[M] Classic Mafia - Page 17

On March 27 2018 14:40 Tictock wrote:


Appeasing me is exactly the approach I expect scum to take here.

I notice Moosy is the only one with the brass to actually try to call me scum at this point, even though it's super weak.

I'm not here to tell you how to play Mocsta, I'm just telling you what I think.

Also I need to get to bed, so peace.

On March 26 2018 07:58 rsoultin wrote:
If I Die Before I Wake

Koshi 100% scum. All you need to see that is reading his posts post-flip. Too happy about players getting themselves modkilled, the comment about Slam, etc. Add to that his complete lack of influence on the game.

*Palmar 98% scum. I lied The way he delurked on weekend to attack n00bking both when NK first brought up the contradiction in his perception of blue claims, and when NK claimed blue, is not only opportunistic but counter to how Palmar normally plays weekends as town. Which is to say, he doesn't. Moreover, it was a classic strawman argument that he made. Namely, that he was saying he didn't push it as he should in the last game so NK was lying. But obviously he 1) did push it with just a few minutes left to go and 2) if he saw it as a mistake he's more likely to try to get such blue claims lynched harder in the future. A strawman argument, given Palmar, doesn't make him scum normally but I'd say it almost certainly does when he makes it seriously. If I get nk'd tonight, he's also probably the reason. Though, to be fair, I probably was going to get NK'd regardless of the scum team. Also, his reactions after the flips were only slightly better than koshi's.

(sorry, rayn. I did find your point plausible, I just don't think he thinks people are going to go digging up old games to see if his approach to the game on that specific point line up. And I actually think it makes disfo a bit more likely to be scum, as well)

Moosy 90% scum. I think there's an eentsy beentsy chance I'm just expecting too much of him. I think he's hoping to bank on Rayn's read and a general perception that he's just a trolly, useless player. To me, he never has been. And because I don't want to call him useless or anything if I happen to be wrong here, I'm just going to say this would have to be a very off game for him given the Moosy I remember, to reduce his game post flips to blind associations everywhere and little interaction with other players.

disformation 60% scum. Wasn't lying about saying fuck it regarding filters. So this is more feels and intuition based off his play in vendee where he was pretty on the ball and off doing whatever he wanted and dumping analysis into the thread. Here it's less like he's poking into things and finding things that interest him, but rather being led by the nose where to sniff. I don't mind waffling when I can see people have points in favor and points against that they want to express to show what's making them unsure. With him, though, there's just too many posts where he talks without really saying anything, like his read on Moosy. That's a different kind of waffle. Caveat is yeah, I'm basing this off two games and confirming he can be active as fuck as scum.

FF 55% town. Putting him at a slight townread because of how he interacted with me at EoD 2. It just seemed very open and honest, like a puppy ;o; This is obviously a very weak read and if I'm wrong on anyone it's probably him and one of disfo/moosy (more likely disfo than moosy).

DF, TT, rayn and Mocsta are always town here (even though I'd love for Mocsta to be our friendly neighborhood SK ;o;). You can of course disagree. But I still stand by my scum probably has next to no motivation to play when the game could probably literally end tonight. Rayn's outburst I don't think ever comes from scum for reasons I've already said.

Coag...if this is the game man, kudos?

On March 22 2018 07:02 darthfoley wrote:


So... none of your top three are gonna happen (unfortunately about KSC). Where's your head at for the vote?

On March 23 2018 06:39 darthfoley wrote:


Depends on who you consider "strong players."

I've thought HF and Vivax were townie since early on.

I've consistently been suspicious on you and rsoultin.

I've ignored Koshi until recently but I'm not particularly impressed by his play. I haven't read his filter individually, but he can be considered somewhat scummy. He's been super detached from the game imo

On March 27 2018 15:45 MoosyDoosy wrote:
idk why we're talking about killing Koshi or disfo or Mocsta this would be the EXACT thing that mafia wants even moreso if we actually have 5 blue roles.

If 5 is impossible and we have 4 blue roles, then we have a better chance of nailing scum in the 3/7 non claim pile for a ~43% chance of nailing mafia instead of 1/3 for a ~33% chance

On March 27 2018 15:59 MoosyDoosy wrote:
fuck me does jailkeeper block a mafia attempting to kill someone too?

like if rsoultin jailed scum and they delivered the shot she blocks it?

On March 27 2018 16:08 raynpelikoneet wrote:
fyi rsoultin jailed me N1 and there is no mafia team where i am not delivering KP on N1. I can't tell from N2 but i can surely tell from N1.

On March 27 2018 16:08 MoosyDoosy wrote:
I mean, if Koshi is scum, the only reason why his claim makes sense is if mafia has a win condition that lets them break lylo i.e. extra KP.

Like this claim is objectively ass as fuck even for lazy mafia and if we take the statistically correct(?) play of leaving claimed blues alone I don't see how things are simplifed for us.

Also disfo could be veteran and mafia could have wasted a KP on him during night in order to kill him this night phase. That's a possibility. But if we take the statistically correct blah laasdfb;asldifn

On March 27 2018 16:16 MoosyDoosy wrote:
And to be completely honest with you Mocsta all of your campaigning and flipping reads and shit is worrying me so if Mafia kill you it would help me lmao

On March 27 2018 16:15 MoosyDoosy wrote:

I'm just saying there might be a world where Koshi's claim is real or disfo is actually veteran so we should wait and see. Like mafia is going to have to kill a claimed blue here and if they're not going to kill Koshi or disfo they're going to kill you

On March 27 2018 16:20 MoosyDoosy wrote:

someone asked earlier why i suddenly scumread fecal and it's literally through PoE. Also the fact that he was willing to lynch rsoul at one point was what struck out to me.

I noted it down earlier because I figured Fecal would be town if rsoul flipped scum but the opposite happened

On March 27 2018 16:22 raynpelikoneet wrote:

What is this shit?

On March 21 2018 03:18 Fecalfeast wrote:
I've skimmed up while I'm supposed tk be working.

Towny
Palmar
Rso - trying to solve game and posting a lot
Hf
Didform

Not towny
Kelsier
Noobking
Moose

Back to work ask me why if you must

On March 24 2018 02:37 Fecalfeast wrote:
Deadline is tomorrow right?

I want to lynch rso

On March 24 2018 02:38 disformation wrote:
yes.
why?

On March 24 2018 02:48 Fecalfeast wrote:
Seems mafia to me