[N] Uninspired Mafia
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On April 23 2019 04:39 MoosyDoosy wrote: do you guys still need someone? Yes | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On April 27 2019 08:22 Tumblewood wrote: /out because i am un cool I've always suspected. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I am interesting. Please pay attention to me. Thanks, Grackaroni. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
For the time I was alive he was town and I thought he was a pretty easy town read. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I had both the scum as my top scum reads so I was quite pleased. I think I can finally read Palmar. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Though I'm pretty sure you're fucking with me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 01 2019 09:07 Holyflare wrote: Not really the wrong idea just the wrong reasoning What's the right reasoning? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 01 2019 19:53 Koshi wrote: Grack rayn and hf are the pinnacle of uselessness. I'm going to take it as a compliment that I'm being grouped with HF and Rayn. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 02 2019 01:09 Pandain wrote: What's your read on me now Grack? And do you have any thoughts on Rayn, he's someone I'm watching eagerly. I don't have a read on you yet. I dislike like Rayn's WBG push because Rayn is smart and always tries to get inside player's heads and thinks about their mindsets behind their posts. I don't think WBG's repeated questions about incognitos guides and irrelevant things are a scum ploy to fly under the radar. I think he's just a bit of an odd-ball especially considering his reply to the incognito question. Also Rayn isn't really pushing his WBG scum read very hard when there's no content happening in thread... so actually I think that's pretty suspicious when thread is as dead as it is. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Other than that I'm basically stabbing in the dark. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I try to pick a new one every year. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 02 2019 04:56 raynpelikoneet wrote: hey mr. jock save yourself! Lol are you being Chezinu? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
If he's town then he should be able to show it. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 02 2019 05:11 raynpelikoneet wrote: Grackaroni do you have any idea why bugs reads you as town? I think he liked what I said about Jock. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + Thug life: 23 pages mafia - 1.13 don't think per page 21 don't think total 169 think 7.34 per page noir 19 pages mafia 0.78 per page 15 don't think 181 think 9.5 per page end of the world 9 pages mafia 1 per page don't think 57 think 6.3 per page time to die 30 pages town 1.35 per page 40 don't think 280 think 9.33 per page ##mafia 15 pages town 1.7 per page 26 don't think 159 think 10.6 per page | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I really like to get the point across that I'm thinking so that nobody else can doubt it. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 07:03 Holyflare wrote: literally the easiest game ever and they gave me the godfather for free Leaves lots of time for shit posting though | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
The worst that I could say against him is that he put more effort into debunking cases and defending people than pushing scum, but I still think he's in the townier half of town. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
WHY DIDN'T ANYONE ELSE MENTION THIS EARLIER. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 08:14 Holyflare wrote: Imagine being called confirmed town by the guy you red checked. Is this legit? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
So we lynched a townie and then lynched him as the cop. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 08:23 wherebugsgo wrote: who do you think is scum here? What do you think of BC talking with Rayn before deadline but not being here now? I think scum is just in MZ/FF/Rels with an off chance of HF. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 08:26 wherebugsgo wrote: HF can't be scum unless I flip VT. BTW, if I flip VT you all HAVE to lynch him, doesn't matter what he says, because you can't let him get away with a town fake claim. He'll eventually do it as scum. I don't think HF is scum trying to trade 1-1 for you. He's either cop or he's going to retract his claim. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I got a good feel from him earlier when he was spamming posts but he needs to pick up his game too. Sheeping his vote based on Rayn is shitty. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Yeah I think that was similar to Rayn claiming veteran. People do a lot of things like that at night these days. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
If he's actually vig then he can claim it and he was probably roleblocked shooting FF, but it makes no sense to claim before shooting as the actual vig when you will just get roleblocked if you aren't shooting town. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
BC's entry feels really townie to me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 09:53 VisceraEyes wrote: It's actually why I ended up playing video mafia as long as I did, that style meshes better with my style of playing the game - my posts are short and conversational. If I walk up to you on a street I'm not going to hand you a letter, I'm going to say "what's up". This game is meant to emulate that dynamic, medium notwithstanding. Anyway, rant over. I will never stop shit-posting, so long as I'm protected by the sub-forum by-laws that allow me to do so in the name of playing the game. You're in pretty good company. Especially now that Slam is in the game. Hijole! | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Grackaroni will solve it all. Atm I'm working on getting drunk in remembrance of Rayn. That's when the real brilliance comes in. Lucid I call it -- because that's a smart person word. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I'm here now and I'll read through but my gut reaction is that we should be lynching into a lurker right now rather than the most active players. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Holyflare's filter is super super townie. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
After rereading his filter I don't like that he makes such a hard turn into being super sure Vivax is the best lynch at the end of the day and tries to milk the credit for voting him for all that it's worth. Rayn put him in a spot where he pretty much had to vote Vivax but there wasn't much chance of Vivax actually dying at the end of the day when the only people posting were me/Pandain/Rayn. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I think Pandain really played up the end of the day vote after Rayn said he wanted to vote Vivax. This reads to me like: "now that I'm bussing I want to get as much credit as possible from the vote." On May 02 2019 04:50 Pandain wrote: I'm down to lynch vivax. Lets go? On May 02 2019 04:52 Pandain wrote: Vivax is a great lynch. He's always obvious town when he's town and super active. Compare that with this game where it is not obvious at all and he's barely contributed (but enough to "pass") On May 02 2019 04:53 Pandain wrote: Grack join the train. You know me and you are mafia bros. Let's lynch scum together. On May 02 2019 04:54 Pandain wrote: Who else is here? There's gotta be mafia lurking. On May 02 2019 04:57 Pandain wrote: Fuck I think Vivax was the best lynch actually. Where is everyone. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 02:40 BloodyC0bbler wrote: Yo grack. Why did you backtrack so quickly on I said that before I read through Pandain/Holyflare's filters. Now I think Pandain has a good chance of being scum. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 04:54 raynpelikoneet wrote: Vivax Wherebugsgo Pandain (Fecalfeast) VE is never mafia for anyone who will question it later. He is just too invested in teh game, i think that was the only unexplained read i had. Goodluck. Fwiw I bet Rayn had 2 of these reads right. I don't think he got killed just over Vivax. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 03:04 Holyflare wrote: Let's assume pandain is town. Really really have to stretch our imaginations but let's just pretend. Now let's also do something crazy and pretend bugs is the opposite alignment to what he is. What has koshi achieved other than complete apathy and small posts and almost 0 activity after vivax was modkilled? You think Pandain and WBG are not together though don't you? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 03:03 Pandain wrote: None of this is true. First of all I had a strong scum read on him, but it wasn't "certain" by any means . Second, Rayn didn't put me in any position and I'm not sure what this means at all. I could have easily not tried to change the lynch, or lynch bugs (Rayn top scum read), or just go afk. So this is completely false. Third, we had no idea how much chance there was. Normally end of day is very active and inactive people come back last 20 or so minutes. There were four non voters which us huge. Your end of day 1 posts read heavily to me like you knew Vivax would flip scum later in the game and wanted your vote on him to look good. You asked Rayn if he would switch to Rels. He said he the only vote he would switch to was Vivax. It would look really strange imo if you came out against lynching Vivax after expressing interest in switching up the vote, so I don't see you ever not voting Vivax as scum in that position. If you wanted a WBG lynch then conceivably you would have voted him already. For the third part, I think it was pretty clear from the game being 20 pages long and me/Rayn/you being the only ones there that there wasn't going to be a sudden urge of interest in the last ten minutes. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 03:15 VisceraEyes wrote: Not my case I was convinced. Bugs slash BC case Oh ok. From the last page I thought you were the leader. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 04 2019 12:17 wherebugsgo wrote: HF is the only person in the thread who has consistently managed to get a wagon going. Jock, myself, Pandain. On May 04 2019 12:24 BloodyC0bbler wrote: Question for you, then. Outside of fake claiming to kill you. Does he seem to be aggressively pushing targets right now? On May 04 2019 12:27 wherebugsgo wrote: He doesn't seem to be aggressive in pushing to me, no. I'd classify his play as opportunistic in this game. This is bullshit. Holyflare was the person pushing people the hardest outside of maybe Rayn and Bugs acknowledged that earlier unprompted.. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 03:40 Grackaroni wrote: This is bullshit. Holyflare was the person pushing people the hardest outside of maybe Rayn and Bugs acknowledged that earlier unprompted.. I don't understand how you can go from Holyflare is leading the thread to Holyflare isn't pushing people aggressively and is just opportunistic. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I don't like this lynch at all. BC's case was just that HF usually plays more aggressively as mafia, and that's definitely not the meta read that people like Rayn/Koshi would use to read HF who are both good players that play with HF frequently. I don't know why BC/WBG are the Holyflare experts when they haven't really played with him in years. I think HF's content has been good this game and I think that he has actually pushed his views aggressively. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 04:11 Holyflare wrote: Can people stop saying this like they know my meta. I can't think of a single game (maybe one but I'm not even sure if it's exactly one or not) in 100+ games where I have actually fake claimed a role as mafia but I can think of almost every game that I have as town. lol the last time you said this you linked me to a filter of your scum QT to prove it and in the QT you were like "I'm going to claim cop lolololol." | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Not sure I only read the QT. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 04:16 Holyflare wrote: Maybe it's worth it if the votes are close but they aren't really that close and who exactly is grack trying to convince? Likely mafia and some afkers. Hardly worth it if at all. MY POWERS OF PERSUASION COMPEL YOU. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 04:24 wherebugsgo wrote: grack I have a quiz for you. Can you guess HF's alignment in each of these posts? 1. 2. 3. Shit. #1 I'm pretty sure HF was town and Damerion was different but I think he was also town that game and that I totally called it too. #2 probably HF is town and I am mafia? It sounds a lot like I was mafia. #3 HF mafia? Tbh I probably played in all of these games and still could be wrong. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 04:35 wherebugsgo wrote: congratulations, you answered incorrectly. your prize for not knowing how to read HF is a ticket to get on this fucking lynch train and sheep the people who do What's the correct answer? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 04:41 wherebugsgo wrote: You were only incorrect about the second one, that's scumflare #1 is town vig, Heroes of the Storm killed n2 #2 is mafia vanilla, Generic Mini II lynched d4 #3 is mafia vanilla, Elementary Mafia survived d4 lol so he made me think that I was mafia. Pro plays. #1 I wasn't actually in so maybe Damerion was mafia. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 05 2019 05:11 Fecalfeast wrote: I knew it fuck lol how did you know it you voted HF. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 04 2019 12:18 BloodyC0bbler wrote: Now this leads the rub. Based purely on player activity (you can check filters) How the fuck between all the walls of text / posting has no one snagged real thread control / direction of the town. Why is the only real cases being made for the day. You and Pandain. Something to me feels wrong about it all. What was your thought process at this point when you said this? You were still scum reading Pandain and HF was the one who actually wrote a case on Pandain at the start of night 1. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 04 2019 11:58 BloodyC0bbler wrote: I know that HF posted this as a reason to vote for pandain. However with the mod confirmation of fixed 1 kp I am inclined to think this post alone would exonerate pandain. Why? Because if you have more information than the rest of the game (being mafia) you tend to be super careful in regards to talking about kp, being vague or what not. I don't see a player of pandains experience being mafia in this case. Fuck. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I think Koshi may be the best bet for mafia at this point. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 02 2019 09:09 wherebugsgo wrote: Pandain btw I can see wheeling around and calling me scum easily for this read. He “thinks” I am town so let’s wait and see how he reacts to that This post is very strange to me. All WBG did was include Pandain in his scum list and he's talking about how Pandain is going to change his read on him for it as scum. I can't recall ever seeing a townie say something like this. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + On May 02 2019 09:08 wherebugsgo wrote: MZ Pandain FF replace one with Vivax/Rels potentially. The problem with FF, Vivax, and Rels is that they are very hard to distinguish. Rels at this rate will get replaced and if the hosts follow their rules to the T Vivax should be replaced as well. iGrok also hasn’t posted so that’s a 20% possibility. I am more than 90% sure we have at least one scum between MZ Pandain and FF and I would give the chance of 2 at 50% or more | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 03 2019 01:07 wherebugsgo wrote: In before HF harps on something minor to misrepresent me, like "oh but you only talked about no lynch after you voted" or whatever noise he wants to push This is the characteristic HF scum meta btw. Not lack of aggression. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I guess I'm a slow reader. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 05:21 Pandain wrote: Good point, but it is convincing because there is a GF. Have there ever been games with a godfather or miller and no cop? Also the last mafia could very conceivably be a Framer, helping to counterbalance things. Yeah it happens pretty frequently actually. The standard balance that we used to use has been 13 person games with 2 blues, usually one defensive (vet/doc/JK) and one investigative (cop/vig) | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 05:23 VisceraEyes wrote: It was FF who was all about the shenannies yesterday right? If it was on to MZ then it was me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 06:13 Pandain wrote: I just want to note that Grack is a notorious shenanigan player, and I would not put it past him at all bussing both vivax and koshi even though I think it unlikely. :O | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 06:36 Pandain wrote: Grack what is your opinion on me and MZ? I don’t think you would have made your post about Koshi’s meta as scum. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Your shit reads super opportunistic to me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 08:36 wherebugsgo wrote: Yeah try and get me lynched motherfucker I dare you You called me town half the game up till now and from reading your filter you’ve tried your hardest to be on the right side of every flip Yeah or maybe I’m the only person in this game that actually knows how to read people. I’m already going to be lynched anyway. Now I can just put the rest of my time focusing on you and making sure that you are lynched next like HF and Rayn wanted. I think I’ve seen your true colors. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 08:38 wherebugsgo wrote: Idc how good you are as town, no way someone is 100% correct on every flip with barely any progression from “hmmm let me think about this person” to “oh I’m confident this dude is X”. You did that with Jock, BC, myself, rayn, HF, and only flipped a read on Koshi I didn’t have Rayn as town and HF was lynched on a terrible meta read | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 08:37 Pandain wrote: Do you really believe this? Do you believe that as scum because I expressed interest in lynching someone else I would have to lynch my mafia teammate because rayn said he would maybe switch to vivax? Yes I do. It wasn't the fact that you switched to Vivax. It was the way that you did it that read to me like you would look really good if he flipped later in the game and had extra information to make yourself look good later in the game. And I still think that it was very obvious that Vivax wasn't going to get lynched when it was just you me and Rayn and the thread was super short with half of town afk. I didn't really have my hopes up that the lynch was going to change at that point, I was just voting for the hell of it. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 08:52 wherebugsgo wrote: grack all you need to do to stop my tunnel on you is post every read you have in the game like you promised I literally stopped half-way reading through your filter when Koshi/BC got shot. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 08:57 Pandain wrote: That's not my question. You said that based on how the day went I was compelled to vote for Vivax. I had to. Really? Yeah I think so because you said you wanted to switch up the vote and do shenannies and Rayn was only ok with Vivax and WBG. Maybe you could have voted WBG but I assume if you wanted a WBG lynch you would have mentioned him to begin with. Vivax had a meh filter and it would look super weird to say, "I want to do shennannies with you but I don't want them to be on Vivax." | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Pandain - Town FF/MZ/Slam - null WBG - scum Reads list done. No reread necessary. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
If town loses the game I'm not taking the blame because BC suspected me and got shot. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 07:41 VisceraEyes wrote: Maybe I start spoiling Endgame every hour I don't hear from MEAPAK. Jokes on you I know absolutely nothing about the Avengers. Something about a Thanos. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 06 2019 09:31 VisceraEyes wrote: Bugs is clear, Grack try again Why is Bugs clear? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 11:43 VisceraEyes wrote: Like yes, Pandain said Koshi was super strong town that one time, but then look at all of this, AFTER the GF flipped... + Show Spoiler [There's quite a bit] + On May 05 2019 05:07 Pandain wrote: Yes time to go into lurkers. Almost certain last two scum is within slam, koshi, FF, and MZ On May 05 2019 22:26 Pandain wrote: Koshi is also a great lynch as well. Completely useless filter and hasn't pushed anyone ever. Has commented on some posts and that's it. On May 05 2019 22:48 Pandain wrote: It's just even if he's busy his posts just are complete trash. Compare them with last couple times he's been town. tl.net tl.net In comparison, it's a lot more like times he's been mafia. tl.net tl.net On May 05 2019 22:49 Pandain wrote: There's just a complete lack of caring about the game, something that does not at all appear in the two above linked games of him being town, but you can tell in the last two. On May 05 2019 23:11 Pandain wrote: I want you to just imagine that Koshi plays the exact same for the next three days, and we mislynch twice and lose the game. Did Koshi ever contribute? Did Koshi ever push? Did Koshi ever do anything meaningful? And if the answer is no, is that what you expect from town yoshi, as demonstrated above? I'm just sayin. There's bussing a teammate, and then there's bussing an entire team. In an atmosphere where there's A) innocent child townies, and B) blocs of townies voting together. And Pandain is ACTIVE and WATCHING it all, so it's not like he's ignorant of what's happening in the thread. Can we please address this before any more votes on Pandain? Yeah I know I said this earlier. I don't think Pandain would throw Koshi under the bus because Koshi actually had the potential to come back and carry scum team to victory. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
His filter is coaching Jock on day 1 into hard-core meta defense of Pandain into saying that HF was the leader of the town into saying that HF was scum for not being aggressive enough into attacking me for not posting a reads list when everyone else was attacking me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Me because he was scum reading me earlier and WBG/MZ because they are old-timey players with a lot of respect for BC's play. I don't see Slam or FF making that NK choice. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 12:29 VisceraEyes wrote: With Slam I got....maybe the mod didn't want to fuck Koshi by modkilling TWO mafia D2? Suspiciously inactive? *shrug* Well if they have a replacement they're going to use it. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I haven't seen an RNG kill on forum though. People kill based off reads or who they respect. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 16:51 VisceraEyes wrote: Its wording is weird. We can't believe a fake claim, because town can just counterclaim and win. not We can't try a fake claim, because town can just counterclaim and win. or We should hope for a fake claim, because town can just counterclaim and win. I was replying to something here but didn't quote (I think it was something Bugs said). You'd have to go back and find out what it was because I don't know what I was saying. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Did not expect to be doing that but it seems right. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
The meta read was good in itself but the FF post saying that he didn't read Pandain's post about Koshi is even more suspicious. It's way way way more likely that FF backed out of his Pandain read because VE and I didn't agree with it rather than him taking the time to write out accusations against Pandain while not reading through his whole filter. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 18:48 wherebugsgo wrote: okay I'm gonna sleep on this but I like where this is going and want to create a second wagon to force this discussion. If we're going to make this decision it should be on the merits of what stands before us and not on momentum. And besides the more people get talking the better anyway, and FF hasn't done enough of that yet. FF would you be willing to kill yourself today so that we have an easier time deciding who to kill tomorrow? Like if you let us kill you now it's basically guaranteed to be MZ right? ##vote FecalFeast This is such a bad post fwiw. Vote for somebody because you think they're the most likely to be scum not because you want to make a second wagon. Wagons don't matter in the slightest it's every man for himself. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 23:00 wherebugsgo wrote: I think Pandain's analysis is mostly pretty good but I don't think it's a slam dunk. If you look for counter examples, you can find them, but like Pandain mentioned they're rare. I haven't had the time to check whether I think they're more common as scum or not but for instance: From End of the World Party Mafia: https://tl.net/forum/mafia/542541-end-of-the-world-party-mafia?page=194#3873 From Classic Mafia https://tl.net/forum/mafia/542541-end-of-the-world-party-mafia?page=194#3873 noteworthy on classic is that he promised a post on someone else (TickTock?) and t hen never did it, so even as town he did something "scummy" There's no analysis in that counter-example post it's mostly just real life reasons for why he hasn't been able to post. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
FF/Koshi probably would have won the game if Pandain was lynched instead of HF and VE was shot instead of BC. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 07 2019 23:06 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: Ah now I see. Well its comforting to see someone agreeing with me although I wish it wasn't Pandain lmao. Here's your order VE FF>MZ>Pandain Again if by some miracle I don't get lynched today and FF is town. I want to die tomorrow bc I'll never survive final 3, everyone but maybe Pandain scum reads me. I will need to die so we can pack as many relatively townread people into the final 3 as possible so we don't end up with me/grack/slam lmao. This is the dream finale. (Hijole) | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
How come his meta reads are always defending people once they come under pressure rather than reasoning to suspect somebody: Look at how many times Pandain says the phrase "I think". Look at this long post FF posted. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Anyways. I know WBG will never be lynched unless I come up with a killer case on him and if it's not him then he'll be night killed ahead of me anyway. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 09:48 VisceraEyes wrote: Can you tell me in one or two sentences why I should believe it isn't you? If I was mafia I would have been fine with killing Vivax but I wouldn't bus Koshi because he is actually capable of a strong scum game. I think I come off as really suspicious because my opinions have been very hipster-y this game between Jock/HF/WBG and I haven't put in the time/effort to write a strong case this game. Hipster-y is usually town though imo. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I have a very good sense of when somebody's push on me is bullshit and who actually believes I am scum. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:11 Pandain wrote: It's not just about activity. Anyone, even mafia, can be active. It's about meaningful activity, and clearly showing that you care about the game and seriously showing that you're trying to solve it. It's also part of why Slam is suspicious. He has 8 pages of filter and I don't actually think one is a good post. I mean he's a spammer but is he normally this bad? This is pretty normal Slam. Actually I think he's been more outspoken than usual in his push on you this game. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:12 wherebugsgo wrote: grack why did you flip your read on me being town? Like I don’t really get the progression and it makes you look really scummy. I can’t get over how it seems you’re always on the right side of the lynch eventually in terms of opinions, but as far as I can tell you have little to no influence in the lynch beforehand. You don’t really participate in the discussions I’d expect you to participate in, and you kind of just shit on people’s posts from the periphery. Why did you accuse Pandain of trying to bus Vivax d1 when you also sheeped that same vote? idk. Just talk it out here, I’m rather confused because I don’t find clear takeaways about your reads. I explained my reasoning on Jock and HF was pretty clear to me and I still think he shouldn't have been lynched. He had the best contributions in the game and you killed him for not being aggressive (when you also fucking said he was the town leader) It wasn't that he voted Vivax, it's the appearance of the posts. The EOD posts looked to me like he knew Vivax was scum and ensured he would get good town-cred from the vote. Honestly I'm going to have to take another look at Pandain in case of hero scum play even though he's played easily the strongest game here out of the players here and has had the best cases/scumhunting. Though I think the difference between Pandain this game and in the last scum game he played is pretty night and day. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:20 Pandain wrote: When your main argument against him is "he never mentioned Koshi!" you know that it's a pretty weak argument. And it's not because he's not mafia, it's because there's literally nothing in the filter you can analyze. He might as well not have posted at all than post 8 pages, it's the same result. I think he's pretty clearly low on time. He just makes a spam of like a page of posts in every 20 minute span that he is here. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:22 Pandain wrote: But the man needs to die. Even as a late policy lynch and even if he's town. If you are able to have 8 pages you are not "low on time", at least not enough to the point where you are this useless and incapable of doing a single actual analysis. Both as town and mafia, it's inexcusable to have the amount of useless spam, sheeping, and generally uncomprehensible material. Woops quoted the wrong post. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:44 wherebugsgo wrote: idk I think grack’s push on me actually makes him seem really townie. Like if I were town in his situation and I didn’t agree with you, VE, I probably wouldn’t rule myself out as scum. Like, from that perspective I don’t think he sees a good reason to townread me because he’s aware to some degree that I can play an active scum game. Unlike slam, who I think doesn’t have enough in the way of opinion-conveying posts, my problem on grack is that it is sometimes hard to follow the logic and rationale for his thoughts. The actual results of those thoughts aren’t my terrible. I also recognize that a scum here would know they need to paint both myself and Pandain badly because it helps in endgame when only one of us is alive Wtf you just said that you suspected me for pushing you. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:41 VisceraEyes wrote: I'll say that Grack strikes me as a deadline player regardless of alignment. :O (Actually I do show up at pretty much every deadline of every game I play. I really like the shenannies) | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 21:48 VisceraEyes wrote: Even at the time I read this post as | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 22:37 wherebugsgo wrote: MZ did martyr and if my gut tells me he is scum and your gut tells you he’s town, and that evidence says he’s town, l say we just go with he’s town ? | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 08 2019 22:55 VisceraEyes wrote: I want to believe that there's enough information in the thread to solve this shit right now. I just can't put it all together. I'm not strong enough. I don't know what to look for. I hate being one of the people mafia bring to endgame because I'm dumb. Well you shot Koshi and I'm pretty sure you're dying tonight. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Lynch should be between me/MZ/WBG. Pandain/Slam are both comfortably town to me. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I'm usually pretty bad at LYLOs anyway. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
Slam > Bugs > you in terms of townieness. You legitimately played the strongest game here. You wrote a case against Koshi and had the best case in the game in your FF case. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
If MZ isn't the last scum then it's pretty obviously going to be me as the final lynch. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
This is what I would call pro-plays. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 11 2019 04:38 Pandain wrote: Fuck I'm scared to switch. Lol I’ve been your top scum read for a while now. Lynch Bugs in LYLO If he’s still alive | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
I probably should have written a case but I spent last night playing BOTW. I killed some centaur dude. It was worth it. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
GG. | ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
| ||
Grackaroni
United States9714 Posts
On May 11 2019 05:25 BloodyC0bbler wrote: What was the reasoning behind shooting me grack? Just because you were pushing me and I thought you might be cop. I didn’t think it would point straight to me I thought there would be more paranoia about Bugs/VE staying alive after killing HF. | ||
| ||