• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 15:12
CET 21:12
KST 05:12
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
RSL Revival - 2025 Season Finals Preview8RSL Season 3 - Playoffs Preview0RSL Season 3 - RO16 Groups C & D Preview0RSL Season 3 - RO16 Groups A & B Preview2TL.net Map Contest #21: Winners12
Community News
Weekly Cups (Dec 15-21): Classic wins big, MaxPax & Clem take weeklies3ComeBackTV's documentary on Byun's Career !11Weekly Cups (Dec 8-14): MaxPax, Clem, Cure win4Weekly Cups (Dec 1-7): Clem doubles, Solar gets over the hump1Weekly Cups (Nov 24-30): MaxPax, Clem, herO win2
StarCraft 2
General
ComeBackTV's documentary on Byun's Career ! Team TLMC #5: Winners Announced! What's the best tug of war? The Grack before Christmas Weekly Cups (Dec 15-21): Classic wins big, MaxPax & Clem take weeklies
Tourneys
OSC Season 13 World Championship $5,000+ WardiTV 2025 Championship $100 Prize Pool - Winter Warp Gate Masters Showdow Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Winter Warp Gate Amateur Showdown #1
Strategy
Custom Maps
Map Editor closed ?
External Content
Mutation # 505 Rise From Ashes Mutation # 504 Retribution Mutation # 503 Fowl Play Mutation # 502 Negative Reinforcement
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion How soO Began His ProGaming Dreams Klaucher discontinued / in-game color settings BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Recommended FPV games (post-KeSPA)
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL21] LB SemiFinals - Saturday 21:00 CET [BSL21] WB & LB Finals - Sunday 21:00 CET Small VOD Thread 2.0
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Game Theory for Starcraft Current Meta Fighting Spirit mining rates
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Mechabellum Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Beyond All Reason Path of Exile
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
Mafia Game Mode Feedback/Ideas Survivor II: The Amazon Sengoku Mafia TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread 12 Days of Starcraft The Games Industry And ATVI Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
White-Ra Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List TL+ Announced Where to ask questions and add stream?
Blogs
National Diversity: A Challe…
TrAiDoS
I decided to write a webnov…
DjKniteX
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
Thanks for the RSL
Hildegard
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1513 users

The Sequel Dilemma - Page 3

Forum Index > BW General
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next All
ziGG
Profile Joined June 2010
United States5 Posts
September 20 2010 19:12 GMT
#41
1st off let me say a what a great read. I come mostly from a cs 1.6 background and remember going thru these stages step by step with css.

That being said from what I understand you are pretty off on the halo transition. Halo 1 was (still is?) Condsiderd the best mutiplayer incarnation of the series. When halo 2 came out most high level players didn't like it nearly as much. But the main league MLG was getting very little attendance. They switch to halo2. And exploded with growth despite the "top tier" players disliking it.

This is where money comes in. Even tho they enjoyed playing halo1 more there was no money to be had. Apernrtly making a living from a video game matter more then playing a game they enjoyed more.

Idk if this was happen with Starcraft or not. But GSL is sure trying to take it i'n that direction. For better or worse
krndandaman
Profile Joined August 2009
Mozambique16569 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 19:50:46
September 20 2010 19:47 GMT
#42
--- Nuked ---
iSTime
Profile Joined November 2006
1579 Posts
September 20 2010 20:05 GMT
#43
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Everyone sticking to BW says the same shit all the time: BW is hard, SC2 is easy, and all the people who play SC2 just want to play an easier game.

This is like elitist go players saying go is hard, chess is easy, and if you really wanted to play a difficult game, play go. Nobody will ever reach the skill cap in either game, so it's ridiculous to call one "easy" and one "hard." Yes, it's hard to make your units even respond in a reasonable way in BW compared to SC2, but that has nothing to do with which game is more competitive, it only makes BW more frustrating to play as a beginner.

Clearly, BW with only being allowed to select 1 unit at a time and not being allowed to hotkey anything would be "harder" than BW in the sense that you guys are talking about, and it would raise the skill ceiling even higher, but would you really want to play it over BW? No, obviously not.

FWIW: Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that. But I do not think people play sc2 because it's easier.



I feel like you missed the entire point of my post. Sure, BW is "harder" in the sense that it's harder to a-move 100 supply in BW than in SC2, and in the sense that dragoons are mind-bogglingly retarded compared to stalkers. However, BW players want to take this fact and say that BW therefor requires more skill to compete at the top level, or that players will reach some skill ceiling in SC2.

There is no reason to believe a priori that the latter is true, and I think all of the top foreigners from BW who play SC2 believe that it is false; that no one will ever reach the skill ceiling in SC2.

As for the former, it is obviously true at the moment, but that's because nobody has spent 5 years playing the game, perfectly their build orders, timings, mechanics, etc. etc.

So is BW "harder" than SC2? Yes, but only if you want to take a very narrow and irrelevant definition of what it means to be harder.
www.infinityseven.net
sCCrooked
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Korea (South)1306 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 20:12:52
September 20 2010 20:08 GMT
#44
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


Has anyone else noticed you only are referring to people who couldn't make it in BW? There's a ton of people who agree with us. I'm a SC2 Beta player who changed back to BW because SC2 was boring as shit to me. Notice noone worth listening to agrees with anyone who has an opinion similar to yours. Its either some other crappy SC2 player or someone who has something vested in the SC2 scene enough so that they'll defend it no matter what. There's no talking to people who are that dumb, so why would we try? I can't speak for the others here but I don't go around the SC2 forum trolling. The SC2 people have no trouble coming here either and continuously proclaiming the death of BW and how sad everything is and how everyone is going to SC2. The bottom line is that the SC2 scene isn't getting a ton of progame teams. Its not getting the multiple large corporate sponsorships, and its not getting ANY of the top 10 players of BW. The next year of tournaments will happen regardless of this stupid-ass Gretech situation as has already been stated officially.

Getting to D+ doesn't mean you know anything at all. I've gotten to C+ within 2 weeks every time I come back and play BW after taking year long breaks, and I don't know any modern build orders (read: I haven't read about build orders/watched pro-BW games since yellow vs boxer). I also don't understand timing attack in BW or any of the other shit you talk about.


We all went to SC2 without knowing what the units were. Within a few days, anyone who could do the basics could be diamond. Today the diamond league is still a huge cesspool of semi-ok players. I was a high diamond on SC2 as well as play BW. I don't care how much you self-proclaim that you're some awesome player on both and how we're full of shit. You're the only one that is constantly proving how full of shit you are. The only good players in SC2 are ex-BW players, and the ones that switched over were either practically retired on BW or sucked so bad they couldn't contend with top BW players anymore. Hell, even NaDa old as he is could probably stand up at the top for a long time on SC2 (definately will stomp the entire current joke of a "proscene" SC2 has). I'm willing to bet you're not really as good as you say you are on either game because quite simply... I've been involved in the inner workings of the proscenes a lot more than most. Noone, and I mean noone who is any good has attitudes like yours. When you learn how to act like an adult, maybe you can join us in trying to have BW and SC2 working together.
Enlightened in an age of anti-intellectualism and quotidian repetitiveness of asinine assumptive thinking. Best lycan guide evar --> "Fixing solo queue all pick one game at a time." ~KwarK-
iSTime
Profile Joined November 2006
1579 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 20:28:22
September 20 2010 20:24 GMT
#45
On September 21 2010 05:08 Diminotoor wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


Has anyone else noticed you only are referring to people who couldn't make it in BW? There's a ton of people who agree with us. I'm a SC2 Beta player who changed back to BW because SC2 was boring as shit to me. Notice noone worth listening to agrees with anyone who has an opinion similar to yours. Its either some other crappy SC2 player or someone who has something vested in the SC2 scene enough so that they'll defend it no matter what. There's no talking to people who are that dumb, so why would we try? I can't speak for the others here but I don't go around the SC2 forum trolling. The SC2 people have no trouble coming here either and continuously proclaiming the death of BW and how sad everything is and how everyone is going to SC2. The bottom line is that the SC2 scene isn't getting a ton of progame teams. Its not getting the multiple large corporate sponsorships, and its not getting ANY of the top 10 players of BW. The next year of tournaments will happen regardless of this stupid-ass Gretech situation as has already been stated officially.

Show nested quote +
Getting to D+ doesn't mean you know anything at all. I've gotten to C+ within 2 weeks every time I come back and play BW after taking year long breaks, and I don't know any modern build orders (read: I haven't read about build orders/watched pro-BW games since yellow vs boxer). I also don't understand timing attack in BW or any of the other shit you talk about.


We all went to SC2 without knowing what the units were. Within a few days, anyone who could do the basics could be diamond. Today the diamond league is still a huge cesspool of semi-ok players. I was a high diamond on SC2 as well as play BW. I don't care how much you self-proclaim that you're some awesome player on both and how we're full of shit. You're the only one that is constantly proving how full of shit you are. The only good players in SC2 are ex-BW players, and the ones that switched over were either practically retired on BW or sucked so bad they couldn't contend with top BW players anymore. Hell, even NaDa old as he is could probably stand up at the top for a long time on SC2 (definately will stomp the entire current joke of a "proscene" SC2 has). I'm willing to bet you're not really as good as you say you are on either game because quite simply... I've been involved in the inner workings of the proscenes a lot more than most. Noone, and I mean noone who is any good has attitudes like yours. When you learn how to act like an adult, maybe you can join us in trying to have BW and SC2 working together.


I don't really card enough to respond in paragraphs, since your arguments are just absurd and you are misrepresenting my position horribly, as well as making unreasonable logical fallacies.

a) I never claimed to be good, I'm only pointing out that most of the people responding are terribad

b) Good job, you made it into high diamond. Did you win any big tournaments?

c) Of course it is easy to get into high diamond 1 month in, but it was easy to be a top player in
BW 1 month in also. Try getting high diamond in 2 years.

d) Doubting that a random can get to C+ and have a shitty attitude towards idiots is LOL.

e) BW players troll harder than anyone, so accusing SC2 players of trolling is ridiculous. Any thread I read in the BW forums that mentions SC2 says this: "BW skill, SC2 unskill, everyone who plays SC2 does it because they're bad." They also say the same thing about WC3.

EDIT: Because you're so incredibly dense, let me repeat this:

Yes, the SC2 is "a joke" compared to BW. THIS IS BECAUSE SC2 IS 6 MONTHS OLD. The fact that you even try to compare the proscene in 10+ year old game to the proscene in a 6 month old (if you include the beta) game is just beyond retarded.
www.infinityseven.net
sCCrooked
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Korea (South)1306 Posts
September 20 2010 20:35 GMT
#46
I don't really card enough to respond in paragraphs, since your arguments are just absurd and you are misrepresenting my position horribly, as well as making unreasonable logical fallacies.


You're trying to pull "logical fallacies" while simultaneously managing to show your lack of understanding of what they are. I usually respond in a longer format because I'm an educated person, and like to cover my points thoroughly. Its ok that most don't choose that route for their minds though.

a) I never claimed to be good, I'm only pointing out that most of the people responding are terribad


The same goes for SC2's side.

b) Good job, you made it into high diamond. Did you win any big tournaments?


No or else I'd probably be practicing my ladder right now instead of posting. I certainly tried though and found I could in fact contend at the earlier rounds and with practice maybe I could've gone farther.

c) Of course it is easy to get into high diamond 1 month in, but it was easy to be a top player in
BW 1 month in also. Try getting high diamond in 2 years.


No, try getting into high diamond after its been out for years AND both the expansions have been out for years (plural). That is when I'll consider the SC2 scene to be as big, dominating, and mature as everyone seems to be acting like it is.

d) Doubting that a random can get to C+ and have a shitty attitude towards idiots is LOL.


Unless you cheese your way there, I literally don't know anyone who plays by 2007's rules (or earlier) and hasn't played in years and never touched SCBW who can just come back and clomp around near the blue ranks. If you play BW, you know that even a little time off will make your skill slip considerably when compared to the people who have been playing the entire time.

e) BW players troll harder than anyone, so accusing SC2 players of trolling is ridiculous. Any thread I read in the BW forums that mentions SC2 says this: "BW skill, SC2 unskill, everyone who plays SC2 does it because they're bad." They also say the same thing about WC3.


This is the most LOL ever. SC2 players are people just like BW players are. People tend to bitch and annoy each other sometimes no matter what. SC2 people definately troll hard like you claim SCBW people do. I don't go over there with a shitty attitude because one day I might be too old to play at 300+ APM on BW or maybe I'll just want to switch over 100% instead of 50-50. The same type of people can certainly exist within SC2 community like they can in SCBW. As for the whole "skill vs unskill" thing... "SCBW Proleague". That's all I have to say.
Enlightened in an age of anti-intellectualism and quotidian repetitiveness of asinine assumptive thinking. Best lycan guide evar --> "Fixing solo queue all pick one game at a time." ~KwarK-
krndandaman
Profile Joined August 2009
Mozambique16569 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 20:41:41
September 20 2010 20:38 GMT
#47
--- Nuked ---
Tazza
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Korea (South)1678 Posts
September 20 2010 20:41 GMT
#48
I just read it and I agree with most of what you said. Its really hard for a beginner to get into SC1 because of the skill level. Even d- players in iccup aren't too bad
sCCrooked
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Korea (South)1306 Posts
September 20 2010 20:59 GMT
#49

Yes, the SC2 is "a joke" compared to BW. THIS IS BECAUSE SC2 IS 6 MONTHS OLD. The fact that you even try to compare the proscene in 10+ year old game to the proscene in a 6 month old (if you include the beta) game is just beyond retarded.


Really? No shit! So stop trying to argue a bunch of retarded points as if the scene is mature and ready to take on the scene of BW. The fact that you come in a forum dedicated to BW, make an ignorant blanket statement that everyone in this opinion pool is a terribad n00b player with no brains IS "beyond retarded".
Enlightened in an age of anti-intellectualism and quotidian repetitiveness of asinine assumptive thinking. Best lycan guide evar --> "Fixing solo queue all pick one game at a time." ~KwarK-
TheAngelofDeath
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States2033 Posts
September 20 2010 21:02 GMT
#50
Very nice write up. Thanks a bunch for it. :D
"Infestors are the suck" - LzGamer
sCCrooked
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Korea (South)1306 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 21:04:06
September 20 2010 21:02 GMT
#51
**Edit double-post somehow... stupid browser**
Enlightened in an age of anti-intellectualism and quotidian repetitiveness of asinine assumptive thinking. Best lycan guide evar --> "Fixing solo queue all pick one game at a time." ~KwarK-
iSTime
Profile Joined November 2006
1579 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 21:31:37
September 20 2010 21:30 GMT
#52
On September 21 2010 05:38 krndandaman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 05:05 PJA wrote:
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Everyone sticking to BW says the same shit all the time: BW is hard, SC2 is easy, and all the people who play SC2 just want to play an easier game.

This is like elitist go players saying go is hard, chess is easy, and if you really wanted to play a difficult game, play go. Nobody will ever reach the skill cap in either game, so it's ridiculous to call one "easy" and one "hard." Yes, it's hard to make your units even respond in a reasonable way in BW compared to SC2, but that has nothing to do with which game is more competitive, it only makes BW more frustrating to play as a beginner.

Clearly, BW with only being allowed to select 1 unit at a time and not being allowed to hotkey anything would be "harder" than BW in the sense that you guys are talking about, and it would raise the skill ceiling even higher, but would you really want to play it over BW? No, obviously not.

FWIW: Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that. But I do not think people play sc2 because it's easier.



I feel like you missed the entire point of my post. Sure, BW is "harder" in the sense that it's harder to a-move 100 supply in BW than in SC2, and in the sense that dragoons are mind-bogglingly retarded compared to stalkers. However, BW players want to take this fact and say that BW therefor requires more skill to compete at the top level, or that players will reach some skill ceiling in SC2.

There is no reason to believe a priori that the latter is true, and I think all of the top foreigners from BW who play SC2 believe that it is false; that no one will ever reach the skill ceiling in SC2.

As for the former, it is obviously true at the moment, but that's because nobody has spent 5 years playing the game, perfectly their build orders, timings, mechanics, etc. etc.

So is BW "harder" than SC2? Yes, but only if you want to take a very narrow and irrelevant definition of what it means to be harder.


No, BW is harder because
1) harder to amove groups of units/control
2) no multi building selection (harder macro)
3) no automining
4) more retarded AI
People think SC2 is a game that requires more intelligence than bw, but that is wrong. SC2 just rewards intelligent thinking more because all of the 'mechanics' are pretty much dealt with by the AI and new features.

I really don't think anyone would reach the skill ceiling in any RTS.

Please ask the top foreigners whether they think bw is harder or sc2.
Most of them will say BW. Though some will prob give the bullshit responses "oh both are hard games" "you cant compare the 2". None, I mean zero, will say SC2 is harder than bw. I also think I remember Nony or Idra saying BW was harder, i forget. im a bit more sure it was idra
edit: or it could be both of them who said bw was harder


You still aren't understanding:

In any player versus player game, as long as there is no skill cap that players can actually reach and the winner is determined primarily by skill (i.e., not mostly luck based), it is meaningless to say one game is harder than the other.
www.infinityseven.net
Jaeger
Profile Joined December 2009
United States1150 Posts
September 20 2010 21:35 GMT
#53
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that.


Regarding Starcraft 2's gameplay, he said that "I think the game has gotten more difficult compared to the original", adding that "But because I had experience playing Starcraft as a progamer, I'm getting better rapidly."

- July officially announces his move to Starcraft 2
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=151746
https://www.dotabuff.com/players/8137911
krndandaman
Profile Joined August 2009
Mozambique16569 Posts
September 20 2010 21:52 GMT
#54
--- Nuked ---
unit
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United States2621 Posts
September 20 2010 21:53 GMT
#55
On September 21 2010 06:35 Jaeger wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that.


Regarding Starcraft 2's gameplay, he said that "I think the game has gotten more difficult compared to the original", adding that "But because I had experience playing Starcraft as a progamer, I'm getting better rapidly."

- July officially announces his move to Starcraft 2
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=151746

July was referring to the ability to dominate the competition is harder, because there is so little that separates the top tier from the rest in SC2 atm unlike in BW where for the top players it was easier to just maintain your skills due to there being more separating the top from the average joe
iSTime
Profile Joined November 2006
1579 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 21:55:41
September 20 2010 21:53 GMT
#56
On September 21 2010 06:52 krndandaman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 06:30 PJA wrote:
On September 21 2010 05:38 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 05:05 PJA wrote:
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Everyone sticking to BW says the same shit all the time: BW is hard, SC2 is easy, and all the people who play SC2 just want to play an easier game.

This is like elitist go players saying go is hard, chess is easy, and if you really wanted to play a difficult game, play go. Nobody will ever reach the skill cap in either game, so it's ridiculous to call one "easy" and one "hard." Yes, it's hard to make your units even respond in a reasonable way in BW compared to SC2, but that has nothing to do with which game is more competitive, it only makes BW more frustrating to play as a beginner.

Clearly, BW with only being allowed to select 1 unit at a time and not being allowed to hotkey anything would be "harder" than BW in the sense that you guys are talking about, and it would raise the skill ceiling even higher, but would you really want to play it over BW? No, obviously not.

FWIW: Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that. But I do not think people play sc2 because it's easier.



I feel like you missed the entire point of my post. Sure, BW is "harder" in the sense that it's harder to a-move 100 supply in BW than in SC2, and in the sense that dragoons are mind-bogglingly retarded compared to stalkers. However, BW players want to take this fact and say that BW therefor requires more skill to compete at the top level, or that players will reach some skill ceiling in SC2.

There is no reason to believe a priori that the latter is true, and I think all of the top foreigners from BW who play SC2 believe that it is false; that no one will ever reach the skill ceiling in SC2.

As for the former, it is obviously true at the moment, but that's because nobody has spent 5 years playing the game, perfectly their build orders, timings, mechanics, etc. etc.

So is BW "harder" than SC2? Yes, but only if you want to take a very narrow and irrelevant definition of what it means to be harder.


No, BW is harder because
1) harder to amove groups of units/control
2) no multi building selection (harder macro)
3) no automining
4) more retarded AI
People think SC2 is a game that requires more intelligence than bw, but that is wrong. SC2 just rewards intelligent thinking more because all of the 'mechanics' are pretty much dealt with by the AI and new features.

I really don't think anyone would reach the skill ceiling in any RTS.

Please ask the top foreigners whether they think bw is harder or sc2.
Most of them will say BW. Though some will prob give the bullshit responses "oh both are hard games" "you cant compare the 2". None, I mean zero, will say SC2 is harder than bw. I also think I remember Nony or Idra saying BW was harder, i forget. im a bit more sure it was idra
edit: or it could be both of them who said bw was harder


You still aren't understanding:

In any player versus player game, as long as there is no skill cap that players can actually reach and the winner is determined primarily by skill (i.e., not mostly luck based), it is meaningless to say one game is harder than the other.


How is that so?
Just because there is no skill cap does not mean that all games have the same learning curve.
It also is easier to reach near the skill cap in some games over others.
I can safely say it's easier to reach near skill cap in say Warcraft III over BW. Right?


What evidence do you have to support that conclusion about WC3?

Also, what exactly is appealing about having a steeper learning curve? As long as the skill cap is high enough that no players will ever reach it, I would prefer games to have a less steep learning curve so that more players can enjoy having at least a half-decent game, and more casuals now-->more competitive players later, generally.
www.infinityseven.net
iSTime
Profile Joined November 2006
1579 Posts
September 20 2010 22:00 GMT
#57
On September 21 2010 06:53 unit wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 06:35 Jaeger wrote:
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that.


Regarding Starcraft 2's gameplay, he said that "I think the game has gotten more difficult compared to the original", adding that "But because I had experience playing Starcraft as a progamer, I'm getting better rapidly."

- July officially announces his move to Starcraft 2
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=151746

July was referring to the ability to dominate the competition is harder, because there is so little that separates the top tier from the rest in SC2 atm unlike in BW where for the top players it was easier to just maintain your skills due to there being more separating the top from the average joe


I'm not going to say this is inaccurate, but where are you inferring this from?. The link given by krndandaman doesn't suggest anything of the sort.
www.infinityseven.net
unit
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United States2621 Posts
September 20 2010 22:03 GMT
#58
On September 21 2010 07:00 PJA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 06:53 unit wrote:
On September 21 2010 06:35 Jaeger wrote:
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that.


Regarding Starcraft 2's gameplay, he said that "I think the game has gotten more difficult compared to the original", adding that "But because I had experience playing Starcraft as a progamer, I'm getting better rapidly."

- July officially announces his move to Starcraft 2
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=151746

July was referring to the ability to dominate the competition is harder, because there is so little that separates the top tier from the rest in SC2 atm unlike in BW where for the top players it was easier to just maintain your skills due to there being more separating the top from the average joe


I'm not going to say this is inaccurate, but where are you inferring this from?. The link given by krndandaman doesn't suggest anything of the sort.

its due to the learning curve being so rediculously easy, July said sc2 is harder, thats because there are way more people at the higher levels and the game depends less on APM which July had relied on for a while (if you were around July IS mr.818 apm)
krndandaman
Profile Joined August 2009
Mozambique16569 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-20 22:04:30
September 20 2010 22:03 GMT
#59
--- Nuked ---
infinity2k9
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
United Kingdom2397 Posts
September 20 2010 22:05 GMT
#60
On September 21 2010 06:53 PJA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2010 06:52 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 06:30 PJA wrote:
On September 21 2010 05:38 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 05:05 PJA wrote:
On September 21 2010 04:47 krndandaman wrote:
On September 21 2010 03:47 PJA wrote:
Everyone sticking to BW says the same shit all the time: BW is hard, SC2 is easy, and all the people who play SC2 just want to play an easier game.

This is like elitist go players saying go is hard, chess is easy, and if you really wanted to play a difficult game, play go. Nobody will ever reach the skill cap in either game, so it's ridiculous to call one "easy" and one "hard." Yes, it's hard to make your units even respond in a reasonable way in BW compared to SC2, but that has nothing to do with which game is more competitive, it only makes BW more frustrating to play as a beginner.

Clearly, BW with only being allowed to select 1 unit at a time and not being allowed to hotkey anything would be "harder" than BW in the sense that you guys are talking about, and it would raise the skill ceiling even higher, but would you really want to play it over BW? No, obviously not.

FWIW: Has anyone noticed that none of the people who switched to SC2 from BW agree with you guys? All of the top players who post on these forums who switched to SC2 pretty much agrees completely with what I am saying. Nony, InControl, etc. Are they all just newbs looking to play an easier game?


For reference, I am a BW player who stuck to BW. Also, it's a known fact that BW is harder than SC2, and I'm pretty sure everyone acknowledges that. But I do not think people play sc2 because it's easier.



I feel like you missed the entire point of my post. Sure, BW is "harder" in the sense that it's harder to a-move 100 supply in BW than in SC2, and in the sense that dragoons are mind-bogglingly retarded compared to stalkers. However, BW players want to take this fact and say that BW therefor requires more skill to compete at the top level, or that players will reach some skill ceiling in SC2.

There is no reason to believe a priori that the latter is true, and I think all of the top foreigners from BW who play SC2 believe that it is false; that no one will ever reach the skill ceiling in SC2.

As for the former, it is obviously true at the moment, but that's because nobody has spent 5 years playing the game, perfectly their build orders, timings, mechanics, etc. etc.

So is BW "harder" than SC2? Yes, but only if you want to take a very narrow and irrelevant definition of what it means to be harder.


No, BW is harder because
1) harder to amove groups of units/control
2) no multi building selection (harder macro)
3) no automining
4) more retarded AI
People think SC2 is a game that requires more intelligence than bw, but that is wrong. SC2 just rewards intelligent thinking more because all of the 'mechanics' are pretty much dealt with by the AI and new features.

I really don't think anyone would reach the skill ceiling in any RTS.

Please ask the top foreigners whether they think bw is harder or sc2.
Most of them will say BW. Though some will prob give the bullshit responses "oh both are hard games" "you cant compare the 2". None, I mean zero, will say SC2 is harder than bw. I also think I remember Nony or Idra saying BW was harder, i forget. im a bit more sure it was idra
edit: or it could be both of them who said bw was harder


You still aren't understanding:

In any player versus player game, as long as there is no skill cap that players can actually reach and the winner is determined primarily by skill (i.e., not mostly luck based), it is meaningless to say one game is harder than the other.


How is that so?
Just because there is no skill cap does not mean that all games have the same learning curve.
It also is easier to reach near the skill cap in some games over others.
I can safely say it's easier to reach near skill cap in say Warcraft III over BW. Right?


What evidence do you have to support that conclusion about WC3?

Also, what exactly is appealing about having a steeper learning curve? As long as the skill cap is high enough that no players will ever reach it, I would prefer games to have a less steep learning curve so that more players can enjoy having at least a half-decent game, and more casuals now-->more competitive players later, generally.


Why do we need more competitive players? The high skill cap of BW makes it a very impressive spectator game. If every player has perfect macro, that immediately takes away a whole element of multitasking. Now things like easy spellcasting, again makes it massively easier and also makes the spells far less impressive to pull off considering they happen in every game perfectly. No more Jangbi storms, no BeSt style players known for their macro. I can imagine the future of SC2 is going to result in much closer games decided by very small mistakes to be honest, to me that is far less interesting.
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
BSL 21
20:00
LB SemiFinal
Sziky vs eOnzErG
ZZZero.O158
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
IndyStarCraft 161
BRAT_OK 117
Railgan 34
DisKSc2 26
StarCraft: Brood War
Shuttle 655
Jaedong 550
Larva 180
ZZZero.O 158
Dewaltoss 148
JulyZerg 45
Rock 38
910 31
Terrorterran 5
Dota 2
qojqva4521
canceldota33
Counter-Strike
fl0m1022
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu394
Khaldor207
Trikslyr76
Other Games
Grubby6705
Beastyqt834
B2W.Neo353
ToD244
RotterdaM215
DeMusliM201
ArmadaUGS158
XaKoH 100
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1176
StarCraft 2
angryscii 32
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 20 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• printf 47
• davetesta27
• Adnapsc2 18
• IndyKCrew
• sooper7s
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• Migwel
• intothetv
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Kozan
StarCraft: Brood War
• 80smullet 8
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV1009
• lizZardDota282
• Ler47
League of Legends
• Nemesis3011
• Shiphtur264
Other Games
• imaqtpie2249
Upcoming Events
Sparkling Tuna Cup
13h 49m
Krystianer vs Classic
TriGGeR vs SKillous
Percival vs Ryung
ByuN vs Nicoract
OSC
21h 49m
BSL 21
23h 49m
Cross vs Dewalt
Replay Cast
1d 12h
Wardi Open
1d 15h
OSC
2 days
Solar vs MaxPax
ByuN vs Krystianer
Spirit vs TBD
OSC
5 days
Korean StarCraft League
6 days
OSC
6 days
OSC
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Escore Tournament S1 - W1
WardiTV 2025
META Madness #9

Ongoing

C-Race Season 1
IPSL Winter 2025-26
BSL Season 21
CSL Season 19: Qualifier 2
eXTREMESLAND 2025
SL Budapest Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 8
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025
IEM Chengdu 2025
PGL Masters Bucharest 2025
Thunderpick World Champ.
CS Asia Championships 2025

Upcoming

CSL 2025 WINTER (S19)
Escore Tournament S1 - W2
Escore Tournament S1 - W3
BSL 21 Non-Korean Championship
Acropolis #4
IPSL Spring 2026
Bellum Gens Elite Stara Zagora 2026
HSC XXVIII
Big Gabe Cup #3
OSC Championship Season 13
Nations Cup 2026
ESL Pro League Season 23
PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026
IEM Kraków 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.