Winter Warfare Mafia - Page 17

Honestly I really don't understand the Koshi kill. I thought Koshi was playing well and I don't think it's bad by any means, but in my interpretation of the situation that kill was marvellosity's 100% of the time, since he has been so involved and influential, and an involved marvellosity is as big of a threat as anyone. I have a hard time seeing marvellosity being mafia this game, if he is though this kill is a major indicator as to why. Part of me wonders if it really could be marvellosity + Palmar as mafia, it's not really what it looks like to me right now but it'd be worth looking into.

I could see one reason for keeping town!marvellosity alive and killing Koshi instead is if Palmar is mafia (or if mafia wanted to try and incriminate Palmar, but this is less likely). Koshi was coming down on Palmar pretty hard towards end of night, and marvellosity has been about as big of a Palmar supporter as there is.

This suggests to me that at least one of marvellosity and Palmar is mafia. I don't have any other reasons to support this, at least not yet, this is just night kill analysis. But I think it's worth keeping in mind.

(emphasis mine)
To me, this reads like she is saying Koshi is mafia. Her only previous post on Koshi is here:which doesn't sound very convinced. Not sure where such a confident scumread of Vivax comes from here?Too scummy to be scum feels like a very poor reason to doubt. But the notion of power roles playing differently is corroborated later. Not sure what to think.Then there's the questions about Palmar, this is the second time she brings this up. Part of it feels like an easy mafia play, bring up something suspicious but give a way to back out of it. Of course, I would never be guilty of anything like that Very interested how she follows up when Palmar's play is discussed later though, since she seems quite interested in Palmar.This wasn't the impression I got about her view on Palmar earlier but I don't think it's particularly scummy either so idk?

Then, probably most importantly, the vote for Vivax (yes, I pulled the previous Palmar quote ahead of this, thought it made sense even though it's technically not chronological). So I literally don't know why she thinks Vivax is mafia? There hasn't been a single reason given. That sends all kinds of alarm bells to me.This is the vote count after die_meatbaby's vote. I know others had expressed interest in lynching Vivax as well, sandroba and I voted for Vivax in the next few hours. Basically saying that the momentum is going towards Vivax's lynch, but it's not secured yet.

This is the first thing that really sticks out for me about die_meatbaby's filter. In my opinion, her vote on Vivax looks really bad. There is zero explanation and zero push, even when she votes her "explanation" is more defensive and doesn't seem to be encouraging anyone to want to lynch Vivax either. Even saying she has her own reasons but not sharing said reasons seems suspicious as all heck to me.

Then she is gone for about 24 hours and comes back with 2 hours to go before the lynch.She says she would vote for me or sandroba but still talks about Palmar. No reasons given why sandroba or I are suspicious.Says Chezinu looks suspicious post-Vivax flip, will see if there is followup. Another 24 hour or so break.
Here she kinda goes into why she wanted to lynch Vivax. The Vivax I remember can play a pretty good mafia game, doing things besides trolling, but maybe that hasn't been true in die_meatbaby's experience? Either way, it feels off to say that Vivax was mafia due to trolling because I don't think he was trolling, I wouldn't characterize his play that way at all.Meta dives, to be honest I have no idea what to make of this post. I don't know what she thinks about Palmar after reading the meta. She seems to be scumreading me instead of sandroba at this point, which is reasonable enough given her perspective, again just going to see how she follows it up. Still suspicious of Chezinu as well. Palmar seems like her top scumread from the possible scumteams post earlier, #1680.

Ends up voting for Chezinu instead of Palmar when Palmar was seemingly her biggest focus. This is the eighth (and final) vote on Chezinu.

To me, this screams like a bus and is the second main point I see in die_meatbaby's filter. She seems very confident here that Chezinu is mafia, see the last sentence of the above quote. But this doesn't really make sense to me from a town perspective for two reasons.
1 - Nothing changed since EoD1 to make her want to lynch Chezinu, except that that's the consensus lynch everyone else went for. Her reasoning was true as soon as Chezinu voted for Vivax and remained unchanged. Chezinu was suspicious but seemingly not her top scumread then, why did this change now? Except for that Chezinu became a major wagon.
2 - No protest against lynching Chezinu or wanting to lynch Palmar, who seems to be her top scumread. Suddenly Chezinu is just as likely to be mafia. This feels very suspicious to me.Emphasis mine, relevant sentence bolded. I get the reasoning but given her perspective going into this, it doesn't make sense at all to me.

Then she goes on to say I'm more likely mafia than sandroba. This really sticks out to me since it's post Chezinu flip, and she was using associations about Chezinu's vote making sandroba look really bad earlier. So why post-Chezinu flipping mafia would she lean towards ME being mafia and not sandroba, whereas she should be leaning towards sandroba being mafia more than me, given her position before the flip and how the flip should change her view?Okay, the word still is crucial here. For how long has Palmar been her top scumread? This reinforces the aforementioned point about the vote onto Chezinu.