EPTWhat is the biggest skill 1v1 fighter game? - Page 3
| Forum Index > General Games |
|
shavingcream66
United States1219 Posts
| ||
|
meegrean
Thailand7699 Posts
| ||
|
Sadist
United States7298 Posts
On January 30 2009 07:59 HamerD wrote: THANKS for this post. Moar of this plz guys. And I know it's lame to group the games into series but I don't want to get into fucking arguments about 'WHY DIDN'T YOU PUT SF4, 3S IS MUCH MORE PRO' and I didn't want to have a poll with 40 options. So I just want you to pick the series which has the most pro game in it, and discount the rest. And btw quite a lot of ppl I know often say virtua fighter too, and that it's just too hard to even get started in so it's best to just go with SF4 or SSBM. My friends all play ssbm but ill get us onto playing sf4. We all have always loved soul calibur because it's kind of the antithesis to pro gaming, it's so easy that a normal person can just pick it up and be relatively competitive...It's just really interesting to see the poll results even if half the people complain about it ^^ I disagree about soul calibur. Its very easy to pick up yes.....but vs better players who know what they are doing its incredibly difficult to win at all. You will get Parried(sp) and abused with the high low high low sideswip shit to death. | ||
|
sung_moon
United States10110 Posts
well all games can b hard... so yea..... | ||
|
qaswedfr25
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Scooter
United States747 Posts
Seeing pro Smash 64 is sex though, Isai's double jump canceled meteor spam with Ness is siiiick. That guy has to break a controller like every week... seriously. | ||
|
xJacky
China375 Posts
| ||
|
SayaSP
Laos5494 Posts
On January 30 2009 10:09 xJacky wrote: how come no one ever talks about KOF in TL. 97 is clearly the best fighting game after street fighter I like this post | ||
|
koreasilver
9109 Posts
On January 30 2009 03:03 SayaSP wrote: lol no KoF. | ||
|
MCMcEmcee
United States1609 Posts
On January 30 2009 10:09 xJacky wrote: how come no one ever talks about KOF in TL. 97 is clearly the best fighting game after street fighter 9898989898989898989898989898 | ||
|
Scooter
United States747 Posts
UMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUMUM | ||
|
Antifate
United States415 Posts
Soul Calibur (which in no way represents the 3D fighting genre), kind of feels like that linear, "memorize this combo and win" game that no one likes. Yes, it may require 3 weeks of practice, but doing the same few things over and over doesn't seem very skillful to me. Null vote. | ||
|
KissBlade
United States5718 Posts
| ||
|
cava
United States1035 Posts
| ||
cgrinker
United States3824 Posts
| ||
Bill307
Canada9103 Posts
Here's a better (more specific) question: which fighting game has the highest execution requirements? i.e. things like doing combos, using "bugs" (wave-dashing, kara-throwing, roll-cancelling, etc.), and so on. From my limited experience, I would say: SSBM - very high. Marvel vs Capcom 2 - probably very high? Tatsunoko vs Capcom - looks like it could be quite high, e.g. Morrigan's "A+B+C [B] up" instant overhead. Arcana Heart - low to very high, depending on character. BlazBlue - low to high, depending on character. SF3:3s - low to high, depending on character. SSB Brawl - low to mid / high, depending on character? Obviously this is different from "most skill", because there are many other skills common to fighting games besides having good execution. | ||
|
Bill307
Canada9103 Posts
 )Also, I will never learn SSBM or MvC2 because of their very high execution requirements. I enjoy having good execution to some extent, but it's definitely not the most enjoyable part of fighting games for me. I'd rather pick up a game where I can practice hardcore for a few days and have 90% of my character's execution down, so that I can compete in the more mental aspects of the game. Another benefit of having lower execution requirements is that it's easier to introduce new players to the game (especially if they've played other FGs before). I don't think anyone wants to play a game where they lose solely because of differences in execution: it's just not fun. | ||
|
ZoW
United States3983 Posts
| ||
|
Scooter
United States747 Posts
| ||
|
DBunny
Canada192 Posts
And as for mvc2 being the hardest game, yes it requires very good reaction and it is fast paced but just because the combos are longer doesn't mean it requires more skill in execution. Pulling off consecutive kara palms is more difficult than most combos in mvc2. I would vote for 3S since skill to me is beyond just mastering timings and execution. I would say that playing someone who has such game presence that having him just crouch one character length away from you has you hesitating to attack since he will likely punish you hard in 3S is more impressive than someone who can combo you all day in mvc2. | ||
| ||
