[M] The Dark Knight Rises (SPOILERS) - Page 60
Forum Index > General Forum |
lynx.oblige
Sierra Leone2268 Posts
| ||
typedef struct
United States84 Posts
On July 23 2012 07:36 TheRabidDeer wrote: Plotholes?: + Show Spoiler + - The stock exchange. To my understanding they didn't throw his money away. They just made bad investments. However, if you invest billions. No matter how bad the investments - you'll still have some value in the stocks. Most likely the companies would actually increase their value. Without having full understanding of the stockmarket, I have a hard time accepting him going broke overnight + Show Spoiler + They bought put options. This means you're buying the ability to sell a stock at a certain price on a certain date. If the stock is worth more than that price at the end of that day, then the options expire worthless and you lose whatever you paid for them. This lets you get a tremendous amount of leverage. Generally when you trade options you buy/sell several different types of options on the same stock, to reduce your risk/cover your ass. Just buying naked options is very dangerous and you could well lose all of your money in no time. | ||
xrapture
United States1644 Posts
On July 23 2012 08:16 TheRabidDeer wrote: + Show Spoiler + They are trapped in the sewer system... you know, where all of the entire cities shit and piss goes. If 6/10 is slightly worse than TDK, have you ever had a movie rated higher than an 8? Yep. Pulp Fiction, Fight Club, The Godfather, Star Wars, Alien, + many others. Extremely over dramatic super hero movies aren't exactly my thing. TDK was done well and the Joker was played fantastically, but when you don't tie up plot lines, hand hold your viewer for the hold movie, and have so many cliches the movie is going to suffer. Also, I didn't really see any running water where the cops were + they were sealed in from rocks. So even if there was a small amount of water running beneath their feet, you expect me to believe that if 3000 tightly packed men were pissing and shitting while malnourished and unbathed for 5 months none of them would get sick? | ||
TheRabidDeer
United States3806 Posts
On July 23 2012 08:32 xrapture wrote: Yep. Pulp Fiction, Fight Club, The Godfather, Star Wars, Alien, + many others. Extremely over dramatic super hero movies aren't exactly my thing. TDK was done well and the Joker was played fantastically, but when you don't tie up plot lines, hand hold your viewer for the hold movie, and have so many cliches the movie is going to suffer. Also, I didn't really see any running water where the cops were + they were sealed in from rocks. So even if there was a small amount of water running beneath their feet, you expect me to believe that if 3000 tightly packed men were pissing and shitting while malnourished and unbathed for 5 months none of them would get sick? "over dramatic" and you list Pulp Fiction? Star Wars? I can see that you just generally dont like super hero movies, but that isnt exactly how you should be rating a movie. The entire series had flawless storytelling with a good pace, great acting in most cases (honestly, when the main star is the worst actor, and its still not bad, thats amazing), great soundtrack, great cinematography etc... I dont see how you can give it a 6. There are very few plotholes, especially for one that is nearly 3 hours long. | ||
Khazidhea
Kazakhstan65 Posts
The two things that really bother me: + Show Spoiler + 1) When the cops fight the bad guys. What the hell happened? The bad guys have tanks and assault rifles. They used a lot of grenades and other explosives throughout the movie. Cops, on the other hand, only have handguns + possibly a small number of properly equipped SWAT teams. Cops just WALK in a big group in one direction. WALK against tanks until just ONE tank is blown up by the bat. Fast forward one minute, we have a melee fight. By the way it felt like hand-to-hand combat in this movie was much worse than in previous installations, with the exception of the very last Batman vs Bane fight. 2) While in prison why would Bane protect the child? Me and my friends joked that he must be a pedophile. Or maybe he had a thing for her mother ... but he was quite fanatic about protecting her. Speaking about fanaticism, why are all the terrorists so loyal to Bane \ Talia? In the end it seemed like they knew who Talia is - they were taking direct orders from her ... so it takes just one, just one guy to spill it ... and it never happened? I get the suspension of disbelief and everything, but sometimes it's just too much. | ||
LeaD
Canada464 Posts
On July 23 2012 08:32 xrapture wrote: Yep. Pulp Fiction, Fight Club, The Godfather, Star Wars, Alien, + many others. Extremely over dramatic super hero movies aren't exactly my thing. TDK was done well and the Joker was played fantastically, but when you don't tie up plot lines, hand hold your viewer for the hold movie, and have so many cliches the movie is going to suffer. Also, I didn't really see any running water where the cops were + they were sealed in from rocks. So even if there was a small amount of water running beneath their feet, you expect me to believe that if 3000 tightly packed men were pissing and shitting while malnourished and unbathed for 5 months none of them would get sick? + Show Spoiler + The whole scene at the end was awful, with the police charging the criminals and that useless cop arriving in full uniform, made me want to laugh with how corny that was. The criminals had full automatics and they decided to fight hand to hand, and how the hell is anyone going to muster the strength to do anything in a fight after being stuck in a hole for 5 months. Did they have a gym down there? Batman is the DARK knight, not the fights in a crowd in broad daylight knight. What happened to the batman that fought with stealth like in the first movie? Watching him take out 8 armed guys by just showing up between them and having 95% of them charge him without firing their weapons was just awful. Alfred leaving was so random too, how is that going to force Wayne too quit? All he's doing is abandoning him and leaving him to treat his wounds by himself, rather than having someone that knows his secret and can help him when shit hits the fan. Goes from "I want you live happy" to "I'm leaving, being your only real family and confidant because....maybe you'll quit?". My favorite scenes were in the prison, never knew you could fix a broken back by simply slamming your palm into the vertebrae and tying someone up to the roof. The doctor was great too, speaks one language for most of his scenes and then out of nowhere he's pumping out fluent english and is now the #1 source for knowing how to get out of the prison (even though he obviously never did it himself). Anyone want to explain how a child finds Ra's and a secret organization of super well trained ninjas? Did they have an advertisement or something? In the first movie they had Ra's al Ghul come to Bruce Wayne, not the other way around. What was up with the daughter sleeping with Wayne out of nowhere? Was there any build up there? Any reasoning behind that scene or was it there just fill up some time? Maybe make her betrayal more "painful" even though it's really just meaningless sex since neither of them seemed to have any relationship (Bruce shunned her before this movie everytime she tried to talk to him).Ra's should teach his daughter how to act too, her death scene was awful. I could understand in the first two movies how no one knew it was Bruce Wayne as batman because really all the batman had was his suit and the sick vehicle (still a little close there but it's believable). How can no one tell who it is now? The guys flying around in a super hightech flying machine, has the bike AND the new batmobile. Who the hell else has those types of resources? Not only that, but Bruce Wayne decides to hide from the world right when batman disappears, and then when Batman reappears, Bruce is back out in public again. Really a deep puzzle there. I wouldn't mind any of this stuff if the entire reason Nolan's movies were so praised was because they are supposed to be REALISTIC (in most aspects), gritty and dark. Going for the cliche "I'm going to blow up your city with a nuke" and have batman fly out and sacrafice himself (actually survived an atom bomb while being right near it only a few seconds before) was sad. There's tons of holes in this movie and I feel like Nolan sold out to make an epic finale that didn't come close to the last two movies. | ||
XenOmega
Canada2822 Posts
Now that I'm rethinking about the end, its a little bit A LA Inception... Its kind of open-ended. Gordon (is that his name?) could be hallucinating Bruce and Catwoman? Didn't he say in a beautiful scene he always dream of seeing him taking a wife and living a normal life? | ||
GrapeD
Canada679 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:12 XenOmega wrote: + Show Spoiler + Now that I'm rethinking about the end, its a little bit A LA Inception... Its kind of open-ended. Gordon (is that his name?) could be hallucinating Bruce and Catwoman? Didn't he say in a beautiful scene he always dream of seeing him taking a wife and living a normal life? + Show Spoiler + I think you mean Alfred (Michael Cain). And yeah hes talking about seeing bruce in florence with his wife every year when he went on vacation and at the end of the movie it happens. | ||
Demonhunter04
1530 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:04 LeaD wrote: + Show Spoiler + The whole scene at the end was awful, with the police charging the criminals and that useless cop arriving in full uniform, made me want to laugh with how corny that was. The criminals had full automatics and they decided to fight hand to hand, and how the hell is anyone going to muster the strength to do anything in a fight after being stuck in a hole for 5 months. Did they have a gym down there? Batman is the DARK knight, not the fights in a crowd in broad daylight knight. What happened to the batman that fought with stealth like in the first movie? Watching him take out 8 armed guys by just showing up between them and having 95% of them charge him without firing their weapons was just awful. Alfred leaving was so random too, how is that going to force Wayne too quit? All he's doing is abandoning him and leaving him to treat his wounds by himself, rather than having someone that knows his secret and can help him when shit hits the fan. Goes from "I want you live happy" to "I'm leaving, being your only real family and confidant because....maybe you'll quit?". My favorite scenes were in the prison, never knew you could fix a broken back by simply slamming your palm into the vertebrae and tying someone up to the roof. The doctor was great too, speaks one language for most of his scenes and then out of nowhere he's pumping out fluent english and is now the #1 source for knowing how to get out of the prison (even though he obviously never did it himself). Anyone want to explain how a child finds Ra's and a secret organization of super well trained ninjas? Did they have an advertisement or something? In the first movie they had Ra's al Ghul come to Bruce Wayne, not the other way around. What was up with the daughter sleeping with Wayne out of nowhere? Was there any build up there? Any reasoning behind that scene or was it there just fill up some time? Maybe make her betrayal more "painful" even though it's really just meaningless sex since neither of them seemed to have any relationship (Bruce shunned her before this movie everytime she tried to talk to him).Ra's should teach his daughter how to act too, her death scene was awful. I could understand in the first two movies how no one knew it was Bruce Wayne as batman because really all the batman had was his suit and the sick vehicle (still a little close there but it's believable). How can no one tell who it is now? The guys flying around in a super hightech flying machine, has the bike AND the new batmobile. Who the hell else has those types of resources? Not only that, but Bruce Wayne decides to hide from the world right when batman disappears, and then when Batman reappears, Bruce is back out in public again. Really a deep puzzle there. I wouldn't mind any of this stuff if the entire reason Nolan's movies were so praised was because they are supposed to be REALISTIC (in most aspects), gritty and dark. Going for the cliche "I'm going to blow up your city with a nuke" and have batman fly out and sacrafice himself (actually survived an atom bomb while being right near it only a few seconds before) was sad. There's tons of holes in this movie and I feel like Nolan sold out to make an epic finale that didn't come close to the last two movies. + Show Spoiler + You missed the part at the end where they discover that Wayne had fixed the autopilot mechanism on the craft. He wasn't in it when the nuke went off. | ||
Burns
United States2300 Posts
| ||
Endymion
United States3701 Posts
| ||
Demonhunter04
1530 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:36 Endymion wrote: the only redeeming feature of this movie was catwoman, she made the whole time worth while... i was bored for the entire movie while she wasn't on screen though. although take it with a grain of salt because i've never seen the first two batman movies.. overall i was disappointed, i liked ultimate spiderman a LOT better You definitely should see the first two, especially The Dark Knight. It might make the whole thing a lot more interesting. + Show Spoiler + I hope to god you are trolling, though. The new Spiderman movie was actually quite bad. | ||
CursedRich
United Kingdom737 Posts
| ||
Endymion
United States3701 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:41 Demonhunter04 wrote: You definitely should see the first two, especially The Dark Knight. It might make the whole thing a lot more interesting. + Show Spoiler + I hope to god you are trolling, though. The new Spiderman movie was actually quite bad. no i'm not i actually enjoyed it haha it was a lot better than the first one anyways.. | ||
TheRealPaciFist
United States1049 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + What was the point of the entire Cleanslate subplot? Just added motivation for catwoman? On July 23 2012 09:04 LeaD wrote: + Show Spoiler + The whole scene at the end was awful, with the police charging the criminals and that useless cop arriving in full uniform, made me want to laugh with how corny that was. The criminals had full automatics and they decided to fight hand to hand, and how the hell is anyone going to muster the strength to do anything in a fight after being stuck in a hole for 5 months. Did they have a gym down there? Batman is the DARK knight, not the fights in a crowd in broad daylight knight. What happened to the batman that fought with stealth like in the first movie? Watching him take out 8 armed guys by just showing up between them and having 95% of them charge him without firing their weapons was just awful. Alfred leaving was so random too, how is that going to force Wayne too quit? All he's doing is abandoning him and leaving him to treat his wounds by himself, rather than having someone that knows his secret and can help him when shit hits the fan. Goes from "I want you live happy" to "I'm leaving, being your only real family and confidant because....maybe you'll quit?". My favorite scenes were in the prison, never knew you could fix a broken back by simply slamming your palm into the vertebrae and tying someone up to the roof. The doctor was great too, speaks one language for most of his scenes and then out of nowhere he's pumping out fluent english and is now the #1 source for knowing how to get out of the prison (even though he obviously never did it himself). Anyone want to explain how a child finds Ra's and a secret organization of super well trained ninjas? Did they have an advertisement or something? In the first movie they had Ra's al Ghul come to Bruce Wayne, not the other way around. What was up with the daughter sleeping with Wayne out of nowhere? Was there any build up there? Any reasoning behind that scene or was it there just fill up some time? Maybe make her betrayal more "painful" even though it's really just meaningless sex since neither of them seemed to have any relationship (Bruce shunned her before this movie everytime she tried to talk to him).Ra's should teach his daughter how to act too, her death scene was awful. I could understand in the first two movies how no one knew it was Bruce Wayne as batman because really all the batman had was his suit and the sick vehicle (still a little close there but it's believable). How can no one tell who it is now? The guys flying around in a super hightech flying machine, has the bike AND the new batmobile. Who the hell else has those types of resources? Not only that, but Bruce Wayne decides to hide from the world right when batman disappears, and then when Batman reappears, Bruce is back out in public again. Really a deep puzzle there. I wouldn't mind any of this stuff if the entire reason Nolan's movies were so praised was because they are supposed to be REALISTIC (in most aspects), gritty and dark. Going for the cliche "I'm going to blow up your city with a nuke" and have batman fly out and sacrafice himself (actually survived an atom bomb while being right near it only a few seconds before) was sad. There's tons of holes in this movie and I feel like Nolan sold out to make an epic finale that didn't come close to the last two movies. + Show Spoiler + Fight at the end: for me I was okay with it through suspension of disbelief... the entire situation was kind of ridiculous to begin with (trapping thousands of cops in sewers with expertly placed explosives so that Bane can... uh... hold a city hostage with a nuke that he plans to blow up regardless? If they know the nuke was a timebomb, then why the hell do they want to suicide along with it? Ra's wanted to clean Gotham by razing it to the ground to build it back up, which involves killing people, but not exterminating millions with a nuke. Wtf?), so this extension of the situation I was fine with Alfred: well, he was emotional! People aren't rational when they're emotional Prison guys full of wisdom: yep, that was pretty random, but not so bad for suspension of disbelief, except no idea why he switched to English Talia: I think Ra's would know about anybody escaping the Lazarus Pit, especially his own daughter. However, I 100% agree with "What was up with the daughter sleeping with Wayne out of nowhere? Was there any build up there? Any reasoning behind that scene or was it there just fill up some time?" Bruce = Batman: I was wondering that during the movie too. The Bat pushes believability more than the tank does, but honestly I don't see a way for Nolan to get around that. Maybe many people assume that Batman is backed by a billionaire such as Wayne, but not necessarily that Batman is Wayne himself I think... I think the finale should have been something close and intimate, not something so grandiose (exact same plot as + Show Spoiler + Avengers Despite all my problems with the movie, I'd still give it an 8/10 just because the cast is so great and the action and cinematography and yadda yadda... but I'm starting to realize that the weakest part of the movie was the plot/writing, which is sad. Batman Begins was finely crafted, and Dark Knight had a bit of a pacing problem but the character of the Joker and the actor in Heath Ledger made it mind blowing, but DKR was not as tightly crafted, and the villain was not as compelling, which makes it feel like a let down in comparison... but I'm happy I got to see Alfred and Fox and Gordon in action again, and Blake and Catwoman were fun additions, and I need to see the movie again some time and see how I feel the second time around | ||
![]()
bkrow
Australia8532 Posts
On July 23 2012 08:32 xrapture wrote: Yep. Pulp Fiction, Fight Club, The Godfather, Star Wars, Alien, + many others. Extremely over dramatic super hero movies aren't exactly my thing. TDK was done well and the Joker was played fantastically, but when you don't tie up plot lines, hand hold your viewer for the hold movie, and have so many cliches the movie is going to suffer. Also, I didn't really see any running water where the cops were + they were sealed in from rocks. So even if there was a small amount of water running beneath their feet, you expect me to believe that if 3000 tightly packed men were pissing and shitting while malnourished and unbathed for 5 months none of them would get sick? Your post illustrates just how subjective movie ratings are! + Show Spoiler + Star Wars and Alien make your list.. but the dark knight and the dark knight rises get a <6/10 - insanity! The movie falls short for me on 2 occasions: + Show Spoiler + 1) Bain should have died WAY MORE epic than the way he did - even if he dies in the fight with Batman outside City Hall in a hand to hand combat scene and 2) Batman SHOULD HAVE DIED IN THE END!!!!!!!! + Show Spoiler + Maybe because i am a massive fanboy of this trilogy and Nolan's work on it but i would have given The Dark Knight a 9/10 and this one an 8/10 | ||
bourne117
United States837 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:41 Demonhunter04 wrote: You definitely should see the first two, especially The Dark Knight. It might make the whole thing a lot more interesting. + Show Spoiler + I hope to god you are trolling, though. The new Spiderman movie was actually quite bad. The new spiderman was good idk what you are smoking. It wasn't as good as TDKR but that doesn't make it bad. | ||
Rimstalker
Germany734 Posts
and as a rock-climber, the 'no one ever gets out' part was quite laughable, especially with huge ledges like that to rest. | ||
Roe
Canada6002 Posts
On July 23 2012 09:36 Endymion wrote: the only redeeming feature of this movie was catwoman, she made the whole time worth while... i was bored for the entire movie while she wasn't on screen though. although take it with a grain of salt because i've never seen the first two batman movies.. overall i was disappointed, i liked ultimate spiderman a LOT better don't you mean "The Amazing"? | ||
TheRabidDeer
United States3806 Posts
On July 23 2012 11:38 Rimstalker wrote: went in with no special expectations, and was a bit bored and confused by the plot. and as a rock-climber, the 'no one ever gets out' part was quite laughable, especially with huge ledges like that to rest. Pretty sure the only part people really failed at was the jump. Also dont get how you can be confused by the plot. | ||
| ||