EPTwhy?
TL Mafia XV - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
HeavOnEarth
United States7087 Posts
why? | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
On October 21 2009 13:52 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: Well, if we are using the DT list to keep good people alive, then DTs can check the medic list. If we want DTs to check people who are about to die, then DTs should just check suspicious people who are on the chopping block to die soon. They can probably figure that out without a list just by following our town discussion. It seems to me that a DT list is either a medic list or a suspect list. Essentially, it seems slightly contradictory to use DTs to keep people alive while saying DTs are supposed to check dead people. Granted, the medic list contains people who the mafia want dead (and I'd guess at least one mafia). Well the point is to use DTs LIKE the medics in the medic lists. Its good to have DTs check people who will die, but we can also use them to deter mafia hits. Because they WONT want to hit people who will get RCed. I guess the tradeoff is do we have people we want to protect vs. do we want to make DTs as useful as possible and as fast as possible. There are multiple suspicious people who could be on the chopping block soon. Plus the way the game evolves we almost always change suspects after night happens/we have more information. So perhaps RCing the people who might attract attention for the mafia might be better than RCing people who might attract angst from the town. | ||
|
Tricode
United States538 Posts
So basically the Dt's should use our lynch list and try to see what they got for their RC for them. To figure out their sanity. Sorry once again for my brain fart. Your suggestion seems sound. Though that means until DT's can get it together (figure out their sanity) we need to try to do our best to attempt to pick best choice lynches. Correct? | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:03 Tricode wrote: Ok, if I think I got the idea of you want to do Incognito. Can't excuse myself from this stupidity of mine (but if it helps my case, I had a midterm today and studying for Spanish test tomorrow.) So basically the Dt's should use our lynch list and try to see what they got for their RC for them. To figure out their sanity. Sorry once again for my brain fart. Your suggestion seems sound. Though that means until DT's can get it together (figure out their sanity) we need to try to do our best to attempt to pick best choice lynches. Correct? Not really. Trying to get DTs to check dying people is good, yes. But I was suggesting using DTs as a deterrent from mafia killing some people we want alive. | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
| ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
| ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7876 Posts
With the Dt plan we can compete, with the mafia who are ever so meek, so we should give it a shot, or risk the chance of us all being caught, and our attempts being for naught. Rise to arms my friends, Let us win the day, and keep the darkness at bay! | ||
|
Infundibulum
United States2552 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:07 Incognito wrote: Not really. Trying to get DTs to check dying people is good, yes. But I was suggesting using DTs as a deterrent from mafia killing some people we want alive. I'm not sure if that's the better approach. Given the permutations, it should take a DT 2 RC's and according deaths to have a good approximation of his alignment. 3 if one of the deaths is a repeat in terms of color. It is definitely a deterrent but I'm not sure of exactly how effective it is. Also, with 21 players, we definitely don't have more than 2 DTs. Do we know if all blue roles listed are actually present? (like in the speed game more blue roles were in the rules post than actually in the game) | ||
|
Tricode
United States538 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:25 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote: I'm not sure if that's the better approach. Given the permutations, it should take a DT 2 RC's and according deaths to have a good approximation of his alignment. 3 if one of the deaths is a repeat in terms of color. It is definitely a deterrent but I'm not sure of exactly how effective it is. Also, with 21 players, we definitely don't have more than 2 DTs. Do we know if all blue roles listed are actually present? (like in the speed game more blue roles were in the rules post than actually in the game) We have to kinda assume the blues are active (hopefully), or at least until we see other wise. The plan is good for now, but it might help to have a back up plan. I think we should be voting for least active people for now, but we need to use the best judgments when we pick our lynches. If anyone can offer up any other ideas, that would be nice though. So we can kinda have more ideas to work with. | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
man it's that time again already? <---running for mayor <---going back to sleep | ||
|
Tricode
United States538 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:43 Ace wrote: *yawn* man it's that time again already? <---running for mayor <---going back to sleep ^earns my vote! | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:25 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote: I'm not sure if that's the better approach. Given the permutations, it should take a DT 2 RC's and according deaths to have Also, with 21 players, we definitely don't have more than 2 DTs. Do we know if all blue roles listed are actually present? (like in the speed game more blue roles were in the rules post than actually in the game) I wouldn't entirely rule out multiple DTs. Given how weak they are early game and given how Ver said they wanted to give the town power but give the mafia options for misdirection (BGs) I wouldn't be surprised if some of the "power" was later game information gathering power. Could be wrong though. But the DT numbers are pretty irrelevant at this point. Im going to assume that there could be none of a role, but I'm not certain. | ||
|
HeavOnEarth
United States7087 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:43 Ace wrote: *yawn* man it's that time again already? <---running for mayor <---going back to sleep hey everyone i heard and since he isn't replying obviously this is true !! | ||
|
Tricode
United States538 Posts
On October 21 2009 14:54 HeavOnEarth wrote: hey everyone i heard and since he isn't replying obviously this is true !! Don't player hate. | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
| ||
|
Chezinu
United States7447 Posts
My brown spirit is also torn vertically! Shall I put the bomb on the one that had betrayed me or shall I have forgiveness and place the bomb on someone random? Of course, placing it on no one is meaningless...it must be two obv. - that is if I have the bombs...Maybe I should place the bombs in a certain order...maybe I might spell something...but only two letters...GO, SO, TO, IT, ME...ect Maybe I can combine names to spell something,,maybe like kill L and then ACE to form LACE. If I do that I can have my revenge...the initials would be JC...hmmm....can anyone think of better symbolic killings because I wouldn't like to go out with a bang! but with a bang! boom! Kaboom! hmm If I die my symbol would be U....GOSU players are Incognito, Scamp, Redtooth, Chezinu....ISRC Insurgent Suicidal Revolutionary Corps!! Let us be strong martyrs for this great revolution! Long Live Brown! Long Live GOSU! Short Live the IRSC...(and ACE if he doesn't apologize) | ||
|
rredtooth
5459 Posts
On October 21 2009 15:17 Chezinu wrote: i don't want to be associated with you. you are mafia. gtfo.My brown spirit is being torn horizontally! Shall I vote for one that speaks in a revolutionary tone or should I vote for the one I was always loyal to but then forsaken me in the previous world... My brown spirit is also torn vertically! Shall I put the bomb on the one that had betrayed me or shall I have forgiveness and place the bomb on someone random? Of course, placing it on no one is meaningless...it must be two obv. - that is if I have the bombs...Maybe I should place the bombs in a certain order...maybe I might spell something...but only two letters...GO, SO, TO, IT, ME...ect Maybe I can combine names to spell something,,maybe like kill L and then ACE to form LACE. If I do that I can have my revenge...the initials would be JC...hmmm....can anyone think of better symbolic killings because I wouldn't like to go out with a bang! but with a bang! boom! Kaboom! hmm If I die my symbol would be U....GOSU players are Incognito, Scamp, Redtooth, Chezinu....ISRC Insurgent Suicidal Revolutionary Corps!! Let us be strong martyrs for this great revolution! Long Live Brown! Long Live GOSU! Short Live the IRSC...(and ACE if he doesn't apologize) besides, i feel that you can't demand GOSU to live and IRSC to die... | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7447 Posts
All have turned against me Detonation time ticking Having nothing to spare All I asked for depleted Totaled and abolished To look in brown silence Everywhere clouds of dust Remote destruction time | ||
|
BloodyC0bbler
Canada7876 Posts
I grab my gun and slide it into the holster, from there I climb the apulster Throwing on my coat, I let out a great shout I strode through my portal, in the town full of twenty - one mortal lingering in the crowd, I watched the falling shroud, why oh way did the good have to die, why oh why did they believe the lie with the morning sun, we had lost more than one, town we must begin the cull, and go back to our lull, so let us find our blades not dull | ||
|
Tricode
United States538 Posts
By the way Qatol, Donatello stills rules! | ||
| ||
