimate reason to not like her. WINNER WINNER. Last sentence. | ||
|
OptimusYale
Korea (South)1005 Posts
And what do you mean as a liberal, her grammar is equal to that of a native speaker if not better. And I say nerds and you flame me, tastosis say nerd and you take it as a compliment. I didn't mean it in a bad way but serious gamers tend to hate change more than any other gamer demographic! I think its because in the hardcore scene there is longer life on games, but you have to accept that at some point something has to change. You don't complain when John makes grammatical errors in the translations. It urks me at times when he makes silly small mistakes, but Kelly makes 0 and if you think she is making mistakes then you are mistaken. Anyway I'm pretty sure she has English as a native language, alas it's an official language of Singapore, and as far as I know its taught the same as US English, so chances are she just speaks with a different dialect/ accent, live with it, americans have different accents, allow the rest of the world to! | ||
|
SharkSpider
Canada606 Posts
| ||
|
kickinhead
Switzerland2069 Posts
| ||
|
RainWhisper
United Arab Emirates333 Posts
| ||
| ||
