Anime Discussion Thread - Page 5335
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
Faust852
Luxembourg4004 Posts
| ||
|
Nezgar
Germany535 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [summery of how stupid that episode was] + Felia is just obnoxious and the rest of the characters have nothing going for them except raw stupidity. They know that Maura has the capability to transform into some sort of super-mech, yet they never bothered to ask, how that actually works. You know, that thing that already saved their asses and will probably safe it a couple dozen times in the future, too. They also never bothered to ask about her powers. And they somehow decided that it was a good idea to not keep a low profile after being chased and attacked by military mechs in the past. Strolling through the street seemed like a much better idea to them - coincidentally in view of that other obnoxious dude and Otto, who just happened to look through his spyglass at the exact right time in the exact right place. I guess it was the only way, so that purple-hair dude can stumble across them by mere chance in this fucking gigantic city. That guy miraculously can control all stuff in the city (even the flow of the sewer system, it seem) and get cameras to follow them everywhere... even though some of the camera angles he was watching them from are simply impossible. When the construction mech attacked, they somehow did not think of using Maura... because that would make sense. It's not like they had to hide his presence or anything, there were no other persons around them during any stage of the chase or fight... probably because involving bystanders would have meant extra work for whoever came up with the story. Deciding to get into that wagon was a brilliant idea, considering that they knew that someone was hijacking stuff all over the city and knowing that they were targeted - and not for the first time, too. Then purple-hair dude can suddenly project animated and voiced holograms at any part of the city that he so wants. Why Kuon and Maura did not interfere against the hologram that was driving Felia towards the fucking door of that cart is beyond me. It's not like Maura is tasked with protecting her and has shown the capabilities to distract people even in his tiny form. Mechs fighting on top of the cables is alright, holding onto them snaps then, however. Because reasons. The MC also happened to drive his thing at exactly the right place at exactly the right time to make an impossible jump that would completely smash him against the card and break every single bone in his body. But the episode is not done with stupid stuff yet. For whatever reason purple-hair dude raises the protection in front of his window, just so that the snapped cable can smash through it at the end and graze his head in such a way that only cuts some part of his hair in a ridiculous pattern. It ends with that guy walking out of a building just to get spotted by the military guy that wants his help for whatever fucking reason. I don't know if I should drop that show or keep watching... just to see whether they can top that amount of bullshit. From what I have seen thus far, the series is a weird mix of infuriating and laughable. Should probably dub it "Comet Convenience" | ||
|
Makenshi
Sweden2105 Posts
| ||
|
BurningSera
Ireland19621 Posts
On October 19 2015 06:34 Nezgar wrote: Oh wow, Comet Lucifer ep3 was terrible: + Show Spoiler [summery of how stupid that episode was] + Felia is just obnoxious and the rest of the characters have nothing going for them except raw stupidity. They know that Maura has the capability to transform into some sort of super-mech, yet they never bothered to ask, how that actually works. You know, that thing that already saved their asses and will probably safe it a couple dozen times in the future, too. They also never bothered to ask about her powers. And they somehow decided that it was a good idea to not keep a low profile after being chased and attacked by military mechs in the past. Strolling through the street seemed like a much better idea to them - coincidentally in view of that other obnoxious dude and Otto, who just happened to look through his spyglass at the exact right time in the exact right place. I guess it was the only way, so that purple-hair dude can stumble across them by mere chance in this fucking gigantic city. That guy miraculously can control all stuff in the city (even the flow of the sewer system, it seem) and get cameras to follow them everywhere... even though some of the camera angles he was watching them from are simply impossible. When the construction mech attacked, they somehow did not think of using Maura... because that would make sense. It's not like they had to hide his presence or anything, there were no other persons around them during any stage of the chase or fight... probably because involving bystanders would have meant extra work for whoever came up with the story. Deciding to get into that wagon was a brilliant idea, considering that they knew that someone was hijacking stuff all over the city and knowing that they were targeted - and not for the first time, too. Then purple-hair dude can suddenly project animated and voiced holograms at any part of the city that he so wants. Why Kuon and Maura did not interfere against the hologram that was driving Felia towards the fucking door of that cart is beyond me. It's not like Maura is tasked with protecting her and has shown the capabilities to distract people even in his tiny form. Mechs fighting on top of the cables is alright, holding onto them snaps then, however. Because reasons. The MC also happened to drive his thing at exactly the right place at exactly the right time to make an impossible jump that would completely smash him against the card and break every single bone in his body. But the episode is not done with stupid stuff yet. For whatever reason purple-hair dude raises the protection in front of his window, just so that the snapped cable can smash through it at the end and graze his head in such a way that only cuts some part of his hair in a ridiculous pattern. It ends with that guy walking out of a building just to get spotted by the military guy that wants his help for whatever fucking reason. I don't know if I should drop that show or keep watching... just to see whether they can top that amount of bullshit. From what I have seen thus far, the series is a weird mix of infuriating and laughable. Should probably dub it "Comet Convenience" lolol i wasnt going to watch #3 but your comment made me haha. Ye, it is that bad, i am done with it haha. The purple hair dude really came out of nowhere hahahaah OPM#3 is excellent. Those without reading manga would laugh your asses off i bet haha | ||
|
XenOmega
Canada2822 Posts
Watched episode 2 of Comet Lucifer : What do you think of this anime? I have a negative feeling about it :O | ||
|
killa_robot
Canada1884 Posts
| ||
|
IceHism
United States1903 Posts
On October 19 2015 09:49 XenOmega wrote: Started Subete today : What are everyone's thoughts about that anime? Watched episode 2 of Comet Lucifer : What do you think of this anime? I have a negative feeling about it :O I like subete. I've seen the drama but that deviated from the source which is a mainstream novel. This one is suppose to follow the source. The dialogue in it is nice. Also, its not an episodic mystery so I'm excited for that. I haven't even checked out comet Lucifer yet but so far I'm hearing that it is really fantastical and light hearted so I'll probably skip it. | ||
|
c3rberUs
Japan11286 Posts
| ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On October 19 2015 12:41 c3rberUs wrote: I didn't watch the 2003 anime but if it dragged out those episodes, then I disagree that it was better. What I liked about Brotherhood was the fact that it got into the juicy parts relatively quickly. Those first parts in fmab already did well to flesh out Ed and Al's character along with the side cast's. They did a good job of not falling into the 'elaborate-some-side-character's-story-too-much' trap. Well, this is my opinion at least. "I've never seen it but I'm sure it's better / worse because reasons." SMH | ||
|
Nezgar
Germany535 Posts
On October 19 2015 11:01 IceHism wrote: I haven't even checked out comet Lucifer yet but so far I'm hearing that it is really fantastical and light hearted so I'll probably skip it. The first episode was fairly good, sparked my interest. episode 2 was meh, mostly annoying and nothing of consequence happened, so I already had a pretty bad feeling going into episode 3... I was not prepared for what I was about to see. I have posted a quick summary of how stupid episode 3 of that series is a few posts above yours. | ||
|
BigFan
TLADT24920 Posts
| ||
|
Spazer
Canada8033 Posts
Not really feeling Garo yet. But then again, s1 didn't have much going for it other than horror design and general fight choreography until ep 12 or so. Seimei is pretty good, at least. The OP is disappointingly mediocre. Even the song's not particularly good for JAM Project. OPM: Now there's a great JAM Project song. The OP's well drawn and animated too. It's the best OP of the season for me by far. Heavy Object's logic seems to revolve around the enemy forgetting about centuries of war and being generally dumb. Dropped. The new gundam seems okay so far. Not a fan of the romance hints though. This ain't Macross. | ||
|
Unleashing
Denmark14978 Posts
On October 19 2015 10:03 killa_robot wrote: I dunno. I think some of the jokes had too large a build up in OPM. Other than that I'm enjoying it though. I had hoped they'd squeeze in 1 more chapter in that episode honestly. | ||
|
Slaughter
United States20254 Posts
On October 19 2015 15:03 Spazer wrote: Comet Lucifer ep 3 was hilariously bad. It's almost impressive how annoying they made most of the cast. The worst part is that the Cafe owner is a man named Domon, and he doesn't even do martial arts. Dropped. Not really feeling Garo yet. But then again, s1 didn't have much going for it other than horror design and general fight choreography until ep 12 or so. Seimei is pretty good, at least. The OP is disappointingly mediocre. Even the song's not particularly good for JAM Project. OPM: Now there's a great JAM Project song. The OP's well drawn and animated too. It's the best OP of the season for me by far. Heavy Object's logic seems to revolve around the enemy forgetting about centuries of war and being generally dumb. Dropped. The new gundam seems okay so far. Not a fan of the romance hints though. This ain't Macross. Could you explain this? I didn't see anything particularly egregious outside the lame attempt to make them seem evil with the "crazy fanatic commander" dude. | ||
|
Spazer
Canada8033 Posts
On October 19 2015 15:13 Slaughter wrote: Could you explain this? I didn't see anything particularly egregious outside the lame attempt to make them seem evil with the "crazy fanatic commander" dude. + Show Spoiler + Off the top of my head: How on earth did "clean war" become a thing at all? People have been fighting wars for a very, very long time, and it has never been humane. Things like the Geneva Conventions are attempts to make it less barbaric, but even in modern times, massacres and atrocities still happen. Even if objects came to dominate warfare, there's no reason to stop once the enemy object is destroyed. In fact, the best time to crush the opposition is when they're routing. Sabotage and guerrilla warfare isn't a new concept. I don't know why they all act like it is. Surely the powers that be have been trying other methods to defeat the objects? Infiltrate the technicians and assassinate the elite. Poison their rations and take out their supply route. Feed them misinformation and lead them into a trap where your own object can take them out. There's a ton of shit that nobody is seemingly doing. The enemy has no mechanized or air support because they have an object. Thing is, combined arms exist for a reason. It's not like tanks stopped being used once RPGs were invented. Even if they can't take on an object directly, they still fulfil important functions in an army. Are you going to have objects patrol enemy territory 24/7? How do you respond to multiple threats if you only have an object? Who's guarding the supply trucks and other logistical elements? Hell, the cost alone would probably mean that objects are grossly inefficient for most of these applications. Now that I think about it, the combined arms thing is something that Muvluv got really right. EXECUTE THE SOLDIERS WITH THE MAIN GUNS. Great idea. | ||
|
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
On October 19 2015 15:56 Spazer wrote: + Show Spoiler + Off the top of my head: How on earth did "clean war" become a thing at all? People have been fighting wars for a very, very long time, and it has never been humane. Things like the Geneva Conventions are attempts to make it less barbaric, but even in modern times, massacres and atrocities still happen. Even if objects came to dominate warfare, there's no reason to stop once the enemy object is destroyed. In fact, the best time to crush the opposition is when they're routing. Sabotage and guerrilla warfare isn't a new concept. I don't know why they all act like it is. Surely the powers that be have been trying other methods to defeat the objects? Infiltrate the technicians and assassinate the elite. Poison their rations and take out their supply route. Feed them misinformation and lead them into a trap where your own object can take them out. There's a ton of shit that nobody is seemingly doing. The enemy has no mechanized or air support because they have an object. Thing is, combined arms exist for a reason. It's not like tanks stopped being used once RPGs were invented. Even if they can't take on an object directly, they still fulfil important functions in an army. Are you going to have objects patrol enemy territory 24/7? How do you respond to multiple threats if you only have an object? Who's guarding the supply trucks and other logistical elements? Hell, the cost alone would probably mean that objects are grossly inefficient for most of these applications. Now that I think about it, the combined arms thing is something that Muvluv got really right. EXECUTE THE SOLDIERS WITH THE MAIN GUNS. Great idea. + Show Spoiler + Pretty much the first thing I thought of after ep1. Why not just attack where the 1 god damn object is not... | ||
|
Slaughter
United States20254 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + As for your concerns about combined forces....well they still have them? I don't see your point there, just cause the enemies base got wrecked and caught with their pants down doesn't mean they didn't have them....I mean their own army swooped in with tanks and stuff once the object blew up and the dudes were literally clearing the runway for planes in episode 1. They still have these things and this directly led to the mcs not getting killed lol. One thing I will give you is the "clean wars" thing because humanity sucks like that. Though that thought got pretty much overturned in episode 2 where the Object moved in to completely massacre everyone. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
On October 19 2015 12:41 c3rberUs wrote: I didn't watch the 2003 anime but if it dragged out those episodes, then I disagree that it was better. What I liked about Brotherhood was the fact that it got into the juicy parts relatively quickly. Those first parts in fmab already did well to flesh out Ed and Al's character along with the side cast's. They did a good job of not falling into the 'elaborate-some-side-character's-story-too-much' trap. Well, this is my opinion at least. You should watch the 2003 anime. It's still a good anime even if FMAB is a slightly better anime. They flesh out the characters a lot better in 2003 where as Brotherhood rushes to get the plot moving at times. | ||
|
Miragee
8638 Posts
On October 19 2015 15:04 Unleashing wrote: I had hoped they'd squeeze in 1 more chapter in that episode honestly. I was hoping that as well but I was pretty sure that they wouldn't do it. The 3 chapters they did were longer as in there was much more talk instead of fighting which takes longer time in the anime. I think they will do the rest of the volume in the next episode because that's what would fit story-wise and is about the length they need for the episode. I guess it's a bit more than for the last one so we will see how that will work out. On October 19 2015 17:45 Numy wrote: You should watch the 2003 anime. It's still a good anime even if FMAB is a slightly better anime. They flesh out the characters a lot better in 2003 where as Brotherhood rushes to get the plot moving at times. To be honest, the only character that gets a significantly better treatment in 2003 is Hughes. On October 19 2015 09:49 XenOmega wrote: Started Subete today : What are everyone's thoughts about that anime? It's a bit weird at times but quite good so far. Pacing is relatively slow but I like that here. I think it layed down the right stepping stones to evolve into something elaborate. | ||
|
ShurykaN
United States338 Posts
Heavy Object + Show Spoiler [rambling] + Isn't the point that the objects make everything else obsolete? One of the characters mentions that they being there and everything that's not directly related to the object seems like wasteful spending, so maybe the other guys were trying to cut expenses. Their tier 2 object did manage to beat the princess so normally they should've won that fight. But you're right going so far as to only have an object seems extreme. And executing them like that with the object is just silly lol, the guys have rifles in their hands they could use that wouldn't decimate their own base. And not being able to cancel self-destruct sequences is a little strange, it didn't even look like it ejected the pilot either. And why would they even be executed in the first place shouldn't they be put in prison to be used as hostages? | ||
| ||