• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 07:02
CEST 13:02
KST 20:02
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Power Rank - Esports World Cup 202550RSL Season 1 - Final Week9[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall15HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)16
Community News
BSL Team Wars - Bonyth, Dewalt, Hawk & Sziky teams4Weekly Cups (July 14-20): Final Check-up0Esports World Cup 2025 - Brackets Revealed19Weekly Cups (July 7-13): Classic continues to roll8Team TLMC #5 - Submission re-extension4
StarCraft 2
General
RSL Revival patreon money discussion thread Power Rank - Esports World Cup 2025 Jim claims he and Firefly were involved in match-fixing RSL Season 1 - Final Week The GOAT ranking of GOAT rankings
Tourneys
Esports World Cup 2025 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation #239 Bad Weather Mutation # 483 Kill Bot Wars Mutation # 482 Wheel of Misfortune Mutation # 481 Fear and Lava
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion Ginuda's JaeDong Interview Series [Update] ShieldBattery: 1v1 Fastest Support! ASL20 Preliminary Maps BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
CSL Xiamen International Invitational [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [CSLPRO] It's CSLAN Season! - Last Chance [BSL 2v2] ProLeague Season 3 - Friday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do.
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread [MMORPG] Tree of Savior (Successor of Ragnarok) Path of Exile CCLP - Command & Conquer League Project
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread The Games Industry And ATVI Stop Killing Games - European Citizens Initiative
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
[\m/] Heavy Metal Thread Anime Discussion Thread Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Korean Music Discussion
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NBA General Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Installation of Windows 10 suck at "just a moment" Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Ping To Win? Pings And Their…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 827 users

Insane Mafia

Forum Index > TL Mafia
Post a Reply
Normal
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 16 2010 22:33 GMT
#17
sounds fun

/in
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 24 2010 19:45 GMT
#66
I can just imagine the killing of a jack o lantern or something similar to that role leading to the killing of another jack o lantern, and another and so on
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 16:26 GMT
#87
Ooh sounds awesome
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 22:23 GMT
#100
Wait so we can't lynch people by ourselves, but instead have to elect a mayor?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 22:25 GMT
#101
On October 29 2010 07:21 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
The Mayor will have one additional vote in every lynch after Day 1.

Oh ok, that's good then, so I can lynch people after day 1

Now who wants to run for mayor? :O

And if mayor dies, does that mean we can elect a new one?

Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 22:41 GMT
#106
Well first thing is obviously to elect a mayor
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 22:52 GMT
#114
On October 29 2010 07:43 CubEdIn wrote:
And what happens if we elect a mayor and he's mafia?

See, I only played haunted before, so I'm only getting used to the basics, but this one seems pretty crazy, so what guarantee is that we elect a good mayor with little to no information about him/her?

Also, do we know of anyone who is definitely blue?

I've never played with a mayor role before, but it's a chance we have to take. And the mayor is always in the spotlight, so if he is mafia, more chance for him to slip up. But if he is good, then I think we probably will have lots of problem.

Everyone who is not a red is a blue.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 22:55 GMT
#115
On October 29 2010 07:52 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 07:27 NB wrote:
no rule list, no ratio town/mafia... no NOTHING,... THIS IS INSANE >.<

btw, for the record: Dr.H has never been a towny b4 in the history of mafia xD...

5 times in a row is too much obviously im not mafia in this game

since i've always been mafia it should be very easy to see if i am playing the same way as i always have

Probability wise you have the same chance of being mafia as everyone else, as long as the roles were randomized that is.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 28 2010 23:55 GMT
#123
Hmm what are bodyguards?

Do they protect the mayor from 1 hit per night?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 00:27 GMT
#142
On October 29 2010 09:16 LunarDestiny wrote:
I am indecisive between bumatlarge and Pandain.

As of now, my opinion of these two are:
bumatlarge
Kind of experienced
Claimed he has a way of proving his innocence
Ran and voted himself as mayor 1:22 after the game started. Either he is a blue role or a mafia who wish to steal mayor without much discussing with his teammates.

Pandain

Experienced
Demonstrated good plays in mafia games

EVERYONE IS A BLUE ROLE(except for reds)

I think I will go with Pandain as I don't know too much about bumatlarge as he was killed early and too lazy to read previous games. So far, I like Pandain's playstyle.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 00:30 GMT
#145
Orgolove, I don't think you can stand scrutiny as a mayor, that is why I am not voting for you.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 02:33 GMT
#211
On October 29 2010 11:31 Pandain wrote:
do people know if they are infected with murraynitis?


On October 29 2010 10:15 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 10:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Does the person with murrayitis know they have murrayitis?

With the exception of any doctor role, players will not be informed if they have murrayitis.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 15:22 GMT
#311
To Fishball: It is so easy to make up a role that would make it seem worth it for you to be mayor. Besides, I am more interested in having a mayor with good analytical thinking rather than because of their role. For example, a dt for mayor would be bad if the dt doesn't know what he's doing and just randomly checks people and actually doesn't catch any red.

To annul: You might have played great in the Haunted Mafia, but you have not shown as your skills playing as a townie. Playing while knowing a lot of information from the start is different from starting out with no information and I have yet to see that you are good at that.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 15:48 GMT
#323
On October 30 2010 00:32 annul wrote:
all i knew at the start of haunted was my team (and i knew which kills were vampire and which were mafia). everything else that i learned, i learned on my own from my own strategizing

I think you are underestimating how much information that is. You know which clues apply to which side, and you know who your allies are which is quite a lot. I still think you need more experience as town first. If you are indeed town this game, then let's just see how well you play.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 16:50 GMT
#332
On October 30 2010 01:34 annul wrote:
for what its worth

with all the masturbation that goes on in TL mafia about smurfs and hiding who you are, etc, you place a very high amount of stock on me "not having enough experience"

i wonder, judge me on how i played in haunted: do you really think i lack experience in mafia?

yes, i am new to TL mafia. no, i am not new to mafia, nor to playing town.

I can only judge what I can see.

To Fishball: Hmm I think I might later when I have time as I have a midterm coming up in 5 hours
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 17:48 GMT
#339
On October 30 2010 02:46 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Well, Aeres, I'm also of the opinion that the Mayoral position is most important for its protection. Yeah, the extra votes are nice, but the fact that you can't die til your bodyguards die is most desirable.

Actually no, the extra votes are crucial, if we have someone stupid or a mafia for mayor, that is 1 additional kill on townies.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 18:12 GMT
#346
On October 30 2010 02:58 annul wrote:
its what, 2 votes? if the vote is close enough (like, 16-14) where my one vote will tip the scale, then perhaps it is not "stupid" to have voted it, right?

the mayoral role is not really a town leader position. it's an extra set of lives and a very weak voting power that can be overcome easily (and is 100% transparent). i am playing along with the leadership meme because hey it makes sense, but think about what POWER the mayor has. the only power it has is protection and a weak voting boost. any other leadership that the town chooses to assign to the mayor player is entirely on their own volition.

why do we want to give death protection to a mason? there is no real reason we want to keep the masons alive above someone else who can actually affect things, right? so he has a circle, cool, what does that do for us and why would his death hurt the town, per se?

if i died it would be much worse than a random mason dying, that is all i am saying. are there others out there with roles better suited to protection? probably. but they aren't talking, so i will.

My bad, it seems that I misunderstood the mayor role. I thought they get to lynch one extra person.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 18:56 GMT
#364
Hmm I am a bit tempted to switch my votes.

I think what Fishball can do is reveal whoever is in his circle and have those people confirm that they are in the circle so if something suspicious is happening within the circle, the town can easily see it. But the problem with this is mafia might start picking off people in the circle one by one.

Can you replace those who died in the circle with new ones?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 19:01 GMT
#373
On October 30 2010 03:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
To those of you saying Fishball could be lying about his role, slap yourselves

he would need to have 5 of his other scumbuddies fake being part of this "circle" in order to convince us he isn't lying meaning town would just be handed 6 mafia on a plate

like i said all we would need is for other people in the circle to come out and post their game related PM's to eachother in this thread. if there is no circle, obv, they get modkilled or they are mafia. it's pretty easy.

if no one is willing to do that we lynch fishball. the first person to come out gets rolechecked by the DT i'm assuming we have.

That is assuming there is even such a circle. He doesn't need to tell us who the members of the circles are. If he is mafia, he could just pretend there really is a circle when there really isn't. He could just misfeed us information such as "blue role told me this last night" and we have no proof whether he's lying or not as everything is done in secret.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 19:02 GMT
#375
On October 30 2010 03:58 Fishball wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 03:56 Pandain wrote:
I would be alright with Fishball for mayor I guess, but again, I just don't know why he has to. His reason is protection, but we have medics, no? This circle can be incrediably useful and a valuable asset to town, and if what he says is true, that "his role is crucial to the circle", then why must he go to the extreme and go mayor?

To me, being mayor is more than just having protection. Sure, it's useful, and obviously a lot of us running might have valuable roles, but really what Fishball has is an unconfirmed circle, with an unconfirmed Fishball, the real power coming from the ability to pm. An extra vote IS helpful in mafia, and with only ~15 people in the late game is a very valuable asset, in addition he gets to decide the first day lynch.

Finally, one possibly very important question:
Can the mayor be infected with murrayitis?


Yes he can.
I've asked Artnais already.

I also asked "How long does it take for Murrayitis to kill a player?"
His answer: "It kills them on the night after infection."

Actually he changed his answer into, players infected with Murrayitis all die when at least half the players have it.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 19:15 GMT
#389
On October 30 2010 04:09 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 04:03 Pandain wrote:
If Fishball becomes mayor, then I would think mafia would try to infect him with murrayitis and kill him. The only way we could keep him alive if they do that is have doctors constantly heal him. I don't know how long we need him alive, but here's my thought right now:

Just protecting Fishball with medics is better than having him be mayor AND protect with medics(since they block night kills anyway.)

As for how to continue with his plan, I think one person from the circle should claim they are in circle, then once we know there is one just protect fishball. Then he can do whatever he says is "crucial".

thoughts?


Medics might not be able to cure Murrayitis, in fact, I'm pretty sure they won't be able to. They would only be able to keep their target from dying.

Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 10:40 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Sorry guys, I botched up the definition of Murrayitis completely. This is the 100% correct definition.

Murrayitis Mechanics. The amount of people infected with Murrayitis is posted at the start of the day. Murrayitis is transferred if a carrier is visited, or visits someone during the night. Doctors can cure someone from Murrayitis. While Plague Doctors can cure and transfer immunity to someone with Murrayitis. If over half of the Game has Murrayitis, every carrier of Murrayitis dies.


It appears that Plague Doctors are the ones that would be able to cure Murrayitis.

So if he were Mayor, he would have protection and require a Plague Doctor for the cure.

If he's not Mayor, and we still feel he needs to stay alive, then it would require a Medic for protection and a Plague Doctor for the cure.

If he's Mayor, that is one more available blue per night.

If you read again doctors can cure Murrayitis, but plague doctor transfers immunity too.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 19:28 GMT
#401
On October 30 2010 04:21 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 04:17 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On October 30 2010 04:14 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
i have nowhere to put the FoS but on you. the fact that bum dropped out is weird and makes it kinda unlikely he is scum unless another scum is running and gaining more popularity.


Who do you think that this other scum running would be?

Youngminii didn't propose a campaign, did he? I do agree that it's funny that bum dropped out though...

i have a weird feeling about pandain

most of the people voting for him aren't giving much reason and he's winning in votes while most of the discussion ITT has been about fishballs candidacy

If you want to know why I voted pandain, it's because I think he is the best candidate out of everyone running right now. His analysis is decent and I think that he is not that hard to read. So if he is mafia, I think he will easily slip.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 29 2010 19:34 GMT
#407
Yes, if people in this so called circle claim up, I might change my vote to fishball.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 02:25 GMT
#655
And the debates continue!

Politics, I dislike it

Just some general points I'd like to make:

To DrH: If you are mafia and your role is similar to what you say it is, it could just be instead of you being able to "confirm your role as a townie" to other people it could be "fake your role as a townie" to other people. You don't need to out other mafias to do that.

I am just highly skeptical of voting for someone because of their supposed role.

To fishball: Get someone from your circle to confirm that your circle really exist, or in fact, tell all of them to come out(not their role just the fact that they are in the circle) if at all possible.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 02:35 GMT
#665
On October 30 2010 11:31 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 11:27 Glasse wrote:
On October 30 2010 11:26 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On October 30 2010 11:23 Glasse wrote:
On October 30 2010 09:59 DoctorHelvetica wrote:


My role has two basic abilities:
-to confirm itself to another player at night. basically I can send a signal to another player once per night that confirms I am the role I say I am.
-to assist in stopping the spread of the plague. i will use this role to reliably coordinate the night actions of plague doctors and the results will show in the murrayitis counts.

Both of these actions can be proven, they have results that cannot be faked.

Secondly, (more like the hundred time I've said this and people don't listen)


So whats the name of your role, i'm curious

Does it matter?

It seems strange that you would want to know. I guess it would do no harm to tell, it wouldn't reveal the exact nature of my powers, which I won't go into extreme detail on just yet.

I'm not sure I should say. Maybe there is a role that knows all the roles in the game? And you're trying to confirm I am who I say I am?

Maybe this is some kinda weird mafia fishing attempt?

I'll think about it.



Sounds more like you just made shit up and can't think of a name that fits the description you gave.


Oh, I see.

The name of the role is Sticky. You can see earlier that I used the word sticky to try to see if Node had the same role as me.

As far as making it up, that would be the worst mafia play in the history of mafia. Again like I said (this is the millionth time now)

In order to fake this role I have to out a scumbuddy every single day, who has to lie, putting pressure on an increasing amount of mafia. I would also have to fake the second part of my role, which would be impossible to do since the results are objective and not able to be manipulated.

To DrH: If you are mafia and your role is similar to what you say it is, it could just be instead of you being able to "confirm your role as a townie" to other people it could be "fake your role as a townie" to other people. You don't need to out other mafias to do that.

Looks like my post is just being jumped over You don't necessarily to have made up the entire role, but it could work just as you said but instead favor the mafia instead of town. Like a mafia role that can "confirm he's town through other people"
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 02:49 GMT
#680
Hahaha this game is so INSANE with no one knowing what roles there are and turning all the roleclaiming into WIFOM as we can't tell if there really is such a role.

I'll be back in around an hour or so and decide whether to change my vote or not after I watch some anime.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 21:51 GMT
#909
Since we're talking about lynch suspect now, I feel that youngminii and orgolove are pretty scummy.

I would also take a look at lurkers. Force them to come out by threating to lynch them as whatever you says go for this lynch.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 21:55 GMT
#914
Wow looks like things finally calmed down.

So it seems that you will probably win this election? Who will you be lynching?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 22:19 GMT
#946
On October 31 2010 07:04 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 31 2010 07:00 Fishball wrote:
On October 31 2010 06:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On October 31 2010 06:55 Nemesis wrote:
Wow looks like things finally calmed down.

So it seems that you will probably win this election? Who will you be lynching?

I'll give my list of considerations and we can talk about it as town:
orgolove
NB
youngminii
kitaman27
coagulation

that's about in order of how much I suspect them of being possible scum.


I like how none of the players who voted for you are on that list

DrH, is there a particular reason you suspect youngminii and not Kenpachi nor SiNiquity?

Siniquity and Kenpachi were pretty inactive in mafia, but they turned out to be villagers.

I still don't like how they're lurking though. Maybe consider it as a future lynch target in the future.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 30 2010 22:27 GMT
#954
Orgolove sounds like veldril last game

Either orgolove is a bad townie or scum, at this point I really can't tell.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 31 2010 02:10 GMT
#1146
On October 31 2010 08:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 31 2010 08:46 bumatlarge wrote:
On October 31 2010 08:39 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On October 31 2010 08:37 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Have we solidified a day one lynch? I feel like this should be our highest priority right now, we've only got a few hours left. I'm still suggesting youngminii because of his scummish posts. Although I feel like Kenpachi would be a good lynch as well, the possibility that he's afk or something gives him enough reasonable doubt that I don't think he should go day one.


SiNiquity is my first choice at the moment. Similar post to youngminii but I feel more confident that his actual vote was scummy than youngs.

I feel that Pandain or BumAtLarge have the highest chances of being scum mayor so I'm looking at their supporters and posting atm.


There is some truth to this, I've been looking through the thread and I've noticed a little something relevant. I think a few of us have suggested lynching a candidate. If there was no mafia candidate, I'd imagine a few scum would say that would seem like a good idea. But it was basically you, fishball and myself who have hinted at doing this. No one commented on it. I think it's likely one of the candidates are scum. Though we only really mentioned it when we were looking like we were gaining soe ground in the race. Kill Pandain I say :D

Pandain is my second choice for now but I'm not sure since he claims to have an uber important role. But how important can it be if it's less important than mine that is mostly important on its ability to confirm itself?

I have a weird feeling about Nemesis. his vote is for pandain but iirc he supported me mostly in this thread. correct me if I'm wrong maybe I'm thinking about someone else.

Also if the boogerthrower knows the identity of the mafia voter somehow, come out and claim. You'll be medic protected 100%.

I never supported you except for finding orgolove suspicious.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 31 2010 02:33 GMT
#1165
Do bodyguards protect the mayor from ALL hit or one hit each
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 31 2010 18:12 GMT
#1250
On November 01 2010 03:07 Glasse wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 01:51 Hyperbola wrote:
On October 31 2010 20:20 youngminii wrote:
oh god that was a shitfest, i didn't read everything to the full but i got the general gist of what's going on

Before you ask me to do something stupid like roleclaim, ask yourselves:
Why in God's name would scum have an ability that allows them to not die? Lynches always bypass the 'oh this guy has two lives' thing anyway.
Why would I not try to defend myself after being pressured for so long? If you thought I was biding my time so that someone could try to take the attention away from me, why didn't anyone?

DrH I'm surprised you didn't think of the second question. Also, a whole lot of your reasoning for your accusations in this thread comes from the metagame, which is stupid because some people like not playing the same style every single game. Stop relying on the metagame, especially if you've only seen me play *once*.

Hang on, your reasoning is flawed anyway because if you actually used the metagame, you would have seen my active posting in Haunted Mafia as scum. Why in the world would you still try and get me lynched?

Ok so these are the aspects of his role (if he's telling the truth):
1. avoid a lynch
2. no talking
So I'm thinking his role is the ability to leave town, turn invisible, or hide in the closet for a night. I don't know why he wouldn't role claim but, more importantly, this doesn't seem like a scum-favored role. Think about it: why would scum leave town? Is the mob getting too hot for him? This would seem almost detrimental because if someone has a valid case against him, he can't argue it and just delays the inevitable 1 turn. I think the role is intended to just dodge night actions and simply dodges lynches and forbids speaking as a side effect. So in short, I think youngminii is innocent to some extent... for now.


Something that is to be considered is that in the role list i was reading (to have ideas of what kind of roles could happen here) there was a role that could hide in his office if he felt threatened. He could not do it twice in a row but he could hide every other days/nights. Now he might not want to say anything because he wouldnt be able to hide again.

:3

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Commuter
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
October 31 2010 19:45 GMT
#1303
You guys are idiots, so many roleclaims already-.-

We should also stop with the WIFOM of what other things "roles" can do as it is just WIFOM. Let's stick to what we know.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 01 2010 03:40 GMT
#1689
Damn this has turned into a shitfest.

Can we please stop with all these "what ifs" bullshit?

I guess important thing right now is who I am going to lynch, then I'm sleeping.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 01 2010 04:16 GMT
#1739
I don't know why there are a good amount of people lynching Aeres. Aeres basically roleclaimed to take a hit incase DC was actually bodyguard. And if he isn't lying about his role, that is basically the best thing he can do with it.

Also, what benefit could roleclaiming as bodyguard give mafia really?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 01 2010 04:23 GMT
#1749
Ok well I have classes tomorrow so I'm off to sleep.

I just placed a placeholder vote in case I don't have time to do a full analysis on who I should vote later on.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 01 2010 04:39 GMT
#1755
On November 01 2010 13:19 youngminii wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 13:16 Nemesis wrote:
I don't know why there are a good amount of people lynching Aeres. Aeres basically roleclaimed to take a hit incase DC was actually bodyguard. And if he isn't lying about his role, that is basically the best thing he can do with it.

Also, what benefit could roleclaiming as bodyguard give mafia really?

Trust? Too much relaxation? As scum they could put us into a state of 'oh hey the Mayor has a bodyguard, he won't die, we don't need a doctor to protect him' if we think he's still got an active bodyguard.

I mean, who the hell would actually go to the trouble of making an entire 'Cruiseship Captain' role by themself? Looks like it was looked over and peer reviewed by an entire team of people imo.

The original Cruiseship Captain Crap:

Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 04:12 Aeres wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
Okay, since it seems that the Doc's position as Mayor is in jeopardy, I'm going to put some interesting info out there.

On October 31 2010 10:23 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Further news I forgot to put in the night post: Due to budget cuts, we have only managed to purchase one bodyguard for the Mayor.


Artanis lied.

There are two Bodyguards, not one. I don't know who the first one is (I suspect it's DC), but I am the second one.

I was going to play dumb about my role of Bodyguard until DC screwed up. I dunno if he really is the other Bodyguard, but if he is, I feel like if he was killed, then the Mafia, upon learning that there is a second Bodyguard (due to a failed hit on Mayor), would start hitting the most outspoken townspeople in lieu of the Mayor. Since I am in fact one of the more outspoken people in this topic, I was at risk of being "tapped", so to speak.

I would also like to note that my normal role greatly assists my ability to act as a Bodyguard. Since Bodyguards block hits on the Mayor, killing them makes the Mayor vulnerable. My role is designed to increase my longevity as long as possible.

My role is called the "Cruiseship Captain". I am eligible to PM a mod in order to set sail for the ocean and leave town for the night, thus becoming immune to any and all night actions (positive and negative alike, including roleblocks and DT checks). I am not permitted to set sail on consecutive nights.

Because of this mechanic, I can survive on my own for a short while. Having a Medic tend to me will not be necessary for the first few nights. Once my role has been exhausted of uses (I do not know how many times I can set sail in this game, only that it is more than once), Medics are more than welcome to assist me.

Also, please keep in mind that my role has an additional function that I am not presently willing to reveal.

Yeah, this is all great, Aeres, but now you sound mighty suspicious to me!

Well, yes, I cannot deny that I seem fishy (pardon the pun, I am a Cruiseship Captain, after all). I also imagine it does not help my case that setting sail makes me immune to DT checks. I assure you all, however, that I am working in the interests of the town. Believe me, I'd rather not cause suspicion when it isn't warranted, but DC's possibly slip-up forced my hand.


Grr last post for tonight. Except he told us that he actually lied so your argument is null.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 01:31 GMT
#1987
Well I'm back and I've been reading a lot.

Yum Yum

Time to give my input on things.
1. LAL is a BAAAAAAAAAADDDDDDDDDDDDDDD policy. What is important is not that they lied or what they lied about, but their reasons for lying aka their motive. Although I do find Aeres martyring himself as fishy.
2. If you are going to go with LAL policy, why aren't you gunning for DrH too, YM and Ace?

3. DoctorH, I have FoS on, but I don't really want to lynch him at this point as he is mayor, and can really help in the lategame if he is indeed town. Besides, he is always in the spotlight, more chance for him to slipup like he's been slowly doing all day.
4. For the youngminii bandwagon, I also have FoS on youngminii but I wouldn't really lynch him yet, and I find it weird how they are ignoring that Ace was also tried to get people to bandwagon for Aeres, but his name is not being mentioned when he's essentially doing the same thing that they are lynching youngminii for.
5. It seems that youngminii and doctorH are defending each other, another thing I find suspicious
6. I don't agree with fishing for inactives is a bad thing. With all these back and forth going on between you guys, the inactives are left out of the spotlight: a perfect place for mafia to hide. Also, inactives makes any kind of post analysis useless on them. For now, I'll vote Veldril.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 01:33 GMT
#1989
sorry but point 1 is a bit incomplete so I'm reposting it again

Time to give my input on things.
1. LAL is a BAAAAAAAAAADDDDDDDDDDDDDDD policy. What is important is not that they lied or what they lied about, but their reasons for lying aka their motive. As inifitestory pointed out, Aeres' motives are pretty straightforward, which is why I have FoS on people wanting to start a bandwagon on him. Although I do find Aeres martyring himself as fishy.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 02:42 GMT
#2018
[quote]2.) I didn't get a bandwagon going on Aeres. I started a lynch on Aeres. If I was starting a bandwagon I wouldn't be using logical arguments, or you know the fact that Aeres lied as proof that he is scum. [/quote
Of course an experienced player won't just use some random arguments to try and get people to bandwagon someone. They try and pick on someone weak who can't defend himself and push for a lynch on him. Also, I don't see how Aeres lied as "proof" he is scum. As been mentioned by other people in the thread, scum are not the only ones who lie, a townie lying can be of benefit to town if done correctly, which Aeres didn't do and as such an easy target for someone such as yourself by pulling LAL.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 02:46 GMT
#2020
On November 02 2010 11:06 Ace wrote:
2.) I didn't get a bandwagon going on Aeres. I started a lynch on Aeres. If I was starting a bandwagon I wouldn't be using logical arguments, or you know the fact that Aeres lied as proof that he is scum.

Of course an experienced player won't just use some random arguments to try and get people to bandwagon someone. They try and pick on someone weak who can't defend himself and push for a lynch on him. Also, I don't see how Aeres lied as "proof" he is scum. As been mentioned by other people in the thread, scum are not the only ones who lie, a townie lying can be of benefit to town if done correctly, which Aeres didn't do and as such an easy target for someone such as yourself by pulling LAL.

Just fixing the quotes
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 02:47 GMT
#2021
I do agree with L that we need to pick a lynch target who isn't part of the heavy arguing going on.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 04:20 GMT
#2062
Can we please move on to other possible lynch targets instead of speculating how people's said role works? We can do that later on if someone told us about their role and got caught in a lie.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 04:21 GMT
#2063
On November 02 2010 13:19 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 02 2010 13:16 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On November 02 2010 13:14 Coagulation wrote:
On November 02 2010 13:10 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On November 02 2010 13:05 Coagulation wrote:
On November 02 2010 13:03 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On November 02 2010 12:59 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On November 02 2010 12:47 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On November 02 2010 12:09 Pandain wrote:
oh wtf, im almost at 2000?
screw the part1/2/3/4/5 crud. I'm a do a full blown analysis.

Don't expect me to post for a while :p


I won't lie to you, I probably won't even bother reading it. I already know what it will say.


On November 02 2010 12:14 infinitestory wrote:
On November 02 2010 12:10 L wrote:
[quote]
The +1 makes sense, but that means that mafia would have had to..

hmm.

Node, when did you recieve the two PMs notifying you who's going to die?

Like I said, he claims it's at the beginning of the day each day. He also claims that he received QuickStriker's name at the beginning of Day 1, but QuickStriker was modkilled at the end of Day 1, so he then received BrownBear's name.


I have known this for quite a while, but it just got me thinking:
What do you think the odds are that the mods would change the "oracled" target if that target was modkilled? Idk, it just seems to me that if the player was modkilled, well that's tough shit for the oracle, his power is wasted for the day. Thinking about this, Node actually does seem pretty fishy.

Eye of Suspicion


That's just speculation. Node seems to think there is a predetermined list and that if a player os modkilled a new target is chosen. Or there is a mafia killing role that must decide on a kill ahead of time

(Decide 1 kill in the day + 2 kills at night) and node is aware of the day choice

there are many possibilities here, I don't think we can draw any serious conclusions from. obviously due to the gravity of his roleclaim his posting can not be ignored.


Haha fair enough. I just wanted to put Eye of Suspicion on someone...

I was gonna on Lexpar, but he posted and placated me. It scares me that we haven't heard from Divinek...



so your basically saying that your just trying to accuse people for the sake of accusing people?
really?
thats as anti town as it gets.


Was I accusing him? No.

I felt left out because of all this ridiculous arguing, and I want people to look at others for possible lynch targets because I believe this argument really didn't get us far.

Go ahead and try to paint me anti-town if you really want to. I'm not sure you'll get too far.


im not trying to paint you anti town. but dont pretend that trying to put eye of suspicion on people because you feel left out is a good way to help town.


Feeling left out isn't the lead persuasion for wanting to search for other targets. Wanting to expand the discussion is.

While I know it is likely there are some blues lurking/being inactive, I would say that it is almost certain there are lurking mafia. This scares me because they can just sit back while people like Doc/Pandain/YM/infinite bicker and split the town into to halves.


The problem with talking about inactives, is you can't really talk about inactives. If players are truly inactive, not posting at all, then really they're all equally likely to be scum and no real conclusions can be drawn.

However it is by no means a good thing that the town gets split 50/50 or that one argument/conflict is the spotlight of the entire day. Inactives need to start posting!

I want to see Divinek post D:

Yes and only way to force inactives to post is to start lynching inactives to scare them into posting.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 04:24 GMT
#2065
Can someone do an analysis on misder? He seems to have a lot of low content post.

I am just too lazy right now as I have a lot of work to do.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 15:21 GMT
#2116
On November 02 2010 22:59 deconduo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 02 2010 22:46 Amber[LighT] wrote:
On November 02 2010 22:28 deconduo wrote:
On November 02 2010 22:20 Amber[LighT] wrote:
On November 02 2010 13:52 Veldril wrote:
On November 02 2010 05:19 Glasse wrote:
I think veldril might be scared of saying anything due to what happened in haunted mafia
I'd love to hear him on this though


I try to post something but having fever and playing Mafia make my head hurts even more T T

Regarding Dr.H and jcarlson, I think there are too many possibilities to simply conclude anything. I still 80% certain that Dr.H is a town player. However, he needs to prove his role quickly or he will lose the trust from me.

On Aeres, I really have no comments at this point (can't have good thinking right now T T). But I would not vote for him simply because of LAL. But I admit that young, and Dr.H made a good analysis on him.

I will put my vote on Divinek for the time being. He's a vet and I want him to say something too. I have yet to see his post about current situation. Also, last game he barely posted and turn out to be red in the end so I think we need to force him to be more active this game too.


If we let Aeres get away with blatantly lying then this cascades into a greater issue later in the game where everyone will feel that lying is the "best way" to bait the mafia; however what will end up happening is the players will bait each other and mafia will never bite. They will know that liars can get away with anything, so they can let the town doom itself. By lynching using LAL as a precedent we're halting future thought of fake claims. Fake claiming is a mafia tell, yet players insist on doing this as a bait tactic. It won't work in the long run.

And we can't just sit here and say "look everyone, don't lie like Aeres did." We won't know what Aeres was really lying about. Mafia will have extra leeway when it comes to a raise in suspicion as well. Picture it...

In 3 days we will go through someones post that has a contradiction and then the accused can just say "oh I was lying to bait someone, like Aeres did." What do we do? Keep our policy of "oh he must be telling the truth, sorry newbie mistake." Learn from your mistakes or don't make them.

Unless there's a better lynch suspect it seems that Aeres would be our best bet for obtaining information.


So you are saying we should lynch Aeres to set an example?



On November 02 2010 22:35 youngminii wrote:
That is what the policy of LAL revolves around, discouraging blatant lies.


^--- This in a nutshell. It's going to be a trainwreck when we have to sift through honest posts and take everything cautiously.


Sitting back and letting 3 letters be law for every single scenario just boggles my mind. Not looking at things in a case by case basis is utterly utterly utterly demented. But hey, people seem to be set in their ways and who am I to change that.

Exactly. I thought we were supposed to lynch people for being SCUM, not for lying. This is a bit of a ridiculous policy. Why must it be one way or the other? We have to consider things case by case, not handle them all the same.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 15:27 GMT
#2118
Too much idiotic roleclaims for the sake of roleclaims this game
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 21:09 GMT
#2192
On November 03 2010 02:28 Infundibulum wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 00:21 Nemesis wrote:
Exactly. I thought we were supposed to lynch people for being SCUM, not for lying. This is a bit of a ridiculous policy. Why must it be one way or the other? We have to consider things case by case, not handle them all the same.


Lynch all Liars is a metagame policy that extends beyond just this round of mafia.

I still have trouble coming to terms with it because last game I was in LAL got a couple townies lynched. Because they lied and fucked up the town, and mafia pushed LAL on them.

Even so, as a long term policy LAL can and will discourage these lying plays on both sides, town and mafia and so it should be used.

As for Aeres, I'm guessing if lynched he's going to flip town. There's less of a motive for claiming BG as a mafia, since the purpose of claiming BG is to draw a hit and the mafia won't hit itself.

The other thing is mafia completely ignored 666's bodyguard softclaim, for whatever reason.

Exactly why I don't like it. Mafia can use it against town every time someone gets caught for minor inconsistencies in his posts.

I really dislike the bandwagon on Aeres right now because of LAL. YOU SHOULD LYNCH SOMEONE BECAUSE YOU THINK THEY ARE SCUM NOT STUPID LAL.

If Aeres flips town, I will go batshit crazy on all the people that bandwagoned him.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 21:38 GMT
#2204
I didn't know that we were back into the "ifs and "what ifs" circle again
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 21:58 GMT
#2216
ENOUGH WIFOM argument please...
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 22:06 GMT
#2220
On November 03 2010 07:02 KtheZ wrote:
#vote Aeres

Looks like we have another lurker again
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 02 2010 23:50 GMT
#2277
On November 03 2010 08:45 Coagulation wrote:
also im wondering exactly how many blues are you allowed to lynch before its justifiable for us to question you?

is there a number?


I would say that if DrH fails to confirm himself this night phase.

This is the part where I say "I told you so"

And the part where I go batshit crazy. Seriously, we don't fucking lynch FOR BAD TOWNIE PLAY, WE LYNCH FOR SCUM PLAY. It was pretty obvious that aeres did the former.

So I really want to lynch the people who started the bandwagon now, but I guess it will have to wait until next day phase.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 00:21 GMT
#2297
On November 03 2010 09:16 bumatlarge wrote:
Here are some theories also. Rolebloker targetted Dr.H we assume, right? Dr.H is immune to M-rus. Mafia has a now dead PD. I think mafia is very conservative in their actions for fear of the virus. Which makes me think that town is likely to have a virus spreading role if they found some unprecedented infected.

I suggest a medic considers dr. h as a target, since he is immune and becoming a clearer townie day by day.

M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it.

As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night:
1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard
2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched.
3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 00:23 GMT
#2301
I think we should stop WIFOMing about whether or not youngminii is red based on what Artanis might add to the circle.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 00:41 GMT
#2306
On November 03 2010 09:21 Nemesis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 09:16 bumatlarge wrote:
Here are some theories also. Rolebloker targetted Dr.H we assume, right? Dr.H is immune to M-rus. Mafia has a now dead PD. I think mafia is very conservative in their actions for fear of the virus. Which makes me think that town is likely to have a virus spreading role if they found some unprecedented infected.

I suggest a medic considers dr. h as a target, since he is immune and becoming a clearer townie day by day.

M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it.

As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night:
1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard
2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched.
3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive.

Hmm actually I suggest to CubedIn to protect DCLXVI, because that would confirm his role + he can tell us if DCLXVI was actually hit as he is the only known medic at this point.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 01:58 GMT
#2347
On November 03 2010 09:51 CubEdIn wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 09:41 Nemesis wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:21 Nemesis wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:16 bumatlarge wrote:
Here are some theories also. Rolebloker targetted Dr.H we assume, right? Dr.H is immune to M-rus. Mafia has a now dead PD. I think mafia is very conservative in their actions for fear of the virus. Which makes me think that town is likely to have a virus spreading role if they found some unprecedented infected.

I suggest a medic considers dr. h as a target, since he is immune and becoming a clearer townie day by day.

M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it.

As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night:
1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard
2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched.
3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive.

Hmm actually I suggest to CubedIn to protect DCLXVI, because that would confirm his role + he can tell us if DCLXVI was actually hit as he is the only known medic at this point.


Yeah that sounds good and all, as long as someone protects me. I don't really care for DCL THAT much at this point, honestly. Maybe if he'd post more often..

Don't forget that by doing this you will most likely confirm your role too.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 02:38 GMT
#2349
On November 03 2010 11:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 10:58 Nemesis wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:51 CubEdIn wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:41 Nemesis wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:21 Nemesis wrote:
On November 03 2010 09:16 bumatlarge wrote:
Here are some theories also. Rolebloker targetted Dr.H we assume, right? Dr.H is immune to M-rus. Mafia has a now dead PD. I think mafia is very conservative in their actions for fear of the virus. Which makes me think that town is likely to have a virus spreading role if they found some unprecedented infected.

I suggest a medic considers dr. h as a target, since he is immune and becoming a clearer townie day by day.

M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it.

As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night:
1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard
2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched.
3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive.

Hmm actually I suggest to CubedIn to protect DCLXVI, because that would confirm his role + he can tell us if DCLXVI was actually hit as he is the only known medic at this point.


Yeah that sounds good and all, as long as someone protects me. I don't really care for DCL THAT much at this point, honestly. Maybe if he'd post more often..

Don't forget that by doing this you will most likely confirm your role too.


Well, this worries me and it doesn't. Assigning blue roles in thread isn't always the smartest thing (as I learned in Haunted) because then Mafia knows what's going on. Downside is we have no PMs, so we don't really have much choice.

One thing good that we will learn is whether or not the +1 Mafia KP can be protected against (as we are assuming this is what Node is predicting). I assume it probably can be, but it would definitely be nice to know for sure.

Well seeing as the DCLXVI kill is predetermined in the beginning of the day post if Node is not lying, I doubt mafia can change that.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 23:26 GMT
#2521
DoctorH, any news on your poking confirmation?

Well I'll be back after dinner
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 03 2010 23:51 GMT
#2547
On November 04 2010 08:29 infinitestory wrote:
Points Of Note in this day post:
1) No additional infections. How the hell did that happen?
2) Someone was protected. I find it highly likely that was DC.
3) Bum's dead. Fuck.
4) jcarlsoniv was Elder. Fuck.
5) hey there Glasse, what did you send for the radio? Also, why is LOONY decapitalized and spelled different?
6) 3 (?) people tried to force their way into houses and failed. Whaaaat? And that extra guy on the rooftops?
7) Someone else was out of town. That's definitely NOT Aeres this time.
8) A silenced shot killed bum? Could that mean something?
9) hello mayor, help us lynch a baddie!

1. I'm gueesing that mafia don't have a role that can give infection, and the first 3 infection was RNG, so the only way for infection to spread is through visiting.
Are we told about the person being infected if someone infected dies?
2.most likely
3. Fuck.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:11 GMT
#2583
Things are moving rather fast

I think it was pretty obvious that bum was gonna die soon, because of his roleclaim. Too many people roleclaiming-.-

Also, Pandain, you better hurry up with that "confirm your role" promise of yours. I think that you might very well have until next day phase before you get lynched.

If we vote for double lynch today, does that mean that we get double lynch the next day phase? Also how does double lynch work: do the two people with the most votes get lynched? Do we get to vote twice for double lynch?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:14 GMT
#2588
On November 04 2010 09:12 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 09:11 Nemesis wrote:
Things are moving rather fast

I think it was pretty obvious that bum was gonna die soon, because of his roleclaim. Too many people roleclaiming-.-

Also, Pandain, you better hurry up with that "confirm your role" promise of yours. I think that you might very well have until next day phase before you get lynched.

If we vote for double lynch today, does that mean that we get double lynch the next day phase? Also how does double lynch work: do the two people with the most votes get lynched? Do we get to vote twice for double lynch?

yes and yes

dunno fi we can use it twice in a row

it starts tomorrow. we each vote for two targets and the top two die.

I don't mean twice in a row, but if there is a double lynch this day phase, do we get to vote twice on who to lynch?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:15 GMT
#2594
On November 04 2010 09:11 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I'm positive Veldril is Town. He brought up lynching Divinek out of the blue.

If we lynch an inactive it should be RoL or Kenpachi

I'm also really uncomfortable about how few posts infundibulum has

Kenpachi is banned so he doesn't really have a choice of coming out of lurking. As for RoL, didn't he sub for another player?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:17 GMT
#2597
On November 04 2010 09:14 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 09:14 Nemesis wrote:
On November 04 2010 09:12 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On November 04 2010 09:11 Nemesis wrote:
Things are moving rather fast

I think it was pretty obvious that bum was gonna die soon, because of his roleclaim. Too many people roleclaiming-.-

Also, Pandain, you better hurry up with that "confirm your role" promise of yours. I think that you might very well have until next day phase before you get lynched.

If we vote for double lynch today, does that mean that we get double lynch the next day phase? Also how does double lynch work: do the two people with the most votes get lynched? Do we get to vote twice for double lynch?

yes and yes

dunno fi we can use it twice in a row

it starts tomorrow. we each vote for two targets and the top two die.

I don't mean twice in a row, but if there is a double lynch this day phase, do we get to vote twice on who to lynch?


it activtes next day phase and you vote for two different targets, you can't stack 2 votes on the same target
Ok thanks, hmm should we activate double lynch for next day phase?
so tomorrow you would vote

Vote: player x
Vote: player y

like that

Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:18 GMT
#2598
Oops it seems that my post didn't go through

Should we use double lynch next day phase then?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:33 GMT
#2610
Ha! I just realized that I will probably be one of the most suspicious if Pandain does turn out to be a mafia since I was one of the 2 people that voted for him other than Coagulation. I guess I'll just have to deal with it when the time comes.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 00:36 GMT
#2615
On November 04 2010 09:34 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 09:33 Nemesis wrote:
Ha! I just realized that I will probably be one of the most suspicious if Pandain does turn out to be a mafia since I was one of the 2 people that voted for him other than Coagulation. I guess I'll just have to deal with it when the time comes.

wtf? how does that work?

I meant I was one of the few who voted for him for mayor along with Coag.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 01:28 GMT
#2661
On November 04 2010 09:39 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Nemesis voted for him immediately iirc. Deconduo also voted for Pandain.

Just wondering what is iirc?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 01:41 GMT
#2684
On November 04 2010 10:34 Coagulation wrote:
think about the name that came back "mafia retard"
dont waste your lynch on me.

Yes I was waiting for your defense for being a retard XD


On November 04 2010 10:03 L wrote:
Nemesis starts off the game pretty apologetic. Makes a case for the mayor being super dangerous, then realizes that the mayor gets an extra vote, not an extra lynch.

He asks fishball's circle to reveal itself to confirm fishball during the elections.

Some M-rus related posts.

Supports pandain on the account that he's a good communicator, but easy to spot as mafia.

Skeptical of DrH's ability to be confirmed. Says he doesn't trust him.

Pushes on Orgolove and Youngmiini as his top 2 scumreads.

Comes out against roleclaiming, despite having asked the fishball crew to step up earlier.

Wow. I'm only halfway through but this is looking pretty bad.

Going to LoL is up for a bit, I'll finish soon.

I can't wait ^.^ Just note the first part is already made up. I didn't start the game apologetically.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 01:43 GMT
#2690
On November 04 2010 10:39 Pandain wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 10:31 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
pandain at this point you really need to roleclaim and do the thing where you "indirectly confirm you are town" to all of us

you know, like you promised you could?

I did it when you brought me under suspicion. Now it's your turn :D


Alright, actually I might as well roleclaim since in all honesty either you or Infinitestory is going to die tonight, so I'm pretty safe.

I'm trash collector. Every night I find out the results of a random person's alignment.

Results:
Night 1 infinite, safe
Night two, nemesis, safe

Wow you really want to bring me down with you

Which part of your role can you use to "confir yourself later on?"
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 01:48 GMT
#2700
On November 04 2010 10:47 Pandain wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 10:47 Ace wrote:
@Infinitestory: Sorry my mistake then. I just remember talking to bum via PM before updating the thread.

@Dr.H: No point in even going further with this. Let's go back to Day 1:

When Dr.H claims that he has a role that can confirm himself to be town, Pandain also does the same. Pandain also says even if he doesn't get Mayor, he'd be able to do this.

Now, it's Day 3 and Pandain doesn't reveal the result of any of this until now. When I read his posts on Day 1, it sounded like his role could be instantly confirmed pro-town and not something that would rely on random chance.

So if Pandain knows his role relied on random chance then why did he seem so sure he could confirm himself easily?


1.I said it would take a couple days
2.I said it would be indirect

And can you tell us exactly how you were planning on confirming yourself?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 03:16 GMT
#2807
On November 04 2010 12:13 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 12:10 Ace wrote:
On November 04 2010 11:53 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I say we lynch Ace and KtheZ if pandain flips blue. If he flips red we lynch Nemesis and Deconduo.

that's why we should use a vig hit IMO


Excuse me? Explain sir.

I'm not impressed with your "scumhunting" in this game, you're basically picking the weakest targets. I feel like if mafia were going to hit any experienced player it would be you first and you didn't roleclaim to bumatlarge even though he was probably the surest blue in the game and the only one you could PM with (to our knowledge)

If you're mafia you'd also be the ideal person to save with a bus. It comes down to the lynch turnout but if pandain turns blue I don't have a better target besides perhaps infinitestory.

Except if Coag flips red, infinitestory is pretty much confirmed.

Looks like, town is set on lynching me if Pandain turns up red. I'll see if I can change your minds if he does indeed turn up red.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 03:44 GMT
#2840
On November 04 2010 12:33 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 12:24 DCLXVI wrote:
Well Doc, you guessed it. Coag was right, I am just trying to save him. Because any real mafia would go to that length to save a teammate who has given up like coag has...

And how does it waste lynches? YOu have already stated that you want to lynch pandain and you seem sure he is mafia, why can't you lynch him today and me tomorrow? I mean if I'm lying then you lynch 2 reds(panda/me) - then coag so 3 reds overall, if I am telling the truth you lynch a red(panda) and one other dies as well(coag) as another scummy player(not sure yet) and me. Seems like it is much better for the town that way, if we just do it your way(coag/panda) then you just get the same result as me lying except you don't know if Im red or blue


You're right. I'm trying to consider what kind of advantage mafia could get from doing this and there isn't one. Why go to that length to save coagulation who is clearly their worst player?

I'll switch my vote to Pandain. I say we go with DC's plan.

what's preventing mafia from hitting you and blowing up your bombs preemptively? Does your bomb switch occur before a hit does?

I'm sorry doc, but you seem to be all over the place now. You are even suspecting DC who was saved by a medic from a mafia hit, and you seem so set that mafia had to have set up that huge shithole in day 2 against you and even pointing inifinitestory who will most likely be confirmed tonight.

Considering all possible situations are fine, but you seem to be running around in a circle of WIFOM right now.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 21:58 GMT
#2899
On November 05 2010 05:43 L wrote:
Re: Nemesis.

This is the portion during which you get apologetic.

Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 03:12 Nemesis wrote:
On October 30 2010 02:58 annul wrote:
its what, 2 votes? if the vote is close enough (like, 16-14) where my one vote will tip the scale, then perhaps it is not "stupid" to have voted it, right?

the mayoral role is not really a town leader position. it's an extra set of lives and a very weak voting power that can be overcome easily (and is 100% transparent). i am playing along with the leadership meme because hey it makes sense, but think about what POWER the mayor has. the only power it has is protection and a weak voting boost. any other leadership that the town chooses to assign to the mayor player is entirely on their own volition.

why do we want to give death protection to a mason? there is no real reason we want to keep the masons alive above someone else who can actually affect things, right? so he has a circle, cool, what does that do for us and why would his death hurt the town, per se?

if i died it would be much worse than a random mason dying, that is all i am saying. are there others out there with roles better suited to protection? probably. but they aren't talking, so i will.

My bad, it seems that I misunderstood the mayor role. I thought they get to lynch one extra person.

Lol, I made a misunderstanding early in the game and make on post that i made a mistake and that makes me apologetic early on in the game. You are one funny man.

After repeated oneliners clarifying rules to other players with no submissions of your own, you start trying to produce real content around the 300 post mark. You then realize your arguments are pretty ridiculous and back off quickly.
Can you at least please point that out. Looking at around the 300 post, my posts are about clarifying people's candidacy for mayor and I was asking them how they can disprove my doubts. I wasn't really arguing.

Its not super incriminating, but its odd that someone who's staring at the rules wouldn't know that the mayor gets an extra vote and not an extra lynch.
I am pretty new to mafia(although I've played it irl), so I don't exactly know all the roles and what they do, which is why I was asking about the rules and stuff. This is my second game here and this game has a different format than last game.


Around the 2k post mark you shift back to one liners and ask other people to do analysis on certain players. You say you're too lazy to do it yourself.
I only asked an analysis on misder as far as I remember, how does that turn into "players"?

You also trip yourself up when you state that you're all for lynching inactives to get them to post, but then you turn around immediately and say that LAL makes no sense because it targets liars rather than scum. Why use one heuristic over the other? You never really make the argument. And that's not just a single point; there are multiple posts of yours on this front.
I never made the argument, because no one asked me too. Those were during different phases of the game. I had forgotten about inactives as most of them have died already at that point. Inactives don't contribute to the game at all if they are townies. It also allows for a place for mafia to hide, and we have no way of knowing which is mafia and which is not.

Lying on the other hand can be beneficial to town if used correctly, and if someone is caught in a lie, you just have to read the intention of the lie to determine whether that lie was supposed to benefit the townie or mafia. Aeres' lie was clearly meant to benefit the town even if it was dumb which was why I was against lynching him.

Does that answer your question?


The 2200 series of posts are pretty much a rehash. Against LAL, targetting inactives and clearing up rules questions. Mostly in one liners. In the 2300 section, he pushes for cube to prot DC, which is reasonable regardless of his alignment.

The 2500 are a bit more interesting. There's a focus on M-rus and asking pandain to confirm himself + questions about double lynches. This is prior to pandain having a bus driven at him. The rest of the posts are literally one liners regarding inactives or in another instance just a quote from DrH. There's a LOT of chaff in these posts.
Look above. Anything suspicious about asking how the game works?

Nemesis opens into the 2600 section by stating that he'll look bad if pandain flips red. There's more one liners including a one liner rebuke of my first post, then s'more another question for pandain, regarding how he can confirm himself.

Overall Nemesis's concrete actions aren't unreasonable after the halfway point during his posts. But there's a problem: he doesn't really do much even when he is posting. There's a lot (a LOT) of one-two line posts that parrot other players, and the majority of his posting seems to be a combination of talking about the rules, and lightly incriminating people who are unlikely to retaliate.
I am just observing for now. I am just "lightly" incriminating people for now as I haven't decided to lynch them. If I decide to lynch them, then I'll be more aggresive. That's just my play style.

Anyways, Take a skim through his posts and tell me if you agree.

Overall, you seem to EXAGGERATE a lot of the stuff that I said. Really? I make one post about making a misunderstanding and you call that "early on, he was pretty apologetic." You might also want to include more quotes of my post if you want to have a proper analysis.

I don't really know what to think of you at this point as you seem to have mostly skimmed over my post and make your opinions based on that. Since you were subbed in, I will give you the benefit of a doubt that you just didn't understand the situation at the time my early posts were made.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 04 2010 23:01 GMT
#2909
On November 05 2010 07:58 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
it would only make sense if they were stalling for LYLO which they can't at this point, unless there is a suicide bomber gambit happening but that doesn't make sense either


What's lylo?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 05 2010 00:32 GMT
#2912
On November 05 2010 09:02 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 05 2010 06:58 Nemesis wrote:
On November 05 2010 05:43 L wrote:
Re: Nemesis.

This is the portion during which you get apologetic.

On October 30 2010 03:12 Nemesis wrote:
On October 30 2010 02:58 annul wrote:
its what, 2 votes? if the vote is close enough (like, 16-14) where my one vote will tip the scale, then perhaps it is not "stupid" to have voted it, right?

the mayoral role is not really a town leader position. it's an extra set of lives and a very weak voting power that can be overcome easily (and is 100% transparent). i am playing along with the leadership meme because hey it makes sense, but think about what POWER the mayor has. the only power it has is protection and a weak voting boost. any other leadership that the town chooses to assign to the mayor player is entirely on their own volition.

why do we want to give death protection to a mason? there is no real reason we want to keep the masons alive above someone else who can actually affect things, right? so he has a circle, cool, what does that do for us and why would his death hurt the town, per se?

if i died it would be much worse than a random mason dying, that is all i am saying. are there others out there with roles better suited to protection? probably. but they aren't talking, so i will.

My bad, it seems that I misunderstood the mayor role. I thought they get to lynch one extra person.

Lol, I made a misunderstanding early in the game and make on post that i made a mistake and that makes me apologetic early on in the game. You are one funny man.

After repeated oneliners clarifying rules to other players with no submissions of your own, you start trying to produce real content around the 300 post mark. You then realize your arguments are pretty ridiculous and back off quickly.
Can you at least please point that out. Looking at around the 300 post, my posts are about clarifying people's candidacy for mayor and I was asking them how they can disprove my doubts. I wasn't really arguing.

Its not super incriminating, but its odd that someone who's staring at the rules wouldn't know that the mayor gets an extra vote and not an extra lynch.
I am pretty new to mafia(although I've played it irl), so I don't exactly know all the roles and what they do, which is why I was asking about the rules and stuff. This is my second game here and this game has a different format than last game.


Around the 2k post mark you shift back to one liners and ask other people to do analysis on certain players. You say you're too lazy to do it yourself.
I only asked an analysis on misder as far as I remember, how does that turn into "players"?

You also trip yourself up when you state that you're all for lynching inactives to get them to post, but then you turn around immediately and say that LAL makes no sense because it targets liars rather than scum. Why use one heuristic over the other? You never really make the argument. And that's not just a single point; there are multiple posts of yours on this front.
I never made the argument, because no one asked me too. Those were during different phases of the game. I had forgotten about inactives as most of them have died already at that point. Inactives don't contribute to the game at all if they are townies. It also allows for a place for mafia to hide, and we have no way of knowing which is mafia and which is not.

Lying on the other hand can be beneficial to town if used correctly, and if someone is caught in a lie, you just have to read the intention of the lie to determine whether that lie was supposed to benefit the townie or mafia. Aeres' lie was clearly meant to benefit the town even if it was dumb which was why I was against lynching him.

Does that answer your question?


The 2200 series of posts are pretty much a rehash. Against LAL, targetting inactives and clearing up rules questions. Mostly in one liners. In the 2300 section, he pushes for cube to prot DC, which is reasonable regardless of his alignment.

The 2500 are a bit more interesting. There's a focus on M-rus and asking pandain to confirm himself + questions about double lynches. This is prior to pandain having a bus driven at him. The rest of the posts are literally one liners regarding inactives or in another instance just a quote from DrH. There's a LOT of chaff in these posts.
Look above. Anything suspicious about asking how the game works?

Nemesis opens into the 2600 section by stating that he'll look bad if pandain flips red. There's more one liners including a one liner rebuke of my first post, then s'more another question for pandain, regarding how he can confirm himself.

Overall Nemesis's concrete actions aren't unreasonable after the halfway point during his posts. But there's a problem: he doesn't really do much even when he is posting. There's a lot (a LOT) of one-two line posts that parrot other players, and the majority of his posting seems to be a combination of talking about the rules, and lightly incriminating people who are unlikely to retaliate.
I am just observing for now. I am just "lightly" incriminating people for now as I haven't decided to lynch them. If I decide to lynch them, then I'll be more aggresive. That's just my play style.

Anyways, Take a skim through his posts and tell me if you agree.

Overall, you seem to EXAGGERATE a lot of the stuff that I said. Really? I make one post about making a misunderstanding and you call that "early on, he was pretty apologetic." You might also want to include more quotes of my post if you want to have a proper analysis.

I don't really know what to think of you at this point as you seem to have mostly skimmed over my post and make your opinions based on that. Since you were subbed in, I will give you the benefit of a doubt that you just didn't understand the situation at the time my early posts were made.

If anything, I understated the majority of the claims I made.

I grouped most of your posts together by post number in the thread, and they're readily accessible here:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/search.php?q=&t=c&f=-1&u=Nemesis&gb=date

Trying to tell me that you're 'just observing' or whatnot doesn't explain why you're making 1 liner me-toos chaff posts. Additionally, if you are just observing why would you be lightly incriminating people? Seems like you just want to have future targets to pick off later without taking responsibility for throwing suspicion on them.
I am trying to get some information out of them, is that a bad thing?

Its silly that your defense here only reinforces the scum-like qualities that were pointed out.

To reply to a few points of yours:
"I didn't bother making the argument because no one asked me to"
Yeah, that's because you were me-tooing me. That doesn't cut it. Its a way of trying to appear active while trying to not take any responsibility.
Lol, let me give you an analogy on your crappy point: If you were arguing about how good this movie is a week ago, and someone claims that the worst movie you have ever seen is "the best movie" ever, would you concentrate on comparing it to the 'good' movie that you saw last week or would you concentrate on points on why that movie is crap? Not the best analogy ever, but you get my point. Wtf would be the point of me trying to compare LAL to lynch inactive. I wasn't trying to make people switch to lynch inactive 'mode' at that time, I was just trying to get them to steer away from that direction.

"I only asked an analysis on misder as far as I remember, how does that turn into "players"?"
The important part isn't the plural, its the fact that you, with all your free observing time, decided it was a good idea to ask other people to do work instead of do it yourself. Its pretty a pretty standard way to play as mafia; tell the town to do useful things, but rejoice silently as they don't bother doing it. That way the town's at a net neutral position, but you end up looking both active and pro-town without actually having contributed anything.
No, it is important as you were exagerating shit that isn't true.

If you were busy in the slightest, this might be excusable, but you readily admit you're just sitting around doing nothing for the sake of watching people.

"I am pretty new to mafia(although I've played it irl), so I don't exactly know all the roles and what they do, which is why I was asking about the rules and stuff."
Very odd excuse given your prior posting, when you were almost zealous in your will to clear up rule issues. Again, like I said, this isn't conclusive proof that you're mafia, but it sets up the claim that I was really hoping you wouldn't make; the "i'm bad at mafia" claim. The clueless newbie persona is a rather common one with new players who are on mafia's side; its easy, low maintenance, and it rarely brings attention to yourself.
I didn't say I was bad at mafia, I just wanted some clarification on some rules that I didn't know how it worked.

So yeah, this last post just made my suspicions worse, given that you confirmed pretty much every tentative theme I had noticed in your posts.

And yes if you actually want to know I am actually quite busy right now irl. I have midterms last week and I have one last midterm this wednesday(I'll probably go inactive around tuesday). I check tl mafia everytime I take a break from studying 'hence my one liner posts.' I didn't mention this, because I know that you are just going to use this against me saying "you're just making up excuses now." But I guess it doesn't matter eitherway as you still try to paint me as red either way.

This is the last time I'm replying to you as to not shit up this thread like what happened during the Pandain/Doctor H/Infinitestory circle. I feel like you will just be making the same points over and over again. You have made your point. I have made my point, there's nothing left that I have to argue about.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 02:02 GMT
#3193
On November 06 2010 10:58 youngminii wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 06 2010 10:10 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
On November 06 2010 09:42 infinitestory wrote:
On November 06 2010 09:05 L wrote:
Bomb*

If the MH loses a bomb because the person it's on is lynched, does he get it back?

Should there be one in the game, then yes. They would get their bomb back.

wait what

changing my vote to coag

WTF, you were planning to change your vote to coag after learning that Mad Hatter will lose their bomb if coag is lynched?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 02:03 GMT
#3195
On November 06 2010 11:02 Nemesis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 06 2010 10:58 youngminii wrote:
On November 06 2010 10:10 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
On November 06 2010 09:42 infinitestory wrote:
On November 06 2010 09:05 L wrote:
Bomb*

If the MH loses a bomb because the person it's on is lynched, does he get it back?

Should there be one in the game, then yes. They would get their bomb back.

wait what

changing my vote to coag

WTF, you were planning to change your vote to coag after learning that Mad Hatter will lose their bomb if coag is lynched?

Edit: Nvm, it seems I didn't read the post properly
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 02:15 GMT
#3199
On November 06 2010 11:11 Hyperbola wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 06 2010 11:06 infinitestory wrote:
On November 06 2010 11:02 Hyperbola wrote:
We need someone who is good at mafia but terrible at manipulation.

pandain is probably the best candidate under these parameters. he is an extremely organized and tactical scum hunter his analyses skills are good and he has a good level head about what needs to be done.

i have also noticed that he is a terrible lier and his posting style makes his motives extremely transparent. this would make it much easier for us to spot a slip up if he is mafia. and greatly increases the chances that he would fail at getting away with scum moves if it turns out he is a red.


DocH You basically said YOU WILL PROVE your town and then basically said "MAYBE DEPENDING ON WHAT HAPPENS I WILL PROVE IT IM NOT SURE"

I dont think pandain would be the greatest mayor
However
i would rather pandain then Annul and his manipulation if he is RED
and i would rather pandain then fishbowl and his "EXTREMELY SHY?? circle"
I would really really like for you to make me feel comfortable voting for you for mayor. but your doing a bad job so far.


Now i am sticking with pandain because he is most likely not a red trying to gain control of town based on the fact that he is not campaigning relentlessly.


Pandain is more then capable of using what tools he has at his disposal to help coordinate a good town strategy and i doubt he would run for mayor if he thought his role wasnt capable of contributing greatly as mayor.. and I FEEL HE is the most TRUSTWORTHY candidate so far BASED ON HIS ACTIONS IN THIS GAME. I Dont get the same feeling from you when your Threatening "FOS" On anyone that doesnt vote you..


IM NOT VOTING on WHOS PROMISING SOME BULLSHIT IF THEY GET MAYOR (town circle?? where??)
IM VOTING ON WHO I TRUST THE MOST IN MY GUT

IS THAT REASON ENOUGH?


Dodging a lynch sounds alot like a scum role.. anyone else think so?


OK i have caught up on reading

1. DOCH naturally I still cant trust you 100% until I can see some of your claims of verifying yourself come to light. I really hope your not a red otherwise we may as well just bend over and let you get to fucking.

2. you have a moron for a bodyguard

3. Node is asking for invites to the circle? i would think twice before letting people who request in. looks like 1 red was already in the circle. he dies and now Node starts asking to get in?(could be mafia trying to get a man back inside)
looks bad but not gonna dwell on it too much yet..

4. pandain I dunno what the hell you are talking about. Im not gonna keep my mouth shut if someone looks scummy just because they are not around to defend themselves.


dt needs to investigate pandain for sure considering he was running for mayor.

also the other people who wanted elected mayor
bumatlarge
fishball
annul
ghrur
glasse
node

also worth keeping an eye on node who is asking for people to invite him into circle.


well regardless we need to get to the bottom of the youngminii thing somehow i think thats the point hes trying to make. i still feel like there is a good possibility that his ability is either a red ability or he was saved by a red allie. i dont want this to just blow under the radar





@Glasse
no your right. for the most part however your "cat like" actions are more along the lines of when the cat shits in your sock drawer. the sock drawer being this thread.

Not sure if anybody analyzed Coagulation's post history extensively before, but now that he's flipped scum I believe it's worthwhile. I did not quote all of his posts but I did quote all relevant to my conclusions. Also Coag got the 1337 post.

Ok so solely based off of Coagulation's post history I've discerned the following.

1. Pandain is almost certainly scum (common opinion at this point). Coagulation supports Pandain all throughout his election and shits on the other candidates. I only quoted some of his posts but he has maaany in support of Pandain.

2. Doctor Helvetica is almost certainly innocent. Coagulation spent the entire thread accusing DocH. If he was a fellow scum then Coagulation, as the prime accuser, might have single handedly caused DocH to get lyched due to all of his attacks. Thus, the probability is low.

3. Youngminii is almost certainly town. Coag again attacks him repeatedly throughout the thread and always tries to draw attention to him.

4. Node is probably innocent and not lying. Although I thought he was suspicious before, Node's credibility is questioned by Coag more than once in the thread.

5. Glasse is probably town aligned. He badmouths Glasse a few times in the thread. Not very strong but there's nothing on Glasse to prove otherwise.


just at a glance, one major thing wrong is that if X shows animosity towards Y, that doesn't mean X and Y are opposite alignments. Same if X shows support for Y, that doesn't mean they're the same alignment. This is especially relevant for points 4 and 5 IMO

I actually considered this. Not to be insulting to Coagulation, but I didn't think him the type of player to use reverse logic as you are suggesting. As for number 4, he has a decent amount of posts against Node to discourage him from joining the mailman circle and questions his credibility. I don't think someone would do that as reverse psychology for a role as sensitive as Node's.

That is called WIFOM. Remember that Coag is not alone in his posting. So even if he might not be smart enough to think of that himself, his mafia friends probably are and could have easily told him to do so.

I don't think we can conclude anything based on coag's post at this point.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 02:56 GMT
#3201
On November 06 2010 11:48 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
coagulation isn't good enough to play mind games

Yes, but you are forgetting that his mafia buddies could be telling him what to say.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 16:47 GMT
#3217
I.S. can prove his role to us by telling us the "role" of one blue in the game and they can confirm that, but not what they can do. Although we might be able to figure out what that role could do just by its name, so I'm not sure I'm up for that plan. But if he can find a way to make the person confirm that he is telling the truth, then it might work.

Since we have double lynch next day phase, we need to start talking about who we are planning to lynch.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 17:52 GMT
#3221
On November 07 2010 02:26 CubEdIn wrote:
Also, why would the mafia hit you (Pandain)? You're one of the prime suspects in tomorrow's lynching. Why waste a hit on you if you're blue? Just saying.

Also, @ Nemesis' "I.S. can prove his role to us by telling us the "role" of one blue in the game and they can confirm that, but not what they can do."

If he were red, he could just tell us that a fellow mafia is blue, and that fellow mafia would go "yeah he's right, I am -random role-". Both confirmed = win?
It's a fairly easy role to fake, but I don't think he faked it. But we'll see as the game moves on.

Well if we find out that he is lying, then that would be a free mafia for us.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 06 2010 23:54 GMT
#3263
On November 07 2010 08:53 kitaman27 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 08:49 KtheZ wrote:
Of course I'm not 100% sure if I am an insane detective. Maybe i only have a 50% chance of mixing it up. However, I do confirm infinitestory as ADD Detective and thus as town.

You being insane is the only thing that makes sense.


I have a question. Why check infinitestory when he has already claimed and proven his role? That doesn't add up.[/QUOTE]
That was night 2, meaning before he claimed his role

Also, NODE HAS SOME EXPLAINING TO DO
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 00:06 GMT
#3276
Hmm, yeah I guess it is plausible that Beneather indeed placed his doll on DrH and NB got protected. Can NB confirm if he was protected?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 00:07 GMT
#3279
On November 07 2010 09:06 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 09:06 Nemesis wrote:
Hmm, yeah I guess it is plausible that Beneather indeed placed his doll on DrH and NB got protected. Can NB confirm if he was protected?

I thought he just said he was?

Oops, I'm bad at reading XD
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 00:51 GMT
#3298
Ok a few things to note is if Pandain is confirmed townie by KtheZ, then I am also confirmed townie since Pandain has scanned me to be townie.

Next is it's time to scumhunt. Right now, my lynch target is L. He made up shit to try and make me look red. I would understand his suspicion on me at the time when Pandain was also getting suspected of, but most of his arguments were made up so I am really suspicious of him.

Also, he tried to put suspicion into CubedIn by saying that the role he was claiming was "impossible for mod to give a role like that" and that CubedIn was lying.

He is either a really bad scumhunter, or red trying too hard to get innocent people lynched.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 01:22 GMT
#3300
Ok I just took a look at deconduo's post in this game and here are a few things that I've noted so far

On November 03 2010 02:29 deconduo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 02:27 CubEdIn wrote:
So you don't think that the mafia knowing that I'm a doctor is a negative?
Basically, I'm a "goto" target each night, and if I want to live, I need to self-protect myself a lot. Thus making my role almost useless.
I don't see why you think anyone else (other than the mayor/bodyguards, maybe) would make a better target than a 100% confirmed by mods doctor.

IMO, by role-claiming, I just leveled the playing field a bit.


I think L's point is that no one would have any reason to pick normal townie, so why were you given the choice if it isn't really a choice.

Hmm lightly supporting L's condemnation of CubedIn based on WIFOM on what mod would do

On November 04 2010 09:50 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 09:39 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Nemesis voted for him immediately iirc. Deconduo also voted for Pandain.

I'll look at his post history then. Gimme a few min.

Also, L did an analysis on me after DoctorH said he was suspicious of me and deconduo, but somehow he only did an analysis on me and not on deconduo.

Voting for L now.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 02:11 GMT
#3301
On November 07 2010 08:57 NB wrote:
OMG, IM ALIVE xD.... Thank you medic :3....

i was assuming that ima die and didnt post anything, sorry guys T_T

NB did you actually get a message that you were protected by medic or did you just assume that you were since you didn't die seeing as DrH was actually switch with someone(most likely you) by bus driver and died because of it?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 04:23 GMT
#3313
Hyperbola has really been inactive this game. Here is DoctorH's analysis on hyperbola. It is not the most solid argument ever, but since we need to lynch two people for today, I will put my vote on him for now until someone else convinces me otherwise or I find a better target.
+ Show Spoiler +

On November 05 2010 03:02 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Here's everyone who hasn't voted yet afaik:
Lexpar
Hyperbola
Amber[LighT]
Beneather
Coagulation

Hyperbola has been SUPER inactive this game, but isn't that off considering he ran for mayor on the basis of his great analysis and being a good player (rather than his role):
Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 07:47 Hyperbola wrote:
Citizens of Insania,

I would like to announce my candidacy for mayor. In light of recent events, most importantly the town's development of many new powers, a new system of government must emerge to quell the chaos that is this town. It has come to our attention that the local mafia has begun to exploit their new abilities and are now aiming for total control of this fine community. In order to successfully repel them, a properly organized inner circle of supertownies must be established. This new circle needs leadership and commitment, and I believe I am the man for the job.

Vote for Order! Vote Hyperbola!



Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 09:45 Hyperbola wrote:
On October 29 2010 08:29 bumatlarge wrote:
On October 29 2010 07:47 Hyperbola wrote:
Citizens of Insania,

I would like to announce my candidacy for mayor. In light of recent events, most importantly the town's development of many new powers, a new system of government must emerge to quell the chaos that is this town. It has come to our attention that the local mafia has begun to exploit their new abilities and are now aiming for total control of this fine community. In order to successfully repel them, a properly organized inner circle of supertownies must be established. This new circle needs leadership and commitment, and I believe I am the man for the job.

Vote for Order! Vote Hyperbola!


On October 29 2010 07:49 CubEdIn wrote:
*heads to the voting thread to vote for Hyperbola*

*giggles*


See, this is bad, we can't have this. Look how much nonsense he spouted. No of that means anything. IT MEANS NOTHING. Then this dude just votes for him? Sorry charlie not having it. You need to be voting for me.

If I am not voed in, I will be
Then I will become a Pandain/BM (without the getting modkilled part) and just bug everyone.

But if I am! I will be :D
Everything will go under my scrutinizer eye and no one will get any biased treatment. Except for maybe Ace, who I owe some respect for that penalty mafia game. He's allowed to do his own thing and not vote for me.

An interesting strategy. You call me out on my magnificent speech and then proceed to say almost nothing yourself. Then you direct attention away from yourself and give the illusion of trying to help town by saying random things about the game. I don't think Cube was being serious when he posted that, but I however, was.
I am very adept at organization and strategic play. Although I may have not been in as many mafia games and tend to stay quiet, I can still manage a team and have done so in games I was mafia in. The same skills can apply to town if we are able to sort out who's who and create a legitimate town circle. Furthermore, I am very adept at sorting out what's what's legitimate and what's bullshit. Unless there are some specific roles which may overcome my keen eye, I can guarantee you that there will be NO leaks in the town circle if I am voted mayor.
As for the issue of whether I am mafia or not... you can be damn well sure that the first person to announce their candidacy for mayor as I did had better be really fucking good at defending themselves from clues if they're mafia. Other than that fact, I cannot guarantee anything. But that is what most elections are: a leap of faith.


A hostile defense and further claims that he is a good scumhunter with a keen eye. No leaks in the town circle? What town circle, considering as far as we know you can't PM? Odd post.

He's called out on that later and then claims town could probably talk on irc but Artanis tells him nope.

Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 10:24 Hyperbola wrote:
All this setback does is simply show that many things can technically be exploited in this game, with the influx of new abilities I believe a great strategy can be devised if the great minds of this game work together under one leader.
I am still running for mayor. A vote for Hyperbola is a vote for a brighter future for us all.


Show nested quote +
On October 29 2010 11:06 Hyperbola wrote:
What I am interested in is how forgetforeverine is going to factor into the game. Is it simply a role playing element and can a specific role can utilize it? Or is it just a way of having people "forget" about other mafia games... in which case we can't make arguments based on past actions.


what is forgetforeverine? i don't remember anyone saying anything about this...

Show nested quote +
On October 30 2010 09:40 Hyperbola wrote:
It's really pointless for me to vote for myself at this point so I guess I'll vote for Pandain. The other two prime candidates are all discussing secret societies and whatnot, and even though I'm all for those types of roles, I believe the mayor should really be a figurehead for the whole town.
1. It would be really difficult, and not to mention disadvantageous, for the mayor to prove they are a free mason or something along those lines
2. The mayor keeps the rest of the town out of the loop (because there wouldn't be a way to transfer secret data) and therefore causes confusion which can lead to unwarranted bandwagoning.
3. If the mayor dies, how will the circle prove itself to town afterward? After losing all leadership, the town will flop and scum will have it's way with the remains.
And as for Pandain, I have seen his play style from the previous game and think he would make a good mayor. If he turns out to be mafia, and unless he has flawlessly acted out the role, people would notice and he'd be gone in a blink of an eye.


Parrots the argument of distrust Coagulation was using that "Fishball is untrustworthy because he operates in secret circles/town circle. But, hyperbola, THE ENTIRE BASIS OF YOUR CAMPAIGN WAS ON CREATING A TOWN CIRCLE.

Back to the "Vote pandain cause he's bad and we can tell if hes mafia ez" argument that coagulation used

Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 01:51 Hyperbola wrote:
On October 31 2010 20:20 youngminii wrote:
oh god that was a shitfest, i didn't read everything to the full but i got the general gist of what's going on

Before you ask me to do something stupid like roleclaim, ask yourselves:
Why in God's name would scum have an ability that allows them to not die? Lynches always bypass the 'oh this guy has two lives' thing anyway.
Why would I not try to defend myself after being pressured for so long? If you thought I was biding my time so that someone could try to take the attention away from me, why didn't anyone?

DrH I'm surprised you didn't think of the second question. Also, a whole lot of your reasoning for your accusations in this thread comes from the metagame, which is stupid because some people like not playing the same style every single game. Stop relying on the metagame, especially if you've only seen me play *once*.

Hang on, your reasoning is flawed anyway because if you actually used the metagame, you would have seen my active posting in Haunted Mafia as scum. Why in the world would you still try and get me lynched?

Ok so these are the aspects of his role (if he's telling the truth):
1. avoid a lynch
2. no talking
So I'm thinking his role is the ability to leave town, turn invisible, or hide in the closet for a night. I don't know why he wouldn't role claim but, more importantly, this doesn't seem like a scum-favored role. Think about it: why would scum leave town? Is the mob getting too hot for him? This would seem almost detrimental because if someone has a valid case against him, he can't argue it and just delays the inevitable 1 turn. I think the role is intended to just dodge night actions and simply dodges lynches and forbids speaking as a side effect. So in short, I think youngminii is innocent to some extent... for now.


bit of a defense for youngminii. Coagulation attacked youngminii really hard. This doesn't clear hyperbola though, there are reasons why mafia might attack another mafia but the way coagulation did it was strangely intense. If Coagulation somehow flips blue I'd SERIOUSLY consider hyperbola.

Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 07:29 Hyperbola wrote:
Lexpar has successfully derailed the thread for like 3/4 of a page, lol. Not that we're really doing anything intense right now. Regarding youngminii, I don't think we really need to get to the bottom of the whole situation just yet as Coagulation stated. I think we should wait till day, analyze the day post and the deaths, and then resume "getting to the bottom of things". But as other people have said before me, role claiming is nothing but detrimental unless it's done right. Do not be like Aeres guys (no offense), his role claim was rash and could put him and others in danger.


Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 09:54 Hyperbola wrote:
Ok let's not fish for the elder. Why do the mafia's work for them? If he want's to be known he'll say it in the thread.

Regarding Node: His role is really easy to fake. A mafia knows exactly who's going to die and he probably has a role that decided who to kill during the day or is just completely faking it. The reason I think this is because he explicitly asked for medic protection on night 1 and 3 people are now infected. I am assuming that Murrayitis starts off with only 1 host because otherwise it would take very little time to infect half of the town's population. I can't really prove anything right now but Node is now quite suspicious in my eyes.


Show nested quote +
On November 01 2010 09:56 Hyperbola wrote:
On November 01 2010 09:53 Coagulation wrote:
On November 01 2010 09:25 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On November 01 2010 09:24 jcarlsoniv wrote:
On November 01 2010 09:22 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On November 01 2010 09:20 Misder wrote:
@DH
Earlier, you said you were going to poke the person you thought is most likely town. So why do you think that jcarls is town?


Agreeable posts, good analysis, cool headed and logical. He didn't make a big roleclaim or bring a lot of attention onto himself and seemed for that reason to be a good target for me.


Awwww that's the nicest thing anyone's ever said about me! ... on the internet...

I didn't realize I was actually an important player in this game.

On November 01 2010 08:15 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I would like to announce that last night I poked jcarlsoniv. I did not receive a PM from Artanis or LSB meaning the poke was successful and jcarlsoniv does not have murrayitis.


I cannot confirm this Dr.H, I did not receive a PM from the mods saying I was poked.


Did you receive any other night actions?

Something stopped my poke from going through to jcarlsoniv.



how fucking convenient.







You do realize it would actually be a smart move for mafia to roleblock DrH? This can really flip either way at this point.



Show nested quote +
On November 02 2010 08:42 Hyperbola wrote:
I honestly do not know who to vote for right now. Nothing seems solid. I'm gonna vote for someone random so I don't get modkilled.


Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 08:41 Hyperbola wrote:
On November 04 2010 08:24 CubEdIn wrote:
Well if you want my opinion about the blue pill thing (let's assume I'm not lying), it's either:
1. A note from the admin. But it would be pointless, because I didn't take the blue pill.
2. A mafia being able to influence the Radio as well. It would make sense, half Glasse, half Mafia.

I don't think this is the case. Otherwise Glasse would have said something.
Anyone else thinks it's kinda weird that DCLXVI would have a "leave town role" like Aeres and potentially youngminii? Either that or Node is BSing us.



Hyperbola has been mostly pretty inactive and a lot of his posts are just saying things the town had already really been talking about.

I figured a mafia would drop out of the race when Mayor was revealed to be vulnerable to rolechecks and the way with which hyperbola ran his campaign fits this profile. I'd consider him as a second lynch tomorrow. A very strong target if coag flips blue imo


Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 05:13 GMT
#3320
On November 07 2010 14:09 Glasse wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 13:16 Pandain wrote:
Veldril is safe.


explain? did i miss something?

He can scan the alignment of one person per night. Where you have been for the last 2 days?>.>
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 06:04 GMT
#3334
On November 07 2010 14:57 youngminii wrote:
Pandain, there's a very real possibility that KtheZ is a paranoid DT. Either way, I'm not convinced, you could be the Godfather for all I know.

Can anyone enlighten me as to what the paranoid DT is?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 06:07 GMT
#3338
On November 07 2010 14:57 youngminii wrote:
Pandain, there's a very real possibility that KtheZ is a paranoid DT. Either way, I'm not convinced, you could be the Godfather for all I know.

Well even if that is the case, it is very unlikely that Pandain is mafia then. His role has been confirmed eitherway(Trash Collector), and since it checks the alignment of one random person per night. It would be a useless role for mafia as mafia already knows everyone's alignment.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 06:59 GMT
#3343
On November 07 2010 15:39 youngminii wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 15:07 Nemesis wrote:
On November 07 2010 14:57 youngminii wrote:
Pandain, there's a very real possibility that KtheZ is a paranoid DT. Either way, I'm not convinced, you could be the Godfather for all I know.

Well even if that is the case, it is very unlikely that Pandain is mafia then. His role has been confirmed eitherway(Trash Collector), and since it checks the alignment of one random person per night. It would be a useless role for mafia as mafia already knows everyone's alignment.

/facepalm

That would be the ideal role, you realise Godfathers don't actually gain the abilities of the role they choose, right?

I was just pointing out that he is not any more likely to be mafia or town if KtheZ is actually a Paranoid DT as compared to Insane DT.


On November 07 2010 15:26 NB wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 11:11 Nemesis wrote:
On November 07 2010 08:57 NB wrote:
OMG, IM ALIVE xD.... Thank you medic :3....

i was assuming that ima die and didnt post anything, sorry guys T_T

NB did you actually get a message that you were protected by medic or did you just assume that you were since you didn't die seeing as DrH was actually switch with someone(most likely you) by bus driver and died because of it?

i have no clue... i did not receive any pm so it could be bus :D (i just check out what bus actually do @_@)

are you supposed to receive a notice if medic save you?

That was how it worked in past games as far as I know. Hmm so if medic didn't save you, that means that there is 1KP missing as Beneather died because he placed his voodoo doll on DoctorH and DCL killed himself.

Did someone else get protected today or maybe mafia KP has decreased?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 08:02 GMT
#3354
Hmm, I have thought it over while watching PL, and I think that meapak is indeed a better target than hyperbola. Well, I'll be sleeping for now.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 21:56 GMT
#3419
Wow, some new information is always nice.

I was kind of suspicious of ace as he was supposed to be a "renowned scumhunter", but so far he hasn't really done anything useful.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 21:58 GMT
#3420
Well back to studying for calculus midterms for now.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 23:13 GMT
#3428
Hmm well the thing is Ace if he is found to be lying, then there is no way he can talk his way out of it next day phase. But I guess it doesn't matter whether we lynch you or him to find out whether he's lying or not.

But the roles which doesn't work exactly compared to a standard mafia game have slightly different names from those of standard mafia role names like "ADD Doctor", so now that you pointed it out, it does seem suspicious.


Well kitaman, as a chance to defend yourself, who else did you visit the previous nights?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 23:18 GMT
#3433

Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 08:39 kitaman27 wrote:
On November 07 2010 08:33 Glasse wrote:
On November 07 2010 08:32 infinitestory wrote:
On November 07 2010 08:30 Amber[LighT] wrote:
Well we could lynch Pandain and another person not on your checks to check your own sanity. We had a plan to lynch Padain anyway so it almost works out that we can confirm your sanity, and it's a safeguard to understand that you aren't lying, after all.

Let's try not to lynch someone who's more likely town than mafia at the moment.


I really hate lurkers, i feel like there HAS to be a mafia hiding in them


Agreed. Carefully watching the lurkers should be a priority. Especially those who disappear for periods of time after the town has formed a majority opinion.


I had a feeling you might claim this. Luckily, I decided to hide my discovery in a post right after I found out you were scum. That way when you accuse me of making the claim up, I can show you I had the information prior to finding out who would be the lynch targets.


I'm sorry but that is a bit of a ridiculouse defense, I'm not buying it XD
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 23:23 GMT
#3437
Well can infindibulum and AmberLight confirm that they both did not leave their house during the respective days they were visited?

Which days were who visited?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 23:27 GMT
#3440
On November 08 2010 08:24 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 08:23 Nemesis wrote:
Well can infindibulum and AmberLight confirm that they both did not leave their house during the respective days they were visited?

Which days were who visited?

i just confirmed infun did not leave his house, based on my knowledge of infun's role
amber also just confirmed he did not leave his house night 2

Can you link or quote me to where Amber confirmed it?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 07 2010 23:34 GMT
#3450
On November 08 2010 08:27 kitaman27 wrote:
Nemesis, I noticed you changed your vote from Ace to me based on his weak defense.

Explain to me why I would put myself out here like this to target a single town member.

14 town remaining
5 mafia remaining

A 1:1 trade doesn't work out too well, now does it?

Hmm well honestly I don't care who gets lynched at this point. Depending on who flips what, the next day lynch is quite clear.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 01:42 GMT
#3494
On November 08 2010 10:07 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 09:56 infinitestory wrote:
On November 08 2010 09:55 L wrote:
Ok. That wasn't a post aimed to make you look bad. I was just showing that denying the plausibility of a role, as if we know better, has not proven successful. Ace is basing his defense on the name of my role, while ignoring the fact that Amber has been able to confirm it.


Uh, but it did prove successful.

wait, are you talking about kitaman's role or Cubed's role here?

Seems like both. Once I discovered the M-rus portion of Cube's role, he was essentially confirmed blue. From mafia's point of view, the claim is hyper-complex to engineer. From his point of view, he didn't even think about m-rus spreading as an argument, nor did anyone else.

If mafia had thought about the trade off, someone would have made the comment very quickly.

Instead, we confirmed that mafia had probably infected cubed if they have a targetted infection method, which makes sense given what we've seen in terms of the M-rus spread. If cube repeatedly targetted himself, a N1 spread to him would have been immediately stopped, whereas n2 had a spread to someone who was involved with at least 2 other people. Given the net +4 infection rate we see afterwards, its likely mrus is actually ramping up its infection speed.

As for Ace's catch, I dont' see any of the standard roles working in a way other than the way they've typically worked. For mafia, a tradeoff here is optimal, but if they can get their player to avoid being hit, its game winning.

They push someone off the vote train and thus get the ability to push him later if they so choose, they pick a dangerous target to them and have him eliminated asap, and they get to control not only today's targets, but also one of tomorrow's. In that environment, they'll lose 1 mafia from the fake claim after protecting today's kp, giving them a net of 2 lynch, 2kp+1, 1/1 lynch, and 1+1. This rolls out to -8 townies -1 mafia, which puts us at 11 townies, 4 mafia.

But the kicker? Mrus just exploded. If mafia pick their targets and know who's infected they're less likely to get infected, which means mrus will explode for 7-9 people worth, killing maybe 1-2 mafia. At best, we're 4 town v 2 mafia. Lylo. At worst we've lost 2-4. And that's ignoring any other tricks they have up their sleeve. What's a probable trick? Their mrus spreader has mrus himself. If he's sacrificed, they don't care; he's going to die anyways.

That's why I'm far more willing to kill players like Nemesis who have been keeping their heads down, because it not only plays to classic mafia strengths, but it keeps blue's attention on other players and minimizes the likelihood that they've gotten infected. Meapak as well decided to show up and post a complete non sequitur, showing he's around but that he still doesn't want to deal with the shit that's been thrown at him. That's. Fucked. Up.

Hmm did I miss something here, because I have no idea what you are talking about. What m-rus portion of Cubed's role? When did you discover it, and when did he get confirmed before he died?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 02:19 GMT
#3513
WAIT A MINUTE, I was just checking over the roleclaims made in the game so far, and I just noticed that something doesn't add up. I was checking over KtheZ's roleclaim and here is something weird that popped up.

Here is his roleclaim: he rolechecked Pandain during Night 2
On November 07 2010 08:22 KtheZ wrote:
Considering that the state of the town is in complete disarray, I will now roleclaim.

I am the detective. However, I suspect that I am an "insane detective".
The reasons and my finding will be below.

On night 1, I forgot to investigate anyone, being the lurker dumbass I was.
On night 2, I investigated Pandain. I found him to be the MAFIA Garbage collector.
On night 3, I investigated infinitestory, and found him to be the MAFIA ADD detective.

Now, what the hell? Why would the mafia have an ADD Detective? This has led me to conclude that I am insane.

Now, assuming I'm an insane detective, it is apparent that Pandain and infinitestory are town-aligned.
I am no longer into lynching pandain; I had found him to be mafia, which is why i was so ardent in pursuing his lynch.

I feel that infinitestory's results are now trustworthy, and that pandain did not lie about his role.

If you think I am lying, look at my posts against pandain. I was so one-mindedly pursuing pandain because I thought he was mafia. However, this night has confirmed my sad suspicion that I am "insane".



Now here are his post in day 3 right after he checked Pandain:

On November 04 2010 10:30 KtheZ wrote:
Pandain, anyone can scream unconfirmable role if they decide to roleclaim.
Why hasnt Dr.H?

And why are you the FIRST PERSON in the game to claim this?
Also, at least giving details on the CONDITIONS that need to be achieved so you can confirm your role would be nice, instead of this vague stuff we keep getting.


On November 04 2010 10:56 KtheZ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 10:51 Pandain wrote:
On November 04 2010 10:49 youngminii wrote:
Wasn't Pandain's main 600 post argument against DrH the fact that he 'lied' and he couldn't confirm himself 100% because he got roleblocked?

Now it's day 3 and Pandain can't confirm himself which is a bigger lie than DrH's? Does this not strike you as fucking stupid at all Pandain? Couldn't you have come up with a better argument/roleclaim?


First of all I still don't see how if I find mafia that doesn't confirm me. Now obviously at most I could do if mafia would be to claim a townie was mafia, and then they get lynched. But then next day, I get lynched. That is definitely not beneficial for mafia.

@KtheZ, we're actually different roles, his is in fact even better than mine :/


The main purpose of a DT check is to check ALIGNMENT. Other tidbits are just useful to know.
Having two ALIGNMENT DTs in a game doesnt make sense. For example, in haunted mafia(which i failed epically and will make up for), there were 2 dts for 60 people. Now, considering that we have ~ 30-40 people, I find it Extremely unlikely that town has TWO RANDOM ALIGNMENT CHECKERS. For all we know, you could be scum; you never claimed alignment (But you'll obviously claim town). And for all we know you could be lying about your role, your role actions, or anything you want.

EBWODP



On November 04 2010 11:09 KtheZ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 11:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On November 04 2010 11:05 KtheZ wrote:
On November 04 2010 11:02 Pandain wrote:
On November 04 2010 11:01 KtheZ wrote:
On November 04 2010 10:59 Pandain wrote: If I die, FoS on KtheZ for pushing me so hard with illogical reasons. At least Dr. H has had decent ones....
On November 04 2010 10:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote: if a vig hits pandain we might have better information for our double lynch
:O
What illogical reasons? I simply ask why it took you so long to roleclaim and why your roleclaim clearly overlaps with a previously claimed role. and what does FoS mean :/
Because roleclaiming was plainly idiotic. It's not like I'm going to claim "Hey mafia, I have a role where I can find out people's alignments!" Also infinite has a good point with the doctor/plague doctor(town does have both fyi) FoS=finger of suspicion.
Note that mafia also had their own plague doctor, so there may be role-checkers for the mafia also. So the standings right now is that you claim to be Garbage collector, and your results have turned up OBVIOUSLY unconfirmable results (who in their right mind would say "I'm not safe omg")
mafia doesnt need an alignment checker since mafia know everybodies alignment
I noticed, which is why I think hes lying about his role/role action


On November 04 2010 10:58 KtheZ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 10:56 infinitestory wrote:
On November 04 2010 10:53 youngminii wrote:
On November 04 2010 10:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
i feel uncomfortable

something about his role feels really plausible to me, but at the same time its very easy to fake and much safer to fake than mine

i suggest we kill pandain/someone unconnected or opposed to pandain

if pandain turns up blue and the other turns up red that could be really good for us in the end.

No, we're killing Pandain. He's posting scummily (as usual though) and there is no reason for Artanis/LSB to make two roles that literally overlap yet have one *slightly* better than the other. If Pandain is blue then FoS infinitestory.

Wait, what the fuck? Doctor & Plague Doctor literally overlap yet PD is *slightly* better >___>


take into consideration that in your case, the mafia had a PD.
And pandain is most likely lying about his role/role action


WTF, he thinks Pandain's lying about his role when he should've checked him by now?

KtheZ's main argument against Pandain was that his role was "unconfirmable" when according to his role claim he should've confirmed Pandain's role at that point of the game.

Now then, what conclusions can we draw from this?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 02:24 GMT
#3517
Just note KtheZ lied about his roleclaim, look at my previous post

So, here are my conclusions from my previous post
1. KtheZ lied
2. He either wanted to confirm Pandain or infinitestory to the town
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 03:12 GMT
#3529
Infinitestory I'm just wondering who did you check the previous days? No need to reveal their roles.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 03:16 GMT
#3531
On November 08 2010 12:10 KtheZ wrote:
have you noticed that in almost each of my posts against pandain, I always said his role/ROLE ACTION could be a lie?
Proves my point above even further.

EBWODP

Except you included that part which means you didn't know the name of his role at all. And you even got the name of his role wrong when you roleclaimed :/

And how convenient is it that the other person you checked was InfiniteStory, another person who has already roleclaimed?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 03:42 GMT
#3533
On November 08 2010 12:33 KtheZ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 12:16 Nemesis wrote:
On November 08 2010 12:10 KtheZ wrote:
have you noticed that in almost each of my posts against pandain, I always said his role/ROLE ACTION could be a lie?
Proves my point above even further.

EBWODP

Except you included that part which means you didn't know the name of his role at all. And you even got the name of his role wrong when you roleclaimed :/

And how convenient is it that the other person you checked was InfiniteStory, another person who has already roleclaimed?


I was trying not to show myself as a detective, since I felt that at that point it was not wise to roleclaim. Plus, I mixed up the words GARBAGE and TRASH. It really is not a notable detail for you to nitpick about.

I have good reason to check infinitestory. Since I suspected myself to be insane, checking him was the reasonable thing to do. Since he had claimed ADD Detective, I could either:
A. Find him lying about his role (and find him town, which would confirm my suspicion of insanity) or
B. Find him telling the truth about his role (and find him mafia, which doesnt make sense and also confirms my insanity)
or
C. Find him lying about his role (and find him mafia, which I really doubted would happen if he actually was town)

The benefit of this is also that we can confirm infinitestory's checks upon other people.

I have had very few (if none at all) scum-like actions this game. The entire pandain ordeal, I always qualified my analysis with the statement that his ROLE ACTION may be a lie, which noone else at the time had ever stated or taken into consideration.

I don't buy your "suspecting yourself" argument here. If you actually suspected yourself, you would have considered the possibility that Pandain was telling the truth, yet you kept insisting that Pandain was lying about his role.

And yes, if you actually had a pm telling you that his role is TRASH COLLECTOR, it would be something that you would not ever mistake as you would actually check your pm's about what your rolecheck would return before posting your roleclaim. as compared to reading about Pandain's role once when he roleclaimed.

I'm still trying to connect how this relates to the town's current situation though, so I'll just check what else I can find out from previous posts.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 05:55 GMT
#3549
Ok, I was just sifting through the thread, and I coudln't really find anything to relate to the ace-kitaman thing going on now. For now I'm going back to voting hyperbola as a placeholder. I'm not really sure what to make of this Ace-kitaman situation yet.

I feel like there is a good chance that kitaman is lying, but there is also a chance that he is telling the truth. Until some more new information comes up, my vote will be in hyperbola as it seems that he doesn't even care about this game as he hasn't even posted once this day phase.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 06:27 GMT
#3557
On November 08 2010 15:13 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 15:09 kitaman27 wrote:
You can't be a Watcher/Tracker because you don't have a target. If you were a legit Watcher/Tracker we wouldn't be having this conversation. I asked you WHO I'm linked to and you can't tell me. If you are a watcher/tracker then WHAT hit was I involved in last night? Are you really selling that the mod told you "Ace was involved in last night's hit" when there were 5 dead people?


Wait, so are you confirming that you were involved in a hit last night?

i think we have a winner here

Not so fast, and I've been thinking, but what if both kitaman and Ace are actually innocent.

If Ace is vigi and he killed deconduo and he is actually infected with M-rus and someone visited him.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 06:32 GMT
#3560
On November 08 2010 15:30 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 15:20 Ace wrote:
On November 08 2010 15:11 KtheZ wrote:

Could you give an example of how a townie can be involved in a mafia hit? I'm just throwing out my ideas.


I wasn't involved in a Mafia hit.

You should read all the pages of this discussion. His claim doesn't reflect any role and doesn't fit with any of the other roles in the game. If it does then prove me wrong.

hits last night:
DrH (bussed by deconduo, likely swapped with NB)
Cubed (roleblocked while protting self, killed)
Beneather (confirmed to have had his voodoo doll on DrH)
DCLXVI (confirmed to have died due to role, selfdestructed)
deconduo (confirmed to have died due to DC's selfdestruct)

so you were involved in the hit of either DrH or Cubed? Why the hell? If you were one of the guys mentioned in the day post, that means you either carried out a hit yourself or were the guy roleblocking Cubed. Since there is no reason to roleblock a confirmed medic, and DrH was confirmed 100% townie just before, I have to assume you decided to hit Cubed. But that doesn't make sense either. Were you somehow involved in a killing in a way not mentioned in the Day post? The possibilities dwindle, and so does the likelihood of you being town.

btw this now means that every inspection that kitaman made has been correct, even if his role name is weird.

There was nothing about deconduo being confirmed to have died due to DC's selfdestruct. Deconduo visited DrH and NB that night so it is impossible for deconduo to get "caught" in the blast. It has also been stated by mod that DC's second bomb doesn't go off if he kills himself.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 06:47 GMT
#3569
The only thing that doesn't make sense to me about kitaman's roleclaim is his targets. Why infindibulum, why Amber[light]?

I can certainly think of lots of better target than those two, that just seems so random. Night 1 best target would probably be DoctorH, Night 2 whoever is suspicious.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 06:52 GMT
#3573
What I'm a bit worried about is that since most of us have some sort of role, I'm guessing all mafias also have some sort of role as been shown by the current mafia deaths, so even if some people's roleclaim does indeed fit together like kitaman, it does not necessarily mean that their alignment is town.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 06:56 GMT
#3577
On November 08 2010 15:52 infinitestory wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 15:50 L wrote:
I suggest you look at 666's hatter role and the last Day post before assuming Decuondo wasn't hit.

Seems pretty clear that 666's bombs did not go off and that he killed himself.

we never said 666 blew deconduo with a bomb, in fact we clarified several times that his bombs never went off at all

ace said (untruthfully, it seems o_O) that deconduo probably died in 666's suicide bomb

Maybe you should have read his role pm when he flipped
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 08 2010 17:10 GMT
#3602
On November 09 2010 01:38 kitaman27 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 08 2010 21:28 Ace wrote:
I don't know, the thing that sits with me is the fact that you were saying I had to be Mafia. It still makes me feel uneasy about you.


So I receive information that you make a hit and there were four hits during the night. Three of them are mafia related and one is unknown. Lets assume there are two vig roles that could kill a scum.

That gives us a 17/19~90% chance you were involved in the mafia hit (actual number doesn't matter, just the fact that the odds were much higher being scum than town). I could have asked nicely for you to reveal your role, but I doubt that would have worked out, so you were put into a situation where you were forced to make a claim to protect yourself. So here are the possible outcomes of your claim:

1) You are a vig variation who killed deconduo
2) You are a scum who fake claimed vig

If the first situation holds true, I can't think of a situation where a mafia would secretly hit one of their own, so you are likely town.

In the second situation there are two possibilities:

1) Another town member targeted deconduo
2) deconduo used his busing ability on a role that triggered his death

With the first possibility the town member who actually made the hit could claim, so until we here otherwise, I will assume that's not the case.

The second part is more difficult to prove. I would think that the town member who made the kill would receive some type of notification that they were targeted, however. Is this a safe assumption?
Seeing as it was obviously NB and DoctorH that was switched by deconduo. If his death had to do with visiting his switch, NB would have already told us about it

As L pointed out, your connection with M-Rus has still not been explained.
Anyone that is infected with M-rus, if they visit someone or is visited by someone spreads the infection to the visitee and visitor. I just asked Artanis and it seems that we won't be notified if someone was infected when they die.We can't confirm this but my guess is that Ace is infected with murrayitis and spread M-rus to deconduo during his visit.

I'm willing to call a truce, unless the town is able to discredit your claim or someone points out a flaw in my logic.

The situation still provided us some useful information, as there were two main groups to be suspicious of:

Those who immediately opposed my claim without a strong reason to believe otherwise.
Specifically: KtheZ, Pandain, youngminii

And the lurkers who immediately jumped on Ace:
Specifically: Nemesis, Glasse, Kenpachi
If I am a lurker, then you are more of a lurker than me before your roleclaim: all of your previous post are no content one-liners. I would say that I've been quite active in the thread, I don't see how I am suddenly a lurker because L says I am.

So unless someone else claims to have hit deconduo during the night, I am going to assume that Ace is telling the truth.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 09 2010 15:53 GMT
#3750
I thought Pandain had been cleared by KtheZ now that he has actually flipped to be insane detective?

Why are we going on the assumption that there is a godfather role?

RoL, if that is your only argument about Pandain being mafia, then that is weak. We can't just assume stuff that might not even be true and lynch based on that.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 02:20 GMT
#3934
Wow, I just got back, and lots of shit happened.

First, NB is most likely blue. He was targetted by the random +1 kill, but he survived because he was switched with DoctorH.

Second, kenpachi lol nice attempt.

Third, that leaves the two mafia with one of these people::
Meapak_Ziphh
youngminii
L


And out of those 3, I'm willing to bet that L is one of the other two mafia. Seriously, his attempt at trying to paint me red was patethic. And as for voting patterns:
Day 1 - DoctorH(Masq)
Day 2 - CubedIn
Day 3 - Pandain
Day 4 - KtheZ and Nemesis

Lastly, do we still have one more double lynch?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 02:21 GMT
#3935
Do we still have one more double lynch
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 02:33 GMT
#3939
On November 10 2010 11:25 Infundibulum wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 10 2010 11:20 Nemesis wrote:
Wow, I just got back, and lots of shit happened.

First, NB is most likely blue. He was targetted by the random +1 kill, but he survived because he was switched with DoctorH.


How does that make him most likely blue? We don't know how the random +1 kill works; it could pick among only the set of blue players or it could pick among the set of all players including reds. If the latter is true, then NB getting bussed says nothing about his alignment except that mafia wanted to kill DR. H. instead of NB.

(as a side note, if mafia can bus the random kill then it isn't really random. so does this entire scenario even make any sense?)

Deconduo was bus driver(he's dead now), that was the only reason they were able to switch the kill to DoctorH. Also, just take a look at all the people killed by the random +1 kill, they all flipped blue. That is why I said most likely.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 02:50 GMT
#3941
On November 10 2010 11:27 Kenpachi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 10 2010 11:20 Nemesis wrote:
Wow, I just got back, and lots of shit happened.

First, NB is most likely blue. He was targetted by the random +1 kill, but he survived because he was switched with DoctorH.

Second, kenpachi lol nice attempt.

Third, that leaves the two mafia with one of these people::
Meapak_Ziphh
youngminii
L


And out of those 3, I'm willing to bet that L is one of the other two mafia. Seriously, his attempt at trying to paint me red was patethic. And as for voting patterns:
Day 1 - DoctorH(Masq)
Day 2 - CubedIn
Day 3 - Pandain
Day 4 - KtheZ and Nemesis

Lastly, do we still have one more double lynch?

You sound confident.. do you know what the fuck your talking about? I doubt you read my posts carefully enough to just post "lol nice attempt." When im revealed blue, ima quote you.


On November 10 2010 11:06 Kenpachi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 10 2010 11:02 LunarDestiny wrote:
Pandain is a legit blue.
On November 07 2010 08:22 KtheZ wrote:
Considering that the state of the town is in complete disarray, I will now roleclaim.

I am the detective. However, I suspect that I am an "insane detective".
The reasons and my finding will be below.

On night 1, I forgot to investigate anyone, being the lurker dumbass I was.
On night 2, I investigated Pandain. I found him to be the MAFIA Garbage collector.
On night 3, I investigated infinitestory, and found him to be the MAFIA ADD detective.


Now, what the hell? Why would the mafia have an ADD Detective? This has led me to conclude that I am insane.

Now, assuming I'm an insane detective, it is apparent that Pandain and infinitestory are town-aligned.
I am no longer into lynching pandain; I had found him to be mafia, which is why i was so ardent in pursuing his lynch.

I feel that infinitestory's results are now trustworthy, and that pandain did not lie about his role.

If you think I am lying, look at my posts against pandain. I was so one-mindedly pursuing pandain because I thought he was mafia. However, this night has confirmed my sad suspicion that I am "insane".

On November 09 2010 09:17 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
On November 09 2010 09:16 kitaman27 wrote:
On November 09 2010 09:13 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
KtheZ the Detective has been piranha'd.
You are the Detective! Once per night, you may pm me to find out the role and alignment of one of the players. Your head hurts though for some reason.


To clarify, would we be informed if he was insane, like with the extra note for the ADD-Doctor?

Yes, sorry. He was indeed insane (returned opposite alignment)


Imo, there are 3 possibilities
1. Pandain is fucking red
2. theres a flaw in pandain's role
3. Someones able to frame others as mafia

nothing in my role is flawed to lead him to find me as a red

Sorry but this is your best attempt? Pandain has been scanned to be blue already, and Pandain has already proven his role.

You could at least try something like "my role makes me show up as mafia" for some reason.

The third one is possible, but I just don't see it.


If you mean previous post, here lemme quote them for you and tell me what can I learn from your posts?

On October 31 2010 09:10 Kenpachi wrote:
LOL THE BOOGER.
well, would it be that someone has a nosepicking related profile? is he even mafia?

also, i am not the elder guys. Is it even confirmed if HE is the mafia either? ~_~


On October 31 2010 09:36 Kenpachi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On October 31 2010 09:11 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
On October 31 2010 09:10 Kenpachi wrote:
LOL THE BOOGER.
well, would it be that someone has a nosepicking related profile? is he even mafia?

also, i am not the elder guys. Is it even confirmed if HE is the mafia either? ~_~

no obviously not

now that you're here wanna discuss the matter at hand:
who should be lynched

cant really say. im not one to decide on inactivity.. right now, i only read posts with my name in it and so far im a suspect again..
Would it be possible to provide evidential clues >_>


On November 04 2010 09:29 Kenpachi wrote:
am back. sorry for a delay from posting.. after all, im just a teenager.

Ill do a page for Pandain.. pg4


On November 10 2010 10:27 Kenpachi wrote:
eh.. fuck lynch Pandain when i die. i cant defend myself from this


[QUOTE]On November 10 2010 10:59 Kenpachi wrote:
+ Show Spoiler [obnoxious replies to posts] +
On November 10 2010 10:11 LunarDestiny wrote:
oh... they'll get one more day to live.

more than 1 actually


On November 10 2010 10:12 Glasse wrote:
dont forget the possibility that there would be a good liar in the "confirmed" list

Pandain imo

On November 10 2010 10:16 Glasse wrote:
the possibility is very small but it's still there lol

0.000000000000001% is still a possibility

it will rise to about 25% after i die


On November 10 2010 09:22 LunarDestiny wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 10 2010 09:15 Pandain wrote:
rofl I've been like "why hasn't anyone even reacted at all yet to my finding?"
Then I realized all the active people are dead(infinite...kitaman somewhat)
Besides Glasse, and somewhat Lunar I guess. But they don't seem to care :/

We care because we can actually win now. We'll lynch Kenpachi.

Im your hope crusher.

On November 10 2010 09:28 Glasse wrote:
we still need to find someone else though. double lynch is active

Pandain


yea im pretty angry right now for feeling pretty helpless but have you guys noticed i voted for Ace on the previous day? And i wanted to kill Coag but DrH and DC were the people to change me to Pandain.. Ace even voted for ME stupids :l His role doesnt benefit from voting Mafia.. mine does but im not mafia
Sorry but bussing someone is an everday thing in mafia/QUOTE]

Was there anything useful that I missed that is supposed to prove your innocence other than your roleclaim?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 03:46 GMT
#3946
On November 10 2010 11:47 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 10 2010 11:20 Nemesis wrote:
Wow, I just got back, and lots of shit happened.

First, NB is most likely blue. He was targetted by the random +1 kill, but he survived because he was switched with DoctorH.

Second, kenpachi lol nice attempt.

Third, that leaves the two mafia with one of these people::
Meapak_Ziphh
youngminii
L


And out of those 3, I'm willing to bet that L is one of the other two mafia. Seriously, his attempt at trying to paint me red was patethic. And as for voting patterns:
Day 1 - DoctorH(Masq)
Day 2 - CubedIn
Day 3 - Pandain
Day 4 - KtheZ and Nemesis

Lastly, do we still have one more double lynch?

L is red because he called me out as inactive?

Sounds legit.

Anyways, where's node at?

Lololol your argument is inactive nowXD

On November 04 2010 10:03 L wrote:
Nemesis starts off the game pretty apologetic. Makes a case for the mayor being super dangerous, then realizes that the mayor gets an extra vote, not an extra lynch.

He asks fishball's circle to reveal itself to confirm fishball during the elections.

Some M-rus related posts.

Supports pandain on the account that he's a good communicator, but easy to spot as mafia.

Skeptical of DrH's ability to be confirmed. Says he doesn't trust him.

Pushes on Orgolove and Youngmiini as his top 2 scumreads.

Comes out against roleclaiming, despite having asked the fishball crew to step up earlier.

Wow. I'm only halfway through but this is looking pretty bad.

Going to LoL is up for a bit, I'll finish soon.

Yes your argument is definitely about being inactive.



You know what time to do a full blown analysis:
On November 01 2010 14:21 L wrote:
Okay, just got my pms and whatnot, so I think this is the game I'm supposed to be in. I'm hungover from last night's partying and drunk from this night's partying so I'll catch up as much as I can after sleeping off the effects of imbibing an amount of alcohol sufficient to disinfect all of the wounded at solferino.

First post, nothing suspicious. He just got subbed in and trying to catch up to the game.

On November 02 2010 01:06 L wrote:
That's because Aeres is probably a hatter type role that wanted to get hit, so he claimed BG to draw attention to himself and away from more vulnerable/valuable players. He's likely not a VI role, because the revealed roles thusfar are relatively watered down and mafia started with 9 fucking members + there's aids going around (unless the game design is based around town's ability to use murrayitis as a shock and awe town controlled kp attack, which it doesn't seem to be).

The push to get him killed here is pretty understandable due to people loving LAL, but there's zero way someone would vote for themselves as mafia with the usual suspects driving a bus over him. Or rather that would hold unless there was a huge benefit to be gained from him dying. Either a mafia bomb type role (seems unlikely due to plague mechanics) or his death pushes another mafia member into a trusted position vis a vis the town where he can ask for roleclaims.

As for this Young/DrH/Pandain/Infinite circle of morons situation going on, there's a few things which just don't really add up; DrH campaigned on being able to 100% confirm himself and clearly lied about it. LAL should apply to him to, right?

Wrong.

DrH can still confirm himself, but he needs to die for it to happen. I'm not sure if DrH is fumbling for time as his ability gathers information which he'll confirm as valid with a self-kill, but it seems rather odd that young would try to focus attention onto Aeres and cite LAL when LAL can be applied to DrH too. This leads me to believe that DrH/Young are in a circle together, and DrH is feeding him information, which he'll, again, confirm by death.
Claims that DoctorH should die so that we can get info on what alignment other people are

If it wasn't for that, based on the aeres situation, I'd suggest killing DrH immediately in order to find out what allegiance Aeres has. Aeres is either innocent or sacking himself to benefit another mafia member; there was no benefit to fakeclaiming BG of all roles. This is based on the fact that DrH stands to benefit the most from the diverted attention and post-lynch bragging rights if Aeres flips red.

There's some kind of intense attention-fu going on here to keep us discussing a certain set of facts, which leads me to believe that someone fucked up pretty hard and outed themselves earlier and we're actively being pushed away from that. Given that I kinda just read pages 10,20,30, etc until 80-92, I'm not entirely certain what's being thrown under the rug, but when I get more time and less women offering themselves to me, I'll be sure go over more material in search thereof.
Says a bit of protown stuff by saying that we are being misleaded



On November 02 2010 11:38 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
Once again L is asking for the death of one player to "confirm" another.
No I'm not. I'm saying in the event that we kill either, these are the likely orientations of the other player because a rank 0 new kid isn't going to throw some crazy mindgames at us like whoa.

In fact, I specifically said if I was going to lynch for information, I'd kill DrH, but that the entire Pandain/Young/DrH/Infinity arguesquare will probably clear itself up and give us a good candidate from it anyways.
Denies that he was asking to "confirm" another player by lynching them, but somehow still says that he'd kill DrH. Idk what he's getting around to here.

So like, I did the opposite of what you're trying to say I did. Cool beans bro.



In other news, this feud is taking up a huge chunk of the thread. That's cool. Super cool even. Super cool if we're picking between two targets that are both town. The debate here is placid, with maybe 2 actors at most on a side weighing in. With 8 total vote power, mafia should be snoooooozing through this if one of the two candidates are mafia, because they can easily deploy enough votes to swing themselves to safety. In all likelihood, mafia isn't even heavily invested in this conversation, since there are at most 6 players making substantial contributions to the (now endlessly repeating) argument. Since both sides seem to have halos of associated players, it would be easy enough to swing a certain direction, then cook up why an unfortunate townie was the most ardent pusher for the lynch and get them killed.

So, L, who do you suggest we pick? I dunno lol. We probably have a 1/6 chance hitting aeres or DrH. The game as a whole provides us with closer to 1/4 odds. Given that, we're probably better off completely ignoring this situation and producing alternatives before the day runs out and I get modkilled for eating curry for 30 minutes longer than anticipated. That said, that's a blind analysis. You can make the % chance even better by seeing what your position on players like Node or others is.

In total, this yield me a list looking like this:


2. Hyperbola
3. Bumatlarge
4. Veldril
7. deconduo
8. Coagulation
10. infundibulum
11. Amber[LighT]
12. Kenpachi
13. RebirthOfLegend
14. Nemesis
15. ghrur
16. KtheZ
18. CubEdIn
19. Meapak_Ziphh
21. DCLXVI
22. Divinek
23. Lexpar
28. jcarlsoniv
31. L
32. NB
33. Glasse
34 Misder
38. kitaman27
39. LunarDestiny

So basically I've removed the players that are too heavily engaged in the stupidity to be cruise control mafia + Node because I think he's legit. There's probably a mafia member up in that group, but they're all hopped up on crazy pills at the moment, so we're not going to get very far with our tea leaf divination technique just yet.

Out of the remaining group, mafia are hiding at the feigned activity level. They'll jump on players who make mistakes, or just lightly brush people with the threat of the shitlist, but otherwise just reformulate other people's posts for giggles. And shits. I haven't read all hundred pages. Closer to 40, so I can't accurately say what happened during day 1. It seems, however, that there was a standard mayoral election, so one of the candidates who's remaining on this list might be a good person to start analysis on. Additionally, anyone who played heavily day 1, but then dropped off is less likely to be mafia, because townies' give-a-shit meter is very low normally (this, however, might be wrong this game because we're all blue and that's awesome), consistently low activity players who haven't asked for replacement or made overt apologies are more likely to be mafia given that LSB is actively kicking people outta his game if they say they're busy, and mafia players are never inactive.
What is this? He tries to look protown by producing a list of 20 people that should be looked at, but doesn't go into specific at who specifically should be looked at

Cept that Caller kid. He's pretty brave, though.


I'll skip a few of his post and just summarize a bit of it. He suspects node, but says that if he is lying about his roleclaim, he'll only last a day or two.

On November 03 2010 02:21 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 03 2010 02:15 CubEdIn wrote:
Oh, I understand, you think I picked townie? No.

I picked doctor, that's why I roleclaimed straight away. No use in just the mafia knowing what I am.

Why would I think that you picked doctor?

I'm saying that the role you say you have does not make sense. At all. So there's probably more to it that you haven't revealed.

Here comes his crazy attempt to put suspicion on CubedIn based on "his impossible role." This continues for a few more post

After that, he tries to push for a Pandain lynch when Coag was scanned red.
On November 04 2010 09:07 L wrote:
Went through coag's posts.

There's 2 main overt things he does:

1) He pushes pandain for mayor the entire time
2) He shits on youngmiini

Pandain's pretty much our best target for tomorrow.

Some less overt stances:

1)Seems undecided on DocH. Starts by being rather deferential, then moves to a "not so sure about you" position.
2)His posts are TINY. He feigns activity without producing very much.

Given my prior assessment it seems like I was right. Most mafia are just trying to keep under the radar.

Tries to make another "alliance" between players and pushes for Pandain to be lynched first over Coag.

On November 04 2010 09:50 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2010 09:39 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Nemesis voted for him immediately iirc. Deconduo also voted for Pandain.

I'll look at his post history then. Gimme a few min.

I've already mentioned this before, but oh look DrH puts suspicion on Deconduo and me. Guess who is the one he analyzed? The one who is now confirmed blue, while he completely ignores the one who flipped red.

Now let's look at his analysis on me
On November 05 2010 09:32 Nemesis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 05 2010 09:02 L wrote:
On November 05 2010 06:58 Nemesis wrote:
On November 05 2010 05:43 L wrote:
Re: Nemesis.

This is the portion during which you get apologetic.

On October 30 2010 03:12 Nemesis wrote:
On October 30 2010 02:58 annul wrote:
its what, 2 votes? if the vote is close enough (like, 16-14) where my one vote will tip the scale, then perhaps it is not "stupid" to have voted it, right?

the mayoral role is not really a town leader position. it's an extra set of lives and a very weak voting power that can be overcome easily (and is 100% transparent). i am playing along with the leadership meme because hey it makes sense, but think about what POWER the mayor has. the only power it has is protection and a weak voting boost. any other leadership that the town chooses to assign to the mayor player is entirely on their own volition.

why do we want to give death protection to a mason? there is no real reason we want to keep the masons alive above someone else who can actually affect things, right? so he has a circle, cool, what does that do for us and why would his death hurt the town, per se?

if i died it would be much worse than a random mason dying, that is all i am saying. are there others out there with roles better suited to protection? probably. but they aren't talking, so i will.

My bad, it seems that I misunderstood the mayor role. I thought they get to lynch one extra person.

Lol, I made a misunderstanding early in the game and make on post that i made a mistake and that makes me apologetic early on in the game. You are one funny man.

After repeated oneliners clarifying rules to other players with no submissions of your own, you start trying to produce real content around the 300 post mark. You then realize your arguments are pretty ridiculous and back off quickly.
Can you at least please point that out. Looking at around the 300 post, my posts are about clarifying people's candidacy for mayor and I was asking them how they can disprove my doubts. I wasn't really arguing.

Its not super incriminating, but its odd that someone who's staring at the rules wouldn't know that the mayor gets an extra vote and not an extra lynch.
I am pretty new to mafia(although I've played it irl), so I don't exactly know all the roles and what they do, which is why I was asking about the rules and stuff. This is my second game here and this game has a different format than last game.


Around the 2k post mark you shift back to one liners and ask other people to do analysis on certain players. You say you're too lazy to do it yourself.
I only asked an analysis on misder as far as I remember, how does that turn into "players"?

You also trip yourself up when you state that you're all for lynching inactives to get them to post, but then you turn around immediately and say that LAL makes no sense because it targets liars rather than scum. Why use one heuristic over the other? You never really make the argument. And that's not just a single point; there are multiple posts of yours on this front.
I never made the argument, because no one asked me too. Those were during different phases of the game. I had forgotten about inactives as most of them have died already at that point. Inactives don't contribute to the game at all if they are townies. It also allows for a place for mafia to hide, and we have no way of knowing which is mafia and which is not.

Lying on the other hand can be beneficial to town if used correctly, and if someone is caught in a lie, you just have to read the intention of the lie to determine whether that lie was supposed to benefit the townie or mafia. Aeres' lie was clearly meant to benefit the town even if it was dumb which was why I was against lynching him.

Does that answer your question?


The 2200 series of posts are pretty much a rehash. Against LAL, targetting inactives and clearing up rules questions. Mostly in one liners. In the 2300 section, he pushes for cube to prot DC, which is reasonable regardless of his alignment.

The 2500 are a bit more interesting. There's a focus on M-rus and asking pandain to confirm himself + questions about double lynches. This is prior to pandain having a bus driven at him. The rest of the posts are literally one liners regarding inactives or in another instance just a quote from DrH. There's a LOT of chaff in these posts.
Look above. Anything suspicious about asking how the game works?

Nemesis opens into the 2600 section by stating that he'll look bad if pandain flips red. There's more one liners including a one liner rebuke of my first post, then s'more another question for pandain, regarding how he can confirm himself.

Overall Nemesis's concrete actions aren't unreasonable after the halfway point during his posts. But there's a problem: he doesn't really do much even when he is posting. There's a lot (a LOT) of one-two line posts that parrot other players, and the majority of his posting seems to be a combination of talking about the rules, and lightly incriminating people who are unlikely to retaliate.
I am just observing for now. I am just "lightly" incriminating people for now as I haven't decided to lynch them. If I decide to lynch them, then I'll be more aggresive. That's just my play style.

Anyways, Take a skim through his posts and tell me if you agree.

Overall, you seem to EXAGGERATE a lot of the stuff that I said. Really? I make one post about making a misunderstanding and you call that "early on, he was pretty apologetic." You might also want to include more quotes of my post if you want to have a proper analysis.

I don't really know what to think of you at this point as you seem to have mostly skimmed over my post and make your opinions based on that. Since you were subbed in, I will give you the benefit of a doubt that you just didn't understand the situation at the time my early posts were made.

If anything, I understated the majority of the claims I made.

I grouped most of your posts together by post number in the thread, and they're readily accessible here:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/search.php?q=&t=c&f=-1&u=Nemesis&gb=date

Trying to tell me that you're 'just observing' or whatnot doesn't explain why you're making 1 liner me-toos chaff posts. Additionally, if you are just observing why would you be lightly incriminating people? Seems like you just want to have future targets to pick off later without taking responsibility for throwing suspicion on them.
I am trying to get some information out of them, is that a bad thing?

Its silly that your defense here only reinforces the scum-like qualities that were pointed out.

To reply to a few points of yours:
"I didn't bother making the argument because no one asked me to"
Yeah, that's because you were me-tooing me. That doesn't cut it. Its a way of trying to appear active while trying to not take any responsibility.
Lol, let me give you an analogy on your crappy point: If you were arguing about how good this movie is a week ago, and someone claims that the worst movie you have ever seen is "the best movie" ever, would you concentrate on comparing it to the 'good' movie that you saw last week or would you concentrate on points on why that movie is crap? Not the best analogy ever, but you get my point. Wtf would be the point of me trying to compare LAL to lynch inactive. I wasn't trying to make people switch to lynch inactive 'mode' at that time, I was just trying to get them to steer away from that direction.

"I only asked an analysis on misder as far as I remember, how does that turn into "players"?"
The important part isn't the plural, its the fact that you, with all your free observing time, decided it was a good idea to ask other people to do work instead of do it yourself. Its pretty a pretty standard way to play as mafia; tell the town to do useful things, but rejoice silently as they don't bother doing it. That way the town's at a net neutral position, but you end up looking both active and pro-town without actually having contributed anything.
No, it is important as you were exagerating shit that isn't true.

If you were busy in the slightest, this might be excusable, but you readily admit you're just sitting around doing nothing for the sake of watching people.

"I am pretty new to mafia(although I've played it irl), so I don't exactly know all the roles and what they do, which is why I was asking about the rules and stuff."
Very odd excuse given your prior posting, when you were almost zealous in your will to clear up rule issues. Again, like I said, this isn't conclusive proof that you're mafia, but it sets up the claim that I was really hoping you wouldn't make; the "i'm bad at mafia" claim. The clueless newbie persona is a rather common one with new players who are on mafia's side; its easy, low maintenance, and it rarely brings attention to yourself.
I didn't say I was bad at mafia, I just wanted some clarification on some rules that I didn't know how it worked.

So yeah, this last post just made my suspicions worse, given that you confirmed pretty much every tentative theme I had noticed in your posts.

And yes if you actually want to know I am actually quite busy right now irl. I have midterms last week and I have one last midterm this wednesday(I'll probably go inactive around tuesday). I check tl mafia everytime I take a break from studying 'hence my one liner posts.' I didn't mention this, because I know that you are just going to use this against me saying "you're just making up excuses now." But I guess it doesn't matter eitherway as you still try to paint me as red either way.

This is the last time I'm replying to you as to not shit up this thread like what happened during the Pandain/Doctor H/Infinitestory circle. I feel like you will just be making the same points over and over again. You have made your point. I have made my point, there's nothing left that I have to argue about.

He definitely has great points against me ^.^ With more than half of his arguments being exagerrated.

When he was finally being called out on his crap last day phase here are his posts

On November 07 2010 13:38 L wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 07 2010 12:17 youngminii wrote:
Holy shit lol, I didn't even realise it was night, looks like I changed my vote to Coag a bit late.

Anyway, I think it's safe to say Pandain's been supported/protected by Coag a lot more than a normal townie would have. Sorry Pandain but one of my votes goes to you. Unless you can convince me otherwise ofc.

Who else is there to choose from? I remember a case on Nemesis, can we get an update on him. Also, can someone do an analysis on L? I feel as if he's been a bit weak, if we look at him as a townie. His town play is usually very, very strong (targets and analyses scum well) but as far as I can remember, that hasn't been happening this game.

See you might have a problem attributing strong analysis to me when you forget that the case you've mentioned isn't attributed to me. So far I've actually produced the most comprehensive analysis of any person in the game, which was vetted by a bunch of people who died and flipped blue.
Most comprehensive analysis? What? What have you done so far? So far you've pushed for 3 now confirmed blues to be lynched based on crappy reasoning.
CubedIn - "definitely lying about his role"
Pandain - "Him and coag are definitely working together"
Nemesis - "Plenty of one liners. Definitely mafia"


I've operated on very limited assumptions this game.

The first of which is that during the Aeres/Youngmiini melee, most of the involved parties were blue and that mafia were staying out of the problem. So far, everyone who's died from that group has flipped blue.
Lol, and how does that help anyone? You didn't try and find another target that day but only said that.

Second is that because of that, mafia would have been very, very quiet day 2. Go look at the people who flipped mafia since then: Divinek, Coag and Decuowhatever. All said the bare minimum, or in the case of Divinek, got modkilled for being flat out afk.

So where does that leave us?

DrH asked the thread to look up Nemesis. I did. He fit straight up into the middle of the qualities that all of the previous mafia members had, and what's more:

He admits to them. He admits to lightly pushing people. He admits to throwing around one liners. He flat out admits he's just watching the game. His response to this? Throw shit on me now that DrH, who supported the view that he was likely a good kill today, is dead.

Seems pretty open and shut on this one. The only question is whether or not we can find one of his scumbuddies to hang with him.
And now he throws suspicion at another person when he's been called out


He doesn't vote at all on the whole kitaman/Ace situation until it had been agreed upon that Ace is most likely innocent.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 04:52 GMT
#3949
On November 10 2010 13:39 L wrote:
Haha, wow. Maybe you should go back and actually read those posts before commenting them, because you've falsely characterized half my arguments. My statements regarding DrH on the top, for instance, were actually a defence of DrH's statement that he could be 100% confirmed.

The rest of the post, similarly, and perhaps oddly, ignores RoL's idea that there might be a godfather in the game, and that its probably pandain.

Why is that odd? Well, because you're 'confirmed' because he has you on his list. But if his list is bullshit, then so is your confirmation. Oh but wait, if his list is bullshit, then Kenpachi might be blue too, and lynching me/him would win you the game. If you were blue, you'd know you aren't confirmed, and that pandain isn't either.

Between you just plain lying about my positions, playing scummy all game, and overzealously trying to claim that you're confirmed, there doesn't seem to be much room for doubt. You've pretty much cemented that you/pandain are mafia in my mind.

LOL you are using RoL's idea that there is a godfather role and it's probably Pandain when RoL flipped red. So you are using an argument that another red used to try and lynch someone? Can you be any more scummy at this point?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 05:25 GMT
#3958
On November 10 2010 14:21 L wrote:
Alternatively, Pandain might be 100% legit, and Nemesis could be the GF. Either way, I'm pretty certain Nemesis is mafia, because he's literally a walking encyclopedia of scumtells at this point.

Walking scumtell?

Tell me who just recently changed their argument to "making a bunch of one liner and lightly accusing people" to "calling out for being inactive."
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 15:36 GMT
#3979
So everyone's helping mafia now except you L, right?

I think that third party roles have already demonstrated that they are not on the mafia side right now by killing Ace. You are barking up the wrong tree. Trying to threaten them to work for you is not gonna work out.

And since you keep trying to somehow paint me and Pandain red, I will actually give proof that I am blue just to make you feel even more helpless. Which also confirms Pandain's role for the second time if people are actually too stupid to believe his argument.

NODE, confirm that I have visited you NIGHT 3, and since you already know my role, and that my role is blue
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 16:22 GMT
#3982
On November 10 2010 15:01 L wrote:
Like Coag?

No, Coag gave up and started calling pandain mafia and spammed the thread until he died. Kenpachi put forth his argument, saw that no one wanted to even bother considering that Pandain was lying and stopped bothering.

If you want 'proof' that someone's mafia, you aren't going to get it outside of someone being a DT, checking someone, then dying. Either that, or having a role and using it. Outside of that, there's really very little 'proof' someone can muster.

Want a demonstration?

1) Pandain claims he checks alignments, he can't prove it.
2) Pandain claims Nemesis is blue, he can't prove it.
3) Pandain claims Kenpachi is red, he can't prove it.

So what standard of information do you want to use here? Town can decide. Not you. You win the game if mafia Ace this lynch. Sorry for doubting you, but I typically don't trust players who have a win right in front of them who say they won't take it.

On the plus side, Node finally arrived and told us who's dying, so I can go ahead and reveal that I'm the Junkie. I've got 2 night lives and once per game I get to pm the mods and tell them I have murrayitis. If i'm wrong, I die. If i'm right, they give me drugs to cure the disease. Being a terrible drug addict, they don't actually work on me, but they give me a night hit.

I've breadcrumbed this pretty much once per day, by throwing up huge mrus posts while no one else was talking about it.

Now that Ace's role flipped as mrus spreader and given that he hates my face, I'm pretty sure I have mrus. So tonight I'll either die, or I'll get to hit someone. I fully expect both third party members to push me today because Lunar'll probably be afraid of my hit. Nemesis/Pandain is probably a given as well. To everyone else, specially you if you're not lying, Kenpachi, please read carefully.

How does your role give you more information about murrayitis than other roles? In fact, how do you even know more than plague doctors. CubedIn who was the only doctor who roleclaimed, he never even once mentioned that mafia had a targeted spreader, which means the only one that knew that is mafia.


On November 11 2010 01:00 L wrote:
Basically the math goes like this:

Right now we're at 6 town, 2 3rd party, 3 mafia. If we lynch 1t/1m we end up with:

5 town, 2 third party, 2 mafia going into the night. Mafia have 1+1 hits and lunar has 1, which makes this:

2 town 2 third party, 2 mafia going into the next day. Town loses. By a lot. Including the secret vote, its 5 votes vs 2 town votes. Third party can't lynch mafia here either because the last remaining mafia player will hit them and make them lose.

I might die or get a kp if I claim tonight, so we're +1/-1. Our only hope if we split 1/1 on the lynch is that I shoot a mafia during the day so that third party doesn't need to worry about being killed. But mafia's decided to toss me under a wagon because I'm the only person bothering to not lose the game and they can't kill me during the night.

So yeah. Those are our only options if we want to win.

What is to stop mafia from killing thid party anyways? And what do you mean third party can't lynch mafia. Unless mafia tells them who they are, then they can't avoid lynching mafia anyways. And if mafia tells them who they are, what's to stop them from lynching them?

So no, your hypothetical scenario of third party helping mafia is far off.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 10 2010 16:55 GMT
#3987
On November 11 2010 01:25 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Happy page 200 ppl.
L who do you suggest we lynch if you don't wanna lynch kenpachi?

Dun Dun Dun, three of the four unconfirmed people banding together with three mafias left. Coincidence? I think not.

I'm off for now, I have a midterm today and somehow I'm wasting my time here.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 02:14 GMT
#4024
Hahahaha, I can't believe that there are actually people who are buying your plan L. Seriously, are mafia really that desperate that they don't even know how to do math now?


Here is your plan as already outlined by LunarDestiny:

Right now there are
6 town
3 mafia
2 third party

Lynch both third party on day5:
6 town
3 mafia

mafia 2 night kill on night 5:
4town
3mafia +secretz mafia vote
MAFIA WINS



Town lynch someone on day 6

A)2town
2 third party
3mafia
(mafia wins)
or
B)3town
2 third party
2 mafia + secretz mafia vote
LYLO - town can still win if third party votes for mafia
or
C)4 town
2 third party
1 mafia + secretz mafia vote


Yes L's Plan leads to mafia winning. That is so protown of you right? You have been hanging around with kira too much.

Also consider that Pandain has been pretty much confirmed blue. If we follow the "confirmed blue" list we have a 2/3 chance of killing 2 mafias, and 1/3 chance of killing just 1 mafia.

Unless you actually think that RoL and L is correct about Pandain being Godfather which is ridiculous as why the hell would RoL put suspicion on the real Godfather when he has just been confirmed blue? Godfather has been given a free pass via being scanned and mafia would bus him?

So L, what's your next attempt at escaping the guillotine?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 02:56 GMT
#4030
Yes you are definitely right, we give up. Pandain is definitely godfather and you are definitely blue even though you have no argument.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 02:57 GMT
#4031
Also, where the hell is everyone? It just feels too quiet in here, it's weird. :X
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 16:44 GMT
#4082
OMG, you guys are idiots, you are actually trusting L over a confirmed Role Checker. XD

If you are going to wifom about Pandain being godfather
Uh, COAG ASKED FOR PANDAIN TO GET DT CHECKED DAY ONE. I don't know if Pandain AND Nemesis are mafia, but I'm 99% certain one of them is.

Yes because mafia don't set other people up right? This whole game the majority of people pushing for Pandain to be lynched have been mafia if you want to WIFOM. RoL, a mafia, had been pushing for Pandain to be godfather the entire time. Now L continues his legacy and you guys believe him.
On November 09 2010 17:19 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
You have to be kidding me -_-; I go AFK for one night and the town becomes retarded. You guys need to think reasonably a lot more often and remember to put a lot of emphasis on what the plans of previous days were because usually when chaos like today happens its because we were close to something and we need to go back and figure out what it was.

First off, I read everything now. Pandain is the mafia godfather, I would say this with 99% certainty. His role checks out with KtheZ but his behavior has been anything but town. Pandain has been playing the role of the mafia aggressor to a tee. He attacked the shit out of DrH with half assed reasons hand in hand with another confirmed mafia. When we were debating between the lynch of the two I would say the mafia swayed that to try to get pandain to live a little longer, when coagulation was dead in the water. While all this is going on we can see plenty of posts from coagulation (from early days) recommending that we check all the mayoral candidates. The reason for this I would assume is because they knew he wouldn't come back as red. When pandain gets called out after the Coagulation lynch he keeps saying let me live and check me while claiming the most easy to fake town role.

Wow, most obvious setup ever and you still think Pandain is mafia? Seriously, if there is a godfather role in this game, why the hell would mafia reveal who he is after he's been checked?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 17:03 GMT
#4085
No, using double lynch today is our best option. I wanted to use double lynch before murayittis hits and wipes out a lot of us. It is also best to use it now while town members are a lot higher in numbers than mafia numbers.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 22:45 GMT
#4134
On November 12 2010 06:15 Node wrote:
Shit, I missed Nemesis' post asking for confirmation earlier. Sorry about that.

I was immunized on Night 3.

You stupid AARRRRRGHHHHHH.

Why the hell would you actually reveal my role? I was only asking you to confirm that I am blue. -.- This is why I haven't come forward until today, I knew something like this would happen.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 22:53 GMT
#4141
Lololol, why the hell are people actually voting me?

1. A confirmed detective comes and say that someone is red.
2. Lynch Detective and people who he checked blue.
3. ????

You are falling for the same trap we all fell too during the Ace/kitaman incident except this one is even more obvious. Although, granted we only fell for that because someone didn't claim to actually have done the hit -.-


And yes, I am actually a plague doctor. Can't help it now that node has basically revealed my role.
These are the people I protected
Night 2 - DCLXVI
Night 3 - Node
Night 4 - Infinitestory(I was roleblocked)

Note plague doctors can't do anything the first night night.
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 22:56 GMT
#4147
WOw mafia has some sort of one-time use ability to change vote and L somehow survives -.-
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:00 GMT
#4154
why pandain?
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:01 GMT
#4157
YOu guys not better listen to L's desperate pelase tomorrow-.-
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:02 GMT
#4159
if town even somehow survives anyways
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:03 GMT
#4162
I should've checked this thread earlier >.<

Well nicely played by mafia, GL Town
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:07 GMT
#4164
Last minute change by mafia, seems they were planning it from the start
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:08 GMT
#4166
L and Pandain did a ninja vote
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:08 GMT
#4167
lynch L first if possible
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:11 GMT
#4171
I believe in you LunarDestiny <3
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:12 GMT
#4172
The fate of the town lies in your hands :O
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 11 2010 23:16 GMT
#4176
I hate you guys

GRR this game makes me rage

GL Town, there is still hope :O
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 12 2010 00:37 GMT
#4221


The hype is killing me :O
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Nemesis
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Canada2568 Posts
November 12 2010 02:49 GMT
#4314
Hahaha this game is insane. It was fun though ^.^
Lee Young Ho fighting! KT P are just CHINTOSSTIC.
Normal
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Esports World Cup
10:00
2025 - Day 3
Reynor vs ZounLIVE!
Solar vs SHINLIVE!
Classic vs ShoWTimE
Cure vs Rogue
Serral vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
herO vs TBD
Clem vs TBD
EWC_Arena6202
ComeBackTV 1869
EWC_Arena_21112
Hui .494
TaKeTV 392
3DClanTV 311
Berry_CruncH228
JimRising 203
Rex177
Reynor105
CranKy Ducklings93
mcanning74
SpeCial45
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
EWC_Arena6202
EWC_Arena_21112
Hui .494
JimRising 203
Rex 177
Reynor 105
mcanning 74
SpeCial 45
ProTech35
StarCraft: Brood War
Sea 9807
Bisu 1500
BeSt 1316
firebathero 992
Jaedong 789
Hyuk 383
Flash 378
EffOrt 373
Stork 360
Zeus 256
[ Show more ]
Soulkey 219
ggaemo 203
actioN 185
ToSsGirL 159
Soma 135
Last 130
Hyun 105
Mind 101
JulyZerg 86
ZerO 78
Pusan 75
Mini 58
Snow 48
Sacsri 43
sorry 31
soO 28
NaDa 26
Sharp 26
yabsab 19
Noble 16
Movie 6
ivOry 5
Icarus 2
Britney 0
Dota 2
XcaliburYe282
BananaSlamJamma219
League of Legends
febbydoto7
Counter-Strike
shoxiejesuss500
x6flipin472
Other Games
singsing2165
B2W.Neo259
Fuzer 183
crisheroes176
Beastyqt23
ZerO(Twitch)9
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1166
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 8
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 4
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV228
League of Legends
• Stunt516
Upcoming Events
Esports World Cup
23h 58m
OSC
1d 2h
CranKy Ducklings
1d 22h
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
2 days
CSO Cup
2 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
2 days
Bonyth vs Sziky
Dewalt vs Hawk
Hawk vs QiaoGege
Sziky vs Dewalt
Mihu vs Bonyth
Zhanhun vs QiaoGege
QiaoGege vs Fengzi
FEL
2 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
3 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
3 days
Bonyth vs Zhanhun
Dewalt vs Mihu
Hawk vs Sziky
Sziky vs QiaoGege
Mihu vs Hawk
Zhanhun vs Dewalt
Fengzi vs Bonyth
Sparkling Tuna Cup
4 days
[ Show More ]
Online Event
5 days
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
6 days
The PondCast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

CSL Xiamen Invitational
Championship of Russia 2025
Murky Cup #2

Ongoing

Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
BSL20 Non-Korean Championship
Esports World Cup 2025
CC Div. A S7
Underdog Cup #2
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25

Upcoming

CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
ASL Season 20: Qualifier #1
ASL Season 20: Qualifier #2
ASL Season 20
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
BSL Season 21
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
SEL Season 2 Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
FEL Cracov 2025
HCC Europe
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.