Newbie Student Mafia VI - Page 13

On February 27 2015 04:03 Eden1892 wrote:
Something about Artanis's reply to my question didn't feel right but I can't follow up rn on mobile. Promise I will before I'm nightkilled

On February 27 2015 05:21 Tronak wrote:


Plausible and interesting, push your theories further please I could buy this one. I read node as town many times at the start of D1, but he dissapearing suddenly...

Would Artanis fit as mafia in this line somehow?

On February 26 2015 03:15 yamato77 wrote:
I like damdred's posts about Snarfs. Dude has been seriously fishy this whole game.

For one, I'm pretty sure Node is town. For two, the way he's sort of just landed on Kels makes me highly suspicious. If someone has to bait you into voting them, it looks bad.

Kelsier looks a lot better now than when I initially voted him. Snarfs looks worse. Artanis looks better, even if he's ununnecessarily fixated on me. Tormented is at least trying, to an extent.

Right now I kinda want to lynch Snarfs. Ever since his first big post, I've had him down as solidly scummy but I've sat on it and waited. He never really got better.

##Vote: Snarfs

On February 26 2015 04:31 yamato77 wrote:
Kels what do you think of snarfs?

On February 26 2015 05:47 yamato77 wrote:
Why do you think snarfs is so townie, Eden?

On February 26 2015 06:02 yamato77 wrote:

Because he's trying to look like he has reads, and is contributing. He's been playing at being "the good, helpful townie" this entire game and it's been filled with performances like his post that you seem to think is "sincere". It's anything but. It looks constructed and fake.

On February 26 2015 06:24 yamato77 wrote:
From Nomination:



lolol it's the dude's formula.

On February 25 2015 13:02 Probulous wrote:

I get that. I just expect more from Snarfs. So far we have a town read on Damdred, a push then back-off on Node. It's not the Snarfs I remember. He is never a prolific poster but he is insightful and thinks carefully about what he posts. A careless mistake like that is uncharacteristic. When he does post it is normally for the throat. Haven't seen that yet.

On February 26 2015 08:27 Probulous wrote:

I don't like a Snarfs lynch, he is active trying and willing to be wrong. Artanis is spammy as hell but so are others and he has been pushing his tormented case all game. He is at least active and trying to find scum.

Wave has done absolutely nothing all game despite being asked for it. Many times. He wasn't a lynch target so he just AFKs. Classic scum.

On February 26 2015 08:55 Probulous wrote:

Geez they just come crawling out of the woodwork don't they. I'll vote wave cause I want to learn from the other guy ?????

On February 26 2015 08:58 Probulous wrote:
Too late for a switch?

On February 26 2015 08:58 Probulous wrote:
Damn you Tronak.

We got scum on this wagon people.

On February 26 2015 22:14 Probulous wrote:
Taking a look at the way the Wave lynch happened I think mafia got lucky. It was my vote which made Wave a legitimate target and the wagon gained speed from there. Wave was safe as houses with no-one doing anything until I changed my vote then in the space of 10 minutes (10:29-10:40) four people jumped onto the wagon. See + Show Spoiler +

Snarfs tied it up and Shining hammered the lynch but it is reasonable for Snarfs to push the other wagon and Shining jumped in too late to change the lynch targets. Anyway by this point the wagon was rolling strong anyway. I don't think Eden is mafia and besides his vote didn't push the wagon along, it was mine and the others that joined him. I made a major fuck up but my reasons are in thread. Even so Wave was at 2 votes when Snarfs had 4 and Artanis 2. The wagon really got going when Damred, tormented and Tronak came on board.

Damred's vote was a consolidation vote and he moved from Snarfs due to his legacy post. Literally this
Which doesn't mention my vote 13 minutes earlier. Odd since Artanis and Snarfs were the lead vote contenders until my vote tied up Artanis and Wave and Eden's passionate cry for assistance didn't convince him earlier. Whatever, he hasn't provided the brilliant analysis he promised and has managed to lie low since I stopped pushing him. We lynched town cause he didn't participate so I am loathe to lynch on broken promises again. He clearly isn't in anyone else's sights so moving on. To be honest I'm tired of reading his filter.

So that leave's _Tormented_ and Tronak. Just perfect, the newbies.
Tormented I can't tell if it is mafia or just blatant newb. Take these posts for example

versus

like three minutes later. He says bad stuff but he is completely open about it. I hate to admit it but Tronak is the same. I thought I had nailed him with his reasoning for voting for Wavewhich is just about the worst reason you could have to vote for someone. You aren't voting for them because you think they are mafia but because you like how the other guy plays. If this was the only time he specifically mentioned Snarfs play it would be blatant attempt to find a reason to vote and I would lynch him so fast but he has actually mentioned this a couple times before.

1. (iii) Scarfs: null about him with big fear of losing what I find so far a very usefull player for my learning.
   
2. I like Snarfs, as said before, he results interesting to exist in my learning curve.
   However, is impossible anyone reading half Artanis's post would miss his tunneling on Tormented.
   How can you explain that Snarfs?

I just don't see Tronak thinking that far ahead.

Which means my two hours spent trying to work out what happened comes down to Damred again. It's past midnight here and I'm just done with this. I'll try and be here before day-break. I'll take a look at Snarfs and his side of the voting then.

Please post your thoughts, hopefully some of this was useful. I especially want to hear from Node, who has also disappeared from the thread.

On February 27 2015 06:31 Snarfs wrote:
Kelsier:





I read this as town realizing too late that it's a lynch between two town. If you're mafia, why do you even bother saying anything at all?



I also think town is more likely to contradict themselves. Especially in a scenario where he probably could have just jumped on my lynch given the aforementioned scumread.

On February 27 2015 06:29 Probulous wrote:
Skimmed so far.

KSc, I didn't think Snarfs was mafia. All I said was his play was different. Not different to his town play. He has certainly been less clear than usual but that doesn't make him mafia.

And no there was no time for another wagon on Tronak. There were two minutes remaining with only about four or five of us posting. Jumping off at that point would have ended up lynching Snarfs.

As for why scum would be on Wave and not Snarfs if Snarfs is town, well Wave was town. Pushing one town lynch over another seems a 50/50 split. There are three scum there could quite likely be two on the Snarfs voting. I particularly think Node is suspicious given he votes Snarfs for no reason and then disappears. We'll have to see what he says when he returns.

On February 27 2015 06:51 Probulous wrote:

OK you're misunderstanding what I was originally saying. I was not calling him town in that first post, I just said his posting style when we played years ago was one of careful consideration. It's different this game but that doesn't make him mafia, or town. I thought that was clear when I posted this later